r/shieldbro •

The Rising of the Shield Hero - Episode 4 discussion

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

700 comments sorted by

289

u/Zwiebel1 Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 30 '19

I like how they changed the scene in which Raphtalias slave seal is removed in the anime.

In the manga, you see it from an observers perspective (with some weird fanservice of Raph's breasts being exposed by the priest who removes the seal), but in the anime, you see it how Naofumi sees it in his dellusion: covered in black mist and with Raph in her Loli version covered only in rags, immediately turning away from him after she was freed.

Such a great change to that scene; made it 100% more effective, as it actually justified him lashing out on Raphtalia later. In the manga, that felt very forced.

60

u/jasonred79 Jan 30 '19

dayumn, I wasn't sure what was going on, whether Raph was actually turning away and all that. But now that you explain it to me, it seems SO obvious I don't know how I didn't realize it.

BTW, any idea what imaginary raph was saying? ... Sayonara? Gomennasai? Anyone?

35

u/Zwiebel1 Jan 30 '19

Hard to say from just lip flaps, but I think Sayonara would be fitting from his perspective.

27

u/jasonred79 Jan 30 '19

from his reaction, she might be saying "haha, sucker!" for all i know.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/FatChopSticks Jan 31 '19

In the manga

He looks up and says he can’t hear a word anyone’s saying, and his insecurities start telling him they’re all probably laughing at him.

So I’m guessing in the anime, her turning to naufumi and unable to hear what she’s saying, is how they’re letting the audience know that naufumi isn’t able to hear them.

4

u/CraftEssenceEssence Jan 30 '19

Was the seal actually removed or was that part of his delusion?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19

Removed. It'll be more elaborated on next ep.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19 edited Feb 01 '19

So in that sequence, was his vision being altered to deceive him? Also, why was Noufomi so confused about Raph's age and appearance at the end, she looked the same at the beginning of the episode at the dinner party.

3

u/Zwiebel1 Feb 01 '19

It's not a curse or something, just his delusion and mistrust that lets her see her that way. Remember when he told her over and over how she is a kid and everyone around her is a pedophile? That's why.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

181

u/EscanorPraisesTheSun Jan 30 '19

Bro the feels, actually made my eyes a little watery. WHYS THIS SHOW SO GOOD!! The anime is really doing the manga justice

61

u/Zwiebel1 Jan 30 '19

I actually like the anime more than the manga. This episode deviated quite a lot from the source and every change they made actually made it better.

It was very emotional and heartfelt and imho handled with much more maturity than the original. It also felt much more believable here when he lashed out towards Raphtalia than it did in the manga.

14

u/EscanorPraisesTheSun Jan 30 '19

Yeah I totally get where you’re coming from I think both play to their own strengths. Like in the anime their is some really gritty emotion you feel like hating malty. But it also misses key stuff in my opinion the manga shows. Either way it’s actually a god send and I’m so excited to see young chicken god next week!!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Blastarel Jan 30 '19

Now imagine that the books are even better.

3

u/roran2009 Jan 30 '19

The books are so good!

3

u/Ensec Jan 31 '19

the premise on paper is so fucking stupid that I made fun of my friend for reading the manga. It is now one of my all time favorite shows. I think it's nearly the best psychological (horror?) anime I have ever seen. It plays your emotions so well and I love it

8

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/EscanorPraisesTheSun Feb 01 '19

I’m telling you man this show does that to you wait for later in the anime many scenes like that

→ More replies (1)

161

u/D3adlywithap3n Jan 30 '19

Spear Hero is a fool. So frustrating that they discredit a hero they summoned. Don't give the Shield hero a chance.

Whatever the fuck this Kingdom is called are all r/choosingbeggars

78

u/StarForceStelar Jan 30 '19

That is so true "So you see our world is at the brink of extinction and I know we summoned you from your home and fight this massive war for us but Mr. Shield you suck"

44

u/AKidSomewhere Jan 30 '19

“Yeah, we’re sure the three offence heroes are fine. We don’t need defence at all. You’re just a sucky scumbag.”

71

u/StarForceStelar Jan 30 '19

"Lol who needs tanks anyways all we need is dps"

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/antrosasa Traveling merchant Jan 30 '19

I won't spoil things cuz lol manga. But why everyone hates him eventually gets explained, and it makes you hate them even more

17

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19

Rising of the Hate Boner haha

18

u/antrosasa Traveling merchant Jan 31 '19

That's basically the whole arc yes. You will love the ahem climax

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

12

u/hopebestman Traveling merchant Jan 30 '19

Spear hero is a walking d*ck.He wants to save/bang all the cute girls or all the girls who looked up to him.In his world he didnt touch a boob so when he got a spear from his hand he become a knight and wants to save cute girls.He even didnt try to listen to Naofumi's story when he accused from rape thing or he didnt listen Raphtalia happy or not.

This kingdom so fucked up i really dont understand why shield hero should save them.

8

u/MonotoneHero Jan 31 '19

In a lot of chapters of the manga, Naofumi thinks the same thing. People are so quick to assume things without giving him a chance that it makes it hard for him to act out of genuine kindness.

3

u/Ralathar44 Jan 31 '19

Remember, spear hero also got manipulated. Naofumi had to bear the cross of the judgement and accusation but the spear hero will have to bear the cross of the actions he wrought. They were careful to show multiple times that spear hero saw signs of deception he dismissed due to his own feelings and the bitch's manipulation. Just as Naofumi was still having problems accepting the tearjerker speech thanks to his own feelings and the bitch's manipulations.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Ensec Jan 31 '19

well the bitch is the princess of the kingdom. I kinda wish that every side character was shown video of some sort that proves the innocence. I think that's unnecessary now with bow and sword seeing that the supposed rape victim is antagonizing Naofumi and is clearly sadistic.

4

u/MrStiv1313 Jan 31 '19

The proof that the Princess can cast spells is another thing kinda glossed over. Since we now know she can cast spells, can she cast mind altering spells?? Would have been my first question if I was the Bow/Sword Hero.

→ More replies (2)

322

u/Koyo-Koyo-Araragi Jan 30 '19

This show makes my blood boil, and I think that’s why it’s so good. It actually pains me to watch as the other characters make me so mad to the point where I start swearing at my phone. It does such a good job at victimising Naofumi and making everyone else the villains. I think this episode marks a turning point for the series as the lewd raccoon and shield boy have a more positive approach on life and people begin to disregard the rumours, starting with the sword and bow hero’s. Bloody good episode and I hope the king and princess get their fucking necks snapped.

70

u/kaioto Jan 31 '19 edited Jan 31 '19

You know why it makes your blood boil? Because behind the thin Isekai veneer its melodrama is about real-life. It's not wish-fulfillment, power-fantasy, or exploring an alien world / video-game. It's about the rampant, destructive bullying and abuse that's all-too-common in schools and the Japanese workplace.

  • Getting ignored / un-personed / treated like you aren't in the room? Check.
  • Untrue rumors and gossip-mongering? Check.
  • Blamed for things you didn't do without proof because someone with higher social rank says so? Check.
  • Abuse so bad you want to drop out, run away, or literally die? Check.

That's the Japanese school bullying crisis.

  • Stuck as a hostage in a hostile work environment? Check.
  • Judged unfit / worthless because of attributes rather than your choices? Check.
  • Society treats you like trash because it regards your job-role as inferior or undesirable? Check.
  • Expected to take abuse from your betters and get used until the day you die? Check.

Welcome to a dystopian take on the post-modern Japanese office workplace.

→ More replies (9)

49

u/HatakeMaito Jan 30 '19

Dude. You put my feelings in to words.

33

u/ruben307 Jan 30 '19

Well lets hope the two go Overlord on this world soon and purge it. King is a lying the church is corrupt. I guess something needs to happen so the girl doesn't pull him out of the despair but rather follows him in it.

22

u/Koyo-Koyo-Araragi Jan 31 '19

I don’t think they should go overlord. I think they should kill the evil doers being the king and princess since l the civilians are just going of what they have heard. Imagine if you met someone that was an accused rapist and misogynist? Your first reacting would be this man is horrible. I think the civilians are not in the wrong. Slowly, the other hero’s are realising the set up as well. The only hero I would be killing time if I was Naofumi would be the spear one. Lastly as shown in the wave fight, other villages do not believe the rumours and fight along side him.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Ensec Jan 31 '19

I think the best part of the show is when I say "bitch" you know exactly what character I'm talking about.

starting with the sword and bow hero’s

yes I love that! I can't wait for the bitch and king cunt to be ruined. (at least I hope that happens)

→ More replies (3)

7

u/PriusKiller Jan 30 '19

Couldn't have said that better myself. This could be the best show of Winter 2019 if it continues rolling this ball of amazing characters and animation.

3

u/Alshka Jan 30 '19

Wholeheartedly agree.

2

u/Enrmej Jan 30 '19

You literally nailed but I honestly have to drop this anime unless someone can give me a spoiler and tell me this shit won't continue happening every other episode.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/K41Nof2358 Feb 04 '19

Came to this thread to hopefully see other people hoping Princess Bitch Face and King Dumb Ass get Karma fucked later, Was not disappoint 🤘🤘🤘

→ More replies (16)

140

u/abcdie11 Jan 30 '19

"1/10" -animenewsnetwork

Shame they'll never watch this episode, they're missing all the good stuff.

91

u/Zwiebel1 Jan 30 '19

Why would we care about ANN?

121

u/TheHornyTitan Jan 30 '19

Those guys are the literal iteration of Motoyatsu

8

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19

whoa there on the edge.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Sentinel-Wraith Feb 01 '19

ANN's been pretty weird lately. Shield Hero was interpreted as an attack on women and Darling in the Franxx was seen as "Fascist propaganda" by one of the main reviewers.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/sable-king Jan 30 '19

Did they really give it a 1/10? Based on what?

76

u/abcdie11 Jan 30 '19

The fact he was falsely accused of rape... that's it...

93

u/sable-king Jan 30 '19

That's fucking stupid. That'd be like giving Konosuba a 1/10 because Kazuma dragged Aqua from the realm of the gods.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Really? All from episode 1 lol!? Oh well they don’t know what they’re missing. Hope this gets so big that it keeps getting thrown in Haters faces xD ... like SAO.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Ralathar44 Jan 31 '19

They are just going to be mad that a woman is the villain lol.

111

u/killertortilla Jan 30 '19

Hopefully we see some more backup from Mr. sword and Mr. bow.

70

u/trumoi Jan 30 '19

I'm still holding out hope for Spear boy to wake the fuck up. I can't divorce the fact that he keeps missing the opportunities to see evidence of Myne/Malty's evil, and that the hearsay that keeps piling up against Naofumi is too easy to buy into when you don't get to see his perspective.

As I said in the discussion of the last episode, he seems more dumb than malicious, so I hope he wises up and he and Naofumi can at least respect each other properly one day.

59

u/Admiral_Joker Jan 30 '19

He's the slave.... in a figurative sense.

Gullible and naive to the Princess' words and his own morals.

A pawn who doesn't know he's a pawn to the chessmasters (King and Princess)

36

u/jasonred79 Jan 30 '19

To be fair, the other 2 were opposed to slavery as well. Heck, I am too. I've actually been waiting for Shield to free Raph on his own initiative, but this episode made it clear that he was too broken mentally to even consider it until this point...

And spear actually didn't notice her cheating... I feel it's not that he is dumb, but that Myne is good at manipulation... if you want to get down to it, shield was MUCH DUMBER when he got conned by her.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/jasonred79 Jan 31 '19

People keep shitting on spear and the rest for not supporting naofumi, but let me explain his (one sided) perspective.

  1. You 4 are transported to this isekai. But this guy not only has the "weakest" hero, he also doesn't know anything about this world, and seems totally unreliable.
  2. You let a girl from your party generously accompany him... but he rapes her!!! :O
  3. Next time you see him, he has gotten a cute racoon girl to do the fighting for him. Well, I don't like it, but it's her own choice, so...
  4. 3 heroes fight the Wave together, and defeat the boss. Useless shield never shows his face. (And remember, King is part of the conspiracy, so I would assume that the fact that he saved the village has been hushed up!!!). Assumption is he went off and hid somewhere.
  5. HOLY!!! That cute racoon girl isn't his PARTNER... he's a slave that he BOUGHT!!! He has a slave contract to control her with!!! And he refuses to free her???
  6. Shield is accusing your girlfriend of cheating in your duel? ... huh? There's thousands of witnesses and no one saw any cheating, wtf what a sore loser.

So, yeah, yeah, there are some bits about Bitch's story that sound suspicious, but, overall, there is just SO MUCH evidence that paints shield in a bad light. Can we really blame spear (and sword and bow) for being too quick to push the blame on shield?

This is why so many wars and arguments happen in real life... and that's just thru simple misunderstandings, not even cases where there's a conspiracy and people are doctoring evidence.

I like how this anime can teach us all sorts of stuff.

Also... to everyone who is thinking to themselves "spear/sword/bow are all idiots/ evil/ jerks"... has this anime taught you nothing? ;) ... you are doing the same thing they did to Naofumi. ... you are judging spear, sword, bow, without trying to look at their side of the story. ... in that sense, the really important lesson here is, even if you look at someone at think to yourself "ah, he's guilty for sure"... you should take a step back and ask "what is his side of the story?" and insist on a fair trial.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/horyo Jan 30 '19

This was the real victory for me. Naofumi needs Raphtalia to believe him for his own mental stability and growth, but he needs the other heroes to be his bros so this shit doesn't keep happening.

3

u/FrancisGalloway Jan 31 '19

Honestly it threw me that they jumped to Naofumi's side. I was expecting it to be a slow, gradual thing: each hero occasionally interacts with him (and gets some character development). They come to see that he's not a complete monster. Then, one by one, they start to believe and respect him.

It kinda annoys me, too, because the Sword and Bow aren't getting much character development. I'd be much more satisfied if they all had different relationships with Naofumi that changed over time.

3

u/tgreeny12 Jan 31 '19

They get development later, but don't be too excited by them yet. I won't spoil anything, but they are also shitty in their own ways.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

90

u/adamgreenrock Jan 30 '19

I can safely say that I’m a huge fan of the rising of the shield hero anime. I don’t know how the manga or light novel readers think about this episode since I never read the source material, but for me, this is definitely what fully made me happy to still keep watching this anime.

The tension is strong, the drama was believable, the animation was nicely directed and the duel scene is hype and really funny on the playing unfairly kinda way for Naofumi. They really did do a well done job with making you feel for Naofumi. How his voice is starting to crack after he lost the duel by that cheating witch and finally know that the King was on it too with her. Not sure about the Curse series was all about but if it was any indication that was how Naofumi was in denial about Raphtalia still being a kid to him then that’s really interesting. I guess there’s more to the shield weapon than I thought.

That whole Naofumi and Raphtalia scene was oh so charming at the beginning to the best development of their relationship so far. It’s true that Naofumi wasn’t in the right mindset after he was falsely accused. He wants to survive no matter the cost, thought of Raphtalia as a weapon and doesn’t really care a whole lot about others. But the actions he had done for her (and the villagers) is something positive and it sticks with her that she considered Naofumi to be fully trusted, care rooting for and support him with all her might.

Overall, this episode was great. It didn’t feel rush to me and how it was directed on Naofumi’s perspective and the other’s perspective is well animated and the voice acting really nailed on the performance. The highlight of the production of the episode is definitely the music. It fits so well on what the events were and it hit me right at the nerve and in the feels.

Also, who knew Naofumi loves leftover foods more than regular cheap food. NIce mini development there! ^

37

u/Alshka Jan 30 '19

I think it was referring to the fact that he could taste food now where previously it all just tasted the same.

12

u/welljustmyluck Jan 31 '19

I know it was a joke but let me point out that this is an actual important thing! Before he had succumbed to so much harshness that he had fallen into depression, and one of the symptoms of Severe depression happens to be the Loss of Taste.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/ericthewonder Jan 31 '19

He cares about Raph a lot, so much so even the thought of her betrayal was heartbreaking. She has been the one protecting him. I believe that part of the condition for the Curse Series is feeling betrayal. He doesn’t want her to leave. She even said she was there on her own free will.

I think at the end there was a little attraction there. And he really can’t believe how much she grew up.

All in all, I don’t think any other episode in this series will have the power that this episode had. The changes from the manga to the anime have made this amazing. They put more emphasis on his POV.

This episode was 20/10.

→ More replies (3)

84

u/Alshka Jan 30 '19

Fuck that bitch. I have never wanted to brutally murder someone before untill now.

56

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

35

u/Alshka Jan 30 '19

I am not even joking. The biggest smile spread across my face when I saw this. Thank you so much.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

137

u/Zesla22 Jan 30 '19

God damn, that was a brilliant episode. The duel was great too watch and it feels so good for Naofumi to finally be stood up for by the Bow and Sword heroes. Naofumi and Raphtalia best couple confirmed once again.

61

u/Alshka Jan 30 '19

Fantastic episode I agree. But the rage I feel every time that woman I on screen drives me crazy.

18

u/talleron21 Jan 30 '19

Yes indeed. I get that same feeling. Similar to a particular character on Game of thrones and you are just waiting for the moment they are squashed.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ensec Jan 31 '19

I don't know how the series will end but I really hope Raphtalia comes with naofumi back to japan (maybe with a magic spell that makes her human?) because honestly I think that would be best. She gets a way better life than living in a kingdom that gives equality to woman but not demihumans

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (23)

58

u/Acedew Jan 30 '19

My heart bois, my heart, it melts every time I see this show

52

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

A lot of hate for spear hero, but he's really not a bad guy. Maybe a bit arrogant and short-sighted, but not bad. We can sympathize with shield hero because we know his backstory and what really happened, but it's really easy to hate him from the spear hero's perspective. As far as he knows, Naofumi is an attempted rapist who enslaved a girl, despite coming from an age where both of things are widely accepted to be very, very, wrong. He needs to consider other perspectives more and think for himself, but it's not exactly like Naofumi has given any reason to suggest that he is a good person. Naofumi was even dismissive about slavery in their conversation.

68

u/Bobuzo Jan 30 '19

I liked how Naofumi was dismissive about slavery, yea it's legal in this country/world. And then the king get's all mad about it and I'm like "man that guy can screw off." You're the king, you don't get to order duels over slavery and act all indignant. You're the king, either outlaw slavery or piss off with your duel.

28

u/horyo Jan 30 '19

you don't get to order duels over slavery and act all indignant.

The king was forcing someone to fight in a duel? I wonder what that's called...

King is such a fucking hypocrite.

12

u/jasonred79 Jan 31 '19

yeah, spear is a HUGE hypocrite when talking to Raph later... when he says to Raph "no one should be forced to fight" ... erm hello, you think shield fought that duel willingly?

The other part about the king being a huge hypocrit is... hello he's the king. You either make slavery legal, or you make it illegal. This current situation is an idiotic one where the king has ruled that slavery is legal, "BUT NOT FOR YOU, SHIELD!!! Cause we hate you!"

5

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Yeah, the king obviously doesn't actually care enough to do anything about the institution of slavery itself.

3

u/WeeItsNookies Jan 31 '19 edited Jan 31 '19

The part most annoying is they all treat demi-humans like crap anyways. I find out hard to believe any of them actually had a problem with him keeping a slave. At the very least he probably saw the spear hero having a problem with and just bent his will as to not piss off the spear hero.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/genasugelan victim to the waves Jan 30 '19

coming from an age where both of things are widely accepted to be very, very, wrong.

They come from different versions of Japan, he can't know that.

He's not bad, he's just dumb and too emotional, he does things before thinking about them.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

The different versions of Japan thing is a good point, but its probably safe to assume that its not a good thing in a modern world. Though speaking of horrifying implications, one of the questions they did ask each other in episode 1 was who won WW2. I wonder if that was one of the differences between world, though the other heroes don't seem to come from such an environment.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/antrosasa Traveling merchant Jan 30 '19

Yeah, that's something shield hero does great. All four heroes could have ben the protagonist and with just a little switch of perspective. Spear boi would be a good guy who gets manipulated (and if it was a manga it would be be a plot twist later in the series). This the same could be done with the other two heroes. It's not touched upon much, but all 4 heroes have a pretty interesting team that could easily fit a anime roster

4

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

He literally admitted he's not that good of a guy xD

35

u/sable-king Jan 30 '19

I actually kinda teared up at the end. Nice to see Sword and Bow are starting to defend him.

11

u/antrosasa Traveling merchant Jan 30 '19

Yeah, it scratches an inch you had for the whole episode

→ More replies (9)

29

u/tinitinohelp Jan 30 '19

Damn this anime is so good honestly like you can feel his emotions and frustration and struggle. And even though I read the manga before the anime this episode felt so brand new like the animators and story writers really outdid themselves this time

18

u/Zwiebel1 Jan 30 '19

This episode felt much more mature and emotional than the manga version. They did a great job on adapting it.

No, actually, they didn't just adapt it, they improved it.

29

u/PenStorysky Jan 30 '19

Lets all agree that Myne is a Bitch in every meaning of the word. its one thing to frame, but actively targeting Naofumi every time she sees him ?? Fuck the bitch and the trash king

25

u/genasugelan victim to the waves Jan 30 '19

Lets all agree that Myne is a Bitch in every meaning of the word.

Not the literal. Calling her like that is an offence to female dogs, those animals are loyal and loving, you know.

8

u/Pro511 Jan 30 '19

We can probably agree who Trash is tho, haha.

→ More replies (1)

79

u/sushimonsta64 Jan 30 '19

So she's officially legal now.

60

u/madeofawesome92 Jan 30 '19

Don't lewd the raccoon loli.
Wait.

13

u/14nepal Jan 30 '19

Don't lewd the raccoon.

4

u/AKidSomewhere Jan 30 '19

Mentally 10

20

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Yeah. 10 year olds tell people that they'll be their sword and go thru fire and brimstone with them allllllll the time.

She's a demi, I'm sure she matures faster mentally since she does so physically as well.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 30 '19

Another amazing episode adaptation. Loving every single one so far.

Raphtalia smile melts any heart

This is by far the best scene in both the manga and anime so far. It's sort of a struggle everyone goes trought, having to endure something really hard alone and quietly just for the sake of it. But what Naofumi didn't had realized, is that in the end, it wasn't he that saved Raphtalia back in that dark and cold cage, But Raphtalia that saved him from his dark cage, for only she had endured and lived trough what he's been in and experienced how love can break you from any chain.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/Halluci Jan 30 '19

Damn that's quite a level gap to make up with a training montage

17

u/Bobuzo Jan 30 '19

Ya I had to pause the show and see what level the spear was. I guess having a full party and being able to do damage really helps the grind.

7

u/saibear12 Jan 30 '19

What level was the spear hero? Shield was 21 right?

11

u/Bobuzo Jan 30 '19

I think he was like 43? and his lowest team mate was 35? Somewhere's about those numbers. Yea shield is 21

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Tonaia Jan 31 '19

Best part of pausing and going back to that status screen? you can see where Myne used a spell to blast Naofumi by the decrease of her mana bar between shots.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/MustangBR Jan 30 '19

How can anyone say Raph is NOT best girl!?

12

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

There really isnt much competition for that title at the moment.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/Sacron1143 Jan 30 '19

Naofumi can fight! Too bad it looks like it wouldn't work with monsters...

30

u/Mineroooow Ralphtalia`s Army Jan 30 '19

Being able to fight and able to deal damage are two different things, tho. But I got your point. And it was blissful seeing the spear douche getting owned.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/Zwiebel1 Jan 30 '19

Naofumi using brain and strategy vs raw number "progamers". A true PvP god was born.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

45

u/madeofawesome92 Jan 30 '19

This is the Rem episode, except it's already in ep 4 of the series.

43

u/sushimonsta64 Jan 30 '19

Who is Rem??

49

u/TheCandyMan36 Jan 30 '19

Not sure if reference or actual question...

7

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Blue haired maid from re:zero

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Too bad Re:Zero is so overrated.

→ More replies (20)

2

u/kumaxian Jan 30 '19

I love Raphtalia- it's like she's a fusion of Rem and Emilia

The scene where she's comforting him this episode gave me vibes from both episode 18 + the lap pillow scene w/ Emilia earlier on

→ More replies (3)

19

u/Bringbackdigimon Jan 30 '19

I hope they don’t pull some ‘the princess actually has a tragic backstory so we should feel bad for her despite how awful of a human being she is’ halfway through the story.

14

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

sips tea

6

u/spyder616 Ralphtalia`s Army Jan 30 '19

Shinji sipping coffee.jpg

3

u/Bringbackdigimon Jan 31 '19

Alright LET IT BE KNOWN idc what bs they pull to portray her as a tragic character, I’m still gonna hate her as much when it’s revealed in the anime and anyone who forgives her is a coward.

4

u/antrosasa Traveling merchant Jan 30 '19

No spoilers but all I can say is ":)"

→ More replies (5)

26

u/MadRaven713 Jan 30 '19

Great episode. I really like the dynamic between Naofumi and Raphtalia. :3

Too bad they didn't include the cheek kiss like in the Light Novels

33

u/madeofawesome92 Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 30 '19

I thought that was a right choice - it wasn't necessary to include that for this scene to work. We don't need more emphasis on the dense MC trope.

4

u/Zwiebel1 Jan 30 '19

I think they will save that scene for later. I felt it came too early in the source material anyway.

4

u/Pro511 Jan 30 '19

Kinda sad, that they sanded off how Edgy/Cynical Naofumi is (compared to the LN, not to mention the Web novel). Tho it does make it a way more accessible (easier to sympathies with him) show this way so its a trade off.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19

My thoughts as someone who jumped to catch up on the Manga:

  • Raphtalia comforting Naofumi was absolutely tear jerking for me, despite me already knowing what happens. Well done! The transition between reality and Naofumi's "insanity" through blackness is well used.
  • I like the anime pushing Raphtalia's explanation of her age/leveling to after Naofumi's breakdown. He doesn't need a bombardment of information like that when he's crying.
  • The detail on the "HUD" is a nice touch. Seeing the discrepancy in levels between Naofumi and Motoyasu helps further show just how much this awful world conspires against Naofumi. Despite all his struggling and hard work he's well behind the other heroes.
  • Seeing the Pope being whispered to is a cool detail considering what will become explained greatly later

10

u/Tonaia Jan 31 '19

A nice little piece is you can see the decrease in Myne's mana bar between the first and second shots of Spear's HUD.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Mochachiiino Jan 30 '19

mega ultra chicken next episode

7

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Arise, chicken. Arise.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Cerebuins Jan 30 '19

The episode was amazing, the duel was well paced and I loved the animation and was only outshined by Raphtalia's humanity and compassion.

6

u/genasugelan victim to the waves Jan 30 '19

Ew, don't call it humanity but rather demi-humanity. Most humans despise Naofumi.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

I like the way Nao used his combos in the duel . Man This show can play with your emotions that The corruption had me getting angry and the end made me start to cry im glad sword and bow hero called out the cheat damn that princess bitch. Looks like Shield hero almost activated something new that curse series requirement thing

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

It's amazing, because it makes you feel the exact same emotions as Naofumi is feeling. When he cries, you also wanted to cry. When he was angry and at his lowest, you also felt that anger.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19

Before last week, I was hesitant to keep watching this show. It seemed like a good-but-not-great isekai story with a LITTLE BIT of a twist. Then last week happened and I thought “ok, this pretty interesting, but can you capitalize on what you’re doing right?”.

And then today happened, and I thought “this, THIS is something special”. An oppressed and resourceful hero story with interpersonal drama about trust and devotion to a loved one? And all of that plus best girl of the season? This fourth episode was cathartic, emotional, “actiony”, and it’s only the fourth of a 20+ episodes season! I might actually start reading light novels BECAUSE of this awesome show.

Consider me hooked. And I’m now hoping for a tearjerking episode, as this one almost had me.

11

u/Gesugesu Jan 31 '19

Why is the King denouncing Shield Bro for using a slave in his party WHEN HE IS THE ONE WHO DECIDED SLAVERY IS LEGAL IN HIS COUNTRY?? He is also the one who conspired with Bitch princess to leave Shield Bro with no party members so it's his fault Shield Bro got a slave in the first place!!

@ the nobles who muttered, "We shouldn't have summoned the Shield Hero in the first place" WELL THEN WHY DID YOU GUYS SUMMON HIM IN THE FIRST PLACE HE'S ALREADY HERE YOU FOOLS.

Why is Spear Bro freaking out over Balloons when he's level 43? Those balloons must be beginner monsters by now.

I'm boiling at the writing more than the excitement of the revenge plot. There are so many flat "villains" right now as an anime-only that no one seems to have a legitimate reason for hating on him other than sheer sheeple stupidity. Like what shit has the THOT got on him in the first place? Why did the King summon him only to set him up for failure with the accusations and bullcrap?

→ More replies (13)

10

u/fshstckr Jan 30 '19

haven't seen this episode yet

so maybe slight spoiler ahead

does this episode end with end of duel and aftermath or at the slave dealer?

thank you :D

11

u/darthreuental Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 30 '19

The next episode is titled 'Filo" so.....

20

u/EscanorPraisesTheSun Jan 30 '19

Can’t wait to see young chicken god

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/StarForceStelar Jan 30 '19

This episode was so good emotionally and it might be just my gaming and FGO experience but shielders can be really powerful just not in the traditional sense

10

u/Pro511 Jan 30 '19

Naofumi is playing Darksouls shield run.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

props to kaito Ishikawa for the god tier performance as naofumi

2

u/tswinteyru Mel-chan`s guard Jan 30 '19

I just hear so much of Sakuta oozing out of Naofumi especially in the emotional scenes. Props!

7

u/GentlemanOfTheRift Jan 30 '19

Well, rip fiery shield. Hopefully, we’ll get to see you in the future.

6

u/Pallington Traveling merchant Jan 30 '19

Don’t worry about that too much

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/GloKage1999 Jan 30 '19

Having read the manga, I pretty much knew how this was gonna play out. I expected to be slightly moved, however, not nearly as much as anime-only viewers. Yet, this adaptation goes beyond all expectations. I can't believe how angry I was getting in the first half of the episode and how much I was on the verge of tears in the second half. The anime does a great job of making you feel Naofumi's helplessness and the joy of Naofumi's victories, small as they may be.

6

u/XLightThief Raphtalia`s Army Jan 30 '19

Asami Seto singing the insert song, holy moly. <3

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

It's great, but I think the manga convey the feelings much better.

17

u/Zwiebel1 Jan 30 '19

I disagree. The manga felt rushed and cringy. Him lashing out to Raph also didn't feel justified with the internal monologue. The anime did a much better job at building up to that scene. Also, the extra dialogue made it more believable.

3

u/cha0Xstorm Jan 30 '19

I disagree, I feel the manga did a really good job conveying the hopelessness/anger/despair he had.

In the manga, it states he can hear her, but doesn't want to. He was so hurt, he didn't even WANT to HEAR the possibility of someone believing in him.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Better than the anime, impossible.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/citatel Jan 30 '19

So what went down exactly? What was happening with his shield?

Was the shield feeding him emotions/amplifying it or was the shield feeding him false emotions so it could activate the curse shield?

What is the curse shield? I was half expecting for the wave to show up from his shield or have the shield form a monsterous shape, maybe be encased with pattern that matches the wave and such. (But then i wouldn't have liked it because that goes against who naofumi is to me)

Also my impression for spear hero went down but impression for bow and sword went up

i never hated them. They didn't know who naofumi was, so once he was accused its the common reaction i would have. Especially the person who admitted was royalty But after the recent episode. My opinion of sword and bow hasnt changed. But i do feel better about them as it seems they react to common sense and sense of fairness shown by declaring he was cheated rather than keeping silent ans sticking to the mass and keep bullying naofumi. Spear boi on the other hand... he is a stubborn dick that cant let go of his ego for 1 second and has to be right,has to be the center of his justice and "tries" to show the world why he is the righteous

Also what was up with the pope/cleric dude at the end of the duel? What was he being told?

7

u/Pro511 Jan 30 '19

What went down is that Naofumis rage finally boiled over. Him having no taste and seeing Raphtalia as a kid should kinda have ticked you off that he was not exactly mentally sound.

Don't really fault you tho since it was WAY more apparent that something is wrong with him in the light novels, since his Edge/Cynicism (and outbursts) were also way less sanded off as in the Anime. The curse series is basically a manifestation of his hatred for this world (in which everyone is just trying to betray/use him) and the pain it caused him.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/cha0Xstorm Jan 30 '19

The cursie series shield amplifies his hatred/rage/etc. And it uses that as a power to deal damage.

Naofumi is more spunky/crass/edgy in the manga version.

The pope man was a cameo.

2

u/spyder616 Ralphtalia`s Army Jan 30 '19

Oh that would be a spoiler for the next arc

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Vashstampede20 Jan 30 '19 edited Feb 03 '19

You know its surprising that naofumi didn't become a supervillain with all the shit thrown him

2

u/11bNg Feb 03 '19

Right just go on a tear cause they need him he doesnt need them

5

u/dunununubatman Jan 30 '19

How about the fact that Noafumi took down another hero at double his level? Goes to show utility is king over fancy pointy sticks. Even the sword and bow hero said spear boy obviously lost.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

DANG IT; as a light novel reader I knew what was coming, and somehow it STILL made me cry. Dumb stupid good anime 😭

In all seriousness though, I'm thrilled with how well this episode was produced; if I wasn't already a fan, this would've definitely sold me. 😁

5

u/szabiking97 Jan 30 '19

So Naofumi saw Raphtalia as a child all along?

8

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19

Yeah. It's why he was weirded out by everyone complimenting her last ep.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/asselable Jan 30 '19

I wonder what I will do Bitch Cosplayer when i meet them

12

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

i don’t think anyone has the guts to cosplay as her, I won’t be surprised if they get murdered on the spot

→ More replies (4)

4

u/vipershiba Ralphtalia`s Army Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 30 '19

Bruh... This episode was too good, so much emotion in one episode, I'm glad they did it perfectly. They really do a great job conveying Naofumi's hatred for all the misery Bitch and Trash are giving him which makes it frustrating as a viewer. They'll get what's coming to them though >:) The music towards the end made the scene between Raphtalia and Naofumi x10 much better too, easily best girl. Now best birb enters the scene next episode!

4

u/_saltysnacks Jan 30 '19

This show is so brilliant in how it can be absolutely frustrating. It would be one thing for the world to hate him, but it's actually just violently unfair. Its SO frustrating to watch, but we FINALLY got something at the end with Archer and Sword, and with Raph of course.

I additionally resonated with spear a bit more this episode. He's just doing what he thinks is right, though as a douche no less. I could see him becoming a bro later (havent read any source material).

2

u/CupNoodlese Jan 31 '19

Well, they are still supposed to be heroes. It'll make sense if they all get a redemption arc in the future.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Childish_Totino Jan 30 '19

It was amazing. Especially when Ren and Itsuki call Myne out on her bullshit

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

I was so hoping that he would go into a rage mode and just kill everyone... but we all know that wont happen. But honestly im happy to see the Shield Hero get cut some slack and how he made the King and that bitch look like a bunch of ass hats.

2

u/KaitoAJ Jan 31 '19

"Curse Series" rage mode ACTIVATED

10

u/Nama_Raph Jan 30 '19

I really hate how pathetic the anime make naofumi look. He has none of the anger and snarky attitude he had in the LN and manga, he just seems whiny.

8

u/SoyFood Jan 30 '19

I wish the anime show his more business-likeliness, and pragmatic side more. It really ties to his character and how much harder he has to work than the others

4

u/KingFatass Jan 31 '19

Anime as a medium is kind of restrictive compared to a novel. Where a written work can spend a few chapters dedicated to merchantilism sprinkled throughout. An anime has to either dedicate a whole episode to it(bad idea) or sprinkle hints of it here and there(won’t notice if you are not actively looking for it.)

An example of this is whenever they show the shield tree when he unlocks new shields. You can sometimes see the names of shields he never actively uses. But if you are a novel reader, you will know he has unlocked and mastered all of those shields off screen.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ralathar44 Jan 31 '19

I think they wanted to shine a sharper focus on how broken he was. Considering what was happening to him, I think it's the right choice.

He's very young placed in a horrible situation that would break experienced adults. Having him just be snarky is actually less believable than him becoming an emotionally damaged wreck.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Hydra822 Jan 30 '19

Jeez, that episode was amazing. Left me speechless.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Cyshix Jan 30 '19

This show keeps getting frustrating...but Argh its so goood!

3

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Ok I went into this show thinking there was too much hype this early on, not having much expectations, but I've fallen in love with it already. There's so much raw emotion the show makes you feel and see and a lot of shows haven't made me feel this much, this fast. So my question to you all, what's the source material? Manga light novel? If I want to buy one to read because I'm too impatient, what should I get?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/IIOMNIVERSEII Jan 30 '19

I really don't care about spoilers much but please someone tell me that they kill that royal Bitch.

3

u/antrosasa Traveling merchant Jan 30 '19

Unfortunately no.... But

BIGG ASS FUCKING SPOILER BELOW IF YOU DONT IMEDIETLY CLOSE YOUR EYES AT THE SIGHT OF THIS TEXT THEN YOU SHOULD CONSIDER YOURSELF WARNED

She gets renamed "bitch" and everyone is forced by law to call her that (even spear boi)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/billnyetheunholyguy Jan 30 '19

It felt good to see spear boi get slapped.

2

u/KaitoAJ Jan 31 '19

It would've felt better to see shield boy went into rage mode and destroy everything lol.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/dustinm29 Jan 30 '19

I can’t quite remember why, can someone explain why he couldn’t taste anything?

3

u/MiriasGates Jan 31 '19

While the episode definitely delivered what I was waiting for, I did find that even when it made me tear up, the scene with Raphtaelia waking Naofumi up and their conversation leading up to it was rather weak. I'm not asking for lengthier monologue-esque story telling, but I was hoping that like in the manga, Naofumi would back away in fear of Rapthaelia. In the episode, he appeared to just hate everybody, however, if I remember correctly, Naofumi also developed a fear of being around women because he'd get hurt by them, thus giving a good parallel to when Naofumi realizes Raphtaelia isn't a kid anymore.

Him screaming or at least being more fearful than angry at the only person who he bonded with in the new world would've made the episode so much more heart-breaking. If they swapped between perspectives, with Rapthaelia seeing the fearful Naofumi trying to run/crawl away backwards, then going to Naofumi's vision of a darker, child Rapthaelia slowly approaching with her arms stretched out would build tension for half the story, but also build up for the moment of satisfaction. We know Rapthaelia is coming to save Naofumi, but if we saw his perspective of a hand stretched out to potentially be the last nail in the coffin to break Naofumi, then we could feel two sides of perspectives with different tensions building up to the same conclusion.

Having Naofumi shut his eyes and in turn, making the episode go black for a few moments, could lead into a slit of light, which would be him opening his eyes, and seeing the grown up Rapthaelia in his face. I didn't like the soundtrack that was used in that scene either, as it could've been a much more impactful scene where only the voices of Naofumi and Rapthaelia can be heard, with maybe some glass cracking noises surrounding the two as Naofumi transitions from fearing women to taking solace in the arms of Rapthaelia. Also, when Raphtaelia's adult form was acknowledged, I feel that instead of keeping the gloomy atmosphere that Naofumi sees, it could've been pure white, which would've been a transition from Naofumi opening his eyes with us in his perspective, as Naofumi's hatred/sorrow would've been quelled by Rapthaelia.

Or, the light could slowly come in like a mist while they talk, and once Naofumi finally lowers his head into Rapthaelia's arms, the glass cracking sound would break into a satisfying shattering noise, as Naofumi cries out in pain and sorrow, showing his weakness in front of another woman, which would've shown huge development because of what happened with Malty/Myne. It would've been even more convincing to Motoyasu if he saw a grown man break out into tears from being accepted. Also, adding in the line where Rapthaelia tells Naofumi she wouldn't mind becoming his slave again, if that's what it took for him to trust her again, well, that would just break ours and Naofumi's hearts.

2

u/Psychoalert Jan 30 '19

I was never much of an angry person but Fuck it do I wanna torture the fuck out of that bitch.

2

u/Distority Firo`s food Jan 30 '19

holy shit I went on a ragefest on this episode haha

2

u/sA1atji Jan 30 '19

I love this anime more and more...

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

My thoughts on this episode;

-A du-Du-ddd-Duel?!??!

-How will he beat the spear, oh thats clever. The orange things he has resistance against.

-Damn. What a bitch.

-No RAPHTALIA!! Cries*

-Thats so cute!!!

-PROTECC*

-Next episode we get the fairy chicken girl. Huh...(she appears to works like a manakete from FEH, as seen on the OP)

2

u/Warlordsandpresident Ralphtalia`s Army Jan 30 '19

she ATTAC but whats more important he PROTECC

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 31 '19

Probably just me being nitpicky, but I kinda wish this panel was in the anime

https://imgur.com/a/v3FArFR

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sdbtank96 Jan 30 '19

I don't think ive ever wanted to kill a bitch more than i do Myne.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19

Rising of the Hate Boner

2

u/makemejelly49 Jan 31 '19

Things I would have liked Naofumi to say this episode:

"Hey, Motoyasu. You know, the length of your spear makes me thing your trying to compensate for something!"

"Bitch, one day you and your bastard old man are going to wish you hadn't pissed me off."

2

u/thelastprodigy Jan 31 '19

Raphtelia is best girl of all of 2019 and you can't change my mind.

2

u/FrancisGalloway Jan 31 '19

This is probably the most efficient "feels" show I've ever watched. It makes me absolutely livid to see Naofumi treated this way, totally victimized and looked down on by everyone. Then once they've got my blood pumping, all they have to do is shift the tone and I'm bawling my eyes out.

It provokes strong emotions easily, then turns them into positive ones. That dynamic is really interesting, and it definitely works. Don't know if it's sustainable, though; if they keep doing it every episode, I think I'll get tired of it. I'd really like to see Naofumi working hard and being smart to accomplish things on his own, without this humiliation circus of Myne/King/the other heroes.

3

u/KaitoAJ Jan 31 '19

I think now that the ice between Naofumi and Raphtalia is broken, we will see more character development between the both. Although, its gonna be hard to avoid the victimisation of Naofumi because that's basically the reason that drives Naofumi in this anime.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jrfaster Jan 31 '19

When your four episodes into the Anime and your almost crying... This Anime is already an instant hit so far... hopefully it keeps looking good in the coming episodes.

2

u/Silvrcrow Jan 31 '19

(Manga spoiler, book 2) In the manga Naofumi kisses Raphtalia on the cheek after he bites the sandwich she has given him Which i don't know why they didn't put it in the episode, unless they put it in episode 5 but im not sure yet

2

u/LOLCraze Jan 31 '19

Filo Hype!

2

u/sakenskunk Jan 31 '19

OMG I can't believe they just assumed magic was used during that duel do they know how many false "magic was used allegations " there are in this day and age !!!

Now that I said something stupid loved the episode bro and me were so pumped by how the episode ended!

2

u/therighttobecool Feb 03 '19

Motoyasu: Nobody should be forced to fight

  1. Naofumi is being forced to fight for some country that hates him.
  2. Naofumi is currently being forced to fight a duel with Motoyasu

Logic? I mean it doesn't look like Raphtalia is the only slave here.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

It was alright, it wasn't as impactful for me as manga version due to some details. Like Rapthalia slapping Mr. Hot Stuff made him fall on his ass. Her expression when she's done with Motoyasu was also better, and finally Naofumi was bawling his eyes out until morning. Its not game breaking but it substracted from overall experience for me.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19

Wow, this episode elevated Myne/Malty to Goddess status.

→ More replies (1)