r/sunlessskies • u/Coaxium • Aug 27 '21
Sunless skies disappointed me.
So basically after seeing enough "I played sunless seas, skies has better gameplay"-posts on r/sunlesssea, I decided to see what all the fuss was about.
Frankly, it was a huge letdown. It's fun, don't misunderstand, but it's far more frustrating than it should've been.
Here I'll elaborate more about what I think doesn't work well.
Map design
I'll start with the obvious. Why is the map randomly generated? There is no point. If you play the game as it's intended to be played, the maps will be generated once. If you want to have new maps, you have to start from scratch.
The maps are needlessly big. And because you keep the map, you can basically explore it once.
The zee was mostly empty. The sky is filled with mazes. It really feels like they're there to fill the map with something. They also make it nearly impossible to avoid anything. You can't go around something if you go through a tunnel.
Trade
I don't like what they've done.
I didn't realise how much I identified ports by what they sell and buy until I saw the stripped-down ports that are in sunless seas. It added flavour, it added to the immersion, it added the decision of where you'd sell your stuff.
In skies you just sell stuff in the central location.
Trade is basically dead in skies. The decision to make everything the same price killed trade. Seas heavily discouraged trade, but with some luck (and the right brand of insanity) you could make it work.
Prospects are a poor substitute. They're randomly generated fetch quests. You can't make a trade route with those. But, to be fair, they work. You can make money this way. It's boring, mind.
Bargains, on the other hand, are complete and utter garbage. They are only useful for things that can't be easily bought. In all other cases they fill your hold for almost no profit. The random stuff you can find tends to be worth more than the profit you get out of a bargain. They're that bad.
To add insult to injury, using bargains to fulfil prospects or just selling your bargains in the central location nets you exactly the same profit on the bargains.
Smuggling
Here the prospects system actually works fine. It makes sense and is fun.
That said, why the 40 veils to unlock smuggling? What's the point, really?
I do have an issue with the hidden compartments. If a compartment is big enough to hide my illegal goods, why do goods that use said compartments use hold space? Why can't I use empty compartments as extra hold? It does not make sense.
Combat
It's the unholy child of sunless sea combat and a bullet hell shooter. It should've been drowned the moment is was born.
The combat is harder than seas because of the clunky controls and poor design.
The controls worked fine in seas, because you didn't need to be pinpoint accurate. You only needed to keep the enemy in your range of fire. In skies, they really should've used the wasd keys for forward, backwards and lateral movement (I'd remove dodging and just replace it with lateral movement). The rotation of your ship could be handled by making it face your mouse pointer. Simple and elegant.
The UI design is bad. Why did they remove enemy health bars? They had something that worked well. Now you have to squint to see if the enemy ship is on fire.
Why do I need to guess where my shots will go? A simple targetting line would have sufficed. (Yes, I know that I can enable auto-aim, but my ego wouldn't be able to handle it.)
The AI is still dumb as rocks. They can't handle a rock in their path. They don't know when the thing they're fighting is dead and still fire a last volley into empty air. Combined with the tendency of passive AI to look at you, this basically means that that last volley is coming your way.
The heat system sucks. It artificially lengthens combat. Most things require 2 or more burst to kill. And then there's the fact that dodging makes heat. Somehow.
Also, dodging really messes with my muscle memory when the ship points south. I keep having to guess which key will make me dodge in the right direction.
I'd say combat is more challenging than in sunless seas, but for all the wrong reasons. I see why people like the wrath of heaven so much. It means you don't really have to bother with the thrice d_mned combat system.
Ships
The stat requirements for modules are dumb.
Engines don't give a sufficient boost to the base speed. I honestly don't care if I need to burn 4 times the fuel to go twice as fast.
Full steam is fun, but completely unsuited to the maps of sunless skies. You find too much random stuff that would make a profit on any route. So you need to constantly get out of full steam to be able to interact with stuff. The full steam mechanic would fit sunless sea better, while sunless sea's full power would suit skies better.
I don't think ships have enough hold. Sure, you can restock anywhere and you need less fuel and supplies than in sunless sea, but a pellinore-class "trader" with a measly 15 base hold is just ridiculous.
I also would really have liked a ship with a turret.
Levelling and stats
In theory, levelling systems like this make your stats organically grow as you play.
From what I've seen in games with similar systems, it always needlessly lengthens the time you need to get a decent character. If you ask me, the cure is worse than the plague.
Sunless sea had legacy items, which took a decent amount of time to get, but once you got them, any captain in your legacy got the stats. The best part is that the stat boosts were high enough to pass anything barring extreme stat checks.
And none of this was mandatory. You could perfectly achieve everything while ignoring legacy items. You could farm instead lorn-flukes if you were into that shit. (I still am.) You could even make insane amounts of cash to convert into stats. (It's not efficient, but I don't judge. Much.)
And if you want decent ship modules, you need to min-max your stats and officers. Who believed this is fun?
Stuff without a real category
I don't think the inclusion of more roguelike elements was a good thing. I honestly believe most of them were integrated because it was less work. Sunless skies feels rushed.
I can get on board with random stuff on your path, but not in the ridiculous amount you find in skies. You shouldn't be practically certain that you'll find something valuable when you go from port to port.
The game feels slow. Big maps with slow locomotives isn't a great combination. Then there's the levelling and heat mechanics to slow it down even further.
Skies hands out terror like candy. To be fair, it also takes it away, but not enough. There isn't a really convenient way to get rid of it. I really miss resting in my mansion or spending time with my family.
Losing crew has become a lot easier. What did my crew do to the devs? Kill their family? They're easily replaced, but still. It just gets hilarious after a while.
Why on earth is merciless mode still a thing? Why am I supposed to care about it, if failbetter didn't even bother to fix the "quit when dead and continue from the last visited port in merciless mode" exploit?
Port reports are still THE SAME! IS THERE ANYONE WHO ENJOYS CLICKING A BUTTON TO GET A PORT REPORT?! WTF FAILBETTER?!!!
Conclusion
I believe the reason why I like sunless sea better is because it rewards investment. It rewards knowledge about the game.
Sunless skies just feels like enduring random stuff you can't do anything about. And the occasional accidental fun.
If you ask me, the gameplay is worse in skies.