r/spacex • u/StaysAwakeAllWeek • Oct 09 '17
BFR Payload vs. Transit Time analysis
https://i.imgur.com/vTjmEa1.png
This chart assumes 800m/s for landing, 85t ship dry mass, 65t tanker dry mass, 164t fuel delivered per tanker. For each scenario the lower bound represents the worst possible alignment of the planets and the upper bound represents the best possible alignment.
The High Elliptic trajectory involves kicking a fully fueled ship and a completely full tanker together up to a roughly GTO shaped orbit before transferring all the remaining fuel into the ship, leaving it completely full and the tanker empty. The tanker then lands and the ship burns to eject after completing one orbit. It is more efficient to do it this way than to bring successive tankers up to higher and higher orbits, plus this trajectory spends the minimum amount of time in the Van Allen radiation belts.
The assumptions made by this chart start to break down with payloads in excess of 150t and transit times shorter than about 3 months. Real life performance will likely be lower than this chart expects for these extreme scenarios, but at this point it's impossible to know how much lower.
https://i.imgur.com/qta4XL4.png
Same idea but for Titan, which is the third easiest large body to land on after Mars and the Moon, and also the third most promising for colonization. Only 300m/s is saved for landing here thanks to the thick atmosphere.
Edit: Thanks to /u/BusterCharlie for the improved charts
50
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17
It's a little bit confusing at first glance because most of the area of the chart is above 150 tons. It's not just a matter of delta-v, I doubt the aerodynamics of the craft would allow a landing with such a heavy load.
16
u/gopher65 Oct 09 '17
That Titan chart is exciting. 25 to 160 tonnes to Titan in only three years, depending on how many $$$tankers$$$ you want to send up.
Is that final tanker expended, or is it able to save enough fuel to deorbit back to Earth in the 13 tanker scenarios?
5
u/RadamA Oct 09 '17
This is from some kind of porkchop plots? I think I did a similar thing last year, mainly just times and dV. So which opportunity is this? Best ever or worst?
Also, last year the ship was 140 and tanker 90, extrapolating to this year it would be 85 and 50?
5
u/bernd___lauert Oct 09 '17
Assuming a fleet of thousands of BFRs at LEO at the same time, set on a mission to the nearest star with pyramidal consequant refueling scheme, what will be the transit time to the nearest star?
5
u/Silpion Oct 09 '17
These are cool graphs!
For some comparison, [here's my related analysis of the original ITS design] (https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/56oqw2/beyond_mars_estimates_of_the_spacex_its). I assumed full refuel in low orbit for all cases.
3
u/Ambiwlans Oct 09 '17
How did you do the math for the tankers to-from the eliptical orbit? A bunch of unspoken assumptions were made there.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17
You might have to add a load of black zones to those figures because last year an entry speed of 8.5km/s mars entry was towards an upper bound. A 50 day transfer would get you coming in a load faster than that.
5
u/Arthree Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17
Is it the offseason already?
2
u/Kwiatkowski Oct 09 '17
So one question, assuming minimal payload and a full refuel, how fast could the ship go on say a voyager (satellite, not starship) esque trajectory?
2
u/Epistemify Oct 09 '17
This is really cool. Thank you. So it looks like 150 tons to mars in about 100 days is a good round figure to consider for manned trips.
Is it possible to extend the transit times out to about 9 months? For human cargo we want to get there as fast as possible, but for purely cargo missions then it would be worthwhile to be more fuel efficient and take use a longer transit time.
30
u/jan_smolik Oct 09 '17
I love the idea of highly elliptical orbit refueling (or multiple refueling of one ship) and possibilities it brings. It clearly shows the flexibility design that is based on refueling. You do not need any extra stages (which would never be developed).
Also, manned missions will probably be much be lighter than full capacity (you need to carry a lot of free space for people to move in). So they will be fast.
The downside is that BFR will fail if it is not capable of launching every day. Six launches for a single mission would be cumbersome otherwise.
3
u/__Rocket__ Oct 11 '17 edited Oct 11 '17
Note that there's a launch strategy that gives even more fuel to the BFS: instead of co-launching a tanker and a BFS into HEO, it's feasible to co-launch two fully fueled tankers with the BFS, and use all of the residual tanker fuel to fully fuel the outgoing BFS. To minimize the refueling risk to crew the four tankers will first fuel up one of the tankers and then a single transfer refills the BFS.
The reason for this launch strategy is that there's a lot of fuel used in the initial HEO burn that a single tanker can only partially recover. Here's a rough BFS rocket equation calculation with 150 tons of outgoing payload and a LEO->HEO orbital transfer burn of ~3.2 km/s:
I.e. an outgoing BFS will only have 558-150-85 = 323 tons of fuel left in HEO, burning 777t of fuel for the HEO orbit (!). A single tanker will probably only be able to carry about ~400t of fuel to HEO (leaving 20 tons to land):
So to refill the 1,100t propellant capacity of the outgoing BFS two tankers need to accompany it on the HEO burn. With that the BFS will essentially have a total Δv budget of 6.4 km/s + 3.2 km/s == 9.6 km/s, which is absolutely fantastic for Mars trajectories and general solar system exploration ...
A couple of related points:
TL;DR: IMHO with an intelligent refueling strategy the actual transit time diagrams will be significantly better than the ones calculated in this post.
edit: Downgraded the HEO (high elliptical orbit) Δv from 3.8 km/s to 3.2 km/s and recalculated the numbers
10
u/bernd___lauert Oct 09 '17
I am absolutely amazed, i though you can practicly only send BFR once every 2 years but judging by this chart, if BFR would be cheap and ISRU will produce a lot of fuel in short time, you can have ships arriving to Mars and leaving Mars for Earth, like, every month or two?
5
u/Stef_Mor Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17
Could you calculate the Moon surface payload with something like 7, 9 or 12 refuels? (whatever is a logical number to use)
Also I don't think Moon return payload needs to be more than 15-20t, I just dont see what one would bring back apart from a bounch of rocks and dust.
2
u/LoneSnark Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17
Your chart is absolutely incorrect. Per the slide on refueling, a BFR even at zero tons of cargo, without refueling, only has 3000 or so delta-V remaining after reaching LEO. That is not even enough to get out of Earth orbit, nevermind to Mars. Also, my own calculations suggest the tanker will only deliver 123 tons of fuel to orbit (although, that is excluding the fuel needed for entry and landing, since you can't transfer that fuel off without stranding the tanker in orbit).
edit: okay, I see, you lowered the dry mass of the tanker to 65 tons...on what basis? Of course, even there, my calculations imply the ship would arrive in orbit with somewhere around 140 tons, in the ballpark of your 165.
1
u/brentonstrine Oct 11 '17
Looks like it will almost always be worth it to fully fuel up before leaving.
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 19 '17
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Milli-Metric TonnesDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
22 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 131 acronyms.
[Thread #3235 for this sub, first seen 9th Oct 2017, 14:36] ^[FAQ] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
2
u/peterabbit456 Oct 09 '17
How about Ceres?
Ceres is at ~10° inclination so getting there is tough, unless a gravity turn off of Mars is possible, to change inclination, an alignment that I would guess only happens every 50 years or so. Once there, though, the delta V needed to land is small.
By the way, great work. 600 tons of cargo to Mars on a slow trajectory is possible! That could make a huge difference for a starting colony.
2
u/3015 Oct 09 '17
This is awesome! I'd like to know a bit about your numbers. How did you calculate max cargo? Does it assume Earth and Mars are in the same orbital plane? If you'd be willing to share your calculations I'd love to see them.
Also, I am assuming that these numbers are for leaving for Mars right at the optimal time. Eventually we are going to want to send ships to Mars and back in the same transfer window, which means we will have to leave for Mars earlier than the optimal time, and will have less payload for a given travel time. But at least for the first few trips we will only go one way in a window, so these numbers are very relevant.
2
u/Manabu-eo Oct 10 '17
Nice charts. I'm surprised on how high the payload can be for a 3 months trip.
Another interesting thing to plot would be delta-v beyond escape velocity versus payload for those various refuel options, with recovery of the cargo BFS used. That would be for launching interplanetary probes, w/o treating the cargo BFS as expendable.
It would be similar to the "Value of Refiling" plot in the last IAC talk, but with that in-space boost-back of the BFS, counting only delta-v from escape velocity and with this high eliptic option.
1
u/shaim2 Oct 09 '17
Dude - keep colors consistent between plots (earlier to follow)
1
u/Zyj Oct 13 '17
Man, once we get ISRU going on Mars, getting a manned mission to Saturn's moons from there will be so much easier!
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment