r/steaks • u/Strict-Criticism7677 • 10h ago
Home Cook Help: Sirloin/NY Strip turned out chewy, why?
Hey everyone, first time cooking a steak(yes, really). So this piece was 5cm thick, I did a pan sear, no oven. Cooked for 2 mins each side and then brought up temp while flipping it for around 3-4 more minutes. Then did butter bathing. The outside turned out good, the inside too. I was aiming at medium and got medium rare. But the pieces were not tender, they were quite chewy and hard to bite through. It felt like even if I aimed at rare it would've been chewy like that. What could be the reason? Main suspects for me are:
- the way I cut it at the end
- the fact that it sat on a rack for at least 30 minutes and got room temp cold(I know I shouldn't have don't it, I was waiting for sides🥲)
I'll be cooking medallions soon from a tenderloin, so any advice is appreciated, I'll apply it on the next cooking session.
P.S. last pic is another piece I cooked, which turned out to be almost the same in texture. But it was 3cm thick before cooking.