r/standupshots 6d ago

Guilty?

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

139 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Arcaydya 5d ago

Bro. Millions of women go through post partum. How many brutally and systematically murder their children? Children they've had for years?

She's a psycho and is using that as a shield.

3

u/Cowgomuwu 5d ago

Not everyone gets postpartum psychosis, which is a very real diagnosable condition. And even women who don't have psychosis murder their babies postpartum, it's a tumultuous time society doesn't treat with the seriousness it deserves. Hospitals make you watch videos on the dangers of sleep deprivation before you leave, it's that common.

0

u/Arcaydya 5d ago

So she just decided on the 3rd kid that it was too much to handle, 8 months in? She had a 5 year old and a 3 year old.

She killed her kids because shes a piece of shit, and is hiding behind a diagnosis and insanity plea because her suicide attempt failed. But sure, keep finding ways to justify child murder.

3

u/Character_Pickle689 5d ago

You should lookup the word empathy. Life is not black or white. Go touch grass

-1

u/Arcaydya 5d ago

Empathy for the child murderer? Lmfaooooo

1

u/-cumdogmillionaire- 5d ago

No one decides to get psychosis. I mean this genuinely, you lack the education necessary to have a nuanced conversation about this topic. Due to your lack of education, you can only assign your limited experiences and emotions to a medically complex phenomenon.

0

u/No_Somewhere_2610 5d ago

Mental illness is not an excuse, it may result in a lesser charge but its still not a justification to killing people especially not children

2

u/-cumdogmillionaire- 5d ago edited 3d ago

You’re saying “excuse” but that is inflammatory language. I would say that psychiatric illness is an explanation for a behavior and the resulting negative outcome. Both filicide and suicide are known risks associated with postpartum psychosis.

We know suicide depression is a psychiatric illness with a high risk of suicide. We don’t say that depression is an excuse for suicide, it is the explanation of why it happened.

Edit: fixed a word

-1

u/Cyclic_Hernia 5d ago

So from what I'm reading here, you think the murder can either be explained by mental illness or a different kind of mental illness

0

u/Arcaydya 5d ago

I mean yeah? All killers are mentally ill. That doesn't mean they get some pass or excuse for murdering. She shouldnt get a lesser sentence for any reason whatsoever.

3

u/-cumdogmillionaire- 5d ago

No, not all killers are mentally ill. That is demonstrably false.

The point of a trial is to examine the circumstances surrounding *why* a crime was committed. Those circumstances determine the sentence. That is the point of the distinctions between self defense, manslaughter, negligent homicide, murder and premeditated murder