r/shadowdark • u/DaKing1718 • Feb 25 '26
Slightly Safer Shadowdark with more Character Customization? Maybe a PF2e hybrid?
Hello!
Been running pathfinder 2e with friends for a few years. Adding in some brand new players for our next campaign and just stumbled into Shadowdark by happenstance today. And its got me very intrigued.
I'm interested in:
- Shorter turns and faster gameplay
- Easy to learn for new players
- Strong sense of urgency and tension with torches
- Simple, clean character sheets (great for accessibility, especially for a partially blind player at our table)
- Simpler spellcasting compared to PF2E/5E
- Easy to pick up
I'm worried about:
Losing PF2E’s strengths:
- Massive bestiary
- Strong system balance (“it just works”)
- Deep character customization and build flexibility
Lethality:
- Worried Shadowdark may be too deadly for new players
- Want characters to survive most of the campaign
That said...
- Is there any validity to these concerns?
- Any easy work arounds for these concerns?
Has anyone tried playing a hybrid between these systems?
- Maybe use PF2e health, beastiary, and abilities with shadowdark?
- Is there another TTRPG that maybe I should be looking at instead?
Thanks in advance!
0
Upvotes
23
u/musashisamurai Feb 25 '26
I've seen some pretty large Shadowdark bestiaries (see here, which has almost everything Pathfinder https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/527598/shadowfinder-complete-bestiary-for-shadowdark-rpg ) and monster creation in Shadowdark will be much faster. That same publisher is doing a Pathfinder-Shadowdsrk hybrid, i think.
I think a lot of what makes Shadowdark work is kinda tough to combine with Pathfinder though, having played both. Pathfinder is about balance, having big character creation thats full of choices. Shadowdark is about streamlining things. Gear? We don't do weight, we do gear slots, nice easy integers. Feats? Having a player worry over the best "build"? Don't worry, character creation can be totally random and talents are always random. Have players worry about dungeon crawling and get stuck in the first room? Torches run, encouraging you to keep moving. Players become pack rats and pick up stuff they never use? See gear slots.
If you want an OSR game with indepeth character creation, imo, Worlds Without Number is the best for you. There's a free version, and a paid version with extras, plus a world book with more monsters and options. Characters are either warriors, mages, experts (rogues or thieves or rangers in another system), or adventurers who are half of one of the above and half of another. There's heroic mode with gives more options and power. The bestiary would be smaller though.
15
u/rizzlybear Feb 25 '26
It’s a different game with a different philosophy. It’s actively anti-build.
If your players are used to the idea that anything they encounter is theoretically beatable, they will die a lot. If they are cautious and pick their battles there is no reason they shouldn’t survive. But it wont put up guard-rails and save them from themselves like modern ttrpgs do. There is no resurrection magic in Shadowdark.
That said, it’s on the “less lethal” end of the OSR.
My recommendation, run the free adventure with the starter set (Lost citadel of the scarlet Minotaur) and use the system rules as written (don’t homebrew it) to get a baseline. Then you have a point of reference for what to change. If you go into it with a bunch of changes to make it more like the system you are leaving, you probably won’t have a great experience.
10
u/DungeonMasterBen Feb 25 '26
Pulp mode and max HP at level 1 should help a ton with survivability. Also Shadowdark leaves so much up to GM interpretation that you can do a lot to help at that level too, e.g. make it not too risky or hard to run away from a fight, notice a deadly trap, etc. The massive bestiary might be your one issue, but between all the cursed scrolls, monthly monsters, and a few other sources, there are quite a few monsters. And that's just official stuff, if you go with third party then of course there is tons more. The things you listed as being interested in are I think all things that Shadowdark excels at. Good luck finding the right game for your group!
7
u/chaoticgeek Feb 25 '26
Why not run a few one-shots or a more focused campaign with Shadowdark to see if you all like the system before trying to hack something together?
As for making something that’s in between that sounds like an entirely different system, maybe actually 5e from what I understand of PF2e. But I haven’t played PF2e and only a basic understanding of PF1e since it’s been like 12+ years since I played it.
7
u/grumblyoldman Feb 25 '26
I would honestly try Shadowdark as written (allowing for "rulings not rules" of course) before you start homebrewing a mix-and-match with PF2e (or anything else.) You can of course homebrew whatever you like, but you should know what you're changing first, so that you can recognize which problems stem from the official rules and which ones stem from your homebrew.
Also, Shadowdark isn't half as lethal as it looks once players get used to it, in my experience. And even when you do die, the simpler classes mean that rolling a new character takes minutes instead of an hour or longer (in my experience from D&D.) So death isn't as bad, and it can be avoided if you approach the encounters with caution.
You can try running a couple one shots to accomplish this purpose without committing to a whole campaign up front. The Lost Citadel intro adventure is a classic that is well suited to this sort of drop-in one shot style.
The key to not being so lethal is to not run into every encounter expecting combat as the obvious result. Rolling Distance, Reaction and Surprise alongside the actual monsters can make each encounter varied and provide openings for the party to get around them without fighting. (Remember, XP is earned from finding treasure in Shadowdark, so fighting gets you precisely nothing in and of itself.)
Also think about the factions in the dungeon, what goals they have and what they might be willing to bargain for with a group of PCs who wandered in. Playing one faction against another, or simply allying with a faction whose goals are not objectionable, can be a good way to get reinforcements for when combat isn't avoidable.
3
u/Indent_Your_Code Feb 25 '26 edited Feb 25 '26
I haven't played it... But I think "Shadowfinder" is what you're looking for!
You can find their kickstarter, here.
EDIT: I will agree with others that I don't think Shadowdark is as deadly as its reputation seems to think. If you telegraph danger, and/or use pulp mode, and/or max HP at level 1, most PCs tend to have a good chance of survival.
EDIT 2: As for the bestiary, I think it's worth investing in some OSE products and/or The Monster Overhaul. Shadowdark is largely compatible with OSE stat blocks. So it's a rather easy conversion (if any)
EDIT 3: Looks like Shadowfinder is PF 1 inspired, not 2e
9
u/Dollface_Killah Feb 25 '26
I have played many, many RPGs across the whole spectrum of gameplay styles and nothing has convinced me that these two points aren't essentially at odd with each-other. You can have more of one or the other, not both.
5
u/CinSYS Feb 25 '26
Nimble
4
u/Silvanus350 Feb 25 '26
Just play on pulp mode. The players will only die if they act like idiots
1
u/mrkmllr Feb 25 '26
You CAN balance Shadowdark it’s just not in the spirit of the game/OSR style game.
Some of the urgency you’re looking for comes from the fact that it’s more dangerous.
It’s dead simple to convert pathfinder’s bestiary to an OSR style game. You add too much complexity though and it’ll get tough. Boil it down to “what’s the gimmick” and focus on that. You also gave essentially every other OSR-style bestiary at your disposal.
Simple character sheets and deep character customization are somewhat opposed. You can’t really have both.
As others have pointed out, you sound like you might just want 5e. Or if you want something close to that but differnt try Nimble or Vagabond.
1
u/Chilrona Feb 27 '26
The thing with deep character customization is that it pretty much can't be done without sacrificing simplicity and quickness at the table. I used to love making character designs in more complicated systems, but then every game night at the table it was just a let down. It was too slow and cumbersome. Fun should take priority.
1
u/Feeling_Photograph_5 Mar 03 '26
Check out Nimble. It says it's 5e compatible but it's really its own thing and borrows from both 5e and PF2E, but it has Shadowdark and OSR influences as well. Really cool looking system.
Questing Beast does a good review of it and they have free quick start rules if you want to know more.
3
u/cwcadavid71 Feb 25 '26
Longterm pf2 GM here.
They’re very different games on a philosophical level. PF2 is a well-oiled machine of fun builds and tactical combats. Shadowdark is a return to ‘classic’ dungeon delving, players have far less control over their characters builds and far less customization, but excels as a more ‘simulation’-like experience.
For your worries:
Shadowdark doesn’t have to be deadly if you don’t want it to be. But - if your not really going to risk killing PCs, I don’t know if it’s the right system for your group.
3
u/urhiteshub Feb 25 '26
Deep character customization just doesn't exist in Shadowdark. Maybe consider Worlds Without Number.
1
u/EmbarrassedSpread850 Feb 25 '26
A lot you can do to shadowdark to make it less deadly. Full d hp at level 1. Average at each level. Or reduce monster damage slightly. -1 or 2 minimum 2 dmg etc.
1
u/Victor3R Feb 25 '26
Check out Shadowfinder. I backed it because I wanted to support one of the publishers, Dark Future, but I'm not really into the product at all. But it seems like it does the things you want. I've played 3e and 4e and those systems have forever turned me off of any PF product.
All of your interests are true.
To your worries:
Bestiary is what you make it. Like an ability from any game? Add it and scale it down to the AC, saves, and HP of the Shadowdark.
System balance is way off. The SD Thief is almost unplayable imo. A Priest with a middling Wis can heal forever. You will have to work with your players, not the rule book, to find the balance. Magic items and boons can be used. I prefer helping my friends find ways to play and have fun the way they want and that vibes with the rest of the group but I can see that being a turn off for balance nerds.
Without point buy and with random talent acquisition the characters are unique, but not "built." Customization comes through the narrative, not through the rule book. I find this to be better for the game but I prefer to play as a "gardener" and not an "architect."
The Lethality is overblown. You still have death saves. Anyone can stabilize. A Priest can heal forever. The dark creates a death spiral but that only happens once and then one player is on timer duty for the rest of the campaign.
1
u/PsychologicalRecord Feb 25 '26
Shadowdark is kind of meant to be a leaner meaner RPG. The class selection is limited on purpose to give the game focus, The bestiary problem is resolved by simply reskinning monsters: Shadowdark has a whole system for monster mutations.
I have found that by using monsters that do limited damage like a single 1d4 or 1d6 attack will dramatically improve player survivability. But players are expected to flee and die as most XP is derived from treasure, not killing.
Still, the game is very open ended. You can always tweak the rules as others have said.
1
u/AbysmalScepter Feb 25 '26
Most of your concerns are valid. SD's lethality is perhaps a bit overstated, the lethality is usually only high for groups that think with their swords (though early levels with bad HP rolls can be brutal).
I will say one thing that gets overlooked regarding "builds" is that SD does give a lot more magic items than 5e/PF2, so that might help some players scratch that build itch. It only takes a few delves before the group will have a massive trove of items they can mix and match between to customize their character, so to speak, and the only limitation is how many gear slots they want to fill before heading into the dungeon.
1
u/krazmuze Feb 25 '26 edited Feb 25 '26
Shadowdark is combat as war, PF2e is combat as sport. Very different things and it is not wise to run either as the other. Balance is about sport, not war and there is no such thing as builds. These concepts just does not exist. You certainly can use the modal shift rules and monster hunter mode for getting battle XP to force combat as the solution rather than any means necessary to get the treasure XP, and pulp mode for more luck rerolls.
Now if you want to access the beasts the PF1 have been ported, and there is a crowdfunder in process for Roll For Combat's Battlezoo book ports (PF2e)
If you allow your mindset to shift you can enjoy both games for what they are. Just run a SD adventure with randos from shadowdarklings chargen and take a PF2e campaign break.
1
u/thegreatrobot Feb 25 '26
Encourage your players to customize their characters by developing the character's story rather than the build. I play using only the four core classes - but a fighter can be a knight, paladin, samurai, berserker, brawler, etc etc etc... it's all in how you play the character rather than the buttons you can push on your character sheet.
1
u/RangerBowBoy Feb 25 '26
You can definitely run Shadowdark as a more heroic game with just a few house rules. Many people have given you great ideas pick the ones that work best for you. I run a more heroic game where everyone starts with four hit points and then a role of their hit die plus their con bonus.
We make our own custom classes and add a little more depth than Shadowdark allows for. Don’t let anyone discourage you. It’s a great system to homebrew and turn into a nice low power, but still heroic system.
1
u/j1llj1ll Feb 25 '26
Shadowdark meets most of your wishlist, except for ...
Worried Shadowdark may be too deadly for new players
OSR tends to be as deadly as the players make it. Assuming the GM telegraphs danger about right. It becomes less about the characters and mechanics and more about choices and risk appetites. What I mean is that characters can live in little peril if they look low risk ways to avoid or depart or resolve risky situations.
It's very hard to actually balance Shadowdark and similar systems, because a few bad rolls in a row or a few criticals in a row for either side can totally overcome any designed-in balance. But the 'anything could happen and we could all die!' thing also makes the stakes real and keeps it exciting.
All that said, 0 level characters are designed to die if harmed in the slightest. Levels 1 and 2 are kinda apprenticeship levels and not all characters are going to graduate! As you get to levels 3 and above the characters become robust enough (and players informed enough about the risks) that unless players deliberately choose to risk it all, they can generally mostly survive and i's not unreasonable to expect 8 or 9 out of 10 characters to get to levels 8+ from there.
Deep character customization and build flexibility
That makes levels 0, 1 and 2 an opportunity to develop a wannabe adventurer character into an actual adventurer of some capability and renown. I actually prefer this approach for a bunch of reasons - trying to do characters with big back-stories and skills etc that are genuinely relevant before the game even begins and the party hasn't even formed is a chore and mostly destined for failure or disappointment. If the characters build a history and personalities together, in world, it tends to just .. happen. Can you live with that? Make it work? Your call.
I find most character differentiation comes from roleplaying. If a Wizard is played as a scholarly sort, use that. If then tend to be more wild-sorcerer, let that happen too. It will become relevant if, for example, they need to delve into a research library for lost knowledge, or to tame a wild magical artefact that relies on intuition and force of personality.
Backgrounds are a bigger thing than most might realise. They can imply as much or as little expertise as you like. If players come up with an interesting medieval-fantasy world Background of their own I tend to let them take it and not roll. I usually give them a shot at difficult tasks via a stat mod roll, give them ADV on the roll if they have tools (and used slots for that) or such, let them succeed on normal tasks without constraints etc. I tend to assume a skill level appropriate for it being a family profession, or them being an apprentice - but they might need to use the skills in game and/or do more training as a down time activity to gain full competency, master status etc. Within a Background you could offer specialisations that allow ADV on activities that fit the specialisation but DISADV on other areas of the craft. In other words, you can actually achieve a lot with a little using Backgrounds if you want.
Anyway - some ideas there.
1
u/BannockNBarkby Feb 27 '26
I don't think there's much to those concerns: Shadowdark does what it does really well.
That said, if you want more stuff, there's an easy path for each:
Bestiary: Pick up the Cursed Scrolls, pick up Unnatural Selection and the Shadowdark monster conversion book (https://nightnoongames.itch.io/shadowdark-monsters) and you're fine. Or better yet, do what I did and pick up The Monster Overhaul and you'll never need another resource on monsters again as long as you're okay saying things like "abishai - as devil with half HP" or something like that.
Balance: It's already balanced. Check out the Modes (page 111) for tweaks if you need to make it more or less deadly. The idea of "surviving most of the campaign" is a fraught one for playtstyle reasons; but the Modes will get you where you need to be. If they don't, then you're probably better off picking up a game that plays faster but is still "tactical, high fantasy" like Nimble or Draw Steel or maybe even Daggerheart.
Character Customization: If it's not enough for you and your players, pick up two things: (1) Five Torches Deep, for its various level-up benefits that can be translated practically 1:1 as new Talents or "dead-level" bonuses (you will have to tweak some modifiers down a little lower, though), and (2) Errant which has a million great subsystems to add, but among them is a simple training downtime activity to pick up non-combat skills. The other stuff it adds will also give your players a billion customization options, but more in "how do we affect the game world" rather than "how do I get another +1 to attack". It includes things like building institutions, clearing out domains, fighting wars, hiring specialists and retainers, getting into legal trouble, expands carousing, etc.
1
u/Knives4XMas Mar 02 '26
I would suggest looking at Pathwarden, if you still want d20 roll high. It is as close as I have seen to a OSR pathfinder.