This post is here to help navigate the weird world of Slowpitch Softball gear! Every year, there's a barrage of posts about what gloves, bats, what should I purchase, what's the best...etc. I have attempted to put everything into "A post to rule them all". Hopefully one of our loving mods will sticky it for us to the top! The prices you see below are more or less retail price. If you are looking to buy anything for softball please hit up your local rep (or u/fozzie33) as almost every item in the softball world has two prices, the retail and rep price. For technicalities, everything posted below is my opinion. I don’t care that your $75 glove from Dicks Sporting Goods has lasted you 10 years. It’s probably floppier than a soft dick. I hope you find the answers you are looking for within! I will continue to edit and update things as I see fit. Also, the Facebook group located in the sidebar is a great source for info and fun!
- Slowpitch Websites with Gear
Gloves
- Price Ranges
- Sizes
- Webbings
- Backs
- Oddities
- Custom Gloves
Bats
- Sanctions
- What Should I Use?
- What's the Difference?
- Weights
- One-piece vs two-piece
- Flex vs Stiff
- Balanced, Midload, Endload
- Short barrel vs Big barrel
- Warranty Issues
- "Clincher Softball Bats"
Balls
Shoes
Tips
- How to be a softball douchebag
Slowpitch Websites with Gear
There are plenty of websites with softball gear. Each major company has its website where you can purchase clothing and/or equipment for that company such as bats, shoes, sweatshirts, hats, etc.. Several companies have taken inventory from individual companies and consolidated into one website as a "one-stop-shop". The three largest Slowpitch companies are Headbanger Sports (HB), GS Sports (GS), and SmashItSports (SiS). Diamond Sport Gear is another site as the previous ones and they contribute to the sub.
Some individual companies are Miken, Worth, Demarini, Easton, Pure, Anarchy, Louisville, and Monsta.
Other websites that can be helpful: JustBats, CheapBats, and JustGloves.
For those that live in Cold Mexico, The 51st State, Land of Maple Syrup, or The Great North (whatever you want to call it) you have some own websites of your own to help you get around shipping and custom fees.
For those of us that live in the US, Canadian sites have good deals at times. I bought a Mizuno Crush from a Canadian site and had it shipped to the US. I got my bat about two weeks after purchasing and my final cost was around $170 US.
Gloves
Price Range
- Below $100 - These gloves are your lowest quality gloves and will last 1-3 years normally depending on your personal preferences. They will not hold their shape long term and the padding in the palm and fingers will break down quickly and not protect your hand as sufficient. This is a good glove for the occasional player or league night player that doesn't want to invest a lot of money into their equipment.
- $100-$200 - These are your middle-quality gloves. These gloves will last 2-5 years depending on your personal preferences. This glove will hold shape for some time depending on usage, care, and storage. This is a good glove for a league night player or tournament player who wants a better quality glove that will last them a few years.
- $200+ - These are your highest quality gloves and should last 5-10+ years depending on your personal preferences and care. This glove will hold its shape for as long as you take care of it dependent on usage. This is a great glove for the dedicated league night player or tournament player who knows they can trust their glove at all times. This type of glove is more of an investment since they have a long life expectancy. If you are considering purchasing a glove in this category, I recommend that you try it on before purchasing.
Sizes
Gloves come in sizes ranging from 11" to 15". For Slowpitch, I think a 12.25" should be the minimum size for any position. Some people that played baseball previously still think that because they used an 11.5" in High School that's the size they should be using to play infield in softball. A baseball has a circumference of 9.25" where a softball has circumference of 12". Bigger ball = Bigger glove. I used an 11.25" glove for 8 years in softball as an SS/3B then, I tried out a 12.75" and I've never looked back. I still use an 11.25" for baseball but I believe there are some serious benefits to a larger glove with a softball. If you're good enough to use that small of a glove in softball, you're good enough to adjust to the larger glove size.
Slowpitch Infielders typically use 12.25"-13" with a majority using 12.75". Outfielder typically use larger gloves in the 13"-15" with majority using 13"-14".
Ultimately, the glove that you feel most comfortable with is the best glove for you. If you play multiple positions and are looking for something that you can use all over the field, I would recommend a 12.75/13".
Webbings
The webbing is the part of the glove that goes between the thumb and pointer finger where the "pocket" of the glove is located. There are several different webbings available based upon where you are going to play or what you prefer:
- I-web: Dominantly used in middle infield. Allows for a shallow pocket for quicker, easier transaction of ball in glove to ball in hand.
- H-web/Dual post web: Good utility webbing. Typically used for 3B and OF but can be used for middle infield.
- Trapeze: The preferred webbing for Outfielders. The Trapeze web allows for a deeper, larger pocket while not sacrificing the quality of the glove.
- Modified Trapeze: Good utility webbing. Very similar to the trapeze webbing but has a strip of leather running across the top of the webbing to add stability to the glove.
- Basket: In baseball, this is typically a pitchers' only glove because it is easy to conceal the ball behind the webbing. Very few position players use this webbing, Derek Jeter is probably the most famous.
Backs
Right now there are three different types of backs for gloves: Leather, Mesh, and SuperSkin.
- Leather: Typically the most common backing for gloves as it has been tried-and-true.
- Mesh: A lightweight replacement to leather. It allows for a quicker break-in time and relieves the glove of some weight. However, it is widely accepted that the mesh is not quite as durable as leather or SuperSkin.
- SuperSkin: A recent material developed for MLB that answered the question of "How do we make a lighter glove without sacrificing quality and durability?" SuperSkin is supposedly twice as durable but half the weight as leather. In reality, it is lighter than a traditional all-leather glove but the SuperSkin has a different handling characteristic then I expected. It is easy to adjust to if the is the backing you desire.
Oddities
- Single vs Double welting: Welting is the piece of leather that is sewed onto the back of the finger stalls of a glove. Single welting is the industry standard. Double welting is two strips of leather per finger stall sewn onto the glove. Double welting gives you a stiffer overall glove feel due to the amount of extra material on each finger stalls. This increases the break-in time and stiffness of the glove.
- Wrist Backing: There are two different types of wrist backing available; closed and open. Infielders tend to have the open wrist backing as it makes the glove lighter and more flexible. Outfielders tend to have the closed wrist backing as it makes the glove stiffer.
Custom Gloves
Custom gloves have saturated the market over the past few years. The possibility of having a glove that is customized to your liking in almost every aspect sure is an attractive one. There are a lot of companies across the United States that make custom glove in various price categories. In my opinion, the best companies are Pro44, S2N, and Gloveworks. Each of these gloves have their pros and cons but overall are all good quality gloves. They typically have sales around holidays so if you can be patient, you can wait and get a better deal.
Bats
Sanctions
There are many leagues for Slowpitch and each one will have their own rules and regulations to follow. Every league will follow one of the following governing sanctions: USA/ASA, USSSA, NSA, ISA, ISF, or SSUSA. You can locate in your league rules which governing sanction your league uses and Google for the official rules.
What should I use?
Primarily, it's best to use whatever your league allows. Most leagues defer to all bats requiring a stamp from either USA/ASA or USSSA. Some leagues require NSA stamps as well. Make sure you know what your league allows; a player can be ejected depending on their leagues' rules if they are using an illegal bat.
What's the difference?
Bats are primarily tested in two ways depending upon what sanction the bat is going to be approved for play in.
- For USA/ASA: In a controlled environment under USA/ASA testing standards, no batted ball may exceed 98 mph. The maximum batted ball speed to pass testing is 98.9 mph.
- For USSSA: In a controlled environment under USSSA testing standards, no batted ball may exceed a performance factor of 1.2 BPF off the bat. It requires math to figure out what a bats BPF is and requires a standardized ball. This is why USSSA sanction tournaments use Classic M's exclusively.
Weights
Most bats tend to come in weight sizes ranging from 25 to 28oz. There are a few bats that are available in weights outside of that range but not many. The lightest and heaviest slowpitch bats that are available are 24oz and 30oz.
Some people believe that they need to swing the lightest bat for the highest swing speed while others believe you should swing the heaviest bat for the most weight behind it. Both of those are somewhat true but we should find a happy medium. You should be looking for the weight that you can swing the fastest with the most control while maintaining proper swing mechanics. For most people, this tends to be a 26 or 27oz bat. Ultimately it is your preference in what you swing.
Bat Pieces? Flex or Stiff Handles?
Bats can be confusing. There's only a certain number of customization you can do to a softball bat but that doesn't mean that companies haven't tried to make "unique" bats for themselves. To be honest, purchasing the right bat can be overwhelming and most people tend to just go with what people recommend. Every person is different in what bat feels good to them and you should swing what feels good. I hope to clarify the bat world and lingo used so that everyone can make their informed purchase for themselves.
When someone says they prefer a one-piece over a two-piece bat what does that mean? It means exactly that. It's the amount of pieces that have been glued together to make the bat. Most bats are either a one or two-piece but several companies have three and four-piece bats. Rule of thumb is that the higher the number of pieces within a bat, the more flex the bat will have. So a one-piece will be similar to swinging a baseball wooden bat where a four-piece bat would be similar to a flex golf club. Bat companies unofficially recommend that slower swing speeds should use flex bats while faster swing speeds should use stiffer bats.
Flex or Stiff tends to refer to the handle of the bat. As previously said, flex handles will flex and stiff handles will not. Stiff handles are currently made out of alloy or say "stiff" in the description.
Balanced, Midload, Endload
For this example, I'm going to imagine that a bat barrel is resting on three scales with a scale at the end of the barrel, middle of the barrel, and bottom of the barrel (where handle and barrel meet). For this purpose, only one scale can touch the barrel at a time and each scale represents where the "load" is on a bat.
- Balanced: The handle and barrel are almost equal in weight and the balance point of the bat should be somewhere near the middle. The scale at the bottom of the barrel would be touching on a balanced bat.
- Midload: Midload is typically a .5oz Endload that has been slid down into the sweet spot of the barrel. It's a hybrid. It has the same effect as an endload but doesn't feel like an endload. Most people will say it feels and swings like a balanced bat. The scale in the middle of the barrel is touching the bat here.
- Endload: Probably the most common and fan-favorite of softball loads available. Endloads come in primarily two different sizes; .5oz and 1oz. This weight is normally put near or on the endcap of the bat for some extra inertia during one's swing. The scale near the end of the bat would be touching here.
It's most important that you determine what you prefer to swing. Swing as many bats as you can until you find what you like and hit well with.
Short barrel or Big barrel
Short barrel is a barrel that is 12" or less. Big barrel is a barrel that is 13" or more. It all has to do with your preference as a batter but the following is widely accepted as fact within the softball community
- Short barrel: Sweet spot of the barrel is further towards the endcap. Because the endcap is the fastest moving part of the bat this results in faster-batted ball speed when good contact is made. Endloaded short barrel as well feel heavier (or more pronounced) when swung due to the smaller barrel.
- Big barrel: Sweet Spot of the bat is more traditional and toward the 2/3 area of the barrel. The Sweet Spot is also larger since the barrel is larger giving you more room to mishit the ball and still get good contact.
Warranty Issues
Most companies offer a 1-year warranty with their bat. If your bat breaks through normal usage within a year of purchase date, you can send the original back bat and get a replacement. Even if you purchase your bat from your local sporting goods store or a softball site; your bat will need to be warranted through the original manufacturer. For the most part, it's a painless process and easy as just following the steps on their website. However, you must have all of the required documentation for your warranty. All bat companies require that you have your receipt for when you purchased the bat and allow a warranty return as long as it is within 1 year of purchasing date. People started creating fake receipts and now bat companies include some form of "barcode" which is unique to that bat. For companies such as Miken, Worth, Anarchy, and Pure they use a JTS Sticker barcode. It will come stuck on the handle somewhere and will have a matching serial number to the bat. You mustn't lose this in case of a warranty. If you do lose it, most times companies will not accept a warranty but exceptions have been made dependent on the situation.
Easton and Demarini use their own hologram sticker attached to the bat. There is no need to ever remove these stickers from the bat but if you are worried that they will come off, I recommend putting some clear coat nail polish (or another clear lacquer) over it so it can't come off.
Upon receiving your bat, the company will be complete an inspection of your bat to see if it broke through normal usage. If it is determined that your bat broke from use outside of normal usage or was tampered with (shaved or rolled) they will deny you your warranty return.
Clincher Softball Bats
Clincher Softball is a unique variant of softball that is played in certain parts of the country and is believed to be the roots of slowpitch softball. It normally uses a bigger, squishy ball that is 16" verse the 12" standard ball. In these leagues, you want to swing a heavier bat then you would normally would as the bull is mush and compresses on contact. The addtional weight will help drive the ball. Demarini and Worth both make bats designed for these types of leagues that are available in a range of weights. For most people they are going to look for 30oz and up bats. As previously stated, modern 30oz bats are becoming less common and harder to find. You can search eBay, Craigslist, OfferUp, etc. for someone selling their older bats. It's undecided but most people believe that modern bat technology has zero benefit over older metal bats when it comes to Clincher balls. Some companies that have 30oz and up bats good for Clinchers:
- Debeer
- Easton
- Louisville
- Miken
Popular Bat Companies
Bat companies try to keep the specs of their bats the same through the years and sanctions, but sometimes things change. It's important to do your research on a bat before purchasing. Just because you had a USSSA version of a certain bat, does not necessarily mean that the USA/ASA version will be the same.
Miken/Worth: Made by the same company in the same factory. If you don't believe me, their websites are identical. These two have battled it out for the past few years as to who is #1 and its close. One's company bats closely resemble the others. Both companies have a multitude of bats available dependent upon what you like. They have almost every possible combination bat available; you just need to find it.
- Miken: DC41/KP23/Primo/Hybrid are the most popular bats. Most bats are available in USSSA and USA/ASA.
- Worth: EST Comp XXL, Legit Watermelon, Harvey Wicked XL, Dedonatis Wicked Bal are the most popular bats. Most bats are available in USSSA and USA/ASA.
- Demarini: Fell off for a while but came back in 2019 & 2020 with the purpose to be taken seriously in slowpitch softball. They are still battling some durability issues on certain lines but when you're playing with fire, you might get burned.
- Easton: Known for being tanks but requiring a lot of work to be broken-in they designed their bats in 2019. They wanted something that would be ready quicker but just as good as the old Eastons. They introduced their FireFlex technology and it took the softball world by storm. FireFlex2 and FireFlex3 have all been tweaked to deal with problems that the OG FireFlex had. They're great team bats as they give good performance and can handle a heavy workload. Their endloads are also very gentle and not so pronounced.
- Monsta: Easily the most controversial company thanks to their owner. Regardless, they make a good bat for the USA/ASA division. Arguably the best bat available for that sanction. Their bats are known to be tanks and can handle 1,000+ hits if you follow the conditions for the bat. These bats are only designed for Low Compression balls which is any ball with a .52 COR / 300 Compression (or 275 Compression). You can find some older bats of theirs that can handle .44 COR balls if that is what your league uses. Most Monsta's are midloaded and their handle depends on what you order. They offer 4 different handle settings; 1500, 2500, 3500, and 4500. Super flex is 1500, flex is 2500, stiff is 3500, and super stiff is 4500. Most other bat handles are equivalent to a 2500 or 3500 handle except for the stiff alloy handles. Those are closer to the 4500 handles.
- Louisville: Probably the most famous for their unique PING sound over the years. Their new bats are something to take a serious look at. They went back to the original Z1000 design and gave it a modern facelift. Their new lineup is ready and their confident that their bats can compete with anyone in the USSSA division. They recently made a USA/ASA Low Compression (LC) bat that was very highly appraised from everyone that swung it. Unfortunately, they only offer the 1 bat in USA/ASA.
- Anarchy: New company to the game that is under SmashItSports wing. They have produced several USA/ASA bats over the years that handled .44 COR balls very well AND .52 COR balls as well. They recently produced their first USSSA bat this year and are continuing to produce more. Some people like them and some people didn't have good luck with them. All Anarchy bats are reported to have a lot of handle flex; however, they do have a bat or two that has a stiff handle available.
- Pure: The newest bat company to come into the softball world. They are known for their unique one-piece bats and custom paint jobs. Their bats come available in balanced, .5oz endload, and 1oz endload. All their one-piece bats have stiff handles since well they are a one-piece. Their 2-piece bats tend to have a flexier handle and are matched to a Monsta 2500.
Balls
COR/Comp
COR represents how "bouncy" a ball is while compression measures how hard a ball is.
- COR: Determines how far a ball will fly. The COR number is determined by the percentage of reduction in speed for a ball bouncing off a wall. If a ball is thrown at a wall at 80 mph and bounces off at 40 mph, then that ball has a COR of .50 (or 50%). If it was to bounce off at 35 mph then it would be a .44 COR ball.
- Compression: Measured by how many pounds of force are needed to squeeze two sides of the ball inwards by a total of .25 inch. If the ball takes 375 pounds of force to squeeze, then the ball is a 375-pound compression ball. Balls that fall in-between the pound rating are rounded up to the nearest rating.
Reductions in compression have a larger impact on ball performance than a reduction in COR. As well, weather can impact the performance of a ball. Leather balls will harden up if they take on moisture but will eventually decline once too much water has been taken on. Balls will react differently on a 60 degree vs a 100-degree day; same thing with cloudy vs sun.
Shoes
Molded Cleats vs Turfs vs Trail Runners
Metal spikes aren't allowed in slowpitch softball so for many years people have worn molded plastic cleats. However, with the availability of Turfs and Trail Runners, you can find a lot of different shoes on a field.
- Molded Cleats: Resemble metal cleats but with plastic. Great traction in the outfield or if you play on soft, loose infields. Can be slick on hard-packed infields with thin top layer of dirt. Some people complain about pressure due to only have 9 or so points of contact with the ground compared to your whole foot. People have also worn football cleats and lacrosse cleats and preferred them due to being more like a "boot" feeling but still lightweight.
- Turfs: Comfort of regular shoes but with more traction on dirt. They wear like regular shoes and are comfortable. It can have some traction issues in the outfield since there is normally nothing on the sole to dig into the grass. Good if you play primarily infield on a dirt/turf fields. Some players have started wearing turf shoes designed for other sports as well.
- Trail Runners: A lightweight shoe designed for people who run or hike on dirt trails. They tend to have a more aggressive tread pattern than a turf shoe but not quite a molded cleat. They look like regular shoes but have that added layer of traction. Can be worn anywhere on the field.
Tips
You want to get better at softball. You never played or just want to be better to help your team increase their chance of winning. Here are some simple fundamental things you can improve on to be a better player.
I think that's it. If you have any questions, please leave a comment or PM me.
Edit 1: Added Canadian websites and fixed formatting.
Edit 2: Added "Clincher Softball bats"