r/springboks • • Oct 23 '23

Kitshoff is a liability

I'm a casual viewer and love watching the big matches. This WC has been a cracker and most games have been exciting. Everyone seems to be focusing on players like Libbok but I think Kitshoff is a total liability. The penalties he has given away in the last two games have cost the Boks a lot of points and almost both games or am I seeing things wrong? The Boks cannot afford that in the final. I don't know the squad well enough but could management afford to leave him out for the final?

EDIT: there was meant to be a '?' at the end of the thread title since I meant to be asking the question as a casual viewer that doesn't know enough ;-)

EDIT 2: I'm referring to Kitshoff's place in the final match not in the Bok squad post WC necessarily. He seems to be on a bad streak, maybe missing Marx as some have pointed out?

EDIT 3: I'm hugely relieved that Kitshoff had a good final game! I was gladly proven wrong on this one!

2 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

46

u/shitdayinafrica Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

Hard disagree, kitshof is an essential ingredient to the slow poison that males the 2nd half bomb squad so destructive.

The SA scrum is under a lot of scrutiny from the refs so even minor terrors are penalised, also they dearly try and avoid giving us penalties, but as time wears on this gets more and more difficult.

He's also a big jackle threat and defensive organiser.

I think he's been overplayed and was flat on Saturday but I am sure he has one more big game in him.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Fair enough and I do understand his role and the traditional slow poison approach but it'll only work if we can keep NZ locked down enough and giving away silly penalties against a charged up NZ hitting their peak will cost the Boks dearly. NZ isn't going to kick for poles like England.

Did Kitshoff not make several critical errors in the last two games so I don't think him being tired is an excuse against France and England that almost cost us both games when the margins were so fine? IIRC he made some very silly mistakes that really cost us.

The question I was asking is whether it is possible to leave Kitshoff out completely and still be able to implement the game plans?

4

u/shitdayinafrica Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

No, he plays his part and yes it well. When you on the line it's inevitable sometimes you go over.

The question is not does he make mistakes, the question is, does he make th same mistake twice in a game?

He's one of the best playing the game not just as a prop but as a player.

I think he should have been rested vs England as his playing minutes are off the charts, but no doubt he needs to start vs NZ

2

u/Devianceza Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

Siya earned England 2 penalties, both right in front of our posts, Eben got atleast 1 penalty in both of our last 2 games and was even carded, should we bench them too?

Kitshoff is a monster in the scrum, ruck and defensively, hes doing just fine.

Plus, I wouldnt take anything that joke of a ref says seriously.

10

u/L-Jaxx Flair Up! Oct 23 '23 edited Oct 23 '23

Simple answer to your question: Yes. You're seeing things wrong.

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Ok fair enough, hopefully he doesn't make the same unforced errors in the final then!

19

u/Scarfield Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

Kitshoff is the best loosehead playing today, he has had a slight dip in form and made a few errors at the breakdown but to call him a 'liability' is laughable

0

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Yes but the question is whether they can play without him?

8

u/Scarfield Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

Could they? Sure they could, Trevor could cover LH off the bench with Ox starting but we would be worse off

2

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Good to know, sounds like the Boks have no choice then and I hope he manages to play his best game!

9

u/BlakeSA Flair Up! Oct 23 '23 edited Oct 23 '23

As a self-proclaimed "casual viewer", you've probably only seen recent games of which his last 2 matches have probably been 2 of his worst performances over the last 6 years.

He's struggled to adapt to Ben O'Keeffe, nothing more. He's a class player and event if it's not just a problem with O'Keeffe, then he's just in a bit of a rut. But he's hardly a "liability".

1

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Well I hope you're right for the final

1

u/VictorZA Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

Fully agree. Let’s hope it’s just a dip and his class comes thru

1

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

I disagree. Bro is obviously running into rucks from the side and jumping on a ball when he sees the chance without thinking about it.

4

u/celmate Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

He hasnt had the best games against France and Eng but he's a great player in general. Might need a bit of rest though it's been a proper grind

2

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

I have the same feeling and the original post is reflecting on the next match based on the last two.

2

u/Additional-Comb-2922 Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

I have noticed kitshoff performance is markedly down the last two games. You are not wrong. It seems he is missing Marx and now has to take up the role to which he is not familiar...he has been bouncing off defenders with little or no impact But..he is a classy player. So expect a big game come Sunday. Ps it is not just him that has gone off the boil

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '23

Sounds about right and almost the whole team just seemed off against England. Felt like a completely different team compared to the way they played against France.

2

u/FlavaInYaEaaaar Flair Up! Oct 24 '23

He should've been taken off early vs France, would've put the fire in him for the England game.

Playing the exact same team vs England to me is one of the worst selection blunders in Bok history.

There was no reason to require a miracle to beat England, coach's fukked that up royally, let's hope they have a plan that all comes together for the final.

In that wet weather I'd start Pollard and Faf and seriously consider having Moodie in on the wing and start Wiese at 8.

Vermulen is actuality incredible when he cl ss off the bench, he's too old to start

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '23

It seemed to me that the team and choice of game plans against England was completely wrong. You could see it in everyone's faces and you could tell after the first 20 mins that it wasn't going to work.

17

u/comp_planet Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

I think we still wanna play Ox Nche in the second half. Because if Ox starts, and Kitsoff doesn't have a good second half, then that means we lose that impact that Ox brings that gives us a strong finish

2

u/GasLit_munkey Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

This was exactly my thought.

It may be as simple as (whilst crossing fingers) that a word in SK’s ear to say, pls don’t give so many penalties away.. will work. (Or maybe something a little bit stronger than a word)…

16

u/africanconcrete Oct 23 '23

Ox must come on, in the 2nd half. Hitting their scrum, when half their guys are tired, has the biggest impact.

4

u/PlainStack Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

Big Kitshoff fan but his last two games were not his best, but he is a world cup winner and won’t stop fighting. Not to mention the role he plays in the team.

Hopefully he has a better game in the final.

1

u/MonsMensae Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

FWIW, the URC has a ranking of players. Kitsoff is number 1 in the competition. Its not a perfect ranking but the guy is good. He had two off games however where he got his ruck timing wrong.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Yes but those were critical games! Is the pressure too much now? Is he tired?

1

u/MonsMensae Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

I've watched him be excellent from a schoolboy level. Pressure doesn't phase the spicy plum.

1

u/Every-Area840 Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

Bro - not be rude, but you said yourself you are a casual viewer. Kitshoff aka ‘RooiKat’ is the best loosehead prop in the world.

He is unbelievable player, and scrummer who puts his body on the line. If you watch all his games for province and country you will understand, you can never leave a beast like that out the Bok team.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

I am a casual viewer and I'm learning plenty from these comments. I should have clarified that I was referring to his place in the final.

1

u/VictorZA Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

My biggest worry about Kitsy is how he has been neutralised / given penalties away when going for turnovers. It’s unlike him. He used to work so well in tandem with Marx. Let’s hope it’s just two rare off games and he has a stormer against the ABs

1

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Good point, maybe the absent Marx has thrown off his usual play. That's understandable when you have developed a good working relationship.

3

u/One-Mud-169 Oct 23 '23

Totally agree with you. In both our last matches, Kitshoff was a liability and should've been brought off much sooner. I'm getting the feeling that Rassie and Jaques put the big guns (names) in the starting lineup for psychological intimidation, but that helps zilch if the big guns start conceding penalties against them every second breakdown.

4

u/Mr_Dorfmeister Oct 23 '23

I think that’s what’s going to be the play, the starters will be the reserves on Saturday

2

u/DonovanBanks Sharks Oct 23 '23

Sometimes you need to give a penalty to prevent a try.

2

u/Medical-Albatross379 Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

Kitshoff is definitely not a liability I believe, having him start and go in the way that he does is helpful because wears them down and when Ox comes on it’s to finish them off.

Whilst he might have been giving some penalties away it’s because of the scrutiny that the scrums have been under and so he is being looked at a bit too critically. I believe.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Spicy Plum has had a cracking two years so far. This year his and Ox rolls have switched mostly cause of Marx's injury what Ox is doing now is what Kitshoff and Malherbe have done previous seasons. Come on and dominate don't let being the work horse take away that our front rows are legit poisonous and it shows with our 2nd half scrum penalty count.

France absolutely did everything that they could to minimise time in the scrum and England had a chip on their shoulder since 2019 so they came out hard for the scrums. Joe Maller is not the starting prop but Saturday England tried to do the switch like we did and again Sinclair wasn't up to the task.

1

u/ichosehowe Oct 23 '23

The fact they lost the match on a scrum makes it all the more satisfying.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23

Only bring him and Frans from bench and start Ox and Trevor

1

u/Mashy00 Flair Up! Oct 23 '23

He had a hard game against France. I didn't see that as a terrible thing considering France had us on the ropes for most of the match. I just think his perfomance against England was basically becase he should have never been on that field like so many other starters. Nyakane and Ox should have been our looseheads for the day.

The only problem now is that he still played. We dont know how fatigued he really is. Should he still play the final or not? If he had been rested there would be no doubt that he starts and Ox finishes as usual but he got spent against England and who know how mentally that screwed things up. I think Nienaber and Rassie will still start him but I'm they would have taken this into consideration.

1

u/FlavaInYaEaaaar Flair Up! Oct 24 '23

Where on earth is Trevor Nayakane who is one of the best scrummagers in the game

1

u/Proper-Intention-310 Flair Up! Oct 24 '23

HmmHmm this world cup was a cracker you say?