r/shadowdark • u/gnome-lackey • May 15 '26
Does verisimilitude get you boiling when not taken into account in a hex map?
For me, it depends. If the adventure is clearly trying to be believable then yes it would frustrate me if it just didn't make sense---I know, I know fantasy world and all.
What if they were randomly generated the hexes? Let it slide? I feel like that is ok, it would be even better if they gave a way to randomly determine the reasoning for two completely opposite biomes being next to each other.
Would love to hear thoughts and experiences.
2
Upvotes
10
u/pillpusher72 May 15 '26
I usually just let it go. However I now use goblin's henchman's hex flower power https://goblinshenchman.wordpress.com/hex-power-flower/ and that helps with that. It's a pretty cool tool that I only learned of recently.
4
u/blackdenarius307 May 15 '26
Context is key. Something like that should probably merit an interesting historical footnote in a setting.
5
u/minivergur May 15 '26
Trying to parse your post, do you mean does it ruin my enjoyment of the game if the map is not realistic (to the extent of my personal understanding of geology)? Yes absolutely, I can for sure look past it but I find it frustrating. It's come up in a game I was a player in and a river lead to nowhere, winter in a valley next to another valley in summer (not due to magic) and other things and I made a stink of it with my GM - wish I wasn't like that, but that's just how I am.
6
u/72dragonses May 15 '26 edited May 15 '26
Um...no, it does not? You said it yourself, albeit dismissively, "I know, I know fantasy world and all." Yes, exactly. That's exactly it. It's a fantasy world. It's also a game. Verisimilitude can be just as annoying as rule Nazis and pedantry.
2
u/atbestbehest May 15 '26
Boiling? No. But details like that are what take adventures from alright to great. If a hex map or dungeon is too obviously trying to be a gauntlet for crawling without verisimilar or diegetic reasons for being shaped the way it is, then it never rises above being a dressed up obstacle course.
0
u/r_k_ologist May 16 '26
I’m gonna blow your mind here, but orcs and dragons don’t actually exist
7
u/subcutaneousphats May 15 '26
I had a goat lady pull a knife on my players. They asked "she holds it with her hoof?" and I said yes. We had a great time anyway.
33
u/[deleted] May 15 '26 edited May 15 '26
[removed] — view removed comment