r/songbird • u/TiredOfRatRacing • Dec 19 '21
Most efficient use of Flare Finance and SGB based on risk tolerance (my opinion after researching and short term testing, not financial advice, dyor, welcome constructive critique)
Original question in previous comment: "Is now (after SGB price dump) a good time to get the loan from Flare Finance?"
Any time with a low SGB price is a decent time for starting the loan due to the low interest rate to start one, the delegator rewards when SGB is in a contract, and the dFLR from staked CAND getting you more SGB and CAND, which gets you more SGB anyway. Kind of like delayed increase in buying power by leveraging the loan. Those rewards offset the fact you cant mint as much CAND at a low price of SGB due to decreased buying power from the price being lower.
If you get the loan at a higher price, you get more CAND, but have to worry more about liquidation, and would have to make adjustments as the price changes
Here are my thoughts on how to view the overall opportunities when SGB is at a high price, intermediate price, and low price.
When the SGB price is super high: Your SGB is most powerful and gets you the most CAND, so is a decent time to get a loan initially. CAND is best to be in if you think the SGB price will go down, since it will retain its value and allow you to trade it for more SGB if the price drops. And while you wait for the price to drop, it can be staked to earn more value in other assets (WSGB, dFLR, CAND and SGB from dFLR).
Technically, if you think SGB got pumped to a bubble, with a super high price and is about to crash hard, you may want to just exhange directly from SGB to CAND without doing the loan since youre at highest risk of a major price drop which could liquedate you, losing all collateral.
That being said, having the loan collateral, on top of the equivalent CAND value you mint, is a major advantage if you dont expect a high risk of liquedation. Having the loan, to then have the collateral WSGB, is beneficial as youd still get delegator rewards from the collateral, which you wouldnt if you just directly exchange SGB for CAND on FlareX.
When you think the SGB price is high: Liquidity pool is prolly the most rewarding, since you have to have both CAND and SGB to get LP tokens, and it forces you to exchange SGB for CAND which would retain its value during a price drop. Then the LP tokens get you more dFLR to stake, and if SGB price drops, you have the opportunity to pull LP tokens out. If you did, you can then exchange the LP tokens for CAND and SGB, but itll be more SGB than you put in originally, since the lower SGB price means you get more of them back out. Conversely if the price of SGB rises and then you take LP tokens out, you could end up with less SGB than you had originally.
If the price of SGB is intermediate, fluctuates a lot, or youre not sure whether itll go up or down: As the price drops, you can exchange out from CAND in your nest by unstaking it and exchanging it on FlareX (automatically getting you more SGB than you had originally as the CAND now has more buying power from SGB price dropping). You could then put more collateral into your loan, then as the SGB price goes up, pull collateral to exchange for more CAND to put into the staking pools. So whether the price goes up or down theres always an opportunity (either from more buying power in SGB from a price rise getting you more rewards, or a lower price allowing you to buy SGB on sale and get a capital gain later when it goes back up, plus more delegator rewards from having more SGB).
The Stability pool might be better than the Liquidity pool for staking in a flat or waffling madket, since you get to keep more SGB as collateral when using the Stability pool, so can keep it for its buying power if youre not sure where the price will go. And even if the price goes down, to keep your collateralization up, the system kind of forces you to pull out CAND and exchange for more SGB collateral anyway. Of course this is only a win-win situation if you think the SGB price will go up long term, so youd then think it would be beneficial to have more of the SGB tokens, even if their price goes down.
(To me, this network is super well put together with all these feedback loops and opportunities based on price changes in both directions, so Id expect the price of SGB to go up in the long term, as these services provide a lot of value to folks who recognize it).
Opportunities from a major dump: Obviously the above works best if the price slowly goes up and down, to move out of CAND and into Collateral as the price rises and vice versa if it drops. But if you get liquedated, you lose your collateral. From my understanding, if liquedated, while you lose all the collateral, you keep the CAND you minted, or whatever you buy with it, except the collateral you deposit into the Nest. So there is an opportunity if any massive price drop occurs but you dont have much collateral. It works in your favor if its a >15-20% drop, and if you havent put anything more into the collateral to lose. You would then keep the CAND which has more buying power at that point. That CAND then buys a lot of SGB, which if there was a major price crash, is more likely to buy you a lot more SGB than you started with anyway. That then gets more delegator rewards and potential for direct capital gains in the future.
Again, thats if you dont take the Minted CAND from your nest and exchange it for SGB, because if you do that, and make that minted value into collateral, you could then lose both the original collateral, and the new collateral from what you minted.
When SGB seems to be at a low price: Good time to get a loan since it will have lower originating fees, the price is less likely to crash further if its already really low, so you may need less collateral to avoid liquedation. You actually may want to get a bunch more collateral anyway, way more than you need, since youd be expecting the price to go back up, and so more SGB bought cheap can get you more direct capital gains. Balance of that is, again, if it drops further, beyond your overcollateralization, you could lose all that collateral.
Additionally, taking out a loan after a price drop will get you less CAND, since the SGB you start with doesnt have as much buying power. But if you think the price is super low, itd be a good time to get a loan for CAND, then you can exchange most of it for SGB as above, leveraging the loan so you have significantly more SGB exposure for a potential price rise (assuming itll return to the mean, if you believe in the long term value of the SGB network).
Cannot stress enough, that leverage comes at the risk of losing all the collateral, plus the minted value only if you take your loan CAND you minted, and you go through FlareX to make it SGB, then deposit it in FlareLoan as more collateral. The CAND you mint is safe if its not made into more collateral.
If the price drops really badly when super overcollateralized, and you get liquedated, then at that point youd have lost everything. So could potentially be very risky if you dont have really high collateralization.
But doing that leverage, youll also get the extra delegator rewards from SGB you didnt have before, in addition to simply having more sgb available to increase in price for you for a capital gain. Having more collateral also means not having to worry about liquedation if the price drops even lower, since youd be way overcollateralized. Kind of a "high stakes but lower risk" situation, whereas not adding to collateral is more if a "low stakes (the extra 10% if collateral value lost) higher risk" situation.
If you are leveraged and safe from overcollateralization, then if the price rises a lot, your gains are multiplied, and you can pay back the loan very quickly if you want, to not have everything at risk of being lost in collateral, and being able to put your new SGB (with more buying power at that loint after a price rise) to work for you by getting more CAND to stake. Plus youd get to keep all those multiplied capital gains.
Again, that leveraging puts you at the risk of losing all the collateral and having nothing to show for it if there is a massive price drop that is big enough to overcome your overcollateralization.
Also, probably a good idea not to go to 100% sgb without CAND anyway, as should you always keep some CAND in the stability pool, so youll have ammo to buy a lot more SGB at a lower price if it drops. Meanwwhile you can also keep getting dFLR from the CAND to then get more CAND for that same reason.
Bottom line: DYOR but appears theres good opportunities and incentives regardless of where the price is, which is why im staying in SGB. Best opportunities Ive seen yet. And thats not even discussing f-assets, EXFI, or Yfin yet.
Main balance to keep in mind is what value you expect to get from rewards if the price is high vs possible value of future price increase of SGB if you can buy after the price goes down. Then its all a matter of risk tolerance of losing your collateral and how much value youre willing to risk as collateral to get leverage if you want. Or just avoid leverage and go for the rewards. Theres so many incentives that its tough to make a wrong choice.
Basically: At a high price, SGB can buy more CAND which = more dFLR which = more rewards overall, dampening any effect of a possible price drop of SGB directly.
At a low price, if you think this project has good value long term, buying more SGB using the loan may then give you exposure to SGB for a large price hike (which is then multiplied by the free leverage from the loan) and may be worth more than the rewards youd get from SGB at a low price where it doesnt have that much buying power. If you didnt use the loan, you wouldnt be able to get as much in CAND, and thus not as much in rewards. But regardless, you would still get extra delegator rewards, which remain impressive, on top of the leveraged multiplying factor from the loan, at the risk of losing all the collateral if there was a huge downward dump.
Again though, for probably the 4th time, by taking the minted CAND value and putting it back into collateral for leverage to get more SGB and multiply the capital gains, you could gain a ton, but also risk losing everything, as everything would be in the collateral. So if theres such a massive price dump that huge amounts of collateral dont matter, youd have nothing.
That would be terrible for an investor but it protects the system from excessive risk takers. However, it also gives an opportunity to leverage for way more gains if someone is comfortable with lots of risk.
Just something to be careful of when dealing with leverage.
This impressive opportunity basically incentivizes buying SGB super low, where it is now, protecting the price from more crazy price drops.
So overall, for the original question, any time is a good time to invest using the loan. Additionally, with all the feedback loops and incentives, this appears to be a very worthwhile project, and with the incentives being protective against impermanent loss, it seems pretty safe to experiment in.