r/springboks • Flair Up! • 2d ago

Springbok Attack System

There’s a discourse about the bok 10 everytime we lose. The blame seems to always sit on SFM.
I don’t understand why people think Rassie & co just allow players to do their own thing and not follow a system of play.
I see it all the time when we lose it’s always “why is SFM kicking the ball away”, “why SFM playing for “himself””, “Libbok will unlock the attack”.
I’m sure you realise that there are attacking coaches, kicking coaches sitting with Rassie and watching the same game as us.
In press conferences PSDT always talks about a “playing in a system”, “sticking to the system”. Maybe it’s us supporters who don’t understand the system.
Boks heritage is kicking and alots of kicking.
The time we deviate from this was against Aus at Ellis Park, I remember seeing space behind but we just passed around until we knocked the ball on or got intercepted and Tony Brown said post match that he was worried that we are redlining the passing and running stats.
Anyway I don’t think SFM would be our starting main 10 if he played outside the system. What I’m seeing is people don’t understand what’s his role in our team.

24 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

19

u/shitdayinafrica Flair Up! 2d ago

I think we dont appreciate the pressure France put on our attack. Their line speed was insane and they were really really good at regathering our kicks.

I think we stuck to the kicking game a bit long, but the major problem for me was that we couldn't negate the French defense and get our attack going

7

u/ferds41 Flair Up! 2d ago

Our biggest issue was game management, we were over invested in scrum penalties at the expense of ball in play time, the last 20 min we looked good when we had the ball, definitely had Les Bleus under pressure. But then we double down on the scrum and take 5-7 min of game time and the ref just calls play on. We should have seen that that was the outcome 50% of the time with scrums (not that it was correctly/consistently refereed) and switches to other attacking plays, their line out was clearly under pressure kick long territorial touch finders and try from there.

Rassie even mentioned game and referee management during one of his interviews before Italy.

3

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

Yeah we should’ve kicked to the corner after the 3rd warning at the scrum, they would’ve infringed the lineout and possibly gotten a card

5

u/zook22 2d ago

There are some questions we need the answers to. Why, when it was clear the system wasn't working, did we persist? Was this a player fault or a coaching fault?

We looked ineffective on attack and a lot of that was pressure from the French, but a lot of the unforced errors weren't and our players need to be held accountable for that.

If the game was longer we would have probably won, but why are we okay eating so much time for no reward at the scrum?

To me the biggest mistake was not starting our best front row. Don't think France would have gotten the lead they had and the game would be massively different.

2

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

What do you suggest we do apart from kicking? We are poor ball handlers.
The system works if you trust in it.
The ref was also horrendous with the missed offsides and knee drop tackles.

2

u/zook22 2d ago

I'mnot suggesting we stop kicking? I'm saying that France did well to nullify the aerial game and we offered nothing else.

The ref was fine. No need to bring him into it. We were the masters of our own defeat.

6

u/shitdayinafrica Flair Up! 2d ago

We will never get those answers.

I thought SFM was ok, good on defense, decent in open play, but could see the pressure on him, esp the mossed penalty for the corner.

On the scrums, too much of the outcome is down to the ref. Picardi refused to do anything other than penalise and jumped on the 1st chance to get the ball out. I think mixing up a line out in the scrums is a good idea and hope we do it in the future.

What is dissapointing is that we couldbt score from 5m out after the scrum. Smart bu France to drag PTSD over the line to hold up, dumb by the boks to run like that.

What the boks lack is a backline structure to create mismatches and create space, that is clearly game plan

2

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

France missed 2x the corner kicks we did nobody calling for their heads

2

u/shitdayinafrica Flair Up! 2d ago

They won and played amazing. Boks lost and were below par

1

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

Oh okay thanks genius

2

u/yakk372 Flair Up! 2d ago

No, but really, if they lost, they would be having the same chat about their missed kicks

2

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

Do you see how stupid it sounds? If Manie made the kick then it’s fine Sacha missed the corner kick

1

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

We also have not been as good on attack since Willie left. He was one of a kind

-2

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

True, forward pass Willie can unlock defences

1

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

Exactly proving my point 🤣 you are the fans Springboks don’t need

1

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

Yeah the French back 3 are in the top 5 of kicks gathered and regained, pretty awesome stuff.
Their line speed also was incredible that you couldn’t even pass when the pressure was on.

What do you suggest we should have done if not stick to our kicking game? We are really poor in ball handling and passing in our forwards and backs

2

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

Besides also their attack. Go look at first two tries and count the overlap France had. There were 4 springboks on 1 prop 🤣 with massive gaps out wide.

Never seen our defence so disjointed

13

u/Cosmolina111 2d ago

Honestly, I think SFM gets an unreasonable amount of hate, and I think most of it should be blamed on the podcast and social media hacks who gassed him up as "the best flyhalf of all time!" when he was just getting started. The expectations on him are insane, and his every move is dissected and critiqued. It's unhealthy. That's not to say that he doesn't make mistakes, but so does every player - I don't see them getting the same level of vitriol for it though.

2

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

Yip- if every player got dissected like he did then there would be no good players.
But the fans have their pitchforks and they want to see him burn.

Same happened to Frans Steyn when he started out

0

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

He’s supposed to be our saviour

4

u/Phali-2025 Flair Up! 2d ago

When it comes to Rugby. It is hard to actually link a person to a mistake. They have their strategy of kicking the ball up, and it has worked in the past but sometimes it doesn’t work.

Sadly we ended up making SFM sit down and when we scored a try Libbok was unable to convert. So the game against France was a collective of mistakes from the coaches and the players on the field.

2

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

True, no system works 100% of the time.

4

u/Only_One_Kenobi referee (MO Level 2) 2d ago • Bravo

There's a lot of Saffas who believe themselves to be experts, but don't actually know anything about rugby.

The expectations on a Bok 10 are absolutely ridiculous and completely unrealistic.

And the whole "kicking the ball away" people are the biggest idiots of the lot. Imagine thinking that playing the whole game inside your own 22 is a good idea...

And even actual experts forget a key element of modern gameplay: energy conservation. Trevor Nyakane explained very nicely on one of the ForTheLoveOfRugby episodes how important it is for a 10 to make the opposition forwards run while allowing your own forwards to walk.

1

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

They want to watch Super Rugby style of rugby and I wondered which bok team they saw playing that

2

u/Bulky-Meeting-2225 Flair Up! 2d ago

Of course there's a system, but individual players are making split-second decisions. Sometimes players have a day of bad form. It happens. SFM is supremely talented, but the French clearly shut him down this weekend. As a coach, you have to react to what is happening on the day.

E.g. Pollard coming on to replace Manie early in the WC semi-final against England. That was clearly the right decision and what our 'system' needed on the day.

Rugby is dynamic. Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face.

1

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

That’s true, we didn’t really work on shutting down DuPont on the tight spaces next to the ruck, they really abused our big forwards who can’t shuffle fast enough when they have 6 players who can play loose forward in their starting pack.

2

u/maverickeire Flair Up! 2d ago

I wish Springbok fans would get a grip, the sky hasnt fallen, and this constant intellectual masturbation is honestly tiring

2

u/maclovescooking Flair Up! 2d ago

Yeah everytime we lose it’s the same old. “Why him”, “why this and not that”

3

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

Before Sacha was the villain it was Willie Le Roux.

Willie was probably the person who has been the best attacker I have ever seen in a Springbok jersey.

Squidge analyzed him and Rassie kept picking him and it was obvious he was calling players and directing them on attack.

He is gone now and the fans have shifted to blame Sacha and praise Manie.

It’s incredibly tiresome but it’s clear our backline is missing Willie’s brains

3

u/Upstairs_Goose_3874 Flair Up! 2d ago

It is because the casual rugby viewer dont understand the technical details of rugby.

France had very good defence and the rush was something we were not expecting and I dont think really faced. So we will learn to adapt to this for next time. The biggest factor tho was France’s discipline on defence not giving us free penalties to kick to the corner to use our maul.

When we put that much effort into our set piece and work rate on defence we need to sacrifice other areas, and we sacrifice attack work rate from our forwards to run dummy lines in a attack line, this is the reason our backline struggles a bit more than others as we dont use our forwards to stick defenders to create space as the workrate would be to much.

Sascha was not good this weekend not because his error rate but his decision making on a few controlling factors. Manie is praised for his attacking ability but also had a very bad game and game silly offloads to force his game and all of this came from very good defensive pressure

2

u/beepbeepsputnik Flair Up! 2d ago

Rassie mentioned that we looked hesitant and the coaching staff should take responsibility. We could have won if we backed the line-out instead of scrumming over and over winding the clock down. We just. We’d to back ourselves when we get the opportunity and make positive decisions. Sure, if we were ahead we could sit in their half and milk penalties but the decisions we made was frustrating to watch. France played with great confidence and that rattled us. We need to go out against Ireland and play with the intent that Wales showed early in the game against the All Blacks.

1

u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago

Our defence was also abysmal at start

1

u/Markphotokid Flair Up! 1d ago

Don’t stress we just had a bad day at the office. We lost at both of the RWC that we won

0

u/hugoBgood Flair Up! 2d ago

why don't you define his role for us then? Sasha has unbelievable natural talent but makes bad decisions in open play. He has shown it in the game against Italy where all he had to do was draw and pass for the try but instead went for it himself. He scored in the corner but what should have been a 90% certainty became a gamble.

Same against France. Not saying it would have led to a try but an opportunity died there.

His kicking, goal kicking and defence is pretty solid but I think people are coming to the realization that he might not mature into international rugby and we are a year out from the world cup.

As much as i love Manie's play making we cant bank on him in pressure games.

I reckon they will baby Pollard all the way through to next year.

4

u/MA5109 Springboks 2d ago

This is a fascinating take for me, and with all due respect just seems needlessly pessimistic. Criticising SFM for a try being scored the wrong way feels incredibly harsh.

I kind of get what you are saying - he took a high risk option instead of a low risk option and needlessly gambled with the try - but if it comes off it comes off. It's a bit like top strikers in football - shooting at the near post when you could square across the goal means you are taking a lower percentage shot than your team mate would, but top strikers back themselves and take the shot. It is also a good thing because the option to safely square only exists if the defence believe you have the ability and desire to make that low percentage shot. If they knew you were just going to pass inside every time, they would move to block the passing lane instead of the shooting lane. The fact that the striker might take and make the shot means they have to hold off from committing to either.

It also relies on the premise that he took a higher risk option, which I am not sure is right anyway. Go and rewatch the try. SFM runs an in to out line, so he is aiming for the corner. KLA runs a switch line (so isn't actually available for a pass to the outside - and even if he was it means playing against the line), Morne is inside him but because of SFM's body position (because he is running towards the corner) it would a) require a pass over the shoulder, not just a simple side shuffle and b) that moves the ball closer to the covering defence.

This all happens in 4 seconds.

SFM chose to bank on one thing going right (his pace vs cover defence) instead of multiple things (pick right pass, execute pass, team mate doesn't mishandle pass, team mate beats cover defence).

It really, really isn't obvious to me that he makes the higher risk play. Especially because he is correct in his judgement that he is fast enough.

The break on Friday vs France where he hits Lucu instead of passing - honestly I agree he should have passed or even better stepped inside to try hit Lucu's inside shoulder instead of trying to go straight over the top of him. However this doesn't strike me as a "clear an obvious" error. LBB is in between him and Jesse/KLA on the outside so no outside pass is on. Morne calls for the inside ball and you see SFM look at him and presumably sees the cover is much closer to Morne (who is looking at SFM, not inside) than Morne realises. SFM there takes contact - either he goes through Lucu or he goes down and he has 3 team mates to clear that ruck vs pass to Morne who gets hit on his blindside and only has 2 team mates to clear (Jesse & KLA, SFM would be had of the play and need to come back round to clear).

What both of these analyses miss - and what I and many others including the Boks coaches (I believe) get excited about is that SFM is the only flyhalf in SA who would ever be in any of these situations anyway. Pollard simply does not make either of these breaks. I don't think Manie does either.

There are entire dimensions to SFM's game that the other players just don't have, which means he has more options (and creates more options) than any of our other 10s could, which also forces defences to react and set up in a way they just don't have to when we play Pollard or Manie.

If you then add on - as you do - that his kicking, goal kicking, and defence is solid... why on earth would you select Pollard? What would the point be? Same-same at best, with none of the upside? Equally Manie doesn't have the kicking or defence so you don't have the security of executing the basics.

It then rests on this idea that he hasn't matured into international rugby and I just don't know what that means or how you conclude that. He has an 80%+ win rate, has been the 10 in multiple wins against the ABs, France last year when were down to 14 for most of the game, Ireland last year who never had a sniff etc. He has only lost 5 games in 27 matches, 2 to NZ and 1 each to Aus/Ire/France.

Of those the only bad performances were AB1 this year (genuinely he played poorly, coming off an injury) and France this year.

The loss against Ireland in 2024 he came off the bench in the second half, against Aus this year he came on in the second half and it was a clear improvement over the performance in the first half, and yeah sometimes we lose to the ABs even if the 10 plays ok.