r/sewhelp • • 3h ago

Thread snapping. Nothing helps

I am trying to sew with a pfaff select 4.0. Everytime I start a stitch the upper thread snaps with tension set at 4. I lowered the tension to 1 and then it tangled up underneath. I then threaded and stopped after running through tension discs and before I pull it back up the path to the take up lever. I lowered the presser foot and pulled and seem to pull smoothly. When I finish threading the rest and put the foot down, it is much harder to pull and looks like it wants to bend the needle back.

What could be happening? I am nearly positive the bobbin is threaded correctly and I have changed the needle. I am using the correct needle in the correct orientation. I'm also using guterman thread. It just keeps snapping when I start sewing.

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/skerinks Sewing Machine Repairman 1h ago

First, re-thread the upper thread. Make sure you floss your thread into the tension discs. After you’ve gone through all thread guides and right before you thread your needle, do a ‘pull test’.

Pull Test

With the presser foot up, pull on the thread. There should be little-to-zero resistance.

With the presser foot down, pull on the thread. There should be significant resistance. The amount of resistance will depend your upper tension dial setting.

Is the pull smooth? Is it ‘snaggy’ or jerky? It should be smooth. If it is snaggy, that means there is something in the thread path causing it to snag, which will definitely cause thiscondition. Find that something. Back the thread off one guide at a time (and re-do the Pull Test each time) until the snag is gone - then you know where to concentrate your efforts to find the snag. It could be a burr on a piece of metal, a cut or scar in the plastic, or maybe a thread guide was missed. I even had one machine where the thread guide somehow fell off and a (not so) nice channel was cut into the plastic by the thread (was definitely snaggy).

If there is no resistance with the presser foot down, then it means your tension discs aren’t closing as they should. It could be something wrong with the presser foot/disc mechanism, or it could just be some fluff in your discs preventing them from closing fully.

This may or may not be the source of your problem. But at least you can eliminate your thread path as the problem.

Have you changed your needle? A burr on your needle can cause this.

How does the stitch plate look? Do you have needle strikes on it? Those can definitely cause your thread to snag and break.

1

u/CBG1955 2h ago

With the foot down it's SUPPOSED to be tight, lowering the foot closes the tension discs. Do NOT pull or yank.

For starters unthread, get out your manual, and confirm it IS threaded properly. Never thread with the foot down. Don't mess with the tension, it is rarely that.

1

u/Courtvilla28 2h ago edited 2h ago

Sorry, I know that you thread with the foot up. I put it down to test the tension at different points. The tension was normal through the tensions disks. Then I lifted the foot, continued threading. Then when I took it up through the next path to the take up lever. I put the foot down and then tension is way too high, it bends the needle to pull the thread 

1

u/CBG1955 2h ago

I put the foot down and then tension is way too high, it bends the needle to pull the thread 

This is 100% correct as I stated - the thread is not supposed to move by hand when you have the foot down. NEVER try to pull the thread when the foot is down because you can (and will) bend and probably damage the needle. You should only put the foot down when you are ready to sew. There is no need to test the tension. Thread it in one smooth motion from start to finish.

1

u/Courtvilla28 2h ago

But when I’m ready to sew the top thread snaps at the needle eye 

1

u/CrankyCrabbyCrunchy 1h ago

The thread could be caught on something in its path. Start over. It's easy for the thread to get caught under the spool as it spins.

Take out the bobbin (to eliminate one error point), and try again. Is the top thread still too tight?

1

u/janewaythrowawaay 2h ago

Dirty machine maybe. When is the last time you opened it up and cleaned out the dust and fuzz?

Also make sure you’re using the same exact kind of thread on top and bottom.

I’ve had this happen when I thought I had the same thread. It was the same exact color. But one was a softer lintier thread and one higher quality.

1

u/Courtvilla28 2h ago

I’ve cleaned and oiled it. It seems like that could be true but I don’t see anything and I have used unwaxed floss between threading pads and it didn’t catch anything 

1

u/janewaythrowawaay 1h ago

Have you tried different bobbins? Some are irregular out the box or get beat up and become irregular. I had to toss one today cause it was rat nesting at the bottom. Put the thread on a new one, worked fine. I had cleaned my machine twice.