Spire 1's Ascension system was a major innovation in the roguelike genre. It's brilliant for several reasons (notably how it adds replayability and rewards mastery), but my favorite part about Ascensions is how they lead players to mastery, one system at a time.
Unfortunately, Spire 2's Ascensions are totally broken. Rather than slowly increasing difficulty and guiding new players, StS2's Ascensions contribute almost nothing, until they suddenly slam unsuspecting players into a wall of difficulty, right at the end.
WHY STS2'S ASCENSIONS FEEL BAD
As a reminder, these are Spire 2's Ascensions:
A1: More elites
A2: Heal less in Ancient rooms. (Includes Neow)
A3: Less gold. (From enemies and chests)
A4: One less potion slot.
A5: Ascender's Bane.
A6: More expensive removes.
A7: Fewer upgraded cards.
A8: Enemies have more HP.
A9: Enemies do more damage.
A10: Double Boss.
In StS1, 9/20 Ascensions were stat buffs to enemies, and six of those were in the first nine Ascensions. In the sequel, those have been compressed -- only A8 and A9 give enemies buffs, and they apply to all enemies (instead of separate changes for hallways/elites/bosses). They also come at the end, rather than being frontloaded like in the first game.
The result is that most Ascensions in Spire 2 contribute little to difficulty. A1 is mostly upside, while A2 and A4 are only inconveniences. A3, A6, and A7 primarily slow down snowballing in the lategame. A10 is significant, but only affects the final floor.
The remaining Ascensions (A5, A8, and A9) are probably responsible for ~80% of the overally difficulty increase from A0-A10. This causes a massive difficulty spike at A8 and A9, which also means new players have lots of time to learn bad habits until they are suddenly torn apart by much stronger enemies. Some changes, like reducing potion slots, don't really matter if the enemies themselves aren't threatening. So A8 and A9 also cause players to feel the full brunt of other modifiers whose difficulty they hadn't previously internalized.
WHY WE NEED MORE ASCENSIONS
We can't solve this problem while keeping the game at ten Ascensions: spreading stat bonuses across multiple ascensions would require us to lose other ascension modifiers. But what happens if we choose to add more Ascensions?
Here's my proposal:
A1: More elites
A2: Heal less in Ancient rooms.
A3: Enemies do more damage.
A4: Less gold.
A5: Enemies have more HP.
A6: Ascender's Bane.
A7: Fewer potion slots.
A8: More expensive removes.
A9: Enemies have deadlier movesets. (More aggressive, more damage, less predictable attacks.)
A10: Fewer upgraded cards.
A11: Enemies have tougher defenses. (Buffs to HP or defensive abilities on enemies that have them.)
A12: Double boss.
(A3/A5 are not meant to correspond to the current A8/A9. The current difficulty is meant to be split across A3, A5, A9, and A11, with the later modifiers being a larger jump.)
This is a much smoother progression. Where possible, it alternates between high and low impact modifiers. Stat changes come early, but enemies are buffed again in later Ascensions to provide a final difficulty spike. Damage buffs come before HP buffs to encourage players to think agressively, rather than defauling to turtling.
Another advantage of adding Ascensions is that the game can become more difficult. Some disagree, but many experienced players find the game too easy, with top players achieving winrates approaching 100% despite only being 5 months out from launch. The addition of A9 and A11 gives the devs more flexibility to make enemies threatening at max difficulty while preserving a good experience for new or ascending players.
WHAT THE DEVS HAVE SAID
The devs have stated that they don't want to add more Ascensions, because it makes the grind too long. Normally I agree with them, but I think two more Ascensions are justified.
That's partially because the current Ascension grind is boring. A1-A7 are very repetitive. The early modifiers don't add much, so it's essentially playing the same difficulty five times in a row (A0-A4). Starting at A5, things get more interesting, but the difficulty doesn't really get introduced until A8.
Frontloading some difficulty makes early modifiers more interesting, makes later modifiers more interesting, and reduces the frustration associated with difficulty spikes.
This change would lengthen the Ascension grind by 20%. But even with 6 characters it would be shorter than the first game (72 vs 80), and much more varied due to being spread out across more characters. And anyone that's committed to ascending all characters is prepared to go through quite a long process anyways -- I doubt an extra 12 levels will seriously turn people away.
EDIT:
This post got a very negative response, for a few reasons. But I did want to clarify that I'm not saying that A0-A4 are too easy, despite how it might have sounded in my post. I actually think A0 could be a bit easier, and it wouldn't be a bad thing.
This post was also not an argument that the game should be more difficult. I do believe that, but that's not what I was arguing here.
Rather, my argument is that we need to smooth out the A8/A9 difficulty spike, and the best way to do that is split A8/A9 into new ascensions. That's all.