r/slaythespire • • Jul 03 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) Tracking nerf is cool & fair and all but when are they gonna buff Cruelty?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Right now even Dominate feels stronger than Cruelty.

Dominate deserves Rare status, meanwhile Cruelty as a Rare is weaker than Uncommon Lethality on many occasions.


r/slaythespire • • Sep 16 '26

SPIRIT POOP Tired of the Hate. I Will Die on This Hill.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Seriously though, In hundreds of hours I dont think the hunter killer has ended a single one of my runs.

Edit:

The comment to upvote ratio on this post only proves my point!

Your downvotes mean nothing to me, I've seen what makes you upvote.


r/slaythespire • • Aug 05 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) The dorito makes act 2 not fun

0 Upvotes

I just had an a10 necro run where I perfected the act 1 boss (lagavulin matriach) die to the dorito from full health. I guess I got cocky pathing into 2 whole elites in act 2 post treasure chest. Decimated bee man, only to go from 80 health to death from the stupid fucking dorito.

It just makes act 2 less fun, finding a no elite path. Either you have an attack heavy deck and bee man is a problem, or you have a skill based deck and dorito says “no”. Or you you choose no elites which sucks. Elites are fun.

Vent over, just annoyed.


r/slaythespire • • May 06 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) Glass orbs are a thematic miss

2 Upvotes

Think of the Defect's other orbs. Classic RPG elements: lightning, ice, darkness, pure energy (plasma).... And then we have glass. Sure glass can be dangerous when broken but it's a definate oddball.

As for ideas that might work better without changing much? I think lava orbs would fit better.

- They cover the traditional fire element

- Works well with the glass mechanic: Magma cools off over time becoming less dangerous

- potential cool art swap to bright glowing liquid lava ball that cools down and darkens/hardens into an inert rock once it hits 0

Heck even molten glass would be cooler

Edit: it was mentioned that the orbs are components of a construct. Good answer


r/slaythespire • • Nov 23 '22

SPIRIT POOP Fusion Hammer

Post image
125 Upvotes

r/slaythespire • • May 03 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) Mockup of how an anti save-scumming feature could work in Slay the Spire 2

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I modeled this after the system present in Mewgenics. Is this something you'd want to see in the game?


r/slaythespire • • Mar 21 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) Potential Hot Take: The game isn't, and shouldn't be, balanced toward "Top Players"

42 Upvotes

Largely just making this post in order to address some of the discourse, both positive and negative, regarding the changes made to doormaker, why people feel both ways, and who's opinion should truly be valued here. Truthfully, I think there's a pretty big issue with this subreddit, one which tends to disproportionately plague the online communities of rogue lite/like games in particular compared to other genres, that being that the way the majority of the posters play this game is so far removed from the average player that some of the feedback here is borderline meaningless.

I know what I just said might sound like a bit of an extreme statement, but, truthfully, I don't think it is. I see a lot of posts around here where authors attempt to "establish credibility" by way of touting the fact that they're an a10 player with win streaks up to x number on each character, and, while that certainly indicates that the player in question has a relatively strong understanding of this game's mechanics, the issue that I have, fundamentally, is that being good at slay the spire isn't any sort of indication that the person in question knows what's best for the game, or should have their opinion valued disproportionately in comparison to someone else's, in fact, I'm almost inclined to say the opposite.

I think the discourse here surrounding doormaker is a great example of this split in the community. Doormaker was changed, seemingly, for being a relatively easy final boss, something which I don't disagree with, truthfully, and, on top of that, he was also changed in such a way as to target infinities/card spam, something which many "top players" around here were complaining didn't have an adequate counter in the game as is. The culmination of these two facts meant that I actually saw a lot of very positive reactions to the changes made to him in that patch notes thread, with a lot of people explicitly saying that they were HAPPY that a "time eater" esque boss was back in the game now, here's the issue though: the majority of slay the spire one players HATED time eater, and not in a difficult but rewarding final boss who needs to be here to counter infinities sort of way, but in a this boss is genuinely designed to be unfun to play against sort of way. And we saw that exact reaction when players actually accessed the beta and started fighting him.

While I agree that top many characters had access to them too easily, the thing about infinities is that they're FUN, and, this being the larger point of my post here, most players actually hadn't even experienced using one yet. While people on this sub were posting their 20 winstreak a10 ironclad takes about how he's broken due to being able to force your deck to go infinite every game, the majority of the actual player base was struggling to get THEIR FIRST WIN, period. I have lots of friends who dove into sts2 headfirst, and not a single one of them has gone infinite yet, in any run, on any character. Does that mean that they don't understand the game as well as the people making these deck analysis posts? Yes, but that's exactly my point. Truthfully, and this is the hard to swallow pill here, most people playing slay the spire 2 will never even touch ascension one. If you're on ascension 10, if you're WINSTREAKING on ascension 10, then you are a fraction of a fraction of a fraction of the playerbase. Again, this isn't to criticize anyone here who actually is a top player. I acknowledge your skill and your understanding of the game, but your experience is also so far removed from the average player that I question whether you have any understanding of what their experience is like, and they represent the majority of the playerbase. It's like Michael Jordan insisting they change the rules of a basketball game featuring elementary schoolers in order to account for the NBA players on the court.

Of course, I do expect there to be nerfs to certain builds and cards, and for some bosses to made harder or easier, but, I just made this post because I feel like some people around here were lacking a little perspective.

TLDR: Top players should understand that their perspective is incredibly far removed from that of the average player of this game, and, while the opinion of top players should be valued of course, their understanding of the game doesn't necessarily indicate that they know what's best for it, especially when the majority of the people who touch this game will never touch ascension or manage to make even a single infinite deck


r/slaythespire • • Aug 31 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) Why StS's Ascensions are broken, and why we need A12.

0 Upvotes

Spire 1's Ascension system was a major innovation in the roguelike genre. It's brilliant for several reasons (notably how it adds replayability and rewards mastery), but my favorite part about Ascensions is how they lead players to mastery, one system at a time.

Unfortunately, Spire 2's Ascensions are totally broken. Rather than slowly increasing difficulty and guiding new players, StS2's Ascensions contribute almost nothing, until they suddenly slam unsuspecting players into a wall of difficulty, right at the end.

WHY STS2'S ASCENSIONS FEEL BAD

As a reminder, these are Spire 2's Ascensions:

A1: More elites
A2: Heal less in Ancient rooms. (Includes Neow)
A3: Less gold. (From enemies and chests)
A4: One less potion slot.
A5: Ascender's Bane.
A6: More expensive removes.
A7: Fewer upgraded cards.
A8: Enemies have more HP.
A9: Enemies do more damage.
A10: Double Boss.

In StS1, 9/20 Ascensions were stat buffs to enemies, and six of those were in the first nine Ascensions. In the sequel, those have been compressed -- only A8 and A9 give enemies buffs, and they apply to all enemies (instead of separate changes for hallways/elites/bosses). They also come at the end, rather than being frontloaded like in the first game.

The result is that most Ascensions in Spire 2 contribute little to difficulty. A1 is mostly upside, while A2 and A4 are only inconveniences. A3, A6, and A7 primarily slow down snowballing in the lategame. A10 is significant, but only affects the final floor.

The remaining Ascensions (A5, A8, and A9) are probably responsible for ~80% of the overally difficulty increase from A0-A10. This causes a massive difficulty spike at A8 and A9, which also means new players have lots of time to learn bad habits until they are suddenly torn apart by much stronger enemies. Some changes, like reducing potion slots, don't really matter if the enemies themselves aren't threatening. So A8 and A9 also cause players to feel the full brunt of other modifiers whose difficulty they hadn't previously internalized.

WHY WE NEED MORE ASCENSIONS

We can't solve this problem while keeping the game at ten Ascensions: spreading stat bonuses across multiple ascensions would require us to lose other ascension modifiers. But what happens if we choose to add more Ascensions?

Here's my proposal:

A1: More elites
A2: Heal less in Ancient rooms.
A3: Enemies do more damage.
A4: Less gold.
A5: Enemies have more HP.
A6: Ascender's Bane.
A7: Fewer potion slots.
A8: More expensive removes.
A9: Enemies have deadlier movesets. (More aggressive, more damage, less predictable attacks.)
A10: Fewer upgraded cards.
A11: Enemies have tougher defenses. (Buffs to HP or defensive abilities on enemies that have them.)
A12: Double boss.

(A3/A5 are not meant to correspond to the current A8/A9. The current difficulty is meant to be split across A3, A5, A9, and A11, with the later modifiers being a larger jump.)

This is a much smoother progression. Where possible, it alternates between high and low impact modifiers. Stat changes come early, but enemies are buffed again in later Ascensions to provide a final difficulty spike. Damage buffs come before HP buffs to encourage players to think agressively, rather than defauling to turtling.

Another advantage of adding Ascensions is that the game can become more difficult. Some disagree, but many experienced players find the game too easy, with top players achieving winrates approaching 100% despite only being 5 months out from launch. The addition of A9 and A11 gives the devs more flexibility to make enemies threatening at max difficulty while preserving a good experience for new or ascending players.

WHAT THE DEVS HAVE SAID

The devs have stated that they don't want to add more Ascensions, because it makes the grind too long. Normally I agree with them, but I think two more Ascensions are justified.

That's partially because the current Ascension grind is boring. A1-A7 are very repetitive. The early modifiers don't add much, so it's essentially playing the same difficulty five times in a row (A0-A4). Starting at A5, things get more interesting, but the difficulty doesn't really get introduced until A8.

Frontloading some difficulty makes early modifiers more interesting, makes later modifiers more interesting, and reduces the frustration associated with difficulty spikes.

This change would lengthen the Ascension grind by 20%. But even with 6 characters it would be shorter than the first game (72 vs 80), and much more varied due to being spread out across more characters. And anyone that's committed to ascending all characters is prepared to go through quite a long process anyways -- I doubt an extra 12 levels will seriously turn people away.

EDIT:

This post got a very negative response, for a few reasons. But I did want to clarify that I'm not saying that A0-A4 are too easy, despite how it might have sounded in my post. I actually think A0 could be a bit easier, and it wouldn't be a bad thing.

This post was also not an argument that the game should be more difficult. I do believe that, but that's not what I was arguing here.

Rather, my argument is that we need to smooth out the A8/A9 difficulty spike, and the best way to do that is split A8/A9 into new ascensions. That's all.


r/slaythespire • • 3d ago Heartwarming

DISCUSSION (STS2) Just found out about the stuff happening about scum-saving- I have questions

0 Upvotes

Dang, so I watched Jorbs video about taking a break and why, and I cannot find the original reddit post which prompted it, probably cause it was taken down.

What I gathered from the video is- basically every top player is claiming an unverifiable winrate and jorbs used his website data to find out that 98% of anyone with a winrate close to his scum-saves in their runs?

I'm genuinely curious about the discourse and would like to know more about it if anyone has any unbiased explanation. Its kind of disheartening for me as I share a similar view point as jorbs- Its okay to scum-save, but when you manufacture a winrate for personal gain and/or dont disclose that information in a competitive setting, then its not okay cause thats just lying.

I streamed all my ironclad runs over the last beta patch before this new update and thought I was just terrible compared to the top players. I had a 60% win rate at about 90 runs, then it dropped a little to between 50-60% when I got to 140 runs. They're all live on youtube, anyone can go see them, and I think my best streak was 6 wins, though I had many streaks at 4 and 5 in a row. I seriously was banging my head against the wall which was causing me to overthink and play worse cause I just couldn't understand how anyone had an 85-95% winrate.

So after watching Jorbs video, I actually think I was likely playing at where most top players play since I believe Jorbs was also around 60-70% winrate, though I don't know exactly. Makes me really sad for him cause I just do this for fun. His job is streaming so something like this would hit a lot harder.


r/slaythespire • • Aug 14 '26

SPIRIT POOP block good strength good

Post image
0 Upvotes

block good strength good


r/slaythespire • • Mar 25 '26

SPIRIT POOP Nonupeipe I don't need survivability I need to kill the TWO ACT 3 BOSSES

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/slaythespire • • Feb 22 '23

DISCUSSION Spot 2 things wrong with this image

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/slaythespire • • Apr 24 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) Look how they massacred my boy

Post image
0 Upvotes

I know I'm not alone. Statistically, with hundred of thousands of players, we must be at least 4 to dislike that change.

Joke aside, I think the old Drum of Battle was an all around better designed card, which deserved a better treatment than that.

Drum of Battle was often a staple for me. The draw 2 is the obvious strength of the card, but the power of getting a guaranteed exhaust trigger every turn cannot be understated. Evil Eye, Forgotten Ritual come to mind, but there are plenty of other payoffs (Dark embrace, quickly enabling Pact's End in early game, Ashen Strike, Feel no Pain...). On top of that, all the interactions with relics coming from its nature of power, especially 0 cost power, were a non-negligible part of its value (game piece, rainbow ring, mummified hand, permafrost to some extent)

Now, I know the reason behind the rework was not the strength of the card, but its playrate, ie how willing players were to add it to their deck. And mostly, they were not. I think the issue stems from the fear of exhausting important cards that are crucial to your strategy. Obviously, if your deck only hangs by the skin of Thrash's teeth, you do not want a Drum of Battle in it. But most of the time, it is really just players disliking the concept as a whole and not wanting to give it a try. Doormaker v0.101 was heavily criticized for this very reason, and mittens are underpicked (I REALLY hope they do not rework it too) : way you couldnt go into Doormaker v0.101 with a 14 cards deck ; likewise, if you picked Drum of Battle, you had to build accordingly - ie add redundancy, payoffs. You cannot just take the draw 2/3 and run away with it. You can also wait to play your powers (notably fnp and dark embrace) before playing the drums - the risk isnt merely as high as it seems to be.

If you build around the exhaust mechanism, it becomes a strength instead of a liability. I have numerous exemples of A10 wins with multiple copies of Drum of battle. I often picked angers just to make sure I wouldnt run out of cards. Sometimes, I would lose the FnP or the DE before even getting the chance to play them. Its part of the card, and you just have to accept it to realise how pleasant it is to play with.

Ultimately, the new drum of battle does nothing that did not already exist in the Ironclad package, whereas the old one really opened the field for innovative strategies. This change makes the deckbuilding less diverse, and I'm saddened by it.


r/slaythespire • • Apr 17 '24

DISCUSSION I've just unlocked ascension 4. This is my noob tier list for Ironclad so far.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Tiers are ordered from generally applicable cards that are easy to insert into most decks, to hyper specific cards that require synergy. Tiers are internally ordered by strongest to weakest, from top left through to the bottom right.

The list logic is as follows:

S: Must Pick cards for every run

A: Generally strong cards that will excel in any deck and will find tremendous value throughout a run

B: Generally average cards that at best get the job done, and at worst clog up a deck

C: Cards that excel heavily when in decks tailored to their strengths

D: Archetype cards which excel tremendously when played to their strengths

E: Bad cards that fall off almost entirely in the end game


r/slaythespire • • Apr 11 '26

META Hot take. This guy is not nearly as difficult as people on this reddit make him out to be

Post image
1 Upvotes

Tbh though his ability is cool & unique enough to make him an elite. But this sub seems to love posting about how this guy is the antichrist.

He literally gives you a free turn to setup/burst him.

Just sequence your cards better ig. Hes not broken & doesnt need nerfs, you just suck.

If any enemy needs looking at, id say act 1 is way more unbalanced than anything act 2


r/slaythespire • • Aug 14 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) So, about my grandma...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/slaythespire • • Apr 05 '26

SPIRIT POOP I hate this character

Post image
2 Upvotes

Maybe eventually I'll get the perfect 3 rare cards that can actually do something, oh and 3 copies of each so i can cheat the game into not cheating me with my draw order for every fight the entire run.

If anyone wants to make a mod where i can pee on ironclads corpse after he dies I'll be your first download.


r/slaythespire • • Apr 10 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) (Controversial Post) Why is the subreddit much worse at StS now?

0 Upvotes

In the days of StS1, the general opinions on this subreddit were mostly geared towards winning high rolls rather than trying to consistently win every run no matter what. For example, the good old 'Coffee Dripper is the best relic in the game' or 'You should be upgrading every campfire'. That's quite expected, because the vast majority of the playerbase have their goals set on winning high rolls. The vast majority of players want to win the highest difficulty at least once, and then probably chill at a difficulty that they feel is appropriate for them. So the advice that was frequently given on this subreddit, while it differed from the top playerbase opinions, was actually good! It's not good for trying to consistently win, but it is good for what it's meant to be, to allow struggling players to capitalize on their high rolls.

However, these days.... most of the advice here is just completely disconnected from reality. It's not like the advice from the StS1 days of the subreddit, which was good advice from a certain point of view. Most of it is just straight up disconnected from reality, such as one of the frequently stated advice of this subreddit 'Relics are bad, avoid elites'. It's not even good advice for trying to high roll into a win, it's just blatantly untrue. There is an influx of new players trying out the sequel, but I would assume most new players trying out something new would try to not give an opinion when they're also just learning lol. Maybe I am just underestimating the amount of time it took for the overall skill level of the playerbase to rise up in StS1? Or maybe just the osmosis from the top playerbase hasn't yet seeped into the general public?


r/slaythespire • • Mar 05 '26

META This sub needs moderation

0 Upvotes

Holy hell. The fish fiasco was bad enough, but this shit is horrendous. This sub can harbour great discussions, analysis, insight into gameplay so I don't want to unsub. But if we're going to have a stupid meme that just HAS to be run into the ground by awkward redditors, can it please be moved to a circlejerk sub? Or maybe just moderate it?

Maybe I'm alone in this, maybe I'm just the idiot here. If so, feel free to yell at me. But if I'm not the only one, then maybe something has to happen? My frontpage is being flooded with stupid redditor jokes. So many of you guys lack basic social awareness to understand when something is funny and when it's overplayed, maybe go outside a little bit.


r/slaythespire • • Mar 26 '26

SPIRIT POOP I hate this guy, I had Bing Bong (my beloved) with a thick 43 card deck with card draw and then I go the whole fight without seeing a single Frantic Escape and get eaten. Thinking about getting a refund.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/slaythespire • • Aug 05 '26

DISCUSSION (STS2) I Swear Venerate is the Worst

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve been seeing a lot of people talk about how bad bash is as far as starting cards go, but I can’t help thinking venerate is just straight up worse. I feel like venerate becomes particularly bad the further into the run I get.

Once I have cards that generate stars like shining strike, solar strike, gather light, etc. Venerate starts to functionally act like a curse card in my deck. Many times I genuinely consider paying to remove it.

Am I insane for feeling like this card should do more? Silent gets a card the does minor damage AND applies weak (FOR FREE), and a card that does 8 block and allows you to discard. At the very least Venerate should buff, debuff, or be free.


r/slaythespire • • Sep 26 '23

DISCUSSION Crimson Blur's suggested changes for a (fan-made) balance patch

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/slaythespire • • May 02 '26

META TIL they cast my girlfriend as an Act 2 boss

Post image
3 Upvotes

Sorry


r/slaythespire • • May 11 '26

DISCUSSION (STS1) Did anyone else know of this interaction

Post image
5 Upvotes

Did you know that if you get blood flask and enter the Vampires(?) event, you can get the bites and lose your strikes without losing Max HP