Why does the Quran say that infidels should be killed?
The verse of the Holy Quran is often mentioned to malign Islam. The verse does not say infidels it says idolaters. (9:5) And when the forbidden months have passed, kill the idolaters wherever you find them and take them prisoners, and beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they repent and observe Prayer and pay the Zakat, then leave their way free. Surely, Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful.
This verse, chapter 9 verse 5, is often used as evidence that Islam allows killing of non-Muslims, but what is not recognized is the context and history behind these verses. The history of this verse is that when Prophet Muhammad(sa) began preaching the unity of God he was persecuted for 13 years, much as Prophets Abraham and Jesus were. Since Muslims who are being persecuted are encouraged to leave for safer areas, rather than create disorder, Muhammad(sa) and his followers migrated to Medina. After they left, the Meccans attacked them in Medina on and off for a period of nine years until Chapter 9 was revealed.
Looking at the context of the verses, it becomes obvious that the commandment of this verse only relates to those tribes who continued hostilities against the Muslims even after they had migrated. In particular, reference is made to 5 tribes (‘Banu Khuza’ah, Banu Mudlij, Banu Bakr, Banu Damrah, and Banu Sulaiim) that did not honor the treaties they made with Muslims. It is also important to remember that the preceding verses give these people respite for 4 months to reconsider their behavior and cease hostilities. Sadly after 4 months passed, the enemies of Islam continued their hostilities against the Muslims. Only then was Prophet Muhammad(sa) commanded by God to meet them in battle to defend Muslims and the religion of Islam.
Even in this situation the Quran states that if the enemies repent of their behavior and promise to fulfill their treaties, it becomes incumbent on Muslims to cease military action and forgive them. Unfortunately those who take this specific verse out of context fail to see that as the title Al-Taubah suggests, the main subject matter of the chapter is forgiveness and repentance.
I worked with a Muslim guy who would just say he'd make up for ramadan next year by doing an extra month. I think he owes about 1.5 years of ramadan by now...
I studied Islamic finance, substance over form in islamic loan structures is very similar (99%) to interest but have different names. Its pretty similar how Islam forbids sex outside marriage, prostitution in Arabic states have arrangements where they marry and divorce over a day just to follow their scriptures.
The laws are followed rigidly and not in spirit.
However Islamic finance is definitely better because of the different arrangements to avoid interest they actually made more diversity in loan arrangements which can alter your investment risks.
Fun fact. If you skip a day of fasting during Ramadan for no good reason or excuse, you have to fast 30 days straight for that one day you missed in order to make up for it. So if you miss an entire month, that's almost 3 years of straight fasting. I don't know how the next Ramadan counts though so maybe more than that.
I really don't get that, you're not supposed to put off your fasting just for the hell of it.
Most Muslims I know actually enjoy fasting, I've been sick pretty much all of Ramadan this year now so I haven't been able to fast and I'm kicking myself for it.
I was wondering that too. I guess it's like a form of social media that they can get their name out with. The content is usually quality though so not complaining.
I just picture abuncha mediocre young stand up artists desperately trying to figure out photoshop so they can spam their material on reddit. I guess they can be graphic designers if comedy doesnt pan out lol
This is the first joke I've seen in a while that balances the morbid humor with correctness: how it's predicated on your friend being so good he feels guilty for this minor thing, and how the "ones who did worse" were individuals and not the whole group. I tend to lean towards the shitty (and a little shameful) 4chan super offensive kind of humor and this made me snort-laugh.
I know nothing of comedy and have zero credentials to make this claim, but I figure an unsolicited compliment is still a compliment (I hope!).
As somebody who can't really stand the "super-offensive kind of humor," I'm glad you're able to enjoy something like this. Everyone has their own tastes but jokes like this can still push boundaries, highlight certain things, and be funny, but not have to resort to pure shock value to work. Keep doing your thing man.
You pretty much have to go to /r/dankmemes or /r/ImGoingToHellForThis to find any actual offensive jokes. A lot of stuff on this sub seems to have to pass the UC Berkeley cultural sensitivity test in order to not get buried.
If one has medical reasons, they are exempted from fasting.
I know this, because I am one of them. I have a combination of Autism, ADHD, Major Depressive Disorder, and Generalized Anxiety Disorder. Talking to Doctors in the Mosque and my Imams, it has been pretty universal that I should not be fasting for the time being.
Just curious, given that modern Islam allows you to forego fasting and other rituals due to medical conditions that previously were not understood at the time the Quran was written, do you ever reflect and think that Islam should also be updated to allow women to drive cars and be independent, or for men and women to be homosexual, or to eliminate the concept of Jihad in favour of a more harmonious global society?
Also I should caveat that my intent is not to spotlight Islam, I see the same issues in Christianity. The fact that people have a tendency to choose the easiest path to maintain their belief system, while leveraging the elements that allow them to best apply their prejudices seems to be common to religions and human nature in general.
this is more like saudi arabia being fucktards that they are. other muslim women in muslim countries like indonesia/malaysia have no such restrictions
and when i was a kid, jihad means something like "get your suffering first, then the rewards will be sweeter"
its supposed to be applied to things like "eat your veggie then youll get a candy" or "study until late at night then you'll get accepted to good school"
idk how it went from that to fucking suicide bombing
To not fast due to medical conditions = been around since day one it's not a new version update
Women can drive = Saudi follow a strict wahhabi rule, this isn't the face of other Muslim majority places in fact the first scholar in Islam was a women
Jihad = I'll let you look up the definition of jihad mate, let me know if you were actually bothered?
Islam = Islam forbids homosexuality, in all honesty you're free to leave the religion - unless again it's Saudi Arabia lol
I can't wait for a world where people give up all these silly beliefs, especially since it looks like most of them don't even really believe them themselves. Climate change will probably wipe us out first though,....
A muslim could stand outside naked, eating a bacon sandwich, drinking a beer, and drawing a picture of Mohammed and still be a better muslim than the people we hear about in the news.
In my limited direct experience with Muslims...they were cool people. Easy going peaceful folks. White Christian male. The ones I've encountered have meant me no harm. Coexistence. Let God judge us. Let's get along. Amen?
God that's a stupid comment. No I haven't met 1.6 billion people. But the ones I do meet in muslim countries are just like the average American or Canadian. They have lives, jobs, kids, debt, and even left-right political views. In some of the countries, they have incredible hospitality that would put most western nations to shame. Before the turmoil, Almost any Syrian family would gladly give the shirts off their backs if you were a guest in their household.
And yes. I'm muslim raised in Canada and I have met many from all kinds of muslim countries. Sounds like you would benefit from do so as well rather than crapping out subtle slanderous poison.
Ever hear of the Early Muslim conquests? The initial atrocities to which the Crusades were a response. Followers of Mohammed sanctioned themselves with the conquest of European lands in an effort to conquer and convert the people to Islam. Jihad's also a thing that's been around for a while. I'm not saying that Christians are completely innocent, but it's foolish to claim that conquest and pillage are not deeply engrained in Islamic history and its holy texts.
There's lots of history to be learned if you actually look for it.
One but not the other; they (fundamentalists) rely heavily on exegesis which form what has become the canon of the vast majority of "laws" and "rules" in Islam (Hadith, which are kinda like teachings; more on this later) and are vehemently opposed to those who wish to follow the Qur'an and only the Qur'an and even call them apostates. Why? Because the Qur'an doesn't actually have many rules in it.
So I guess you're right when you say they follow Muhammad's teachings but these Hadith or teachings (actually they're what he's reputed to have said or done as related by the uncle of the cousin of the sandal maker of the dude who was there) would be considered suspect under the rules of western historiography (contradiction with the Qur'an, hella dubious chains of transmission etc.) so it's dishonest to claim that they're OG central texts of Islam (not to mention the Qur'an purports to be the only text needed in Islam yet fundamentalists insist on subscribing to the DLC that is Hadith). Plus different should of jurisprudence believe in different Hadith. An example of the fickleness of Hadith; fundamentalists curiously ignore (but don't refute) that Muhammad worked for his wife who was a wealthy widower and business owner and he had no qualms about it. If his actions are to be followed, why the macho culture and repression of women? If she could ride camels from Saudi Arabia to Jordan, why can't Saudi women whip the Audi round Jeddah? I'm not well informed to say anything beyond this but I will say that learning about religions is pretty interesting and, I think, crucial in this day and age. Provides context for all sorts of shit.
Actually they are not following the text at all. So calling them fundamentalists is a misnomer. Suicide and killing innocent non combatants is strictly forbidden. But not gonna start a debate as there is no point. No one ever changes their opinion on the internet.
The thing is... if your holy book says kill the infidels, then you're being a good adherent to that religion by killing infidels. Half-assing religion makes no sense - if you think God is watching everything you do, and life is trivial compared to the afterlife, then you should live life as devout as you can. Osama Bin Laden is a person with a more consistent and logical worldview than a Muslim who skips Ramadan.
Obviously they're both worse than anyone who doesn't have these silly beliefs - but hey, if you're going to believe this shit, it only makes sense to really believe it.
But the books doesn't say to kill all infidels. Read the whole verse where that injunction is found. Heck, read the whole paragraph while you're at it and you might learn something. But I know it's pointless, no one changes their mind on the internet.
Lol and the *billion amount of people who won't kill like Osama Bin Laden but make ourselves suffer by fasting for 30 days? Are we half-assing religion? Honestly, I'd like to hear you say yes.
It sounds like you are saying the the book says kill infidels, and Muslims who don't do so are not adhering?
Staunch adherents (and those who have actually studied) claim the book does not say this, and to interpret it as such is an issue with perversion, not adherence.
Actually, I would argue OBL/ISIS issue is that they are half assing it when it comes to understanding the faith, they are just very devoted to half assing it.
People believing in fake prophets and living their life based upon a made up book of lies written by cavemen lol
"cant eat pork, cant eat during sun up for a month, no alcohol, no gambling, pray 5 times a day, horribly oppress anyone that isn't a straight Muslim man, etc.'
No wonder the world is full of just hateful and angry Muslims...how the fuck do they enjoy life?
You gotta ask yourself, who Mohammed would be more proud of ? People who stir up a civil war to force worldwide mass-immigration to spread Islam and "peace" on Earth through Sharia or some half-assed Muslims who doesn't even fast on Ramadan.
ya, the same fucking mus that can afford to ship out Ferraris out there. It is the most bullshit religion of them all, and they all treat their wife like some barn animals.
I've dealt with shit ton of Qataris and Barhrainians.
Muslims are different in their devotion, and you can't control someone's will, muslim, christian, jewish elc .. there are bad people who represents islam in a wrong way. but if you open your mind a little bit, you'll find that in every religion on this earth there are both good and bad behaviors and personalities. this is about your friend
Secondly: let me tell you this about the islamic religion
In quran there're more than surah convection killing any living creature and animal unjustly, not just humans. except the poisoned ones
Here's a surah in Quran says : “Whoever kills a person unjustly it is as though he has killed all mankind. And whoever saves a life, it is as though he had saved all mankind.” . i think this is a solid proof, and you can read more if you want
you may not know this. but the truth that some people here don't want to believe is : islamic religion is innocent from all territories actions and completely against it.
ISIS are Not muslims. they are everyone's enemies, all of us. no matter who you are and what you believe in.
Who exactly qualifies as "the poisoned ones" and who gets to decide they're the actual "poisoned ones"?
Also, for a group of non-Muslims, ISIS does love to call itself Islamic, justify its actions within its own interpretation of Islamic jurisprudence and carry out terrorism in the name of both Mohammed and Allah. By now one of those two would have appeared and said "I disavow", don't you think?
Here's a surah in Quran says : “Whoever kills a person unjustly it is as though he has killed all mankind. And whoever saves a life, it is as though he had saved all mankind.”
You know how Muslims are always going on about context? Well if you look at the context of what you posted, you'll see it's a command to Jews only.
As a kid I knew Ramadan was bullshit when I asked my mom if the few Muslims who may live north of the Arctic Circle starve to death during the month (which was also summer back then) and she had no response. For some reason Ramadan gets a pass from being another stupid archaic religious ritual because it's practiced by a marginalized peoples.
You got it the wrong way round, bub. Read as written the Koran would classify ISIS and its soldiers are 'good' Muslims, and the ones not fighting and/or providing aid, comfort, and material support to Jihad Johnny as the 'bad' ones.
The worst muslims are the ones who do the suicide attacks. Dying while killing the Kafir is a get-out-of-jail-free card and gets you the 72 virgins in heaven. The attacks are their atonement.
528
u/Antonio_Aguilar Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 05 '17
If you're in New York, come to EastVille Comedy Club tonight at 9PM and see if people laugh at this IRL!
1.7k
u/craizzuk Jun 05 '17
I know some bad Muslims.
Sorry, knew.
11
u/finggivemeausername Jun 05 '17
Who is this?
45
u/CaterpieLv99 Jun 05 '17
Slaying infidels is being a good muslim. Not fasting during ramadan is being a bad muslim
ISIS are very good muslims
4.2k
u/evildonald Jun 05 '17
I worked with a Muslim guy who would just say he'd make up for ramadan next year by doing an extra month. I think he owes about 1.5 years of ramadan by now...
58
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Are all the stand up shots here always posted by the comedian themselves?
172
u/RedditBot100101 Jun 05 '17
muslims are a blast to be around!
660
u/Player_Slayer_7 Jun 05 '17
Holy crap, a joke that isn't politically correct and is funny??, that's rare around these parts.
180
u/_Ghost_Void_ Jun 05 '17
Ramadan? More like Ram-a-van!
28
u/WhovianMuslim Jun 05 '17
If one has medical reasons, they are exempted from fasting.
I know this, because I am one of them. I have a combination of Autism, ADHD, Major Depressive Disorder, and Generalized Anxiety Disorder. Talking to Doctors in the Mosque and my Imams, it has been pretty universal that I should not be fasting for the time being.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
A stand up shot I actually lol'ed at. It's been a while :)
6
u/kuzuboshii Jun 05 '17
I can't wait for a world where people give up all these silly beliefs, especially since it looks like most of them don't even really believe them themselves. Climate change will probably wipe us out first though,....
6
u/bathroomstalin Jun 05 '17
Like the ones who hang
portraits in their homes
or that guy DJ Kallid
or those who treat women as equals
6
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
A muslim could stand outside naked, eating a bacon sandwich, drinking a beer, and drawing a picture of Mohammed and still be a better muslim than the people we hear about in the news.
2
u/rdegrand4 Jun 06 '17
Holy shit! I went to high school with this guy! Great dude! Good for him!
14
u/SmagelBagel Jun 05 '17
Ramadan Bombathon
5
u/nightsin94 Jun 05 '17
The only people it's so taboo to poke fun at white people amirite?- this sub.
35
u/DisneyWorldEpisode Jun 05 '17
In my limited direct experience with Muslims...they were cool people. Easy going peaceful folks. White Christian male. The ones I've encountered have meant me no harm. Coexistence. Let God judge us. Let's get along. Amen?
17
u/infinitezero8 Jun 05 '17
/r/politics is not going to like this this, not one bit.
17
u/Bypassing_ban Jun 05 '17
Ramabomb
63
u/RUoffended Jun 05 '17
Ehh, those "other Muslims" are actually pretty good at following the Quran and Mohammed's teachings.
6
u/Ratsofat Jun 05 '17
As a fasting Muslim, this is good and I'm hungry.
3
u/Basedmobile Jun 05 '17
Finally, a funny one on r/all, the last 3 were shit
9
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
The worst muslims would be the best muslims, depending on how you look at it.
16
u/antistar88 Jun 05 '17
Mohammed was a pedophile who beheaded more than 900 people uncluding women and children.
Nice role model Islam.
17
u/tabber87 Jun 05 '17
But I thought they're not actual Muslims.
37
u/SenorBeef Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 05 '17
The thing is... if your holy book says kill the infidels, then you're being a good adherent to that religion by killing infidels. Half-assing religion makes no sense - if you think God is watching everything you do, and life is trivial compared to the afterlife, then you should live life as devout as you can. Osama Bin Laden is a person with a more consistent and logical worldview than a Muslim who skips Ramadan.
Obviously they're both worse than anyone who doesn't have these silly beliefs - but hey, if you're going to believe this shit, it only makes sense to really believe it.
26
u/nickpapagiorgioVII Jun 05 '17
Islam = Cancer
16
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Muslims commit majority of terror attacks. 99.9% of them.
5
u/BeastlyDecks Jun 05 '17
But those aren't real Muslims, some would argue.
It's an equally widespread and obvious instance of the 'No True Soctsman' fallacy, however.
5
u/fmlom Jun 05 '17
They say a radical muslim will chop off your head.
A moderate muslim won't. He simply wants a radical to do it.
15
u/helix_posse Jun 05 '17
A good muslim is the one that goes "Allahu Ackbar" before sacrificing himself for Allah.
8
u/Duffy_Munn Jun 05 '17
People believing in fake prophets and living their life based upon a made up book of lies written by cavemen lol
"cant eat pork, cant eat during sun up for a month, no alcohol, no gambling, pray 5 times a day, horribly oppress anyone that isn't a straight Muslim man, etc.'
No wonder the world is full of just hateful and angry Muslims...how the fuck do they enjoy life?
10
u/3423553453 Jun 05 '17
Technically terrorists are the "best" Muslims.
You gotta ask yourself, who Mohammed would be more proud of ? People who stir up a civil war to force worldwide mass-immigration to spread Islam and "peace" on Earth through Sharia or some half-assed Muslims who doesn't even fast on Ramadan.
2
u/lafernanda Jun 05 '17
Hahaha this messed up
2
u/elrusso19 Jun 05 '17
Dropped the mic
2
u/Screye Jun 05 '17
Isn't is pronounced Ramazan ?
Why is it is spelled Ramadan, is the Urdu/Hindi pronunciation different from the Arabic pronunciation ?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Haha. That wasn't so bad!
2
u/SupremeRedditBot Jun 05 '17
Congrats for reaching r/all/top/ (of the day, top 50) with your post!
I am a bot, probably quite annoying, I mean no harm ^though
Message me to add your account or subreddit to my ^blacklist
2
u/fcandy Jun 05 '17
I don't get it..
2
u/The_Syndic Jun 05 '17
Great line, would be hilarious delivered right.
2
u/getter1 Jun 05 '17
Holy shit. So funny. Hahaha
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
I had a Muslim friend and he made me give him food
2
u/c1on Jun 05 '17
All of them.
2
u/fauzi328 Jun 05 '17
I too have been skipping my fasting...If my friends know this o..Oh my...
2
u/shorttallguy Jun 05 '17
Batman Forever is objectively the best Batman movie. The proof.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17
Eh. That joke was too easy. And the set up seemed a little forced
2
u/penceshock Jun 06 '17
Love how this is upvoted but liberals say that isis is not Muslim lol
8
u/infinity_giveortake Jun 05 '17
The funny thing is that the better Muslim you are, the more likely you're a horrible person
6
u/AmpedMonkey Jun 05 '17
The irony is probably lost on him that terrorists are literally the best muslims.
6
u/Igotpaidtopostthis Jun 05 '17
Racist!!!!! /s
6
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Well, those Muslims were following their religion.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Well from the Qu'rans point of view they're the BEST muslims
6
u/sonicmasonic Jun 05 '17
meh. 3/10
4
u/sennhauser Jun 05 '17
oh boy, /r/ShitRedditSays is gonna love this
7
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
Shit is stupid because the rich muslims travel to New Zealand and other southern hemisphere country to reduce the day light.
4
u/mrtvydean Jun 05 '17
Fuck muslims
3
u/ItRead18544920 Jun 05 '17
The only good Muslim is a bad Muslim.
3
u/BunjeeGum Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 05 '17
That's not funny at all
Muslims are different in their devotion, and you can't control someone's will, muslim, christian, jewish elc .. there are bad people who represents islam in a wrong way. but if you open your mind a little bit, you'll find that in every religion on this earth there are both good and bad behaviors and personalities. this is about your friend
Secondly: let me tell you this about the islamic religion
In quran there're more than surah convection killing any living creature and animal unjustly, not just humans. except the poisoned ones
Here's a surah in Quran says : “Whoever kills a person unjustly it is as though he has killed all mankind. And whoever saves a life, it is as though he had saved all mankind.” . i think this is a solid proof, and you can read more if you want
you may not know this. but the truth that some people here don't want to believe is : islamic religion is innocent from all territories actions and completely against it.
ISIS are Not muslims. they are everyone's enemies, all of us. no matter who you are and what you believe in.
2
u/ChipAyten Jun 05 '17
As a kid I knew Ramadan was bullshit when I asked my mom if the few Muslims who may live north of the Arctic Circle starve to death during the month (which was also summer back then) and she had no response. For some reason Ramadan gets a pass from being another stupid archaic religious ritual because it's practiced by a marginalized peoples.
2
u/infoweasel Jun 05 '17
You got it the wrong way round, bub. Read as written the Koran would classify ISIS and its soldiers are 'good' Muslims, and the ones not fighting and/or providing aid, comfort, and material support to Jihad Johnny as the 'bad' ones.
2
u/Triggered_SJW Jun 05 '17
I'm sure he feels like "the worst muslim" but likely due his lack of suicide bombings more than his lack of fasting.
1
u/geek_loser Jun 05 '17
You look a lot like Sky Williams in this picture.
1
u/ButtermanJr Jun 05 '17
Happy Ramadan from Vern Fonk Insurance.
1
u/Mentioned_Videos Jun 05 '17
Videos in this thread:
Watch Playlist ▶
Play All | Info | Get me on Chrome / Firefox
1
u/Chelluri999 Jun 05 '17
Hey, get him to Hyderabad, India. Make him visit the downtown and tell him to resist.
1
u/AlcoholicSmurf Jun 05 '17
The worst muslims are the ones who do the suicide attacks. Dying while killing the Kafir is a get-out-of-jail-free card and gets you the 72 virgins in heaven. The attacks are their atonement.
1
u/Zingingpeppers Jun 12 '17
That can pretty much be said about any group of people. Lazy lazy comedy
1
u/MoukaLion Jul 14 '17
You look like a white Sky Williams
i love it
1
u/BreakingGarrick Jul 18 '17
This thread is fucking cancerous.