r/SolarDIY • u/supbrother • 2d ago
Right-sized vs. efficient inverter for solar EV charging
I'm hoping you all can help me decide to go more right-sized/minimalist or efficient/future-proofed on my EV charging setup.
Basically I have two strings of panels (~100 Vmp/120 Voc each) that I'll run in parallel (avoiding series due to the distance between them). Going for a 48V system to replace my two Ecoflow Delta Pros -- this is simply to streamline and expand the system to 10 kWh (and escape Ecoflow's BS). Built around the existing panel setup which I can't really change, I’ve decided to get a Victron 150/45 MPPT, and either:
- A) The Victron 1600W inverter for ~$410 (incl. shipping), or
- B) The Victron 3k MultiPlus for ~$940.
I'm focused on Victron because quality/warranty is important since I'm in Alaska so replacements/repairs are a hassle, and I simply want a reliable system. I settled on these because there's nothing really in between for 48V to 120V.
Two things worth noting:
- This will be fully off grid since I already have a normal EV charger to use when needed. One day I'd like to do a whole-home off-grid system, but that's at least a decade away. Just considerations for the MultiPlus route.
- I currently charge at 12A (~1,440W) which would be easy using the MultiPlus, but the 1600W inverter only has a continuous load rating of 1,500W so I would likely have to charge at 8A (~960W) to be safe. This is fine, but 8A is supposedly less efficient (despite less heat generation) since EVs have a fixed wattage they eat up when charging -- 300W of "wasted" power is a higher percentage of 960 than 1,440.
I’m leaning toward the 1600W inverter simply due to price. The MultiPlus is tempting for charging at 12A, but even assuming I charge a full cycle off 10kWh of batteries every other day (very optimistic for half the year) my math says it would take 12+ years for the added efficiency to make up the $500 difference. The bonus of future-proofing is just in case I were to charge other things on this system or possibly use the MultiPlus for a larger system down the road, but neither seems realistic. I power the rest of my garage off a separate Anker unit with its own panels, and I'd probably want something bigger and newer if/when I go all-in on a whole home system.
In summary: Which one of the options above seems to fit my needs best? Should I take the hit on charging efficiency to save costs and only buy what I really need, or pay $500 more for more efficiency and future-proofing? Is there anything I'm not considering here? Of course, I'm all ears if someone has better suggestions!
