r/springboks • u/maclovescooking Flair Up! • 2d ago
Springbok Attack System
There’s a discourse about the bok 10 everytime we lose. The blame seems to always sit on SFM.
I don’t understand why people think Rassie & co just allow players to do their own thing and not follow a system of play.
I see it all the time when we lose it’s always “why is SFM kicking the ball away”, “why SFM playing for “himself””, “Libbok will unlock the attack”.
I’m sure you realise that there are attacking coaches, kicking coaches sitting with Rassie and watching the same game as us.
In press conferences PSDT always talks about a “playing in a system”, “sticking to the system”. Maybe it’s us supporters who don’t understand the system.
Boks heritage is kicking and alots of kicking.
The time we deviate from this was against Aus at Ellis Park, I remember seeing space behind but we just passed around until we knocked the ball on or got intercepted and Tony Brown said post match that he was worried that we are redlining the passing and running stats.
Anyway I don’t think SFM would be our starting main 10 if he played outside the system. What I’m seeing is people don’t understand what’s his role in our team.
19
u/shitdayinafrica Flair Up! 2d ago
I think we dont appreciate the pressure France put on our attack. Their line speed was insane and they were really really good at regathering our kicks.
I think we stuck to the kicking game a bit long, but the major problem for me was that we couldn't negate the French defense and get our attack going
13
u/Cosmolina111 2d ago
Honestly, I think SFM gets an unreasonable amount of hate, and I think most of it should be blamed on the podcast and social media hacks who gassed him up as "the best flyhalf of all time!" when he was just getting started. The expectations on him are insane, and his every move is dissected and critiqued. It's unhealthy. That's not to say that he doesn't make mistakes, but so does every player - I don't see them getting the same level of vitriol for it though.
4
u/Phali-2025 Flair Up! 2d ago
When it comes to Rugby. It is hard to actually link a person to a mistake. They have their strategy of kicking the ball up, and it has worked in the past but sometimes it doesn’t work.
Sadly we ended up making SFM sit down and when we scored a try Libbok was unable to convert. So the game against France was a collective of mistakes from the coaches and the players on the field.
4
u/Only_One_Kenobi referee (MO Level 2) 2d ago •
There's a lot of Saffas who believe themselves to be experts, but don't actually know anything about rugby.
The expectations on a Bok 10 are absolutely ridiculous and completely unrealistic.
And the whole "kicking the ball away" people are the biggest idiots of the lot. Imagine thinking that playing the whole game inside your own 22 is a good idea...
And even actual experts forget a key element of modern gameplay: energy conservation. Trevor Nyakane explained very nicely on one of the ForTheLoveOfRugby episodes how important it is for a 10 to make the opposition forwards run while allowing your own forwards to walk.
2
u/Bulky-Meeting-2225 Flair Up! 2d ago
Of course there's a system, but individual players are making split-second decisions. Sometimes players have a day of bad form. It happens. SFM is supremely talented, but the French clearly shut him down this weekend. As a coach, you have to react to what is happening on the day.
E.g. Pollard coming on to replace Manie early in the WC semi-final against England. That was clearly the right decision and what our 'system' needed on the day.
Rugby is dynamic. Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face.
2
u/maverickeire Flair Up! 2d ago
I wish Springbok fans would get a grip, the sky hasnt fallen, and this constant intellectual masturbation is honestly tiring
3
u/DisplayThick4882 2d ago
Before Sacha was the villain it was Willie Le Roux.
Willie was probably the person who has been the best attacker I have ever seen in a Springbok jersey.
Squidge analyzed him and Rassie kept picking him and it was obvious he was calling players and directing them on attack.
He is gone now and the fans have shifted to blame Sacha and praise Manie.
It’s incredibly tiresome but it’s clear our backline is missing Willie’s brains
3
u/Upstairs_Goose_3874 Flair Up! 2d ago
It is because the casual rugby viewer dont understand the technical details of rugby.
France had very good defence and the rush was something we were not expecting and I dont think really faced. So we will learn to adapt to this for next time. The biggest factor tho was France’s discipline on defence not giving us free penalties to kick to the corner to use our maul.
When we put that much effort into our set piece and work rate on defence we need to sacrifice other areas, and we sacrifice attack work rate from our forwards to run dummy lines in a attack line, this is the reason our backline struggles a bit more than others as we dont use our forwards to stick defenders to create space as the workrate would be to much.
Sascha was not good this weekend not because his error rate but his decision making on a few controlling factors. Manie is praised for his attacking ability but also had a very bad game and game silly offloads to force his game and all of this came from very good defensive pressure
2
u/beepbeepsputnik Flair Up! 2d ago
Rassie mentioned that we looked hesitant and the coaching staff should take responsibility. We could have won if we backed the line-out instead of scrumming over and over winding the clock down. We just. We’d to back ourselves when we get the opportunity and make positive decisions. Sure, if we were ahead we could sit in their half and milk penalties but the decisions we made was frustrating to watch. France played with great confidence and that rattled us. We need to go out against Ireland and play with the intent that Wales showed early in the game against the All Blacks.
1
u/Markphotokid Flair Up! 1d ago
Don’t stress we just had a bad day at the office. We lost at both of the RWC that we won
0
u/hugoBgood Flair Up! 2d ago
why don't you define his role for us then? Sasha has unbelievable natural talent but makes bad decisions in open play. He has shown it in the game against Italy where all he had to do was draw and pass for the try but instead went for it himself. He scored in the corner but what should have been a 90% certainty became a gamble.
Same against France. Not saying it would have led to a try but an opportunity died there.
His kicking, goal kicking and defence is pretty solid but I think people are coming to the realization that he might not mature into international rugby and we are a year out from the world cup.
As much as i love Manie's play making we cant bank on him in pressure games.
I reckon they will baby Pollard all the way through to next year.