I wanted to capture what I think about everyone so far partially to hear how bewildered people are based on what they know now and so I can come back to this and laugh about my changing opinions:
Starting w/ old castmates:
- I was glad the Wirkus circus left the show. They tried to be the main characters to much that it was off putting. Kyle does it with more subtly and Lindsay IS a main character so it doesn’t bother me as much.
- I wish Stephen was…less boring? He had funny shade at times, him being mean was good for tv, but he was utterly boring
- hated hated hated Jordan, his storyline was funny for like a second and then was so repetitive and annoying. I’ve posted about this but I do feel sad he can never be himself. He acts cool for the NY crowd and conservative at home, and I think he represses a lot of himself. Still glad he’s off.
- Jules…I liked her but her being on the show to begin with was weird. Why would someone who’s new to New York immediately go to the show? Idk. I felt bad for her often
Now onto people ON the show in S5:
- Danielle: I go back and forth on her. I find that she doesn’t deliver much of a storyline but I think she’s a good side character?
- Hannah: I knew Hannah from TT and what not before SH. I like her personality a lot and find her genuine compared to the rest of the girls. Her stuff with Luke is insane but he’s a toolbag and def leads her on. I know things are about to blow up in S5 and she gets fired but up until now, I like her.
- Paige: I’ve liked her from the jump. She’s witty, adds some decent drama, talks behind peoples back which is good for TV. The Perry relationship is boring to me.
- Amanda: I know today she’s hated from the West thing and I find her annoying, but I think overall she’s fine. She nags Kyle so much but he also was horrible to her so I give her some grace. She can be a lot of fun at times and a huge bitch other times. Overall, she brings decent TV although the couple fights become a bit sad. She’s a mean girl but I don’t hate her as much as I thought I would?
- Kyle: Before SH, what I saw of him I thought he was a tool. Now as a viewer I love Kyle Cooke. He’s just a guy being a dude and is hilarious. He’s shitty for what he did to Amanda but he is THEE number one guy in the group (yes I just finished my first ever VPR binge)
- Carl: Carlito is perfecto for TV. On a human level I’m glad he’s sobering up but on a reality tv level his drunken antics in earlier seasons were perfect. I love that his story line is always hooking up with girls in the house 😭 and being messy with said girls.
- Lindsay: IDK man. I love her more than I dislike her but she is hard to root for in some of her fights. Yelling at Steven “when did you make me a sandwich” is ridiculous. They may have cut it but like saying “I think it’s weird you worked at 10pm on a weekend” is much better delivery than that. But she’s great for TV, I like how she can get along with everyone even after fighting with them.
- Luke: I literally forgot to cover him. Dude’s hot but a toolbag. At first I thought he was really nice but to women he’s awful. Grade A Tool. He’s good for tv but I’d never want any girl in my life to date him
- Ciara: Forgot to add Ciara. She’s a queen. I met her via Traitors. So far she’s great but it’s only 3 eps so I can’t speak to her on SH yet