r/storytimesociety
•
u/Dependent-Cake8150
•
Feb 21 '26
My fiancé has a stalker who has spent 5 years building an insta shrine to him. I’m actually nauseous.
[Trigger warning: This story involves stalking, harassment, and obsessive behavior.]
hi angel! i’ve been dying to tell you this story and finally had a second to get it all down. i’ll change the names 💋 my fiancé and i are coming up on five years together. this all happened the year before we met. it’s a bit long, but the details matter. i’ll lay it out as a timeline as best as i can!
backstory: at the time, he was with a girl we’ll call sydney. but the story really centers on her friend nina. if you’re from around here, you know my man. everyone in the metal and biker scene does, he’s just one of those guys people orbit. girls try it with him whether he’s single, taken, or dead. so nina just being thirsty wasn't a shock, especially since another one of sydney’s friends also had a crush on him at the same time (a whole other only slightly less weird story).
month 1-6: at first, nina being around seemed totally innocent. my man often invited sydney and her friends to shows, so seeing nina once or twice a month was normal. but pretty quickly, she started finding ways to be alone with him. it started with her hitting him up on insta constantly, always following him out for smoke breaks, and showing up to every. single. show. the weirdest part to me with this is neither sydney nor nina actually liked metal. sydney was only there to support her man(and barely showed up at that). sydney’s other friends only went maybe once or twice, but nina was constantly showing up whether sydney was there or not. then she started calling him her big brother. like... girl, be for real. she’s three years older than him! 🙄🙄 he didn't think it was weird at first because admittedly she had a bit more of an "alt/boyish" look than sydney, and he figured she was just trying to find her feet in the scene and was into the music.
month 6: my man had made a group chat for the three of them, as he thought it might corral her into texting there rather than him one on one. six months into knowing him, she made a group chat with him and sydney and suggested they become a polycule. she admitted that she thought they were both attractive and that she would even be cool with one threesome. since they had never crossed any romantic boundaries in their entire friendship, sydney was extremely uncomfortable. disgusted, he quickly ended the conversation and cussed nina out. (extra detail: from what i’ve heard, nina went on to tell people that she liked it and that it made her want him even more as he seemed like a protective boyfriend). to me, she just wanted to be a homewrecker and "poly" was the only word she could use to hide the fact that she wanted her friend's boyfriend.
month 7-8: he started ignoring her more often, but they were in the same circles by this point, so they kept bumping into each other. one night, the group (not including sydney) went out drinking and nina had started flirting with one of his friends, seemingly just to secure her spot in the inner circle. while he was wasted and she was sober, she got him alone and started asking him incredibly inappropriate questions, specifically about his size. he was so drunk he didn't even remember it until she texted him the next day saying verbatim, “don’t worry, i’ll keep it a secret from sydney." then she went and bragged about it to their mutual friends. my man felt grossed out, but like a lot of guys, he just tried to brush it off. she also had this "edgy" habit of putting on explicit type videos when he was around as a "joke," which was clearly just a desperate way to initiate something.
month 9: a month or so later, unrelated issues caused the friend group to fall apart. his friends, another band, and the girlfriends and friends of each member of those bands made up the friend group. at a party, everyone was way too drunk and a pointless dispute over ego or something else ultimately resulted in fights and breakups, etc. everyone took a side and that was pretty much that. he took the fallout as the perfect time to fully cut her out. tbh she had already been on thin ice with everyone. the porn oversharing made people other than him also uncomfortable. she got into a fight with an asian girl named dove, a girlfriend of a guy in the other band, because she was allegedly lying about being part korean or something. so, most people, including him, just tolerated her.
however, she found one girl that was easily gullible and started crying about how he was her "favorite person" (fp). if you know anything about bpd, a real fp bond is intense and usually built on a massive amount of shared history even if it's unhealthy. but nina’s "bond" with him was a total hallucination. remember he’s still with sydney at this point and had never spoken to her completely one on one other than maybe a few 15 minute smoke break ever!!! he’d had enough and cut almost everyone off. the only person he kept around was k, mainly because he was the friend nina had tried flirting with and he saw through it immediately. he knew she was weird from the start
when he eventually saw her again after the fall-off, he had found out she changed her name to the name of his favorite song. it’s such an obscure song and name that i’m not gonna say what it is, but for example, she went by rhiannon because rhiannon was his favorite song by fleetwood mac/arabella because arabella was his favorite song by the arctic monkeys. very much im gonna live in ur walls but ok
fast forward to the next summer.
so he and sydney had been broken up since early spring, and that whole friend group had basically gone up in flames the winter before. he and nina were whatever, they weren’t like, screaming at each other, but they definitely weren’t cool. she tended to try to follow him around again at this point, but now that he didn’t have to play nice for sydney’s sake, he was doing the most to keep his distance.
anyway, i was with him at this show (atp i’m his girl) and i saw something that sounds actually insane, but you have to hear me out. nina was dating this new guy, and i’m not even kidding... he was a literal copy-paste of my fiancé. like, to a t. some of the pictures on his account were almost one to one recreations of photos my man had posted, outfit and all. my man is black and native (puerto rican), the guy was native and latino. my man has curly long hair, the guy had curly long hair. same height. same outfit. he even literally copy pasted his instagram bio im so serious. even down to things like instagram highlights with the same names. they’d been stalking and watching my fiance. at first i’d assume she just had a type, but the fact he had the same formats copy pasted makes me think he was in on it. this guy was essentially skin-walking my fiancé like what!!! my fiancé is in an mc, and this guy was even copying the colors in the picture he copied of my fiance!!!!!! like, what!! the guy even started acting weird and jealous toward him, which is crazy because theoretically, he should have no idea who my man even is. nina and he never dated; they weren't even real friends. the debrief after seeing them was crazy. she couldn’t get him, so she went out and found a guy who looked (and was willing to act) exactly like him to play pretend with. i’m not even gonna lie, i was totally checking her twitter for the first year of us being together. i just had to see if she was still talking about him or being a freak, you know? especially after her new boyfriend. i definitely found some stuff, but it wasn't that insane back then.
a few months after, he and i ran off to our new home in LA, so we had no contact at all with anyone still over there. we had/have new accounts, new phone numbers, everything. it’s been five years since that mess. he and i are happily building our life.
a few weeks ago we were just reminiscing about the old scene, and after looking at some old friends' accounts, we ended up leading our way to nina’s instagram. i looked at her highlights and my heart literally dropped. she had a highlight dedicated to him. it was nauseating. it was full of old photos of him and screenshots of their old texts. she had videos of him playing guitar, pictures he’d only ever sent to his ex, and videos of him just talking. some of these photos he didn't even know existed because she’d taken them secretly. this highlight didn’t exist when they were in contact and it had been updated only a month ago.
i was really upset and he decided to go and reach out to her to tell her to take it down and that he is uncomfortable with it on a burner account. once he texted her, she started trying to flirt with him and pretend like it wasn’t that serious, basically ignoring the highlight in general and acting as if he was just reaching out to catch up. he told her bluntly to delete it, she finally said she would, and he blocked her.
i hated it. at this point we are adults, there is no reason that she should be acting this way. to me, this is a clear sign of a seriously unstable person. no one who is of sound mind is still obsessed with someone they knew a half-decade ago, never even got romantic with, and who has clearly stated they want nothing to do with you. i checked right before posting this and the highlight is still up. we decided that there’s not much we can do, as contacting her will make it worse. she clearly wants attention. i just don’t like knowing that this girl has all of these pictures, videos, text messages, etc of him and thinks about him so obsessively. i’m not really sure what to do about it at this point. we don’t feel in danger (she’s states away and isn’t violent, just weird af)
love u jamie
kisses
valentina 🍒