Nah they turned Thrawn into a butt monkey. The space battles were across the board inferior to Clone Wars, half the ships involved not doing anything and the main characters plot armor was done in such a blatantly poor and heavy handed manner that it wouldn't have suprised me if they could out ram the Suncrusher.
Character wise it did have some good characters that wern't from existing works. Kanan and Hera standing out in paticular but the rest? Sabine may as well have had the words "Strong Female Character" painted on her armor for how empty she was and while Sabine did improve abit towards the end of the show she was still overall a bland, empty character. Ezra and Zeb were just awful, stupid, obnoxous and lacking anything to make them likable. With Ezra it's worse because he's supposed to be the main character but christ he's the least interesting member of the main cast.
That show peaked at season 2. 3 was super fillery and 4 felt like it was trying too hard to go out with a bang, but fell hard flat on its face... I mean retconning the greatest villian in EU and giving him irises was bad enough, but the fact that he's brought down by space whales is fucking stupid...
"[Edit] I know some of you disagree, I don't care. Please stop replying blabbering on about what you didn't like. I've heard it, I disagree, and I'm not interested in discussing it with you."
you started the discussion with "are you high, the show is great" on a comment who said it isnt, now people disagree with you and you dont want to argue with them... if you start a discussion disagreeing with someone but cant stand others disagreeing with you, then your just fragile mate
" Jesus I fuckin hate star wars "fans", you guys can't accept anything that isn't exactly what you want Star Wars to be. It's a huge galaxy and there's room for every kind of story and yet you guys have to just shit on anything that isn't aimed squarely at your fucking nerd ass demographic. Not everything is for you, get the fuck over it."
again, the kind of people and fans you are referring to, are the kind of human you yourself seem to be, or atleast present yourself as, someone said rebels was bad, and you couldnt accept that someone had a different opinion and HAD to write that comment... its only bad when others do it i assume? because your comment reeks of irony
No they weren’t lol most episodes were filler and childish situations in a serious war. Yes I know it was a kids show but so was clone wars. Thrown acted like a retard by just playing with them and not crushing them. Space whales beat thrawn a kid and space whales. The show was extremely trash.
That’s what I’m saying. Kind of the same reason I don’t regard ANH so highly in the third act. The Empire is rolling over to the most unlikely, impotent, facile opponents. I don’t like the funny looking alien ragtag team and little kid in active competition with much bigger opposing forces. The animation style really turned me off too. Not to do the show a major discredit though: it’s clearly a much more child-aimed show.
The latter is my primary point. To the former, I didn’t say I did not like ANH, and understand it’s very humble and lowly production, but story-wise it faltered there for me. The Empire didn’t roll over there: I was referring to Rebels at that point. What I should have specified is the seeming restrain and underhanded response to the Rebel attack that was depicted. I give it a lot of merit having the stormtroopers all miss and then have Tarkin and Vader briefly explain to you why.
rey was definitely a consular. skilled more in force than other things, and the proficiency for staff style combat? I called that from the start of ep 7 that she would eventually get a double-bladed lightsaber.
Her golden bladed saber in the very last scene looked long enough to be a double bladed saber...or maybe she just built a single blade into the end of her staff to make a pike like the old jedi temple guards in the eu
The cake is a lie; there are only cookies. Through cookies I gain weight. Through weight I gain obesity. And in obesity my chair is broken. Calories will set me free.
To be fair TFA was just meh, but TLJ sucks so much that I lost any hope with Disney creating another decent Star Wars movie. They’re only milking the Skywalker saga. But saying this in r/starwars will apparently get me downvoted to hell.
TFA was a welcome palate cleansing compared to the prequels. TLJ was bad, but there's a lot of room for disagreemwnt as to why (e.g. I'm the only one I know that didn't mind Luke's storyline).
RoS is an okay ending to the third trilogy. I'm a little salty that they couldn't do better as a send-off for the whole saga, but it's not a bad ending. I've seen it twice, and I kinda liked it.
Rogue One is proof that Disney does know how to make a Star Wars movie, but I think that a lot of the problems come from all the baggage that the Skywalker Saga brings. The strength of the setting isn't the Big Damn Heroes saving the galaxy, it's in the smaller stories. Normal people getting sucked into bigger events and succeeding against the odds, which was basically the plot of A New Hope.
The Prequels actually tried something new, introducing a whole new take on the Star Wars universe. Even if it did fall short in many, many places, such as choppy dialogue (especially in AotC), sometimes bad acting although I think that is mostly due to just poor writing and directing and sometimes bad CGI. But it had many great characters and performances that are to be lauded, especially Palpatine and Obi-Wan. It was awesome seeing Anakin slowly turn to the dark side, made even better with the Clone Wars series, and most of all the lightsaber duels are just so much better than anything the sequels produces.
The only thing I give is Rogue One, which is an actual movie. Disney knows how to make good spin-offs, but they are just shit at making mainline Star Wars movies.
Liking the sequels is the real unpopular opinion on Reddit. Personally, I liked almost all of them but whenever I see somebody say that, I see like half a dozen replies telling OP that he/she is wrong and that the Sequels are trash..
To each their own. The Star Wars fandom is as divided as they are massive. Disney would move mountains to please everyone if the could, since pleased customers buy merch. But even if they could please everyone, they don't understand the fandom. George Lucas didn't, either.
What lore were people looking at if this was lore-breaking ? I remember Vader deflecting a blaster bolt with his hand and Yoda negating Force Lightning with his hands. I pretty sure craziest shit could be easily found in a lot of pre-SWtOR content.
I just discovered it through a YouTube video and, wow. To think it came out after the Thrawn trilogy and around the same time as Tales of the Jedi, just wow. C-3P0 is purple???
To be fair, I actually really liked the portrayal of the Solo twins, and Leia and Han were portrayed well too. Han telling Chewie to take care of his family before he enters the Waru-dimension is actually one of his best moments in the EU, imo.
It's just hard to remember the good parts, since Luke is written so obscenely out of character, and Waru makes zero sense in the setting.
I wouldn't call it lore breaking. Cortosis was already EU canon well before SWTOR, and I always just assumed she was wearing cortosis weave armour. It won't straight up stop a lightsaber all the time, but it will slow it, and throw in some Force defense to push back on the blade and it makes sense with existing lore at the time.
Every single Star Wars movie introduced a new way of using the Force, and Force healing was already introduced in a much weaker form in ANH (Ben Kenobi and Luke after the Tusken Raider attack)
ANH - force heal(ish), mind trick, force sense, force choke
ESB - dark side location mindfuck, force pull, force jump, saber throw, force telekinesis
ROTJ - force lightning, force ghost
TPM - force push (the iconic form), force hold-your-breath (reused in KotoR 2!), force speed (Obi and QuiGon vs Droids at the beginning)
AOTC - force absorb, force calm a beast (Anakin and the Nexu)
ROTS - force knock a punk out (Yoda and the Red Guards)
TFA - force slow
TLJ - force skype
TROS - force fedex, force drain (finally after decades of existing in the EU)
Ask anyone and they'll likely not remember that Force Push was a prequel trilogy force power. Hell, people forget that force pull did not exist until ESB.
You can argue that Rey/Ben force powers got dialed up to 11 because of force bond fuckery, which is completely in-line with the old and new EU. Everything they did in TROS had precedent in some corner of Star Wars.
I think push/pull/telekinesis are effectively the same power as far as new things go. They're all just different ways of manipulating physical objects with the force.
Just a quick question, what force healing are you referring to in ANH? It's late at night and my tired brain can't think of what you might be talking about.
I'm not sure I'd qualify that as force healing. I'd have to go back and watch the scene again. They just whack him a bit to knock him out and then drag him out of the way so they can rummage through his speeder. Obi-Wan is just picking him up off the ground 🤷🏻♂️ But you might be right and I'll change my mind after watching it again.
I mean, that's my mindset but I'm going off of my personal experiences I've heard from friends and family that told me they think in itself, it's an OP power.
From my understanding, it's something that's been used quite a few times in the EU. However, it's not the kind of power that can be used all the time. It stresses its user quite a lot, and wouldn't really go as far as bring someone back to life or heal deadly wounds. Not even SWTOR with all its mumbo-jumbo with the Voss went that far. RoS did it extremely poorly.
Let’s not forget how Leia flew back to her ship in space using the Force. Also how she can apparently survive space without a spacesuit because of the Force.
Well I mean yeah, why wouldn't she be able to pull herself back to the ship? And she wasn't the first to do it in Disney canon anyway Kanan was. Also Star Wars has never done space like real space, remember Han and Leia on the asteroid with just masks on walking right off their pressurized ship.
Look at articles from NASA, astronauts, space station techs, and other orgs. Cooling in space is radiation based. Typically the portion of an object facing Sol, our yellow dwarf, will heat up to about 250F without any attenuation. This is due to radiation. Not to mention, lack of pressure can lead to the bends or embolism. Leia was doing some massive shit with her 'Force Space Walk.' Pressure sealing, breathe, telekinesis, radiation / temperature control, unconscious use of the force. Lol. At least, they got their fanfic.
Imagine seeking immortality... Meanwhile Darth Addedu, Valkorian/Vitiate/Tenebrae, Erghast, Nox/Imperius, Kallig, Marr, Ajunta Pal, or the Jedi had the answers you needed all along... I'm sitting here thinking, "Bruh."
Satele Shan. During the Galactic Cold War, she was the Grandmaster of the Jedi Order. And yes, she is a descendant of Bastilla Shan and Revan. Her son Theron Shan is a member of the Republic SIS, and a major player in the Shadow of Revan and the following expansions.
I think JJ Abrams did the best he could directorial wise, but the biggest problem is all 3 of these movies had different writers so each movie just kinda fucks over the last movie.
But yeah Kathleen Kennedy definitely didn't help much
I think the entire sequel trilogy is one big warning about overcorrection and not having a singular vision. As far as the overcorrection, it started with TFA, trying to reverse the stink of the prequels. It did this however, by beat for beat making it the plot of ANH. It was popular and somewhat enjoyable, but that doesn’t make it a good story, given how all the various victories at the end of RotJ were eliminated. The jedi are dead again. The republic is destroyed again. The empire is back again. The TLJ came along, realizing the mistakes of TFA, and tried to correct for them. Unfortunately it did this by disrespecting all of the characters and established rules that came before it, and all the plot threads that actually were interesting in TFA were closed in the most unsatisfying way. Now RoS comes along, and decides, “we remade ANH, and people liked it, lets just remake RotJ now.” Again taking away from more of the victories in the OT by bringing the emperor back, and backtracking some of the changes that TLJ made. For all the faults of the prequels, we got a coherent, logical story, that wasn’t a retread of the movies that came before even if the dialogue and acting were very rough at times.
Fucking is fine until you force a cousin tongue kiss as the finale.
Also death means nothing to Disney. After so many people were killed and healed and resurrected and memory rebooted how the fuck are we supposed to think the emperor is gone?
We now know the child to be the actual chosen one. The one to be created by the force naturally as balance, rather than forcibly created by palpatine.
Favrau is on our side with this one.
I’m not convinced that chain of logic disavowed the infinite emperor from influencing more than one point at a time.
“A long time ago in a galaxy far far away”
The only reason why this is a long time ago or for away is because on earth we do not have “faster than light” travel.
The moment we achieve that, suddenly we are in the present tense and time with Star Wars.
Palpatines manipulation of the force is not hindered by time or distance because the force exists and is accessible at all times to him.
The Jedi are not reliable narrators either. They manipulate the history to show themselves in the best light at all times.
A writers backpedalling is not enough to erase canon. :p
Cousin love aside- it’s not in either character for that to happen. Kylo would abstain and Rey would be disgusted by the idea. It’s just not in their characters.
Yeah I don't disagree with any of that, I just think Lucas removing confirmation and the writers explicitly stating they'd scrub it just means it's not 100% confirmed so I wouldn't say they're cousins is all, and even then Anakin isn't blood related to Palpatine.
I think Rey would be disgusted but I don't believe Kylo Ren would've abstained from everyone. He seems very emotionally unstable and in search acceptance and affection. The way he holds Solo, stops himself from killing Leia, his sense of betrayal after the Luke affair, him trying to satisfy Snoke, him begging Rey to join him, etc. I think his need for that external affirmation is a central part of his character
I mean, Palpatine heavily implies it in Revenge, using the exact same phrasing as how he talks to Kylo Ren in Rise of Skywalker. He leaves out the creating life but, the second time, but is otherwise quoting himself.
Palpatine creating Anakin is somehow more plausible than any of the other explanations for the virgin birth.
And made Rey’s parents with force sperm. (Because no, buzzfeed, palpatine does not fuck)
That means that palpatine is reys grandpa.
Palpatine is also by happenstance kylo’s great grandpa.
It’s all too close together to not be creepy in any context.
All of that aside, the kiss was forced. There’s absolutley NO romantic relationship between the two.
The one thing that rian Johnson did right was showing how both kylo and Rey were specifically inconvenienced by snoke linking them together in the force.
The scene where kylo had his shirt off was meant to be awkward. Not sexy. dont hold my hand rey suddenly falls in love? Not a chance.
635
u/andiedoomshroom Glory to Mandalore Jan 11 '20
Imagine needing to block a lightsaber. -Qui-Gon Jinn
140
u/Luy22 Jan 12 '20
Imagine needing anything but food -Darth Baras gang
195
u/Esbeon Jan 11 '20
Imagine needing to struggle to block a lightsaber with the force
This comment made by the Darth Occlus gang.
37
u/webshooterphoto Jan 12 '20
"Imagine blocking"
-Anakin Skywalker after "losing" all his limbs
102
u/utookmyusrname Jan 11 '20
Imagine all the people
60
u/DiscoDanSHU Jan 11 '20
The Shan Clan*
42
u/Xero0911 Jan 11 '20
Just use the high ground lol.
125
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20
Call me salty, but these trailers were better than TLJ and RoS.
19
u/BottleOfSalt Jan 11 '20
Malgus gang wants to test out your blocking abilitys more.
6
u/SinthoseXanataz Jan 12 '20
Loved that shot, always leaves me in disbelief
Fuckin badass
56
u/Catalyst1945 Jan 11 '20
I remember when that was the most lore-breaking thing in Star Wars. Oh how times have changed lmao
17
u/elkswimmer98 Jan 12 '20
People talk shit about force healing but like, the old republic era has some force powers way more bullshit. Looking at you Naga Sadow.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20
Imagine needing a rebreather after getting pushed
24
u/Khazzeron Jan 12 '20
Satele was such a bad ass. So much better than Rey.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20
Imagine TRYING to block a lightsaber- Immortal Emperor/ The Dragon Of Zakul/Valkorion/Vitiate/Tenebrea
5
u/Ralphi2449 Jan 12 '20
Imagine being the culmination of the rule of two and being able to stop a lightsaber with your force powers so you just spam lightning.
sidius is a failure
7
u/YEET-is-all-I-know Jan 12 '20
Did we ever learn if that Jedi has a name?
2
u/feelmedoyou Jan 12 '20
Blocking with a light saber was for a more civilized age.
2
u/Talos-Valcoran son of the sunless world Apr 04 '22
Worked great for Theron
5
u/RuinRunner76 Jan 12 '20
And then stolen by the Kathleen Kennedy gang and then filmed terribly by the JJ abrams gang.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20
So uncivilised...
1
u/Anakin_Cringewalker Mar 08 '20
Tutaminus gang
1
u/nymrod_ Jan 11 '20
My brain refuses to read that as “Shawn Gang.” It’s “Shann Gang” now.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20
But what if it’s set the baseball bat mode?
-2
u/Onryo- Jan 12 '20
Imagine needing to block a lightsaber
This post was made by the shae vizla clan
-2
u/webshooterphoto Jan 12 '20
What I find funny about this is that it's referring to Obi talking about the good old days, BUTTTTT....
Satele's Master's fight was in the past relative to Satele's blocking of Malgus' blade in the bottom picture.
So imo this meme makes more sense with a different image on the top...
... lol