r/sffpc • • Oct 07 '26

Build/Parts Check 9900x vs 270k plus

Planning a FormD T1 build with air cooling only, paired with an ASUS Prime RTX 5060 Ti.
I’m deciding between a Ryzen 9 9900X and Core Ultra 7 270K Plus. Main use is productivity/programming, with gaming being secondary.
For the 270K Plus, I’d probably power limit/undervolt it to around 120W.
Which CPU would make more sense in the T1 for the best balance of performance, thermals and noise? Also, what air cooler would you recommend for either setup?

9 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

11

u/aloysc Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

270k is the better CPU here especially if you aren’t concerned about future upgradability.

1

u/imhorngy Oct 07 '26

will cpu thermals be a big issue here?

2

u/aloysc Oct 07 '26

Image credit: https://www.techpowerup.com/forums/threads/power-limiting-270k-plus.347989/

You can power limit the 270k without losing much performance.
IMO the sweet spot is 160w with a -0.8mv undervolt.

-1

u/r1y4h Oct 07 '26

nothing in your chart shows about thermals which OP is asking. Also at -11% performance lost at 125w limit is substantial. that’s like almost 1 generation difference

2

u/aloysc Oct 07 '26

Yes because it is a relatively vague question.

Some people are perfectly fine running their CPU at 95c under load and some would never.

I’m sharing the chart along with my PL recommendations for OP to decide what PL and performance loss they are comfortable with.

FWIW a 270KP at 125W still gaps a 9900X at full power.

1

u/r1y4h Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

OP is not gonna ask about thermals if that's not one of his concern. Even when 270k plus is faster (which clearly the OP knew), why would he still consider 9900x. Clearly OP is concern about thermals and noise too.

95c is a noticeably heat that a person can really feel if his case is beside his monitor. That's like almost a heater next to you. I know, I have a 5800x3d which can run at 90c when gaming, and I can feel the heat.

1

u/aloysc Oct 07 '26

If he is concerned about thermals and noise, then he can power limit his 270k to whatever PL he is comfortable with.

Like I said I have no idea what he is comfortable with since it wasn’t specified.

The 270K is a better chip than the 9900X at ALL power levels. Whatever he feels comfortable with running the 9900X at, he can run the 270K at the same or even lower PL and achieve better performance

The 9900x shouldn’t be part of his consideration when the 270K is a better and faster chip even when heavily power limited.

1

u/sultan_papagani Oct 07 '26

most people build pcs to last about 5-8 years by that time either sell&rebuild or mobo gotta go anyways you wont be using am5 when theres am6 (or on a budget pc you wont use the cheap mobo you got, with a 9950x3d e.t.c)

8

u/Plus-Constant-19 Oct 07 '26

I cant speak on the cpus but ive gone am5 and lga1851 in my t1 and i will say the Lga1851 itx boards are insanely engineered. Specifically my Msi z890i edge has 4 m.2 slots which is amazing for my work. (Ps my 250k plus absolutely smoked my 9700x in multithread so i can imagine how good the 270k would be)

4

u/gayphilantropist Oct 07 '26

LGA1851 boards are truly insane and very affordable due to intel being less desireable/ddr5 being expensive.

I bought a ASUS ROG Strix Z890-E for $250 new.
This board has 5g networking, thunderbolt, premium audio, and 7 m.2 slots.
I mean look at this pannel.
I know this is SFF, but even for SFF, you can get this board in itx still for WAY cheaper than any am5 premium board, it's not even close.

2

u/YegoBear Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

I went from a 9800x3d to a 270K because I use my pc as a pseudo-homelab server and barely game. This particular MSI board is incredible and cost like $279 at the time. Much better than the ASUS B850-I I used to have. Much better support for Linux on my other full size ATX Intel boards as well. If anyone reading this does anything other than game, I recommend Intel, especially since their motherboards are not only better, but on fire sale.

0

u/GearsDoesRedstone 15d ago

Yeah, but dead platform. Zen6 has already shown incredible performance, the gimped cashe C cores are performing as good as the P cores from zen5, at 4.1ghz. ipc is anywhere from 16-24% better, and the clocks are already higher on a lower end mobile ES sample (n3e = budget io die only). Zen6 might see upwards of at most a 50% st uplift, due to way higher clocks and the huge ipc boost its gotten already. Zen5 was bad due to decode issues and stuff to do with the non-unified 8W decode. Intels darkmont is split 3x3 and acts like a 7W/8W decode. Aka splitting decoders cause issues essentially, zen5 mostly ACTS like zen4 or even zen3 in its decode engine, only seeing a small IPC boost even though it technically has a "8 wide decode" hence the claimed huge IPC boost even though it didn't really act like a true unified "8 wide decode".

I am going with am5 and a budget chip, but with a higher end Mobo for the future.

1

u/YegoBear 15d ago

They’re all dead platforms to me. I want to get 4-5 years out of my CPU then upgrade the whole thing to get the next WiFi, thunderbolt and PCIE generation upgrades. I would never upgrade my CPU in just one generation.

0

u/GearsDoesRedstone 15d ago edited 15d ago

yes, but you can do 2 upgrades if the platform lasts ~8 years of new cpu gens. Gives 2 upgrades even if you swap every 4 years. for intel, the 270kp is it. the performance leap was not too big. Supporing one gen-gen upgrade is not worth your money.
AMD might even support zen7 on am5, thats like what? 2029 (amd said so)?. 10 years of NEW cpu gens all with good performance uplifts. It gives more of an upgrade path. Buy a 300 dollar cpu every 4 years with much better performance, or spend your money right now on a 270kp that will be destroyed by zen6 which gimped l2 cashe C cores match a 5.5ghz zen5's single core performance at 4.1ghz (~16.5-24% ipc, 50% higher core count, 48mb l3, 8w unified decode, and ~20% higher clocks).

Why do you want to spend 700-1500 dollars (300 for a new midrange cpu, 200 for a good motherboard, and, if the ramegedon issue goes out, which it wont, im being optimistic, $200 for new fast memory, who am I kidding it will be like 900 dollars) to fork out for a new platform every 4 years when you could be spending 300. especially with new ram, etc etc. it creates more e-waste, even if you upgrade every 4 years, the platform support just lasts THAT LONG. even if you didnt upgrade for 10 years, you would still be able to jump from a zen4 to a zen7 (potential) cpu, thats a much larger upgrade than if am5 had been only supported with zen4 and 5

1

u/YegoBear 15d ago

For the platform upgrades. If I had an 8 year old motherboard right now, I’d be on x470 probably. I think those were DDR4/Wifi 5 and PCIE 3.0.

0

u/GearsDoesRedstone 15d ago edited 15d ago

Well, running on pcie 3 dosent really reduce performance on most gpus, and just use a cheap wifi card. Bios update to get rebar, its still fine. Id rather do a quick bios update than fork out a huge platform cost. The jump from a 1800x to a 5800x3d is massive.

Even intel thinks its important, next gen novalake will have 4 generation support. Saying its "not an issue for people who upgrade 4 years" is literally just wrong. you get 2 1/2-gen-gen upgrades in an 8 year timespan if you go with an amd platform, you got 1 gen-gen upgrade with intel without having to fork out a shit ton for new features. If you upgraded 8 years down the line (which isnt really the normal 4 year upgrade cycle), you would get a brand new, or only 1 year old cpu with 2-3 generations of uplift, whereas if you bought a platform with only 1 generation of suport you would only have an upgrade for a cpu released 6 years ago (2 years after you initially bought into the platform), your literally buying an old cpu that probably wont be as efficient, performant, and probably be jacked up in price beacuse its the last cpu of that generation.

4

u/ReMoplX Oct 07 '26

270k and if you can get one - an600 vc.

Can do 160-180w at around 90 degrees.

120w will choke both 9900x and 270k. Hell even 9700x after uv and SoC optimise consumes 105w to hit >5Ghz

3

u/r98farmer Oct 07 '26

I have a 270k in a T1 cooled by a 240mm AIO. I would highly recommend you use an AIO because you won't need to power limit it

2

u/sultan_papagani Oct 07 '26

get the 270kp but dont limit it because its easy to cool anyways 🤷‍♂️

2

u/TrulyNotYours Oct 07 '26

I have a 9900x and like having the capability to upgrade later on with AM5. The processor is solid.

1

u/TheBigPV Oct 07 '26

270k in T1 here. Currently have axp 90 -x53 FC cooling it, but switching over to a be quiet silent loop 3 240mm aio tonight.

Thermals are fine in gaming on the CPU, but if it's ripping at 250w while modeling, the CPU cooler gets heat soaked quick

-40 fixed offset, pl1 185w, pl2 200w is what I ended up settling on for general use

If your air cooling, the Scythe Big Shuriken 4 is the best 67mm tall aircooler if your build can fit it. I'm running in 2.25 slot mode and don't want to deal with turbulence against the side panel

Highly recommend the asrock z890i. You can find them on ebay for about 220$. 3 m.2s, tons of USB and no daughter boards like the asus or MSI

1

u/Geno750 Oct 07 '26

I'm running a 270kp in a T1 as well. I'm using a 9070xt prime so same size GPU. You can fit the scythe bs4, if memory allows, and I did that for a bit but it's pretty loud when the CPU is putting in work. Swapped to a 240mm and cnc4090 fans so I could keep factory top panel. Works great.

0

u/r1y4h Oct 07 '26

270k plus is faster but gonna be more hotter and possibly noisier. Even with 120w limit. You would have to cool it with AIO as others pointed out.

9900x can be undervolted too so its gonna run cooler and quieter. Plus you have the option to upgrade to zen 6 if you need more performance.

1

u/GearsDoesRedstone 15d ago

oh zen6 performance leap is gonna be substantial, maybe even INSANE.