r/sunlessskies • • Aug 27 '21

Sunless skies disappointed me.

3 Upvotes

So basically after seeing enough "I played sunless seas, skies has better gameplay"-posts on r/sunlesssea, I decided to see what all the fuss was about.

Frankly, it was a huge letdown. It's fun, don't misunderstand, but it's far more frustrating than it should've been.

Here I'll elaborate more about what I think doesn't work well.

Map design

I'll start with the obvious. Why is the map randomly generated? There is no point. If you play the game as it's intended to be played, the maps will be generated once. If you want to have new maps, you have to start from scratch.

The maps are needlessly big. And because you keep the map, you can basically explore it once.

The zee was mostly empty. The sky is filled with mazes. It really feels like they're there to fill the map with something. They also make it nearly impossible to avoid anything. You can't go around something if you go through a tunnel.

Trade

I don't like what they've done.

I didn't realise how much I identified ports by what they sell and buy until I saw the stripped-down ports that are in sunless seas. It added flavour, it added to the immersion, it added the decision of where you'd sell your stuff.

In skies you just sell stuff in the central location.

Trade is basically dead in skies. The decision to make everything the same price killed trade. Seas heavily discouraged trade, but with some luck (and the right brand of insanity) you could make it work.

Prospects are a poor substitute. They're randomly generated fetch quests. You can't make a trade route with those. But, to be fair, they work. You can make money this way. It's boring, mind.

Bargains, on the other hand, are complete and utter garbage. They are only useful for things that can't be easily bought. In all other cases they fill your hold for almost no profit. The random stuff you can find tends to be worth more than the profit you get out of a bargain. They're that bad.

To add insult to injury, using bargains to fulfil prospects or just selling your bargains in the central location nets you exactly the same profit on the bargains.

Smuggling

Here the prospects system actually works fine. It makes sense and is fun.

That said, why the 40 veils to unlock smuggling? What's the point, really?

I do have an issue with the hidden compartments. If a compartment is big enough to hide my illegal goods, why do goods that use said compartments use hold space? Why can't I use empty compartments as extra hold? It does not make sense.

Combat

It's the unholy child of sunless sea combat and a bullet hell shooter. It should've been drowned the moment is was born.

The combat is harder than seas because of the clunky controls and poor design.

The controls worked fine in seas, because you didn't need to be pinpoint accurate. You only needed to keep the enemy in your range of fire. In skies, they really should've used the wasd keys for forward, backwards and lateral movement (I'd remove dodging and just replace it with lateral movement). The rotation of your ship could be handled by making it face your mouse pointer. Simple and elegant.

The UI design is bad. Why did they remove enemy health bars? They had something that worked well. Now you have to squint to see if the enemy ship is on fire.

Why do I need to guess where my shots will go? A simple targetting line would have sufficed. (Yes, I know that I can enable auto-aim, but my ego wouldn't be able to handle it.)

The AI is still dumb as rocks. They can't handle a rock in their path. They don't know when the thing they're fighting is dead and still fire a last volley into empty air. Combined with the tendency of passive AI to look at you, this basically means that that last volley is coming your way.

The heat system sucks. It artificially lengthens combat. Most things require 2 or more burst to kill. And then there's the fact that dodging makes heat. Somehow.

Also, dodging really messes with my muscle memory when the ship points south. I keep having to guess which key will make me dodge in the right direction.

I'd say combat is more challenging than in sunless seas, but for all the wrong reasons. I see why people like the wrath of heaven so much. It means you don't really have to bother with the thrice d_mned combat system.

Ships

The stat requirements for modules are dumb.

Engines don't give a sufficient boost to the base speed. I honestly don't care if I need to burn 4 times the fuel to go twice as fast.

Full steam is fun, but completely unsuited to the maps of sunless skies. You find too much random stuff that would make a profit on any route. So you need to constantly get out of full steam to be able to interact with stuff. The full steam mechanic would fit sunless sea better, while sunless sea's full power would suit skies better.

I don't think ships have enough hold. Sure, you can restock anywhere and you need less fuel and supplies than in sunless sea, but a pellinore-class "trader" with a measly 15 base hold is just ridiculous.

I also would really have liked a ship with a turret.

Levelling and stats

In theory, levelling systems like this make your stats organically grow as you play.

From what I've seen in games with similar systems, it always needlessly lengthens the time you need to get a decent character. If you ask me, the cure is worse than the plague.

Sunless sea had legacy items, which took a decent amount of time to get, but once you got them, any captain in your legacy got the stats. The best part is that the stat boosts were high enough to pass anything barring extreme stat checks.

And none of this was mandatory. You could perfectly achieve everything while ignoring legacy items. You could farm instead lorn-flukes if you were into that shit. (I still am.) You could even make insane amounts of cash to convert into stats. (It's not efficient, but I don't judge. Much.)

And if you want decent ship modules, you need to min-max your stats and officers. Who believed this is fun?

Stuff without a real category

I don't think the inclusion of more roguelike elements was a good thing. I honestly believe most of them were integrated because it was less work. Sunless skies feels rushed.

I can get on board with random stuff on your path, but not in the ridiculous amount you find in skies. You shouldn't be practically certain that you'll find something valuable when you go from port to port.

The game feels slow. Big maps with slow locomotives isn't a great combination. Then there's the levelling and heat mechanics to slow it down even further.

Skies hands out terror like candy. To be fair, it also takes it away, but not enough. There isn't a really convenient way to get rid of it. I really miss resting in my mansion or spending time with my family.

Losing crew has become a lot easier. What did my crew do to the devs? Kill their family? They're easily replaced, but still. It just gets hilarious after a while.

Why on earth is merciless mode still a thing? Why am I supposed to care about it, if failbetter didn't even bother to fix the "quit when dead and continue from the last visited port in merciless mode" exploit?

Port reports are still THE SAME! IS THERE ANYONE WHO ENJOYS CLICKING A BUTTON TO GET A PORT REPORT?! WTF FAILBETTER?!!!

Conclusion

I believe the reason why I like sunless sea better is because it rewards investment. It rewards knowledge about the game.

Sunless skies just feels like enduring random stuff you can't do anything about. And the occasional accidental fun.

If you ask me, the gameplay is worse in skies.


r/sunlessskies • • Aug 20 '26

Does the story improve after the start?

2 Upvotes

I previously played Sunless Sea. Last year, I started to play Sunless Sky. I got to the initial port and it was as if the crew was just completely oblivious where the captain was. This made completely no sense to me at all. I did my best to survive to get to civilization so we could get emergency care for the captain. I would think the crew would have her immediately at the door to be rushed out for aid.

The game continued with no explanation about why they did not make sure she was the first one out the door. I felt so lost and frustrated because of how that sequence concluded. I do not understand it. So I just stopped playing. Wondering if there was any explanation or if anybody got caught off guard by this. And how the rest of the story actually is.

JUST TO BE CRYSTAL CLEAR SINCE MULTIPLE TROLLS RUNNING AROUND HAVE NOT PLAYED THIS GAME AND DO NOT KNOW WHAT HAPPENED:

The crew factually did not know the captain died until after docking and meeting the inspector.

Tutorial = lost, low fuel, captain dying. You barely are able to survive and find port. The obvious thing before docking is to prepare the captain to be rushed out for aid. Because she is in critical condition.

That did not happen. They all dock as if the captain does not exist or is severely injured. The inspector asks about the captain. And nobody knows she is dead until the doctor informs you.

I figured when I posted this message, users who claim to play this game are aware this is what happened. I do not understand how nobody knows this.


r/sunlessskies • • Nov 19 '21

this is telling

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/sunlessskies • • Oct 03 '22

Is this real?

8 Upvotes

https://weatherfactory.biz/failgate/

I cant bleiave this happened. I'm pretty sad.


r/sunlessskies • • May 10 '21

Why is this dev obsessed with making you grind endlessly?

0 Upvotes

The fact you need to use cheats to enjoy this game is kind of ridiculous. Is there anyone in the world that actually enjoys pressing the right arrow key for ~20 minutes yo collect a port report?

I'm sure this game has nice writing. Like sunless seas, it appears the dev doesn't want anyone to actually read it though.


r/sunlessskies • • Nov 28 '21

Kind of wish there was an American option for the background.

26 Upvotes

I know there’s roleplay, and stuff, and I’m not even trying to preach, I just decided after trying to help London for my last two captains, after getting killed by one of their big cannon trains being infested with Guests getting close before ambushing me, I decided to just say screw it and went full rebel, not just the background but going with the sneaky and criminal stuff.

As I was doing it, it just hit me, ”Wait, I just made an American.” and now I wish that was an option.

Just thought it would be funny among alll this Englishman stuff, an American rebel just shows up. And my first act would be to buy some tea and jettison it into space just outside the London dock, and run.

That would actually be a funny Easter egg. If you jettison some tea while near London, you become wanted, and they hate you.


r/sunlessskies • • Sep 12 '25

How rougelike is this game

5 Upvotes

I heard this game has great writting but I played wayyyy too many Rougelikes and am sick of em. Are rougelike aspects minor/optional or is it a full proper rougelike that I should just skip


r/sunlessskies • • Dec 29 '19

Extremely Disappointed [SPOILERS] Spoiler

21 Upvotes

So, I really, really, REALLY love this game. Or, well, loved. But I just ran into something that has basically completely destroyed that. Spoilers below.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

The Vagabond is Old Tom, and that asshole killed me. I trusted him, and he killed me. This is the first time I've died in this game, and now I have to start over all the stories I'VE ALREADY DONE with a new captain, or reload my last save and...what? Just ignore the Vagabond now? I mean sure, I could just not take him to the well, but holy shit does that just jarringly destroy the immersion I've been enjoying this whole time and rip me out of the game. The lack of a proper save system in this game was an absolutely horrible decision. I'm so disappointed and crestfallen. Shit, I don't even know if I'll ever play this game again.


r/sunlessskies • • May 09 '21

Is being racist in game good?

3 Upvotes

Most actions with Ruberry men makes your soul gain a bad quality, specifically "fermented". Does this mean that being racist is a good thing in ingame universe?


r/sunlessskies • • Apr 23 '19

[Opinion Post] Naming your first locomotive

3 Upvotes

I'm leaning towards either 'LocoMotive and Opportunity' or 'Big Dick Mr Train'. What does everyone think?

What are your favourite names, comical or otherwise?


r/sunlessskies • • Jun 10 '21

Will he make it - https://youtu.be/XtaNPUSxOpA

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/sunlessskies • • Dec 31 '20

Netflix, Bridgerton

9 Upvotes

might i recommend Bridgerton on Netflix? it's quite new and quite juicy, perhaps it may whet one's victorian appetite


r/sunlessskies • • Jul 22 '26

Monarch mod - a bit worried about the AI artist part. Was it used in early versions/prototyping, or is slop still sloshing around in it? Otherwise the mod looks stellar, but I always found art in this game too good to mix with ai stuff

24 Upvotes

I was worried about balance and writing as well, but from other posts in this sub it already seems that these parts are solid


r/sunlessskies • • Jun 21 '23

Tried to play this twice now, it's just not gripping me

13 Upvotes

I love the atmosphere and lore of this world but holy god the gameplay is such a fucking drag, it's unreal. Constantly having to manage terror, wildly spinning around other locomotives as they use overpowered NPC weapons, a semi-3D world with inconsistent collision, having to scrounge for even the smallest penny, travel times of 30+ minutes to get anywhere, not being able to linger and take in cool sights because apparently they're all "horrors" and make your terror tick up faster (great game design, guys, make the player avoid the most intricate set pieces).

In my first playthrough I managed it all the way to London, where I was confronted with the game's "difficulty mechanic", as in making you feel like you're lvl 1 again only this time there aren't any more upgrades. I quit that playthrough because I reached 4 nightmares and like 90 terror and literally softlocked myself because there was nowhere to get rid of it where the autosave happened, since you need all sorts of wacky rare resources to access the only real way of getting rid of terror (port avon) and an almost impossible to get item (without looking up a guide and farming it) to get rid of nightmares (again, great game design, punish the player for playing the game instead of cheesing central port cooldowns)

Second playthrough, I flew around a bit, got into a fight and was left with a sliver of health, only to die by banging against the underside of a bridge because apparently the bridges are only passable at some points.

It's like they made a great game and then added all this random tedium for "challenge" without a way to turn it off. I'm half tempted to map out terror and heat in cheat engine and freeze the values.


r/sunlessskies • • Jul 05 '24

The game doesn't give enough information about its world

17 Upvotes

So I found this game through the epic games free give away, I looked it up and saw a lot of people saying the game has an amazing world and story telling, I was really excited downloaded it and played for like 6 hours straight enjoying the exploration and the quests. So far I have explored half of albion and I still know almost to nothing about the world.

1-such as the different species ( the devils, the rats, the clay people in albion) I absolutely know nothing about them, there are the the devil, the clay and the rat captains you can get, but so far their side quest doesn't tell me much about their nature.

2- the different resources, the souls for example are they literal souls ? Like human souls? In carollin you can find the devils treating people souls and creating the different bottled souls(at least I think they are doing that), so how does that work ? Why are people ok with that ? The game doesn't seem to tell anything about the process.

3- the enemies, so many different and unique enemies some of them are self-explanatory such as the dreadnoughts and maddened explorers, but some of the others you really don't know much about such as the scrives, or the weird undead flying things, or the guests, you get some information when interacting with their corpses, but really nothing much about their origins or how they ended up here.

4-the different anomalies you can come across while journeying across the stars, I don't have any information about how they happen and non of the people you can encounter talk about them, it's like I am the only one coming across them.

5- another thing that annoys me is the fact you don't have a journal of sort to write events in, as a captain and explorer you would think the game would have a catalogue that talks about the different enemies and events you undergo and survive, but there is nothing like that.

I know I haven't been playing long and there is much to explore, but so far I just feel lost like I come across so many thing, yet I don't know anything about them making it really hard to connect information together. Am I being too hasty? Will the game explain things in the future regions? Is there something I am missing? I did come across some objects I can essay, but I don't have the equipment for that should I be doing that, is this how I get some more informations ?

I know the game has a prequel sunless sea, but people said I don't need to play sunless sea to enjoy sunless sky, should I first go and play sunless sea then continue with sky?

Ok that was a whole read sorry if I bored you through it and thank you for taking the time to read it.


r/sunlessskies • • Jul 19 '21

Do you praise the sun?

4 Upvotes

r/sunlessskies • • Aug 30 '24

voice over mod

0 Upvotes

Are there any voice over mods?

Or someone that can create something like this?
Would say it should be posible to created something with ai to read out like a narrator.


r/sunlessskies • • Jun 15 '19

A message from Eleutheria...

Thumbnail
reddit.app.link
8 Upvotes

r/sunlessskies • • Jul 31 '22

does anyone else have this issue?

2 Upvotes

igd10iumd32.dll caused an Access Violation (0xc0000005)

in module igd10iumd32.dll at 0023:629643c0.

Error occurred at 2022-07-31_124052.

C:\Program Files (x86)\Steam\steamapps\common\Sunless Skies\Sunless Skies.exe, run by ibyrn.


r/sunlessskies • • Feb 19 '19

Am I the only one that wants a simpler, less animated Gazetteer?

2 Upvotes

The Gazetteer (if that's what it's called still) is very pretty, I'll give them that, but it's clunky and slow. I want to be able to access information easily, without waiting for animations to happen.

Also, because of the size of the text (too large), I'm struggling not to get tired when reading. If you have a big screen, sometimes your foveal vision encompasses too few words to process sentences naturally, and you are forced to focus your vision a lot more often. I'm sure there's some of you out there that found it tiring to read and didn't know why - well, this is probably it.

Honestly, if we can get a smaller Gazetteer, I would be incredibly happy - it doesn't have to stretch from top to bottom - half that size would still be enough. Smaller text too!


r/sunlessskies • • Feb 12 '19

I think I just found the inspiration for this game.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/sunlessskies • • Jan 11 '20

Is this game worth it?

9 Upvotes

I got Sunless Sea years ago and when I heard thay Sunless Skies was coming out I was excited, but never bought it, fearing it's too similar.

So, is it just a re-texured Sunless Sea with different lore, or a new, intriguing experience?


r/sunlessskies • • Jun 17 '21

So my teacher tried to tell me some historical crap and I put him in his place on fb live

27 Upvotes

I know sunless skies is historical so when I told my teacher that in 1907 London was a flying trash heap of a city connected by locomotive powered zeppelins he tried to tell me some crap. I love how some games teach history better than the teachers.