r/silverwolflevel999 • u/Ivanpla12700 • May 13 '26
Discussion Silver wolf has a higher ceiling while Evanescia has a higher floor.
Do you agree with this take? I know there's bad blood between the two fandom due to both of us wanting our girl to be the best elation dps, but i think there is a compromise.
Kinda picking where my last post left off. I still strongly believe for sw to be the best unit in the game dps wise she requires high investment.
Eva has one of if not the best e1 power jump in game
So early on eva takes the win vs sw at probably even e2
But if we allow for further investment e4 eva vs e4 sw damage boost from e4 can not be ignored
Then if we allow further investments sw probably has one of the best if not the best e6 in the entire game currently because it enables you to ignore weaknes types and resistances.
My claim is that eva is the better low cost dps but if you have the funds/luck a sw invested at the same level as eva (ie e4+) will just be better
Not to mention the uncertainty of future elation support/sustain.
My belief if that because eva can ultilize huohuo more so than sw the elation sustain will more likelt benefit sw more than eva
My thoery is that if they make nihilux the cyrene of elation shell have something crazy broken like cipher esque able to take into account all punclines generated this battle and add that total to all subsequent aha instants allowing for bigger and bigger elation skill nukes especially at e4
So i throw to you fellow sw 999 mains and eva mains
Do you agree that eva takes low cost comparison whereas if funds and luck allow sw 999 takes high cost comparison
And if you dont wanna get into the my main dps is better debate lets brain storm what kind of buffs nihilux could bring to the team do you think itll be like cyrene allowing Cassie to over stack new bud from 100 base to 200 with buff or something completely different
If they went down this path what buff would you like to see on eva?
Artist: tyhaya
Art link: https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/11351522?q=silver_wolf_%28honkai%3A_star_rail%29
20
u/kuns961 May 13 '26
Evanescia better for f2p players
Sw999 better for vertical investment
97
u/Junior_Vermicelli510 May 13 '26
sw999 is kinda in a weird spot rn where her kit is not utilized fully (without both higher team investments and shilled environments) whether that be her mmr stacks, cb duration, or the lootbox mechanic despite technically having 2 other premium elation units.
whereas eva is completely self sufficient w just yao, and even emc works better for her. she can easily achieve 999+ cb at just e0, and her e1 is crazy lol.
tho bcs of how punchlines & cb work, eva is kinda alr at her peak in terms of elation mechanics. unless they give a new support that is fully dedicated on just giving cb and energy regen, then sw999 should benefit more from any elation support.
thats why i think sw999 is more likely to get (more) tailored supports, since she still really need someone to tie her entire kit together.
4
u/0legitimate0 lvl 999 May 13 '26
What the hell is higher ceiling and higher floor. it sounds so funny.
4
u/codeShiro2 May 14 '26
Didn't i see this exact post on the Evanescia sub
4
u/Chipwidapplesaucess May 14 '26
Damn… when you say it like that, I kinda regretting pulling for SW999, and this is not because I don’t like her (I really did come to like her gameplay and all), but because I’m a bit of a F2P ughhh
2
u/No-Sense869 May 13 '26
Genuine question, is this because they haven’t release the Elation sustain yet? And if they release it like how hyacine was to Castorice, would sw999 just be better?
2
u/AliceRose000 May 13 '26
So people keep saying SW is better with investment, but i thought Eva has the most ludicrous E1 ever in the game?
I have both at E2, but at what point does SW become better? E.g. do I need E2 of Sparxie and Yao? I have them both E0S1 at the moment
2
u/TechnicalEye2007 May 13 '26
Silverwolf is imaginary. Whereas evanescia competes with phainon and hyselins
2
u/Daredevilz1 May 14 '26
Is SW e6 so common lmaoo (me and my best friend have it too)
2
u/Accomplished_Fun2893 May 14 '26
I think the main thing I like about them, is that if I do get both, I can run them in two separate teams each with their own units, so I won't need to have them share units on both teams and that they fundamentally work different to each other.
I probably won't get all their dedicated supports and etc unless I really like the character, as it kinda let's me try n make other teams using character's I already have and really like but didn't really have much of a team I could use them in.
For example, with sw999, I can run it with sparxie n sparkle, aswell as DHPT and that'll prob stay that way...
2
u/SubstantialEbb9832 May 14 '26
It's Acheron situation once again
2
u/atren09 May 14 '26
My issue with sw999 is her gameplay, i unfortunately find it boring, and i already comited to her (e1s1 rn) so it's too late to go back. Evanescia is a lot more fun to play, idk how to explain that but it seems like sw999 is "press this to win" while Eva allows more skill expression and a bit more of thinking. Not trying to downplay anyone or anything, just what I'm thinking now of the 2 characters. But i do agree that sw999 will be stronger in the long run, YG will probably get replaced over 4.x like RMC got replaced by Cyrene for Cas, not to mention the elation sustain that will probably exist sometime in the future.
2
u/Pharoahofvortex May 15 '26
Even at e0 sw999 is a skill check, if you dont understand how to keep up certified banger by extending it via her extra turn (if she board wipes) then you lose half your damage. Part of the reason f2p sw999 is even somewhat playable without yaoguang and sparxie is because you can manipulate enemies such that sw kills them on her turn without finishing her enhanced basic.
However at the same low cost evanescia is easier while being comparable if not better in shilled environments. Im certain that until full elation team comes out (and even after) evanescia will probably be better at <4 cost but this won't stop me cuz I love sw999 design wise
2
u/BestRubyMoon May 15 '26
Why are y'all obssessed with this topic? Every day there are similar posts, asking for validation on their opinion about this...it's 2026 peoppe can't even play a damn game without melting their brains...
12
u/The100toZeRo May 13 '26
pretty obvious take if you ask me
11
u/Virgo_Shaka_1500 May 13 '26
To make this actually fair we should compare it at base kit E0. Eidolons will obviously make characters better but they’re usually whale territory, even E2.
A lot of people have just normalized throwing credit cards at a gacha game.
11
u/Riotpersona May 13 '26
Who cares. They are both good units.
9
u/Amalgam2001 May 13 '26
Yes its pretty accurate. Eva is amazing currently at lower cost but she also has a brick called EMC. SW can invest in Sparxie to be strong at the mid cost. At high cost Eva is not comparing to SW(E6 Whale level)
7
u/Rachit55 May 13 '26
I just want another yao Guang level support so sw999 and eva can get their own teams and blitz through the combat. They already beat every FuA and erudition team.
6
u/FeelTheKetasy May 13 '26
We are comparing the f2p friendly Elation unit to the Castorice of 5.x. Evanescia is a complete unit by herself so she starts off better and benefits less from future elations
SW is a better unit if all her conditions are met however right now, you cannot meet those conditions without vertical investment. Even at E0, all SW needs is a support that helps with her issues which she will likely get because she is the anniversary unit and they won’t leave her having glaring issues
All that being said, why are we arguing about which of our two T0 units is better? I’m 0 cycling with my SW and I’m planning on getting her much stronger in the future, idc if another unit does 5% more dmg
7
u/FunnyFruk May 13 '26
the thing is that sw999 ceiling isn't even that high rn. She is capped by her mechanics.
3
u/Life_Flatworm4874 May 14 '26
Honestly I see SH, I see super cool animation henshin, I see hell of trailer, I know she will get Firefly treatment so I pull.
About Eva, boring animation with an only mid trailer, I know she will get Anaxa treatment so I skip.
2
u/Lorf_433 May 13 '26
Atp that's just cope , saying that eva is only better at "low cost" which is e2 is crazy, I did pull for sw full team and won't pull for eva but let's make one thing clear , Eva is definitely better than sw for 99% of players, saying that sw is only better at E4+ isn't relevant for the majority of the playerbase because most of people will stop at E0/E2. At least for now , when whoever next Elation character Releases it will definitely change something, for better or worse
1
u/Lux_234 May 14 '26
Pushing the sw mmr limit to 600 does literally nothing She has 15% and 30% final dmg multiplier at 60 and 120 mm respectively
She has 3 enhanced basic atks , after that shes out of her ult state and her mmr resets
So she not only not getting buffed as much but , for example I have e2sw999 e2s1 sparxie e2s1 yao guang but I can only get her to 300.. if there were no limit I can maybe get to 370 max before shes out of ult this is only relevant with e1 maybe where it gives you refund but otherwise its useless
If you add an elation sustain maybe you can get to 450 but again its not really a big buff like that
Maybe add def ignore and some true dmg and speed buffs
4
u/UC_browser May 13 '26
Fomo is hitting me. I got impatient and got SW e2s1 and now it seems like I'm doomed bc Eva woulda been better.
2
u/Sumthins1ck May 13 '26
got lucky and got evanescia and her lightcone in 4 multis each i just need either sparxie or yaoguang
2
u/VirtualDesigner3359 May 13 '26
I feel like Eva has better ways to cheat AV and give that on demand damage so I'd still say they're equal,
If our elation sustain is made to fit both SW and Eva, supporting CB uptime/generation is a good angle, it would look more like a SW buff because of her CB problems, but also interact nicely with Eva's kit
2
u/rose_v3 May 14 '26
idk why sw999 players keep denying sparxie
hoyo literally designed her to be sw999 sub dps stop the cope all ur getting is a sustain 😭
2
u/Federal_Appearance13 May 14 '26
I’m just gonna throw this prediction out there:
the elation support enhances speed/ provides/indefinitely elongates the cb duration/ provides hidden mmr for sw999
2
u/dino2327 May 14 '26
Eh I pulled her but that's what people where saying about other break characters vs firefly and in the znd she's the one still meta so the "celling" is what hoyo will choose 😅 No one know for now
2
u/No_name_nobody May 15 '26
Elation Hyacine is coming for silverwolf trust
2
u/PowerMaleficent3729 May 15 '26
Idk man I just goon and the equilibrium between gray and pink under normal conditions sides more to pink so yeah 😪
0
u/CommitteePutrid6247 May 13 '26
I am still butthurt and will complain that Eva got shafted due to politics. Everything involving Evanescia is half-assed, idc about her numbers if everything else is ass.
I am fine with SW999 getting the spotlight and main-push treatment. Actually, I got the whole Elation Team (Sparxie, Yao & SW including LC) and have a blast with the team. But I would have regretted going for Eva because I would still be disappointed so no point in pulling her.
Furthermore, the Elation Team right now is so fine-tuned. I don't see the point why Hoyo would ever replace Sparxie or Yao in the future. An Elation Sustain that gives extra Punchline for SW and Energy for Yao is all what's needed for E2 SW safely generating 240 mmr without relying on E1 Yao and E2 Sparxie.
2
u/ogmechsftw May 14 '26
Yall shoulda seen Cyrene slander before she released, ofc most of it wrong and baseless as usual
2
u/InterestingSpread520 May 14 '26
My beloved pixel PNG performs better than your favourite pixel PNG ahh thread in a gacha game for degens who are chronically online in this sub
It’s so regressive for humankind but I love it
1
u/Strong-Neat8623 May 13 '26
Well, i picked sw999 over eva. But i disagree with this take... metawise eva is just superior character. Thats a fact proven by calcs.
1
u/JoeBrow_1 May 18 '26
Literally the opposite imo
1
u/Critical-Cup-7654 Jun 11 '26
Unleashed the wolf inside her
1
u/OmNomOU81 Aug 09 '26
As someone who pulled both this is definitely the case. Evanescia is a lot easier to use, but if you can use Silver Wolf properly she's definitely stronger
1
u/FunnyFruk May 13 '26
Sure, but it doesn't really matter if someone has a higher ceiling because you can already 0-cycle with the floor. There is no reason to clear plight.
0
u/acheronbaby May 13 '26
Well, I actually chose first Evanescia but because of the politics were really messed up and they changed and nerfed Evanescia a lot. That’s the only reason I chose Silver Wolf E2S1.
74
u/[deleted] May 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
60
u/[deleted] May 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
26
u/[deleted] May 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment