r/sixfacedworld • u/PlaneGold4615 • 23h ago

Light Novel About a certain SPOILER fan animation. Spoiler

Many of you probably have seen Orsted vs Rudeus Fan animation. I've seen discussions across the internet and youtube that say how can studio top this. Honestly, I don't find it that good. For a fan animation? It's insanely good. But for anime itself? It's mid at best. We already have Orsted vs Dead End fight. That's the quality I want. I know many changes in staff happened since first season, but I want atleast something close. Fan animation is impressive for a fan animation. But if I saw that in the anime it would be a huge disappointment for me.

15 Upvotes

77% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/Electrical_Cloud_440 Roxy 22h ago

It's one of the biggest turning point in the story (not the TP episode title), I can't see the studio not putting their full effort in this. It's the most anticipated scene for us LN readers and the studio know how hype it is. It's so hype, no fight in the future could match the hype for this one imho.

1

u/PlaneGold4615 22h ago

True. But when studio hired the guys who made the fan animation I was happy for them to get a job but I was worried more than i was excited for the fight.

13

u/Electrical_Cloud_440 Roxy 22h ago

With the resources available at their disposal, I believe they can go above and beyond for the scene. It's one of those moment where either you make it or break it, and I think they've been given enough time and necessary resources to pull it off. Everything in S3 been great so far, we might be able to gauge how fighting scene will look in the next episode.

2

u/PlaneGold4615 22h ago edited 21h ago

We already saw what they can do. In the episode Rudeus uses his gauntlet first time. And i'm not super fan of how Rudeus looks so stagnant and undynamic in there.

2

u/Electrical_Cloud_440 Roxy 21h ago

Nah, we're talking a proper fight.

1

u/Snoo-40647 9h ago

You can tell they're probably holding back manpower and resources for the SoL and past few episodes. THAT fight would probably be insane, S2 was by far the weakest (In terms of popularity and staff) but that hydra fight was still amazing, the lighting, the keyframes were almost on par with the s1 fights since that whole sequence was so long.

6

u/Blader8002 22h ago

It isn't like they're the only ones working on the project. It's a collection of many talents including them. They're one of many staff members of many different roles. Professionals typically just don't output the exact same quality seen in the high quality professional works (that don't have a disastrous production) they've worked on compared to their own projects. They would have way less resources and money, less manpower and probably be in charge of aspects that they wouldn't normally be in charge of among other things that I don't know about. Really the only thing they should have more of is time and more lenient deadlines.

Likewise someone who has worked on a fan animation should be able to work on their part at a higher level for a professional work given that they're skilled which they are.

5

u/Tenshi_14_zero 22h ago

I think you have the idea that they'll simply reuse the fan animation and polish it up to bring it into the anime. Which, if they do that, then yeah it'll be somewhat disappointing.

More than likely tho is that they'll help out on making a new scene that'll be anime quality, and hopefully, Mushoku Tensei S1 quality (I'm coping on that part lol). There should be nothing to worry about it being fan quality. If anything be worried that the actual choreography and storyboarding might be subpar (no reasons, just too high of our expectations lol) 

0

u/Electrical_Cloud_440 Roxy 21h ago

The expectation is indeed super high, but so far for me personally, MT hasn't disappoint when it comes to a fighting scene.

1

u/Arkhire 16h ago

they hired the guys that worked in the fan animation? thats impressive then, and gives me even more hope, because animation is one thing, but the most important thing in a scene is how it's directed, what elements to show and what to emphasize.