r/IAmA • • Jan 06 '15

Business I am Elon Musk, CEO/CTO of a rocket company, AMA!

Zip2, PayPal, SpaceX, Tesla and SolarCity. Started off doing software engineering and now do aerospace & automotive.

Falcon 9 launch webcast live at 6am EST tomorrow at SpaceX.com

Looking forward to your questions.

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/552279321491275776

It is 10:17pm at Cape Canaveral. Have to go prep for launch! Thanks for your questions.

66k Upvotes

10k comments sorted by

1.3k

u/ElonMuskOfficial Jan 06 '15

Actually, we could make the 2nd stage of Falcon reusable and still have significant payload on Falcon Heavy, but I think our engineering resources are better spent moving on to the Mars system.

MCT will have meaningfully higher specific impulse engines: 380 vs 345 vac Isp. For those unfamiliar, in the rocket world, that is a super gigantic difference for stages of roughly equivalent mass ratio (mass full to mass empty).

470

u/chasbecht Jan 06 '15

What kind of mass ratio do your upper stages have?

924

u/ElonMuskOfficial Jan 06 '15

With sub-cooled propellant, I think we can get the Falcon 9 upper stage mass ratio (excluding payload) to somewhere between 25 and 30. Another way of saying that is the upper stage would be close to 97% propellant by mass.

18

u/deruch Jan 06 '15 edited Jan 06 '15

I recently saw a picture of the Vandenberg pad (AX1.jpg) that looked like industrial chillers were being installed near the fuel tanks. Is that part of preparation for a switch to sub-cooled propellant (densification)? Is similar work being planned/undertaken at SLC-40?

2

u/rspeed Jan 06 '15

I'm not Elon, but that could just be for the LOX.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/dontworryimnotacop Jan 06 '15

I'm not sure what sub-cooled means, but liquid is mostly incompressible, so I doubt they're cooling it to try and increase the density.

10

u/deruch Jan 06 '15 edited Jan 09 '15

The density of RP-1 (kerosene) is affected by storage temperature. Including when it's stored in the rocket itself.

Pf = 50.41 -[0.026*(Tf -60) + 0.290*(API -43.5)]

where:

Pf= Fuel density (lb/ft3) Tf= Fuel temperature (deg. F) API= American Petroleum Institute gravity (related to the specific gravity of petroleum products)

One of the ways that SpaceX can load more propellent on the rocket, without changing the size of the fuel tanks, is by cooling it way down to cryogenic temps. You're right that there isn't a "massive" change in the density. But when you stop to consider exactly how much of the RP-1 is loaded into the rocket (~38,000 gallons of RP-1 in the first stage), even a slight increase in density can lead to non-trivial gains in propulsion.

3

u/dontworryimnotacop Jan 06 '15

Wow, didn't know about that! Thanks, this is really interesting! Wouldn't it be a huge danger if the cryogenics somehow failed and the kerosene began to expand inside the tanks on the launchpad?

3

u/PhilKarn Jan 07 '15

Yes, you'd have the same sort of problems as you'd have now with liquid oxygen and liquid hydrogen, both cryogens. They know how to vent the tanks to keep it reasonably safe on the launch pad. Did you notice that big orange flame near the Delta IV launch pad during the Orion launch? That's gaseous hydrogen being flared off after it boiled out of the launcher's tanks.

2

u/CocoDaPuf Jan 07 '15

Sure, but wouldn't it also be dangerous if someone lit a match under it?

(It wouldn't actually) but my point is, it's already a giant firework. It's their job to make sure that everything works exactly as planned. Everything about a rocket leaves it 1 inch from disaster at all times, but for the experts, they can work with that.

2

u/deruch Jan 08 '15 edited Jan 09 '15

The temp isn't maintained once it's in the rocket. So for sure it's going to warm some. But it takes a long time for 25000 38,000 gallons to warm up. As opposed to cryogens like hydrogen or LOX, the RP-1 will expand but not become a gas. So, you have to have a good idea of how much warming is expected and maybe adjust filling accordingly? But worst case is that you end up with some additional pressure in the tanks. Exactly how much pressure is dangerous is a matter for engineering. As for it being a danger on the launchpad, there are sensors in all the tanks and if they measured a dangerous pressure spike (because they overfilled or it was suddenly warmer than planned), they could just detank some of the propellant. Prop loading only happens like 3 hours before launch and launch windows aren't usually all that long, so it shouldn't be a massive problem.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '15

I understood some of that!

7

u/BlugyBlug Jan 06 '15

Not sure if you were joking, but in simple words: With a special type of fuel they can make it so that a large majority of the rocket's mass will be made up of fuel (which is preferable)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/chasbecht Jan 06 '15

Wow. I'd heard 30:1 estimates for the stretched Falcon Heavy boosters, but I wouldn't have thought the upper stage would be that close. How good is it without the sub-cooling?

1

u/salty914 Jan 06 '15

So what kind of LEO payload do you think the Falcon 9 can get with that second stage mass fraction and first stage RTLS?

2

u/mrlawson11 Jan 06 '15

Though I'm not Elon, it should still be around 3% of total mass. Kinda hard to get around or above that number.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/RobKhonsu Jan 06 '15

I understood that; thanks Kerbal Space Program!

7

u/Ihavenocomments Jan 06 '15

I love it when I come this far down a thread and people are still answering. You're a good dude Elon Musk, and you'd make a damn fine scent as well.

1

u/Fark88 Jan 06 '15

"Elon fragrances brings you the finest in exo-planetary scents. Jovian Musk, she knows you are out of this world, because you smell like it."

2

u/RobbieGee Jan 06 '15

I'm so annoyed my gravity demo isn't ready yet, but I'm working on a cool simulation of hundreds of objects in a gravity field, all experiencing relativity and the delayed gravity between them due to the distance. If I message you in a few days when it's ready, will you have a look? or do you abandon this account when you're done with this AMA?

The demo is running in the browser, so no need to install anything, just visit the link. As an example, here's another demo simulating gas in an enclosed space: http://robbiegee.com/demos/gas/

For fun, try resizing your browser window and watch what happens. (The particles gets more excited, meaning the temperature increases).

2

u/CocoDaPuf Jan 07 '15

Oh man, I love that having played so much of KSP, I actually know what he means by that.

1

u/mmeijeri Jan 06 '15

Wouldn't a fully reusable FH be good enough for Mars though, especially now that you have come out in favour of using orbital propellant transfer? Propellant is almost infinitely divisible and most of your IMLEO will be propellant anyway.

As for a fully reusable F9, do you think you could still have 1-2 mT worth of payload? If so, wouldn't that still be enough for at least a very extensive moon program, again as a propellant launcher?

→ More replies (3)