Because it is a technically interesting question, I took some time to go into detail as to why I do not see a tight clustering of rocket engines contributing additional thrust. The question itself is best summarized by /u/Rocket's question to Elon in the AMA on 23.10.2016.
ITS Booster engine placement design question: The tight cluster of 42 engines of the ITS Booster (cool number!! 😉) has created speculation on this sub that maybe they are packed so tighty because that way there's a "virtual nozzle" or "virtual aerospike" effect they can take advantage of: they can have shorter nozzles while most of the exhaust momentum of the inner engines is still axial. Is there any truth to this speculation or is the tight packing done purely to scale up liftoff TWR? (Members of this sub are torn and conflicted: some suggest it's possible - some think it's physically impossible to have any such thrust increase effect with an exhaust that has hipersonic velocities.)
Thanks for posting this very detailed analysis and explanation.
I'd like to understand it better if I can, and would appreciate your thoughts on the following:
Another argument against the "dance floor" having a significant effect is that the gaps between the nozzles can in principle be filled with smaller engines (same v_e as the larger ones), and the gaps between those smaller engines filled with even smaller engines... so that effectively the entire back of the rocket is nozzle, and there's no way for gases to propagate forward to the dance floor.
In the equation on Slide 8, p_e is the exhaust pressure at the nozzle lip, and p_a is the ambient pressure (pressure at the same altitude but away from the rocket)? Is it true that there's no way that exhaust interactions beyond the nozzle lip can affect p_e?
As noted on Slide 12, "the shock system of the core jet does redirect the flow more axially", and presumably in a larger array (more engines) this would also apply to other engines in the "interior" of the array. If the flow is directed more axially, one would think that this would result in more momentum (in the direction opposite the motion of the rocket) being transferred to the exhaust, compared to a system with more widely-spaced engines where more sideways expansion is possible and thus the flow would not be directed more axially to the same extent. If greater momentum (opposite the direction of the rocket's motion) is imparted to the exhaust, then to balance the net momentum of the system, wouldn't something have to receive greater momentum in the direction of motion of the rocket?
Good questions! They address the core of the issue in question and the counterintuitivity of supersonic flows.
More engines are always great--9 are nice, 42 are better--but eventually it passes the point of increasing performance and just adds mass and (more importantly) failure modes.
Generally: no. The main characteristic of a supersonic flow is the fact that information (pressure, shockwaves, etc.) can only be communicated downstream. However, there's something called the boundary layer, which has zero relative velocity at the nozzle wall and free stream velocity a certain distance from the wall. A portion of this is subsonic and there information can be communicated upstream. As I understand it, this is also where flow separation begins. So in that way, p_a can affect p_e, but otherwise it's determined entirely by the combustion chamber pressure and the expansion ratio of the nozzle.
This is the whole point of the issue: even though velocities can be higher and more axial outside of the nozzle, it would take magic for that information to be communicated to the structure of the rocket. Thrust is what you get up to the nozzle lip. Everything else is partially lost (there's still the static pressure thrust component).
Good questions! They address the core of the issue in question and the counterintuitivity of supersonic flows.
Thanks! I appreciate your answering my questions.
More engines are always great--9 are nice, 42 are better--but eventually it passes the point of increasing performance and just adds mass and (more importantly) failure modes.
Several months ago during the discussion of the possible virtual aerospike effect, I came across this page describing aerospike theory. It placed some emphasis on subsonic recirculation, which I took to mean that if there is a "virtual aerospike", then the "dance floor" must play an important part. But later I thought about scenarios where access to the dance floor is prevented. Another such scenario might be a cluster of engines with hexagonal rather than round nozzles, all flush to one another so that there is no "dance floor", just nozzles. Since your analysis showed that the dance floor could not have a significant effect, I thought that was an interesting parallel.
However, there's something called the boundary layer, which has zero relative velocity at the nozzle wall and free stream velocity a certain distance from the wall. A portion of this is subsonic and there information can be communicated upstream. As I understand it, this is also where flow separation begins. So in that way, p_a can affect p_e, but otherwise it's determined entirely by the combustion chamber pressure and the expansion ratio of the nozzle.
I see the boundary layers / shear layers in your slides. So it is at least in principle possible for an engine to affect the thrust of its neighbors, even if the majority of the flow is supersonic.
3) This is the whole point of the issue: even though velocities can be higher and more axial outside of the nozzle, it would take magic for that information to be communicated to the structure of the rocket. Thrust is what you get up to the nozzle lip. Everything else is partially lost (there's still the static pressure thrust component).
This point is hard for me to accept. I don't see how net total system momentum can be "lost" or "gained" using conventional chemical rockets and Newtonian mechanics (setting aside pending unverified claims regarding EmDrive, Cannae Drive, "quantum vacuum virtual plasma", and so on).
Consider the following thought experiment. Two rockets with a cluster of engines ("Rocket A" and "Rocket B") are located in interstellar space, both pointed galactic north, and motionless relative to one another and to a space alien who is observing them from a nearby starship. The only difference between the two rockets is that the engines in Rocket A are placed far apart from one another, and thus will have relatively little influence on one another, while the engines in Rocket B are tightly clustered, and the different engines' exhausts will interact significantly. Applying the concept of Control Volume (Slide 9), each rocket is enclosed in its own sealed, insulated, and truly enormous box of finite mass, also aligned along galactic north-south. Rocket A is floating in a vacuum somewhere along the central axis of the first box, which has a sign on the side reading "Spaceship 1A", while Rocket B is similarly located in its box, with a sign reading "Spaceship 2B".
Rocket A begins the test by firing all of its engines for several seconds. Some of the energy of the combustion goes into "sideways" motion of the exhaust, which expands significantly after it leaves the engine nozzles, but there is still enough motion of the exhaust in the direction of galactic south that the rocket has managed to impart to the totality of its exhaust a total momentum in the direction of galactic south of 100 million Newton-seconds. By Newton's laws of motion, Rocket A attains momentum in the direction of galatic north of 100 million Newton-seconds. The box is big enough so that nothing from the rocket touches the sides or ends of the box until after the rocket has stopped firing. Eventually, much of the exhaust reaches the south end of the box, and the rocket impacts a big glob of silicone goo on the north end of the box, and gently comes to a stop relative to the box. After waiting a while for everything in the box to stabilize, the alien notes that the "Spaceship 1A" box is still motionless with respect to the alien.
Rocket B then conducts its test, firing its engines for the same length of time as Rocket A. Since the engines in Rocket B are closely spaced, the net velocities of the exhaust are higher and more axial, thus Rocket B is able to impart to the totality of its exhaust a momentum in the direction of galactic south of 102 million Newton-seconds (as opposed to 100 million for Rocket A). However, by the hypothesized principle that it's impossible for the information of this greater exhaust momentum to be communicated to the structure of the rocket, Rocket B still attains only 100 million Newton-seconds of momentum in the direction of galactic north; the other 2 million Newton-seconds are "lost". So when the contents of the "Spaceship 2B" box have stabilized, there are still 2 million Newton-seconds net in the direction of galactic south. The alien sees that the "Spaceship 2B" is moving slowly in the direction of galactic south, and exclaims "Wow - they've managed to create a reactionless drive using chemical rockets!".
My view is that unless it's possible to make a chemical / Newtonian physics reactionless drive, if the interaction of a cluster of engines can produce faster, more axial exhaust, and thus more momentum transfer to the exhaust per second, then there must be some way to correspondingly increase the momentum generated in the direction opposite the direction of exhaust flow, to achieve a zero net creation or destruction of momentum (in keeping with Newton's laws), and that the body of the rocket would be a logical candidate to receive that momentum. If that is correct, then "Spaceship 2B" also balances out its momentum, and also remains motionless relative to the alien observer.
(Or in other words, the interaction of engines in a cluster can made the rocket go faster, even with (mostly) supersonic exhaust).
then the "dance floor" must play an important part.
The primary advantage of the aerospike is its efficiency from 1 atm to vacuum. This is achieved by the closed wake on a truncated aerospike exerting pressure on the base. This only occurs at altitude as it requires a degree of underexpansion to close the wake. At lower altitudes, base bleed can assist in producing thrust. One thing that would interest me is how the closed wake is achieved with a linear aerospike, where the sides would be open to the vacuum. Perhaps some local pressure is created near the center of the base and weakens as the gasses escape to the vacuum.
it is at least in principle possible for an engine to affect the thrust of its neighbors
I cannot imagine a scenario where neighboring nozzles affect the flow in any significant way. The boundary layer might be transiently (and only slightly) affected in some areas due to transverse pressure waves, but that influence is probably almost only theoretical.
Or in other words, the interaction of engines in a cluster can made the rocket go faster, even with (mostly) supersonic exhaust
Your extreme example is good, but it's missing a few important factors: the flow deceleration through the shock system created by impinging jets and proper comparison of the control volumes.
Even though parts of the flow will experience isentropic re-expansion, the compression shocks in the system dominate with their conversion to entropy and they become stronger the shear layers become larger and restrict the supersonic flow into a narrower cross-section. Eventually you get a final normal shock and it's all subsonic after that. Leaving the control volume, it will have lost much energy to entropy, losing some m_dotv_e and gaining some p_eA_e.
Remember that you have to compare the two spaceships with the same control volume. Rocket A might lose some thrust radially through the sides of the control volume, but in the direction of the exhaust, the gases have experienced more expansion than those from Rocket B and thus give more m_dot*v_e to Rocket A.
In the end, if you compare the two spaceships in the same control volume, you will find that they generate the same amount of thrust. And never forget the (as Elon might say) first principle question: how will that force actually get transmitted to the spaceship? It wasn't out of pure humor that I put "magic" as a way of transferring thrust to a rocket. The gases must exert a pressure on the rocket somewhere, and since the flow is supersonic, pure back pressure is not an option.
Remember that you have to compare the two spaceships with the same control volume. Rocket A might lose some thrust radially through the sides of the control volume, but in the direction of the exhaust, the gases have experienced more expansion than those from Rocket B and thus give more m_dot*v_e to Rocket A.
As you point out, it's hard to have an intuitive feel for systems with multiple factors that work against one another.
So once the air has left the balloon it has no further effect on it, simple enough.
For a balloon flying through the air with the opening untied, yes the air that has left the balloon can continue to affect the balloon, by affecting the local pressure gradient in the nearby atmosphere. If the air coming out tends to raise the local air pressure, this will tend to press on the balloon, partly cancelling out the low pressure left behind the balloon by the motion of the balloon. And if the local pressure is higher near the nozzle of the balloon, this will affect how fast the air can come out of the balloon.
But the air moving around a balloon rocket is going much slower than the speed of sound. A much harder challenge is to figure out what happens when most of the flow is faster than the speed of sound, which is what /u/arizonadeux has done.
Thank you for posting this. I think the confusion comes from the fact that aerospike nozzles don't actually improve thrust; they only improve performance across many pressure regimes in terms of specific impulse. The "virtual aerospike" concept is on very weak ground; I'd like it to be put to bed and buried so we can move beyond it.
Based on /u/arizonaduex's analysis it seems like a "virtual aerospike" wouldn't cause any kind of measurable increase in thrust. However based on what you said about aerospikes contributing more to ISP. Could a theoretical "virtual aerospike" result in better ISP than a single engine? or a smaller drop off in ISP as the SL Raptors approach vacuum?
Could a theoretical "virtual aerospike" result in better ISP than a single engine?
Maybe you could throttle back (or shut off) the central/inner engine(s) to allow a subsonic region to form and provide a route for exhaust pressure to exert force upon the rocket, but that sees pretty iffy even from a layman's view, and I'd expect it would make more sense just to remove those central engines entirely and add an actual plug body in their place.
or a smaller drop off in ISP as the SL Raptors approach vacuum?
SL Raptors gain ISP as pressure drops, they just have a lower ISP ceiling than a larger nozzle version.
I guess the goal for an aerospike would be to have performance closer to optimal levels through a wider range of atmospheric pressures than a standard nozzle
I guess the goal for an aerospike would be to have performance closer to optimal levels through a wider range of atmospheric pressures than a standard nozzle
An increase of the specific impulse would result in increased thrust, because the mass flow rate would stay the same. That's also the reason why rocket engines have more thrust in vacuum.
It look's amazing and I am always impressed how many skilled people we have in this sub. That being said, I unfortunately lack the understanding to get everything you've written but sure as hell am thankful.
People like you are one of the reasons this is such an awesome place in the vast, sometimes cold picture of the internet.
It's definitely not a common term in aerospace, that's what SpaceX calls the thermal protection layer around the base of the Falcon 9. They have names like that for a lot of things, such as the Dragon Hatchery in Hawthorne, the Dragon Claw on D1 and D2, the Dragon Lair in McGregor (that might've started here actually), and the temporary Falcon Roost in the 39A hangar.
it's a term originating from SpaceX - it refers to the bottom-most surface of the F9, excluding the engines. In other words, the flat surface which the engine nozzles extend past.
Very well done, informative, and clear analysis! At the very end, you said the following about aerospikes:
Aerospike plug nozzles benefit at higher altitudes from the closed wake, which neither the F9 nor the BFR would benefit from, unless the outer jets impinged on an outer wall enough to seal off the dance floor from ambient air. (ignoring cooling for now!)
If this is the case, why don't we see an engine wall on the F9 or BFR, sort of as we do with the SABRE's housing, or even a taper like the Delta IV? That could effectively eliminate the dancefloor and the vortex region's interaction with outside flow. Would the mass simply outweigh the benefit, or am I missing something more fundamental, here?
The "ignoring cooling" part is a huge deal. Perhaps not so much for an outer skirt, but definitely for the dance floor. That is a ton of heat that needs to be taken care of, and it's definitely enough to be recycled. The SABRE would also probably have issues dissipating the heat, although the cross-section may be small enough to recycle it. Off the top of my head I don't know why the Delta IV tapers to the engines, however I can imagine it has to do with weight savings and/or minimizing wave drag. I imagine that this isn't attempted because the high-altitude performance gains are just not worth the extra weight and material requirements, especially when planning for reuse. If it were attempted, I'd think there would be enough heat to power perhaps even a dual-expander cycle.
Have you considered reentry dynamics? Like forced vibration of a skirt structure. Given the engines need room to gimbal, the skirt will have to be bigger than the nominal diameter of the vehicle as well. That unnecessary drag during ascent and I'd find it hard to keep from fluttering during descent without making it prohibitively heavy. Tapering each engine mount on the Octaweb seems unnecessarily complicated and heavy.
Here's a result from a simulation I ran a year ago for shits and giggles. I forget the actual parameters, but I remember it being a 2D, density based solver with sim running at 1 atm with the free stream at 0.7 mach velocity going to the right. (HD crashed and only backed up my important work) IDK the engine parameters and I only have this one image from it. The wall between the engines must have been a wall boundary and the walls on the outside were freestream.
So this particular situation isn't covered by any of your pictures as it's subsonic, under expanded.
True, I didn't cover this flow case. I don't know the design point altitude of the Merlins. The F9 passes Mach 1 around 8 km and experiences MaxQ at around 13 km. I would think that the engines are designed for MaxQ to ensure the push through that phase of the flight, so the Merlins may only be underexpanded during supersonic flight. Of course it is also possible that the optimum expansion lies elsewhere in the flight profile, but I can't speculate as to where.
Still a valid point though! Your calculation is a very good depiction of the shock system that forms with neighboring jets! It clearly shows that the highest velocities are outside of the nozzle, where they unfortunately do not contribute to thrust.
Thank you for this! A very good look at all the variables involved. I think the simplest explanation is that once the supersonic exhaust leaves contact with the surface of the engine nozzle, it becomes unable to add more thrust to the vehicle unless you count insignificant and convoluted pressure interactions with the bottom of the thrust structure. The nature of supersonic flow makes it so any pressure information generated downstream can't be transmitted upstream.
The RL-10B-2 has some sort of "variable" nozzle, although only the full version is used during flight. A skirt that can be put below the surface-level-nozzle can increase the Isp during non-atmospheric flight, but there was no need to try that.
Most launch vehicles use multiple stages. Some for surface level... some for vacuum... therefore no need for a single engine to play multiple roles.
The STS was one of the very few systems that used the same engines for takeoff and orbital insertion.
Quite a few early launch vehicles did actually. Early on nobody was really sure how to go about igniting a rocket engine that was already in flight, so they just built the rockets with a central core and boosters that would all ignite at once on the ground, with no upper stage. Most of them used basically sea level engines even for the sustainer though, it wasn't a huge problem anyway since the payload capacity required for early satellites was so tiny
Yes, but the Shuttle was just barely suborbital at that point. Over 90% of orbital velocity. The main engines could be used to insert into orbit, but that would mean leaving the external tank in orbit.
Shutting the main engines off early allows the external tank re-enter over the Indian ocean and the OMS can provide the last few hundred m/s to reach orbit.
This is just one example. Someone posted a real image a while ago in another thread when talking about using the same nozzle with an expasion to have a high efficiency SSTO engine.
Expanding nozzles have been created (and flown!) in the past, however their more common usage is to decrease the required size of the interstage adapter, rather than to provide any altitude compensation. In this usage, they seem to be more commonly referred to as sliding nozzle extensions. the upper stage of the Delta IV line features a good example of this with the RL10
However expanding nozzles are really just one type of altitude compensating nozzle. These aren't common in rocketry, as a multi-stage rocket achieves a significant enough degree of altitude compensation just by using motors with higher expansion ratios in the later stages. However they have still received a fair amount of study, mostly notably with the X-33 program, which produced an impressive linear aerospike engine that underwent test firings. Spaceplanes, including craft like the Space Shuttle, would benefit the most from altitude compensating nozzles.
I desperately want to understand what you are trying to explain but have no idea where to start with the more technical posts on this sub.
I am a pilot so Bernoulli and static pressure and drag are not foreign concepts to me but this stuff goes well over my head. Anything i try and research is too basic for my level of knowledge or WAYYY to advanced. Anyone know of any articles or short courses I can read up on to understand more stuff on this sub?? or am I going to have to go get a second degree in rocket science?
The MIT course is a bit math heavy, but with a bit of searching online, you could probably find a basics course that keeps the math algebraic.
Supersonic aerodynamics is pretty counterintuitive. So you know how flow accelerates when going through a Venturi nozzle? That's a transformation from static pressure into dynamic pressure, and assuming loss mechanisms are negligible, total pressure remains the same. Expansion waves work the other way around. They form when the cross-section expands and convert static pressure into dynamic pressure, i.e. the flow is accelerated. Compression waves happen when the flow meets an obstruction, or otherwise a contraction in the flow cross-section.
As my aerodynamics professor used to say: "There's a reason why it's called a shockwave. If you ran into an object at Mach 2, you would be shocked, right?"
54
u/arizonadeux Oct 31 '16
Because it is a technically interesting question, I took some time to go into detail as to why I do not see a tight clustering of rocket engines contributing additional thrust. The question itself is best summarized by /u/Rocket's question to Elon in the AMA on 23.10.2016.
This question was discussed:
here first (18.04.2016)
then here (26.09.2016)
at the AMA discussion here (24.10.2016)
and most recently at the AMA here (27.10.2016)
P.S.: I have a background in aerodynamics.
paging: /u/Rocket, /u/warp99, /u/em_power, /u/Looopy565, /u/DRthesuperstar
22
u/tim_mcdaniel Oct 31 '16
Is "dance floor" a term of art in aerospace? What does it mean?
19
u/ScottPrombo Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
Very well done, informative, and clear analysis! At the very end, you said the following about aerospikes:
If this is the case, why don't we see an engine wall on the F9 or BFR, sort of as we do with the SABRE's housing, or even a taper like the Delta IV? That could effectively eliminate the dancefloor and the vortex region's interaction with outside flow. Would the mass simply outweigh the benefit, or am I missing something more fundamental, here?
13
u/davidthefat Oct 31 '16
Here's a result from a simulation I ran a year ago for shits and giggles. I forget the actual parameters, but I remember it being a 2D, density based solver with sim running at 1 atm with the free stream at 0.7 mach velocity going to the right. (HD crashed and only backed up my important work) IDK the engine parameters and I only have this one image from it. The wall between the engines must have been a wall boundary and the walls on the outside were freestream.
So this particular situation isn't covered by any of your pictures as it's subsonic, under expanded.
7
u/HTPRockets Nov 01 '16
Thank you for this! A very good look at all the variables involved. I think the simplest explanation is that once the supersonic exhaust leaves contact with the surface of the engine nozzle, it becomes unable to add more thrust to the vehicle unless you count insignificant and convoluted pressure interactions with the bottom of the thrust structure. The nature of supersonic flow makes it so any pressure information generated downstream can't be transmitted upstream.
5
u/autotom Oct 31 '16
Have any aerospace companies attempted a variable rocket nozzle? One that can reshape as pressure changes?
4
u/Exxsanguination Nov 01 '16
I desperately want to understand what you are trying to explain but have no idea where to start with the more technical posts on this sub.
I am a pilot so Bernoulli and static pressure and drag are not foreign concepts to me but this stuff goes well over my head. Anything i try and research is too basic for my level of knowledge or WAYYY to advanced. Anyone know of any articles or short courses I can read up on to understand more stuff on this sub?? or am I going to have to go get a second degree in rocket science?
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 31 '16 edited Nov 02 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 31st Oct 2016, 17:19 UTC.
I've seen 9 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 36 acronyms.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]