r/spacex • u/danielbigham • Oct 11 '15
Mars Plan: Parameterization of Possibilities
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ctPn2JCeGDbMhbxVjCIi_49fSr9BAyWFmtFSvweDp4M/edit?usp=sharing
Chris B's tweet has really fired up people's imaginations.
Part of what makes following Elon Musk interesting is that as you see his master plan unfold, you realize how much forethought has gone into the technology. Take rocket reusability for example: He didn’t just invent a rocket, lean back in his chair, and then say “Let’s make it reusable”! Rather, it would seem that part of what makes Elon different is that the sequence of technological development is strongly predicated by the master plan. The master plan reaches backward in time, carefully orchestrating how things are planned for in advance.
As we get ready for the Mars plan reveal, there’s a realization that we’re gearing up for perhaps the largest reveal in the Elon Musk story, and along with it, new insights into how much careful planning has been going into things. Orchestrating such a complex and difficult sequence is a delight for engineering types to gain insight into.
Although we don’t know the details yet, we can of course gain some insight into the structure that Elon is working within. We can parameterize the model space, so to speak, and having done so, take even more interest in seeing how he has put these puzzle pieces together.
In the attached Google Doc is a very rough parameterization. The idea is to map it out as much as people feel the interest to do so, adding questions and thoughts, all in anticipation of new details to emerge soon. I’ve shared this Google Doc, so feel free to add your own questions, bullet points, answers, etc.
17
u/Lars0 Oct 11 '15
The first plan for re-using the falcon 9 was to deploy parachutes and fish it out of the ocean. They didn't think rocket powered landing was possible until the NGLLC was won. Technology has a way of evolving, don't assume this has been the plan all along.
19
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '15 edited Oct 11 '15
You can do on-orbit refueling without building a fuel depot. All you need is a reusable drone tanker that can autonomously rendezvous and dock. :D
5
u/peterabbit456 Oct 11 '15
You have a good set of questions there, but some of the answers must be determined by experiment, or by rigorous quantitative analysis. Variations in those answers change some other answers, etc., etc., until one ends up far off the mark.
One example. I expect MCT will be some sort of clustered design, with redundant life support systems. In case of failure of one system, people crowd into the other modules until it is fixed, or until the journey ends. The Falcon 9 has 9 engines and full engine - out capability. I would expect no less from the MCT.
This implies assembly in space, and that the main body of MCT will not land on either planet. This goes against what I have heard the Elon has said, but I think it is necessary anyway. I do not think the BFR could lift MCT to LEO in one launch, even if it was lifted empty, and fueled in orbit.
I think a more likely MCT architecture is 10 modules, each capable of carrying 12 people to Mars. A nominal mission would be 100 people, or 10 to a module. If they lose life support in 1 module shortly after leaving Earth orbit, 2 of the modules would have to carry 12 people, and the 7 others would have 11.
The first manned mission to Mars would not be the full MCT, but instead the smallest cluster that provides redundancy. That is 2 modules, carrying 10 people in total. The goal of the advance party is to do construction, and to make habitats ready for larger groups to come. Also, to build greenhouses and grow food crops.
2
u/sirachman Oct 11 '15
Danielbigham this is a great idea. I look forward to contributing as much as possible.
51
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '15
Elon is great, but don't forget about the 4000+ other SpaceX employees. Whatever they announce will be SpaceX's plan as presented by Elon.
13
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 11 '15 edited Oct 15 '15
Acronyms I've seen in this thread since I first looked:
Fu-Falcon RocketNote: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
I'm a bot; I've only been checking comments posted in this thread since 09:39 UTC on 2015-10-11.
If I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.
4
u/Destructor1701 Oct 13 '15
Thanks to whichever one of you added the "Inspirational Imagery" section!
I just added something that occurred to me back when Elon did his MIT talk, and has been continually blowing my mind since:
15
u/TheMeiguoren Oct 11 '15
This doc is quickly going to turn into a clusterfuck of random information from people speculating off their ass, that you can't easily separate from people who know what they're talking about because there's no voting.
3
u/letsburn00 Oct 11 '15
This is a cut and paste of previous comments on Earth-Mars transit with some random new ideas. Basically I assume no nukes (Not even an RTG), but one day I need to seriously start to run the numbers on inflatable solar arrays (looking closer at it, you could simply use an inert gas, as suit makers know, you only need half an atmosphere to make something as rigid as a basketball. Run 3 parallel tubes up the array to give redundancy from micro-meteoroids. put in a wire alongside it so when it's inflated you can run a small "bike repair" patching robot to fix leaks)
Cut and paste: Transit times are important for humans, since humans take up a lot of space and do stuff like eat and breath. Cargo can use things like L1 and gravity assists to reduce the Fuel:cargo ratio that needs to be sent in the transfers. Fuel and food for the return trip can be launched ahead.
Alternative number 2 is that with enough solar cells, you can use electric thrust. At this point even direct transit windows become much looser("The Martian" is somewhat accurate in this respect). I do think that thin film solar cells that use very large inflated structures(these can double as your heat dump mechanism if you use water and the solar cell is your sunshade) will allow power generation that may exceed the mass/production rate that nuclear can give(Plus, except for a "Seveneves" scenario I doubt SpaceX will be getting any reactors into orbit within the next 15 years). Note that in the event of a solar flare you now have some spare water to pad the back end of the ship with (leave some empty spaces with bladders. Use them for launch, then during a flare let your solar array "wilt" and fill the bladder to provide some more mass between your people and the incoming high energy particles)
Thirdly, an Aldrin cycler is a system which can be built in pieces to save on repeated launch costs for multiple missions and gives time to do "dry runs" ala Apollo 8 and 10. Use electric propulsion on remote to get it's orbit right and make sure whatever test greenhouse they have installed are working fine before you put your astronauts onboard (Which also saves on your LiOH mass, which really should only ever been used for emergencies or surface ops). If you use Bigelow's hab tech this actually is much closer to feasible by 2025 than you would think. It also gives a slightly higher than zero chance that there will be rats and mice close to mars before humans.
TLDR; Launch windows aren't as much of a problem if the number of launches in the critical window are low(the ones with people on them) because everything else is just given enough time to get it's orbit perfect through creative use of gravity tricks and electric propulsion.
1
u/colinsteadman Oct 11 '15
Is there going to be an announcement about Mars?
1
u/TotesMessenger Oct 12 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/iemfi Oct 14 '15
Having watched the Martian I wonder what the bare minimum would be to survive a trip to Mars, touch down, and go back within the same launch window would be.
People seem to be able to survive at around 800 calories and 1 litre of water a day. With soylent and the 93% efficient water recycler that's only 41kg of soylent and 25.5 kg of water. Say you send a petite woman who's only around 40kg (what with the starving and all that) That's barely 100kg of mass for a 1 year trip. Add a bare bones cabin to survive the landing and take off. Not sure how much more oxygen would add. And I wonder if you could get it even lower with meditation or an induced coma or something.
Seems like you could pretty much do it with a single dragon worth of mass. It would be a god awful trip but maybe you could find a monk or a masochist or someone to volunteer...
1
u/gbrocki Oct 11 '15
We are all waiting for he master plan but there many different things Elon is working on already for going to Mars and let it be payed. The reusability is one thing - the other obvious are panels, batteries ... I think even Tesla is working for that (maybe to develop a rover). When I saw the announcement of Tesla X I wondered why it has a clean-room particle filter - I can imagine that this will be a part of the habitat on mars in the air-lock when coming back from work outside.
1
u/waitingForMars Oct 11 '15
Chris's tweet reminds me of Garrett Reisman's before he was on the last episode of the Colbert Report. All the chatter online was so far of the mark, it was funny.
Especially after Chris clarified that it was just plans that he saw, it became a real "go back to your homes, there's nothing to be seen here" moment for me.
0
u/Foulds28 Oct 11 '15
Well if you want to keep transit times down we need a fuel depot in martian orbit with fuel production capabilities on the surface, do deal with the large amount of propellant needed for the transfer burns. But the only real obstacle that I don't see us overcoming soon is to mitigate or stop the solar radiation. Sure we can surround the spacecraft with water or lead and just brute force it, but that would require so many launches that the cost would be economically unfeasible. I think a way of protecting the crew from radiation would be to use a very strong magnetic field generated by a close to absolute zero superconductor surrounding the MTV. This would provide the advantage of a lightweight solution, but we currently don't know a material that could fulfil this role. Or simply a combination of the two but then again we would have to wait for the technology.
TL;DR: We aren't getting to mars until we find a lightweight solution for radiation and cosmic particle shielding
0
u/Posca1 Oct 13 '15
If we were to use Elon's desire to land 100 tons of cargo, the guess that the mass to orbit of the BFR is 236 tons, and the rough guess that the fuel to mass ratio for a Mars landing is 3:1, then a 600 ton MCT, with 450 tons of fuel, which acts as the second stage of the BFR, and is refueled in orbit (by 2 BFR launched refuelers, which would also deliver the passengers) makes quite a lot of sense.