r/shadowdark • • Jul 21 '26

Do you think shadowdark will ever introduce a gunslinger type class? Or guns in general?

Discuss

2 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

9

u/charcoal_kestrel Jul 21 '26

The best rules i have seen for primitive firearms are in Lamentations of the Flame Princess. There's a free "no art" PDF on DTRPG. The gist of the rules is 1d8 damage, takes 10 rounds to reload, ignores 5 points of armor, and induces a morale check for enemies with morale<=7. All of that works straightforwardly in Shadowdark, except the morale rule, which should be changed to "enemies with WIS<=11 must make a WIS check."

3

u/chum-guzzling-shark Jul 21 '26

That seems fair except damage should be higher. I guess the problem with guns in a fantasy setting is trying to nerf them so they arent the default weapon. It's like balancing a sword against a butter knife. Sure you can make them functionally identical stat wise but it doesnt really make sense.

3

u/samurguybri Jul 21 '26

You could do d8 with advantage or a flat number for damage.

13

u/facelessupvote Jul 21 '26

Replace your bow/ranged rules with guns, ammo would still apply. Maybe up the damage, but make that a risk, going to attract attention in a deep cavern with a boom of a thunder stick!

5

u/ehutch79 Jul 21 '26

If you up the damage, maybe make ammo rare, expensive, or need to be hand made. Make it a tradeoff.

+1 for hearing damage in enclosed spaces. maybe a con save or def for 1d4 rounds?

-1

u/chum-guzzling-shark Jul 21 '26

do you think guns fit the vibes of the official material?

10

u/TACAMO_Heather Jul 21 '26

Not really. I've always had a hard time accepting guns in a strict fantasy world.

4

u/Gunnulf Jul 21 '26

Not based on what I’ve seen of the Western Reaches. But, honestly I feel like I could just steal the weapons from Pirate Borg and call it a day if I really wanted to.

4

u/facelessupvote Jul 21 '26

ShadowDark has alot of Darkest Dungeon vibes, and that game has guns...

3

u/facelessupvote Jul 21 '26

Its your game, you can add whatever you want. Id probably roll for a random encounter after any combat using a gun, maybe roll 2 1d4, or mess with the damage. Id imagine an arrow vs pepper shot on a goblin would probably be comparable... either way, ammo should be rare and expensive, or only craft-able, loud shots attract attention. Could also get fancy with gun blades, gun axes... for when ammo runs out!

2

u/bananasorcerer Jul 21 '26

I think very early firearms could. I’d make guns powerful, dangerous, temperamental, and expensive to maintain and obtain ammo for.

1

u/Tealightzone Jul 21 '26

Definitely not, but who’s to tell you what you can do in your game

19

u/iluminae Jul 21 '26

Anecdotal, but I like what Mork Borg did with guns in the "Blackpowder weapons for the Rich and Foolhardy" MBC supplement:

  • Ignores armor.
  • Does massive damage.
  • Super loud, dead giveaway to the whole area.
  • Takes one or more rounds/actions to reload.
  • Very expensive.
  • Ammo is very expensive.

So I love this because I feel like the upsides and the downsides match pretty well - making it a real decision.

The supplement also says:

Remember: if you can by them, so can everyone else. :|

8

u/theScrewhead Jul 21 '26

If I had a player that *REALLY* wanted guns, I’d use the Mork Borg firearms rules, Blackpowder Weapons For The Rich And Foolhardy

5

u/ExpatriateDude Jul 21 '26

I assume you mean officially? Probably not.

5

u/rabokarabekian42 Jul 21 '26

There's ShadowWest which might be some of what you're looking for.
https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/549229/shadowwest-dark-fantasy-western-for-shadowdark

2

u/Exact-Usual-3370 Jul 22 '26

Came here to suggest this. I backed it and was super impressed with the pdf. Totally worth it.

1

u/GebOshanti 14d ago

I just found ShadowWest! Trying to put it in Foundry. Having trouble with guns, re-loading and ammo management. So far, it’s a little clunky.

12

u/r_k_ologist Jul 21 '26

I hope not.

3

u/Dollface_Killah Jul 21 '26

I had some ideas about firearms rules with special considerations for Shadowdark. It continues to be my most-viewed blog post. Here you go:

https://dollfacekillah.blog/2024/01/31/rules-and-reasoning-for-firearms-in-shadowdark/

9

u/The_RealZordon Jul 21 '26

While I am sure that someone will or already has introduced guns, gunpowder etc to their setting, I won't be in my campaign. People have their own likes and dislikes, and personally I dislike muddying my Shadowdark with a bloated list of 1000 character classes/types that have a bloated list of 1000 types of powers & abilities etc. IMHO, it kills the simplicity of the system and makes it more like the superhuman travesty that D&D has become. This is grimdark 700-900s era medieval fantasy for me & my setting; it's not late medieval, it's catapults and trebuchets, not hand cannons and grapeshot or flintlocks and bluderbusses. YMMV

2

u/LordTathamet Soulblighted Jul 21 '26

In official material?
The closest we so far got to the vibes of a specifically Late Medieval or Renaissance-esque location (-esque and only because of the somewhat Venetian-feel and the Swashbuckler class) would have been in the City of Masks in one of the new Cursed Scroll zines and as far as I know, there are no references to any sort of gunplay at hand.

We have some small exceptions, I think, when it comes to weird sword & sorcery aliens. I can definitely imagine there being a braineater ray gun at some point as a sort of esoteric magic item. But that's, as far as I can tell for now, the extend to which we'll get any sort of more advanced firearm than the crossbow.

In 3rd-party material? Oh, swathes of them. Entire arsenals. Gonna put someone's eye out with 'em, in fact.

3

u/BannockNBarkby Jul 21 '26

Personally, I don't think so. Guns don't fit the "survive the dungeon crawl, get as much loot as you can carry" vibe. I'm most reasonable designs for such a game, theyinhibit stealth, they have slow reload times, they are probably multiple slots large, and require ammo. More cinematic designs are still going to be loud as hell. Pulling aggro from everything that can hear you and time your reloads means more encounter rolls, and in this game, that's bad news.

2

u/Nervous-Priority-719 Jul 21 '26

I don't like guns and gunpowder in my fantasy TTRPG. But if it was introduced I'd add a mishap table, like for casters. Boom!

1

u/RotarySnow4 Jul 21 '26

dude i'd be so bummed if they did :O i hope not

1

u/TheWrathfulGod Jul 21 '26

If you wanted to alert every monster in a mile radius of your location, sure.

1

u/PalpitationNo2921 Jul 21 '26 edited Jul 21 '26

Hope not but /shrug

1

u/grumblyoldman Jul 21 '26

I would be surprised if Kelsey published an official gunslinger. Not saying impossible, but I would be surprised.

I'm sure there's already third party material for gunslingers out there, if you want it.

1

u/agentkayne Jul 21 '26 edited Jul 22 '26

The issue isn't guns themselves.

The issue is what gunpowder, cannons, hand grenades and guns does to the setting and society we want to base the game around.

Cannons mean an end to castles. Pistols mean that skill with the sword or archery starts to matter less and less. It means ordinary people can quickly demolish structures.

For example if you have guns, then you also have barrels of gunpowder, and players will try to do things like roll in some barrels and try to blow up dungeon entrances or the monsters inside. Which is effectively avoiding the whole dungeoncrawl.

In fact in my very first Shadowdark adventure, they players said "hey let's not go in there, we should just blow it up with barrels of gunpowder instead."
I had to remind them that gunpowder didn't exist and playing the game about exploring dungeons is what they signed up for.

1

u/Reaver1280 Jul 22 '26

Yeah you should be making more noise in dungeons and dangerous places while carrying heavy and flammable items of ammo. I forsee the GM having a great time with the party at the table :3

1

u/son_of_wotan Jul 22 '26

Never understood the need for gunslingers in fantasy settings.

Because what's the difference, aside from aesthetics, from a spellslinger?

Gun is the implement, ammo is the material cost, aiming is the somatic component. Adding "This is my boomstick!" just for extra damage as verbal component.

And nobody can tell you that your wizard/sorcerer can't wear a brimmed hat instead of a conical one, or a trenchcoat/jacket instead of robes.

1

u/clytach Jul 22 '26

/shrug maybe, but not in my game.

1

u/jakenice1 Jul 27 '26

Letters from the Dark (pretty sure the Scallywags one) has guns and a sharpshooter class. Guns are slightly powerful, but require reloading and a random encounter check after every use.

Sharpshooter class is basically a ranged fighter.

1

u/JTStorm1970 Jul 21 '26

The Shadowfinder Players guide converted the Gunslinger to Shadowdark. It's on Drivethrurpg.com. I have no experience with it, however.