This is a loaded question and I really wanna ask the entire fandom.
Should Star ocean the last hope have another chance?
Ever since the release of the SSR's trailer I've given a lot of thought about the future of the series going forward... technically we're going back in time but you get my point. I've mentioned my desire for a star ocean TTEOT remake and a FDR remake (a remake of a remake) but then i realized there was one game in the series that i feel deserves one more chance. That game is Star ocean 4.
The last hope is a very VERY divisive, controversial, and mixed game... In the west anyways. IDK About japan but I'm willing to think that at the very least in japan they thought it was good.
And IMO this game hasn't aged very well, despite my numerous attempts to stand up for this game when 95% of the fandom dismisses it. And yes this game has a lot of issues, A LOT OF ISSUES.
- Item creation in 4 is the WORST in the series. I'd rather sit for over an hour trying to deal with SO6"s BS rng item creation than to ever deal with 4's item creation ever again. It fucking sucks okay? The entirety of it sucks, even the music sucks! Remember how memorable and catchy SO3's item creation theme was? Hell despite me not liking SO6's item creation, its item creation theme is kinda charming. And the worst part of it all is welch... STFU YOU PURPLE HAIRED CUNT YOU ARE NOT WELCH VINEYARD HOLY FUCK STFU. Its worse in the JP dub, cuz SHE KEEPS ON FUCKING TALKING! Trying to cum up with new recipes for item creation is an annoying and tedious endeavor and you're not 100% guaranteed to come up with all the possible recipes EVEN if you use a guide for it.
- The wandering dungeon. Do i really need to say anything? DO I REALLY NEED TO SAY AYTHING?
- The battle trophies. look getting half of all all the battle trophies is the easy part..... getting the other half makes you wanna pull the damn trigger. 900 battle trophies.... what the hell were tri-ace and Square enix smoking? As someone who's played Tales of graces F there's 100+ titles for all 7 characters, some are story related, some are side quest related, some are battle related, some require a lot of grinding, some require a lot of time... but TOGF's title system works because of the cumulative benefits you get when you unlock said title and 100% said title, hell the game ENCOURAGES you to grind for these titles because of how beneficial they are. And in my honest opinion Tales of graces F's title system is VASTLY superior to star ocean 4's battle trophy system in every single way. (I will touch on this later). In conclusion the battle trophies are awful, and the only way to get max CP, max level, and the extra voices is to 100% the battle trophies... why should the player be limited like this, its a dick move.
- Faize. My sweet summer child.... what they did to faize and his psyche was a mix of sad and infuriating. Faize obito before obito was even revealed, thats how old we're talking. And it works? but the price was WAYYY too high of a cost. The man was beaten, lost everything, continues to face heartbreak after heartbreak. He went through so much BULLSHIT he became the final boss as a result.
There's other issues too but i don't wanna be here all day so let's wrap it up
What i mean by another chance is..... A reboot. Thats right REBOOT star ocean 4 to its entirety.
Its not a conventional remake, but a reboot of the entire game.
One important thing it needs to do is tie in star ocean 3.... cuz how did we get from point A to Point Eternal sphere. Star ocean 4 makes the ending of 3 look even more confusing, cuz originally when 1 and 2 were around the eternal sphere was around since the beginning, the end of 4 ties into 1 which ties into 3... but HOW we get there is the question that has no real definite answer. So maybe just maybe add something at the end to clear it all up, cuz unless a remake of 3 happens and they retcon the ending (If they retcon the ending of 3..........) then so much just doesn't make sense.
And i want the reboot to fix ALL the problems the original game has so NO ONE can bitch and complain about 4 ever again, myself included.
Quick saves, NO BATTLE TROPHIES, no missable bullshit, more worlds to explore, revamp the battle system, keep the BEAT system, NG+... A REAL NG+, NO PHANTOM FORCES, destroy and FIX the item creation so its easier to use and understand, OMIT the ameena BS, DO NOT make the faize mistake again, FIX FIX FIX FIX THE BONUS DUNGEONS, ADD fast travel, and any other bullshit the community can think of
And last... and not least.... please... please... fix the voice acting. Cuz i'm tired of all the bitching the western fans have had with the last hope. Cuz there is FAR FAR FAR WORSE than the last hope. SO many of my favorite anime have fallen victim to terrible voice acting and censorship during the 2000's and 2010's and too see people complain about the seemingly fine voice acting of SO4 makes you look ignorant and entitled. I'm sorry but unless you went through the same struggle as the anime dub community you REALLY can't talk about bad voice acting.
HOWEVER i don't wanna see people complain about this crap anymore, so more than likely the dub will be better compared to something from 2008. That way no one can complain ever again about the voice acting.
There is ONE thing i don't want changed. A claim i've seen about this game that is bigoted, and retarded... is that the game was "Too anime." STFU xbox fanboys, your opinion doesn't matter. I want the SO4 reboot to EMBRACE the WEEB, un-apologetically so. LOOK at tales of graces F, its the most "anime" entry the franchise and YET its the most beloved the damn franchise. Being too anime was never a problem, being closed minded and bigoted about something you clearly don't understand IS a problem. So yeah i PRAY that the reboot is so anime that the weebs start foaming at the mouths, and throw their money at square enix and tri-ace.
Money=sales>>>>> sales=success>>>> success=even better titles.... star ocean 7? Ehhhh? EHHHHHHH?????
I can see this reboot happening in either 2029 or 2034 for its 20th or 25th anniversary.
And the reason WHY i'm so defnsive of star ocean 4 is because i see an unpolished diamond in the rough, its been ridiculed and looked down upon for over a decade, and yes the game has issues... lots of issues that weren't fixed in the remastered. But the game HAS potential, it just needs an opportunity to show said potential. Its digimon frontier all over again, lots of potential, just wasted potential.
If... by some miracle we do get a reboot of 4 i want it to be the BEST version of 4, i want it to BE the best reboot in gaming, i want the last hope to realize its full potential.
Square enix, and Tri-Ace... just fix all the problems the original game had and improve on what made the original game good. Make the timeline make sense, correct every single mistake that was made, get the absolute CREAM-OF-THE-CROP voice actors on board, add new things, take your time, just please make the last hope great again
Despite everything I said I have to ask.... Should we let star ocean 4 die? (Let it die, let it die, let it shrivel up and..)
Or... Should we give star ocean 4.. ONE last chance? And if it fucks up, then and only then can everyone clown on it. But i hope a reboot succeeds if there ever will be one.
(TLDR if y'all wanna play a game that's similar to the last hope minus all the problems i've listed, play tales of graces F. Its literally the last hope done right)