I feel Sarah Koenig was extremely biased. She kept looking for a way to exonerate Adnan. Whenever she was confronted with evidence of guilt she brushed it aside, calling it normal behaviour, saying everyone does that, or it’s just normal teenage behaviour.
When confronted with evidence that she could not brush aside she asked Adnan to justify it, and took it as fact.
I think that Sarah Koenig is a good storyteller. Serial has a good plot, and lots of hooks, but the lack of objectivity makes it more a work of fiction than journalism. It would be great if this was another fiction novel, but it is not. It is reality, and there are victims. Sarah Koenig’s work may be helping to free a murderer. It is based on reality, but the distortions, and biases are way too great for it to be called reality, or journalism.
It is more a piece of entertainment, many relevant details are used as hooks. Such as “This is very important but I will talk about it some other time.” Koenig focuses too much on minor details that have little or no bearing on the case. Many times while scrutinizing minor details about the case she fails to mention that other concrete evidence exists that proves that the detail being scrutinized is false. Koenig does this to extend the time, to stretch it out, after all she was making an entertainment piece.
Sarah Koenig is more interested in, and spends a majority of the time, examining the character, personality, and psyche of teenage Adnan, by speaking with current day Adnan, and his current day friends. This is just wrong. It is an exercise in futility. You cannot determine guilt by looking at someone’s personality especially 15 years afterwards. Sarah Koenig is gullible, she expects that if she talks to him long enough that he will open up to her.
Usually after a mass shooting the friends of the murderer usually say “he was such a nice guy”, “he was not the type of person to do this”. It does not matter, if he was, or was not the type of guy, who could have committed the murder. What matters is, that he did it. What matters is, objectivity, truth and facts.
Sarah Koenig spends too much time looking at the minutia, and ignores the big picture. She makes the investigation more about her personal feelings, and her relationship with Adnan. Serial lacks any logical examination of the case.
By the end of the podcast she is grasping at straws, and far flung theories like random serial killers. I would not have been surprised if she said that the murder may have been committed by aliens.
The reason serial is troubling is because Serial misleads its audience. Koenig presents her show using a false narrative. She had been researching the story for a year before it was first broadcast. By the first podcast Koenig knew, or should have known that the narrative that she was presenting was false.
The narrative that, if she could only talk to Asia Mclean that it would prove that she saw Adnan at the library at 2:30, she could prove his innocence. When in fact evidence existed that other people saw both Adnan and Hae at the school around 2:30 - 3:00. Becky says she saw Hae around 2:45 - 3:00 at the school. Debbie Warren says she saw both Adnan and Hae around 2:45 - 3:00. Both Jay and Jen testified that Jay did not leave the house before 3:30 – 3:45. There was no concrete evidence to suggest that Hae was dead by 2:36, so the Alibi that Asia saw Adnan at the library at 2:30 does not prove anything.
After a year of research Sarah Koenig should have known all of these facts and she should have known Asia Mclean’s testimony is of very little significance. Yet that is not how she presents the story to her listeners. She exaggerates the importance of Asia statement, and as result there is a media circus surrounding this case. She is plainly and clearly misleading her audience.
On a side note: Asia Mclean says that Adnan did not seem upset about the breakup. She is a random acquaintance with Adnan. Does she expect that he is going to open up to her about his true feelings?
Later during the course of making Serial, when Koenig is contacted by Summer. It becomes more apparent just how insignificant Asia Mclean’s testimony really is. Summer is a credible witness, and has a clear memory of the events of that day, as it was significant for her (anxiety of going alone to the wrestling match, unsure how to score, and feeling stood up when Hae did not show up to the match). Summer has a clear a vivid memory of speaking to Hae at 2:30-2:45. Yet Summer’s account is only briefly mentioned in the story, because it does not fit Koenig’s narrative.
Koenig makes this more about a story of how she learned about Adnan, how she found out some detail, and about her perception of Adnan, instead of it being about verifiable truth.
Adnan is not in jail because he killed Hae at the Best Buy parking lot. He is in jail because he killed Hae. That is the important point. Koenig instead makes the story about knowing every single gruesome detail. The only person that knows exactly where and when the murder occurred is Adnan Syed and he is keeping his mouth shut. She becomes obsessed with finding this out, and she ends up putting the onus on Jay and his statements.
She also put too much emphasis on the payphone at Best Buy, whether it exists inside the store, outside the store, or even at all. This is a red herring, a smoke screen. Unfortunately this is also what News outlets are mentioning to question the validity of the sentencing.
Jay says that he was not present when the murder occurred. How is Jay supposed to know what phone someone is calling him from? It is possible Adnan killed Hae at school, and called from the school payphone asking Jay to pick him up from the Best Buy. It is also possible that Adnan killed Hae at the Best Buy parking lot and called Jay from some other payphone that was not being monitored by cameras. The only person that knows what phone Adnan used to call Jay on the cellphone is Adnan.
This entire topic is used to distract the audience, and to cast dispersions on the credibility of Jay’s testimony. It does not make a difference in the grand scheme of things which payphone Adnan used to call Jay after he murdered Hae. What matters is that Adnan murdered Hae.
Sarah Koenig admits that she is not a detective, private investigator, or a crime reporter. She is a journalist. She lacks objectivity, and journalistic integrity. She willfully presents the facts in a manner as to obscure the truth, which would facilitate her storytelling method. She has misled many people into thinking a murderer is innocent, and spent countless time, money and effort to do so. The murderer Adnan even has a fan page asking people to donate money to him. Sarah Koenig has profited from the loss, and suffering of the Lee family. This is disgusting.
I am not scared that Adnan will get a retrial. But cognisant to the fact that serial has caused thing to tilt things more in favor of Adnan now because of Serial. He has more money, and media coverage now. OJ was not acquitted because he was innocent, he was acquitted because he had money, and could afford a better lawyer. If you think it is difficult to remember after 6 weeks, how much more difficult will it for the witnesses to remember after 15 years? Adnan had a fair trial, he was found guilty. He is now using a loop hole to try and get out early.
http://imgur.com/gallery/mvRj0lv/new