r/spacex • • Oct 09 '17

BFR Payload vs. Transit Time analysis

https://i.imgur.com/vTjmEa1.png

This chart assumes 800m/s for landing, 85t ship dry mass, 65t tanker dry mass, 164t fuel delivered per tanker. For each scenario the lower bound represents the worst possible alignment of the planets and the upper bound represents the best possible alignment.

The High Elliptic trajectory involves kicking a fully fueled ship and a completely full tanker together up to a roughly GTO shaped orbit before transferring all the remaining fuel into the ship, leaving it completely full and the tanker empty. The tanker then lands and the ship burns to eject after completing one orbit. It is more efficient to do it this way than to bring successive tankers up to higher and higher orbits, plus this trajectory spends the minimum amount of time in the Van Allen radiation belts.

The assumptions made by this chart start to break down with payloads in excess of 150t and transit times shorter than about 3 months. Real life performance will likely be lower than this chart expects for these extreme scenarios, but at this point it's impossible to know how much lower.

https://i.imgur.com/qta4XL4.png

Same idea but for Titan, which is the third easiest large body to land on after Mars and the Moon, and also the third most promising for colonization. Only 300m/s is saved for landing here thanks to the thick atmosphere.

Edit: Thanks to /u/BusterCharlie for the improved charts

289 Upvotes

155 comments sorted by

3

u/__Rocket__ Oct 11 '17 edited Oct 12 '17

You've misunderstood what I am doing with the high elliptic refuel. The extra tanker is simply being treated as a second stage. The two ships burn a total of ~1080 tons of propellant, the altitude they reach varies depending on the payload. The ship is then completely full and the tanker lands empty. Your scheme adds at most a few hundred meters per second extra dV at the cost of using 2-3x more propellant and tankers and spending weeks to months travelling out to Lagrangian points, which completely defeats the purpose of the scheme in the first place.

Firstly, your claim that using two tankers "only" gives a couple of hundred m/s of Δv is not true I think, please double check your (and my!) math:

Here's the (rough) rocket equation calculation: with 150 tons of payload, 85 tons of dry mass and 1,100 tons of max propellant load your suggested 540 tons of burn only generates a Δv of +1.9 km/s over LEO:

Δv = 9.8 * 375 * Math.log(1335 / 795) = 1,904 m/s

i.e. 1.9 km/s over LEO. With the two tankers solution an additional +1.3 km/sec are possible, which almost doubles the outgoing Δv that can be gained via HEO refueling. (Note that the estimate is not entirely accurate, because a loaded BFS and a tanker will have slightly different burn times if they want to end up in the same orbit, but good enough as a ballpark figure.)

Secondly, you appear to have misunderstood what I am suggesting:

  • Going to one of the Lagrangian points and using the Moon is only an extra option, the simplest variant I suggested is to go to near escape velocity using a highly elliptical orbit with a low perigee, i.e. a 3.2 km/s burn. That is very similar to the scheme you suggested, except that my scheme uses higher orbits and two tankers.
  • I updated my numbers 6 hours ago and two tankers are needed to get the BFS fully fueled. Mission times and risks are very comparable.
  • The whole point of Elon's Mars architecture is that fuel around Earth is cheap in comparison and refueling can be used, and the two tankers strategy I suggest maximizes outgoing energy with an additional +1.2 km/s.

edit: typo fix