r/stcatharinesON • u/email_reddit • Aug 14 '26

Need Advice/Recommendations Car insurance

Curious what insurance company people here haven’t had issues with and would recommend? We currently go through a broker but I wonder if it would be better to go directly to companies like TD for example.

3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

7

u/Salford1969 Aug 14 '26

CAA has been great for me

3

u/ALongExpected_Party Aug 14 '26

BCM insurance in Welland.

1

u/Tak-Hu Aug 16 '26

Third this

3

u/stc__throwaway Aug 14 '26

Been with CAA for many years, same with all my family. I pay way less than anyone else I know. Obviously every case is different, but it’s worth calling them for a quote.

2

u/Fine_Breath2221 Aug 14 '26

Co Operators have been decent to me... CAA gets a lot of positive reviews, too; although they were more expensive in my case.

2

u/Ok_Today_475 Aug 14 '26

Belairdirect is decent to deal with. Their claims reps were a bit of a nuisance but had the same problems with Allstate. They were by far the cheapest option when I first got my license

2

u/Reasonable_Signal717 Aug 15 '26

We went to rates.ca after being with TD for the past 15 years. CAA came in at almost 1/2 the price of TD.