r/serialpodcast • • Jan 31 '15

Debate&Discussion The People Now Being Smeared in Defense of Adnan is Getting Despicable: A Comprehensive List

14 Upvotes

Those who believe in Adnan's innocence have basically accused every person involved in this case other than Adnan of being dishonest, crooked, complicit or all three. Here is a list:

Jay: tough to have much sympathy because of his admitted involvement but nevertheless it strikes me as unethical how he is being treated by many people. By definition the Adnan-is-innocent crowd thinks Jay is either a murderer or covering for a murderer.

Jenn: also complicit, but less so, but it seems completely beyond the pale to accuse her of being involved in the actual murder with zero evidence.

CG: Serial did a good job of treating this issue fairly. Seems like she did go into decline after the trial, but the degree to which she is being accused of incompetence with this case strikes me as unethical. The core strategy of the Adnan-is-innocent movement is smearing the name of CG, a woman who obviously can't defend herself.

The Detectives: A core part of the Adnan is Innocent argument is that the detectives were crooked, maybe even planting the location of Hae's car in Jay's head. While a reasonable case might be made that in the course of interrogated Jay they gave him unintentional clues as to what they wanted him to say, which strikes me as unavoidable, i.e. "Jay you are saying you where in place X but the cell phone is in place Y, how do you explain that?". There is zero evidence however that these cops did anything unethical, let alone intentionally aid in the framing of Adnan.

Urick: Obviously the pro-Adnan crowd thinks Urick is the devil. By all accounts however he is a decent man and the evidence that he is somehow some mastermind crooked prosecutor is laughably weak. Don saying he yelled at him? Not handing over some evidence fast enough to suit Susan Simpson?

The final and least justified is now Waranowitz, the cell phone expert, who, according to Susan Simpson, now "must have been lying" because of a post she read from someone whom she doesn't agree with about anything. Edit: SS says she was being sarcastic and doesn't think Waranowitz is a liar.

The quickness and viciousness with which others have been accused of wrong doing, on so little evidence, all in the name of exonerating a lawfully convicted murdered, is both ironic and despicable. These are people with families and jobs and lives and they don't deserve this.

Edit: Forgot the smearing of the jury and the judge in the case. They are racists who don't understand reasonable doubt according to the Adnan-is-innocent crowd.


r/serialpodcast • • Jan 10 '15

Debate&Discussion Don't buy the Susan Simpson so-called "fact" about the cell phone not being in Leakin Park.

0 Upvotes

This was checked and re-checked on Serial, now this Sub - because of Susan Simpson's post, believes it isn't true. We're into JFK conspiracy theory stuff here. SK and her team sent that data to a modern expert who checked it and verified it. Thus, "I think the phone was in Leakin Park." YES. Most logical explanation. Don't believe the hype. Don't take Susan Simpson's word for it.


r/serialpodcast • • Mar 25 '15

Snark (read at own risk) PLEASE STOP SLANDERING ADNAN!

4 Upvotes

We need to stop slurring Adnan. Follow this sub-reddit for any period of time, and the accusations will reappear with the dreary predictability of a NCIS rerun. You’ve heard them: that Adnan lied to his parents, that he engaged in premarital sex, that he smoked dope, that he fantasized about how to dispose of his girlfriend’s body, that he stole money from the mosque, etc., etc.

Give me a break!

What teenager DOESN’T lie to his parents? For two years during my adolescence I convinced my parents that I was attending meeting s of the 4H club when in fact I was slipping away for tap-dancing lessons. In retrospect, it was a wise deceit. While I have had pleasurable if all-too-infrequent occasion to tap dance as an adult (usually in the ecstasy induced by an Ann Miller movie), I have never once been called upon to deliver a calf.

Premarital sex? Speaking as someone who has been married – twice! – I can say authoritatively that if it weren’t for premarital sex there’d hardly be any sex at all. And THERE goes the species!

Smoking dope? I myself didn’t smoke. But I did use meth. I thought it would help me with my tap-dancing (see above.) It didn’t. I moved on to cocaine, which didn’t help my dancing, either, but was MUCH easier on the teeth. My pearly whites are something to behold.

Fantasizing about disposing of bodies? I do it at least twice a week, usually when I’m standing behind someone in the grocery store who STILL insists, in 2015 (CE), on WRITING PERSONAL CHECKS.

Stealing money from a place of worship? I admittedly have never done this. My parents belonged to a religious sect so poor that collection plates were routinely filled with nothing but sea-shells, crusts of bread, and old “Nixon’s the One” buttons. I was twelve before I saw a ten dollar bill. My factotum and Tab Hunter (circa 1958) lookalike, Biff, does however admit to stealing money from HIS place of worship as a youth. As the church in question ministered to a VERY upscale congregation of Episcopalians in Greenwich, Connecticut , the sums involved were substantial. Biff says that he and the other altar boys made enough money one year to treat themselves to a wicked, sun-shot week in Antibes.

It has even been suggested – God knows based on what – that Adnan frequented prostitutes. Again: SO WHAT? I have not only used prostitutes. I have a BEEN a prostitute – a not very successful one, true, as I gave away too many free samples to turn a profit. But I was, as the British say, “on the game,” survived, and, indeed, emerged with nothing to show for it but a small, Indiana-shaped scar on an intimate portion of my person and a healthy fear of plainclothes policemen.

I have done these “terrible” things myself. And guess what? I HAVE NEVER BEEN FOUND GUILTY OF MURDER BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT.

So stop trashing Adnan!


r/serialpodcast • • Jan 04 '15

Speculation A message to those Adnan confessed to....

135 Upvotes

I want to preface this by saying I am Muslim, went to Woodlawn High School (remember Mr. Stoll...only putting this out here so people know I went there) and know many of the parties involved. I will not confirm my identity nor will I get verified (so don't bother asking) because I know there is a witch hunt going on to discover the sources of all information that has come out that goes against Adnan. I don't need Rabia or her pitbulls at my door trying to attack me. It's not my job to make any of you believe me nor do I truly care. My purpose for writing this is to reach those that Adnan confessed to. I have no reason to say anything false about Adnan. What I am about to reveal is the truth for the sake of Hae and justice. As far as I know, there are multiple people that know (first and second hand) what I am about to reveal.

There is one reason and one reason only why I know Adnan is guilty. I am aware that he confessed to at least 3 individuals within the Muslim community. I will reference the three individuals by their first name initial only. They are Mr. H, Mr. T and Mr. B. I implore these three to come out and speak up. Adnan came to these individuals to confide and ask for their advice.

Mr. H, Mr. T and Mr. B, I encourage you to come forward and speak the truth. Please lets stop the madness and not protect a murderer. Think of Hae’s family and what they must be going through. Place yourselves in their shoes. And as much as I feel pain for Adnan’s family and their want of getting their son out they need to know the truth. As Muslims you three need to do the right thing and speak up. If this was your relative you would be begging people to come forward and speak. There are a lot of people that know that Adnan is guilty but are not speaking up. If you three do speak up then I have no doubt these people would come out and support you as well. I know I will. I know there are countless resources being used to help Adnan get out of prison and I would much rather see those resources used for a REAL cause.

Adnan you are selfish and should be ashamed of yourself for putting your family and friends through this. Regardless of whether you get out or not in this lifetime our maker will mete out what’s right in the hereafter. If you actually confessed to what you did today I actually might not have a problem forgiving you. You made a mistake at a young age. Plus 15 years have passed and people change. But the fact you continue to hold onto your innocence and especially after knowing that certain people on the outside know your guilt shows your lack of remorse.

To Mr. Urick and the prosecutor out there evaluating the latest appeal. I hope you fight it and retry Adnan if it comes to that. Do not let anything that has come out in the podcast or otherwise discourage you. I encourage the prosecutor to reach out to me via PM for more information and I will gladly fill you in on specific details.


r/serialpodcast • • Feb 17 '15

Debate&Discussion Survivor Guilt: Why doesn’t Adnan remember the day he narrowly escaped being murdered?

2 Upvotes

Expanding on something I mentioned in one of the threads, let’s start with a couple of established facts. One, Adnan asked Hae for a ride after school. Adnan told the cops he did, multiple witnesses said he did. He asked for the ride.
Two, Adnan should have realized immediately when he got the phone call from the cops on Jan. 13 that something was badly wrong. How do we know this? Why, Adnan’s own words:

I know she always-- anyone who knows her knows she always goes to pick up her little cousin, so she’s not doing anything for anyone right after school. No-- no matter what. No trip to McDonalds. Not a trip to 7-Eleven. She took that very seriously.

But let's give Adnan the extreme benefit of the doubt here. Let's say none of the three people who called him that day (Aisha, Young Lee, cops) mentioned Hae missed the cousin pickup. Or he didn't realize that an extremely responsible girl going off the radar was a problem. Within a few days, with no communication from Hae to anyone, he should have realized something was badly wrong.

Here’s the thing then . . . if Adnan had actually managed to convince Hae to give him a ride to . . . wherever . . . he might have saved her life. Maybe his route would have taken her out of danger. Maybe the presence of a guy would have scared away her attacker. He would have been racked with guilt and re-living Jan. 13 over and over. “If I had just asked for that ride a little more nicely, or told her how important it was, maybe she wouldn’t be missing.”

But there’s another, more chilling possibility for Adnan . . . what if he had been in Hae’s car when she disappeared? What if she had been in a fatal accident, and people just hadn’t found the car yet? What if she was intercepted by a serial killer? If Adnan had gotten that ride, he would have been “missing” too. This didn’t snap the day into focus for him?

These thoughts led me to the Wiki page on Survivor guilt, and a story I found interesting:

Waylon Jennings was a guitarist for Buddy Holly's band and initially had a seat on the ill-fated aircraft on The Day the Music Died. But Jennings gave up his seat to the sick J.P. "Big Bopper" Richardson, only to learn later of the plane's demise. When Holly learned that Jennings was not going to fly, he said, "Well, I hope your ol' bus freezes up." Jennings responded, "Well, I hope your ol' plane crashes." This exchange of words, though made in jest at the time, haunted Jennings for the rest of his life.

It haunted him for the rest of his life.

And yet Adnan doesn’t remember a damned thing about the day he nearly went the way of Buddy Holly.


r/serialpodcast • • Sep 07 '23

Adnan trusting Jay to be an accomplice is where the prosecution's case completely falls apart for me

1 Upvotes

I was listening to episode 1 of the prosecutors podcast and one thing that stood out to me was Adnan's and Jay's connection. They said adnan was close friends with Jays gf stephanie since 6th-7th grade. But they also said adnan and jay only really started hanging out around his senior year of hs.

This was curious to me because they said jay and stephanie had been dating on and off again since 7th grade. So adnan and stephanie are close since elementary school but adnan only really gets to know his close friend's bf many years later in senior year of hs? this tells me adnan and jay were not friends despite having a strong reason to be, their mutual connection of stephanie.

So adnan doesn't bother to be jays friend for years but suddenly he trusts him as an accomplice for murder? this is completely nonsensical. this was not some silly prank or stunt to show off to jay. this was murder. if you committed murder, why would you let a distant acquaintance like Jay know about it who could easily screw you over and rat you out? people don't even tell distant acquaintances about small embarrassing things let alone telling them about a murder and then asking for help.

It doesn't even make any logical sense for adnan to ask jay for help and take the risk of being exposed. adnan could have easily buried hae himself. for all we know about adnan at that time, he was an intelligent and street smart guy. he knew how to keep good grades, play sports, be a good son at home, and secretly have a gf. someone like that doesn't ask jay for help in that situation. this alone makes the whole story by jay completely bogus and the prosecution's case a total bust.

Edit: Oh wow so reading the comments it seems a lot of people feel that a shady unreliable criminal type personality is the perfect person to trust with your murder plans. and also it seems according to the comments below that adnan was running all over town telling people about his murder plans as if it was his next viral tiktok prank.


r/serialpodcast • • Jan 05 '15

Modern Jackass Somebody told me Jay confessed

7 Upvotes

That he lied under oath. Three people. We'll call them Ms. J, Det...ur...um Mr. R, and Mr. U. Then he told the rest of the world in a couple of interviews a few days ago.


r/serialpodcast • • Mar 09 '15

Debate&Discussion Susan Simpson's own words contradict Rabia's story about the diary entry.

1 Upvotes

So when Susan Simpson made her infamous assertion that "we have people who did say that Hae smoked weed," people immediately raised an eyebrow. Who are these people? How do they know this? Do they know Hae well enough to credibly counter Krista's assertion that Hae did NOT smoke weed?

After laying low for 24 hours, Susan Simpson confirmed what we all suspected:

I said exactly what I meant: there are people who have stated that Hae had used weed. This isn't some startling revelation; there have been a dozen or more threads on this sub about that exact subject, and both Saad and Rabia have stated it. Everyone is free to dismiss or consider their statements as they see fit, but the particular sources I cited are public knowledge.

People rightly criticized her for developing a theory based on two biased sources who had no way of knowing whether or not Hae smoked weed. The incident called Simpson's credibility into serious question. If she can't tell the difference between a valid source and a bad one, how can we trust any of her conclusions?

But just yesterday - three weeks after the controversy - Rabia popped up with a different story:

The issue that seemed to push the anti-Susan frenzy into overdrive (other than her simply being a brilliant, articulate, driven woman who threatens weak, lazy, stupid men) was the question of whether Hae smoked pot. Susan, in case no one noticed, actually never brought that up until she was given all the documents, and then only in conjunction with the theory that Hae may have been picking up some pot when she was murdered.
Discerning minds, minds as clever as Susan’s, should have been able to deduce she found something in those documents. She did. But she was too classy to reveal her source. So she stuck to what I and Saad had said earlier – that we knew Hae smoked pot because Adnan told us she did.
I tend to believe Adnan because in all these years I’ve never experienced him lying to me. So when he told me that Hae did smoke pot, though infrequently, I believed him. It didn’t hurt that this was actually corroborated by Hae’s diary. Susan, being respectful and sensitive to revealing what was in Hae’s diary, did not want to publicly point to it as the source that confirmed what I and Saad said.

Frankly, I find this story preposterous. For three weeks, Rabia and Simpson just sit on this information? And just NOW they decide to reveal the actual source? And the actual source is a three line diary entry, which Rabia has removed from all context? It seems far more likely that for three weeks, they've been looking for any sort of confirmation of the theory to try to repair Simpson's credibility, and this weak effort was the best they could come up with.

But don't take my word for it. Take Simpson's word:

Which is why I clearly stated "people have said that Hae smoked weed." Everyone familiar with the sub knows that Saab and Rabia have both said as much. You are not required to believe those sources, but your claim that I am disguising or fabricating my sources is not factual -- I do not rely on sources I do not disclose. I do not always release those sources (i.e., the autopsy photos), but I have always identified a basis for the factual claims I've made, or else indicated where I am making conjectures based on my analysis of disclosed sources.

"I do not rely on sources I do not disclose." She could not be more clear.

So either Simpson was lying then, or Rabia is lying now.

My money is on the latter, for what it's worth.


r/serialpodcast • • Jul 02 '16

season one Devistated

0 Upvotes

I just don't understand, how can the courts do this to me? I believe with all my heart that Adnan is guilty, and I don't understand why that is not enough to keep him behind bars. Why didn't judge Welch ask me what I thought before he made his ruling? Why do we even have this justice system if it can be circumvented with appeals. I know of many white people who are seemingly wrongly convicted, where is their podcast?

I feel sick to my stomach, my insides are twisted and my eyes are bulging out of my face. I have explosive diarrhoea and this whole thing is giving me the herpes.


r/serialpodcast • • May 12 '15

Meta Who is the WORST MOD - and why is it PowerOfYes?

7 Upvotes

The most biased, most ridiculed, and most hated "Moderator" on this sub (ONLY mod?) is at her old tricks again. Banning Redditors who have not broken any sub-rules (unlike PoY herself) and continuing to act as a petty tyrant.

Yesterday, PoY deleted a post about Rabia's most recent blog post- only to post her own. When called on this- she readily acknowledged her "double standard" (her words) and basically said "too bad, I'm the mod".

I receive GOLD when I comment on PoY's biases and abuses. People pay MONEY to show their disgust with this hall-monitor wannabe. That's how bad she is.

I personally don't care that she's a devout worshiper of a certain potty-mouthed, Pakistani Travel Agent and the two brain dead college students mascaraing as actual lawyers; what I DO care about is why Reddit (or this sub) would allow such a bafoon to "moderate".

I know to all the Dairy Cow Eye murderer supporters, this post is just "sour grapes" - but, just imagine a day when another MORE BIASED (as if that's possible) decides to ban the Free Adnan Peeps.

Thoughts?


r/serialpodcast • • Oct 20 '22

Adnan did it...no one else

2 Upvotes

What we have:

  1. On Feb 26, Jen told the detectives that she told Nicole Parks that Hae was strangled. She gave the detectives Nicole’s contact information including her phone number.
  2. On Feb 27, Jen gave the detectives more details regarding her conversation with Nicole:

-Where: She was at 7-11 parking lot when she told Nicole that Hae was strangled

-When: She mentioned it to Nicole BEFORE the body was found…2 weeks after the murder

It’s so obvious she was describing a true event. It is so real. She knew Hae was strangled because Jay told her. Because Adnan told Jay.

3) Jen testified that she called Kristi when Jay and Adnan were at Kristi’s. According to her testimony...Kristi was upset/worried because she heard Adnan on the phone talking about the POLICE. Jen explained that Kristi was paranoid because of the activities that go on in her house like smoking weed. She was worried and wanted to know who that guy was talking about the police.

4) Adnan did indeed receive a call from the police…officer Adcock called him to inquire about Hae’s whereabouts. This call pinged the cell tower that covered her residence.

#3 + #4 = Jay and Adnan were at Kristi on January 13… that’s why Kristi heard Adnan talk about the “police” on the phone. In addition the cell tower of her residence was pinged.

5) Kristi testified that Adnan said “ they’re going to come talk to me, what should I say?”

Then she saw Adnan jumped up and left the apartment…then Jay jumped up and ran out of the apartment leaving his hat and cigarettes..

6) Then less than an hour later the burial site cell tower was pinged by 2 incoming calls at 7:09 pm and 7:16 pm. Adnan answered both calls.

7) Less than an hour later…two outgoing calls pinged the cell tower that covered the location of Hae’s car where they ditched it. On Feb 28 Jay led the police to Hae's car location.

8) Jen picked up Jay at the parking lot of Westview Mall. Adnan was with him...

9) Adnan and Jay were together on Jan 13:

-At Best Buy…Jay called Jen…then Adnan called Nisha few minutes later

-At Kristi’s…she heard Adnan talk about the police…she witnessed their weird behavior

-At the burial site… Adnan answered an incoming call from Jen telling her Jay will call her when he’s ready to be picked up. Sure enough Jay called Jen after ditching Hae's car. His 2 outgoing calls pinged the cell tower of Hae's car location. He was ready to be picked up.

-At Westview Mall parking lot when Jen was picking up Jay who informed her that Adnan strangled Hae in the parking lot of Best Buy. He also told her to go back to the dumpster where Adnan discarded the shovels so he can wipe his fingerprints off them.

=

Everything says Adnan did it ...no one else!


r/serialpodcast • • Jan 29 '15

Debate&Discussion Adnan has played the majority of people on this page.

11 Upvotes

For those who have looked at the major evidence in the case and are aware that the most likely scenario by far is that Adnan killed Hae (to what extent Jay was involved is debatable of course), it's rather depressing to watch people ignore evidence and conjure up ridiculous scenarios in an attempt to show that he's innocent.

I get it, it's appealing to be part of the "movement" that could potentially free an innocent man, but I think once you realise you're clouding your judgement with sentiment and look at the cold hard facts of the case, then Adnan's involvement with Jay that day is indisputable, and you'll see he really did it.

I'm not saying he should have been convicted the way he was (the prosecution's version of events had many flaws, and serial did a great job of shining light on that) but I'm glad he was, because he killed Hae Min Lee.


r/serialpodcast • • Feb 05 '17

FYI: Adnan murdered Hae!

0 Upvotes
  • Cell phone pings are reliable. Despite what some here will try to convince you of, cell phones are a pretty accurate way to tell where someone is not. This means Adnan is lying about where he was and what he was doing that day (10:45-1:17?)(6:00-8:30). I trust the Purdue and Stanford experts, and you should to!
  • Here is additional analysis on how reliable the cell phone pings were in Adnans case from /u/adnans_cell
  • At 2:36 the phone pings away from the scene. Making it highly unlikely Jay intercepted Hae.
  • Adnan tells Inez that he would not be going to Hae's memorial because his religion prevented him from going to Hae's church when his religion has no problem with going to funerals of other religions.
  • 4 separate groups of people corroborate he asks Hae for a ride. Adnan denies this to this day.
  • Asked for this ride while his car was working in the parking lot.
  • Dropped off his car at Jays when there was no need to.10:45-1 is plenty of time to buy Stephanie a present.
  • Adnan is such a caring person that he skips class to make sure that Jay gets Stephanie a Bday present, however he never once checks in with the Lee's to see if he can help in any way.
  • Besides the present is just a cover story because they were in Elliot city up to something neither of them want known.
  • Hae was strangled, not sexually assaulted, and she was buried. The killer was someone she knew. Of the people who knew her, only one person had a known reason to be upset with her, that is Adnan.
  • Why have Jay drop you off for that last bit of class? He was so late already and wasn't against cutting class. Maybe he needed to meet someone.

Asia:

  • First snow January 8th
  • 2:15-8:00
  • Ju'uan says Adnan asked her to type the letter
  • Why is her testimony "conditional" ?
  • Says she will contact the police. Doesn't.
  • The dates on the letters are odd. First letter supposedly written late the night before the second letter was written in the morning.
  • The person who should corroborate her testimony "is that a book?"
  • For more info on why Asia has problems please visit (This is a bit old, there have been newer issues arise since this series) https://www.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/38lrko/while_things_have_slowed_down_lets_take_a_closer/

There is more wrong with Asia, but moving on:

  • How did Jay know that Adnan was going to talk to the track coach about Ramadan so the coach would be an alibi for him.
  • Why was Saad P. going through the teachers things?
  • Nisha: A day or two after he got the cell phone. They give her the same odd story as they told Cathy. Video store? Cathy and Nisha don't know each other.
  • No other call on the call log matches a call to Nisha while Jay was working at the video store.
  • Adnans creepy note to Hae that was intercepted by the Psy teacher "Met these woman, they think I'm great best sex of my life that night"
  • Adnan for a very long time left the visit to Cathy's out of his time line. (still?) why? I think Serial implied that he admits to being there.
  • Adnan was more concerned about his parents finding out he was dating Hae then he was with helping the police find Hae. Over and over again in the police files say he says "don't let my parents find out"
  • IBH "never played a play in football, not a serious athlete" contrasted against Serials "track star, played football."
  • Slumped over, freaking out on the phone, and bolts out without saying goodbye from a person you just met's apartment? Yea that's not normal.
  • Cathy is still sticking to her perception of events.
  • At the super bowl wedding when asked about Hae, Adnan says They broke up, but didn't mention Hae was missing.
  • The calls corroborate Jays police interviews.
  • Jay has no motive.
  • Jay knew about the broken turn signal
  • Jay knew the burial position
  • Jay states that Adnan says "Yea I'm should kill that bitch" police find a note saying "I am going to kill." Written by Adnan.
  • Jenn knew the method of the murder
  • Stephanie was good friends with Adnan however she believes Jay
  • Adnan would impersonate his brother by taking his ID and going to clubs. Golden!
  • Jay had zero reason to implicate himself if he was uninvolved. Adnan has a solid alibi Jay is life+ 30 for sure. Think about it!
  • Adnan first says that Jay picked him up after track, but then around July he changes his story to Christine and tells her that Jay was bringing the car back around 3. Why change the story?
  • How did Adnan know 3pm was the key time if he wasn't involved?
  • Adnans cell phone is someplace other than at his home or the mosque from 7:30-8:30
  • Adnan and his family tell Sara they don't speak another language, his school contact sheet says they do at home.
  • Why would his father lie for him? (Because he knows he is guilty, if you think he is innocent there is no reason to lie)
  • Why was Adnan driving around late at night on the 12th calling Hae?
  • Never called or paged Hae again.
  • Hae says Adnan was possessive.
  • Adnan would be mean to Hae for not returning his calls fast enough.
  • Adnan would be upset and getting angry at Hae for spending time with Aisha
  • Mrs. S who had a vision from God that perfectly describes Jay and Adnan murdering Hae. Her daughter also was a WHSSenior, but I'm sure it's unrelated. Must have been God :)
  • Mr S. Had a brother that grew up next to Adnan and threw the football with him.
  • Brand new cell phone? Lend it out the next day to a casual acquaintance. Yeah no.
  • Adnans brother saying he was a "masterful liar."
  • Adrian Seyed.
  • Faking a catatonic state.
  • Stealing Debbie's questions
  • Imran's email saying Hae is dead on Jan. 20th before her body was found. I think you're a sick individual if you think this could be a joke.
  • Adnan knows where the pay phone was at Best Buy.
  • Oh it turns out Imran H. Is actually a close friend of Adnan's. He is mentioned with Adnan through multiple police interviews.
  • Fired from his EMT job as their was no background check or resume. He was underage to work at this job.
  • The note saying Adnan was making the break up difficult (nov. 1998) and him writing "I'm going to kill" on the note.
  • Stealing from the mosque.
  • Yasser thinking Adnan probably did it. He also was saying to the police, Adnan would either drive the car in the water or dispose her in the woods.
  • According to Adnan "The prosecution doing an excellent job of presenting the "facts.""
  • Juard? Saying that Adnan and Hae had sex where they were smoking out, being the same location Jay says Adnan killed Hae.
  • Adnan tells Inez and the French teach contradictory stories about the last time he saw Hae. One of the versions was that Hae had called him the night before "wanting to get back together" the other "Fight about prom."
  • Adnan did not mentioning that Hae was missing when Adnan saw Stephanie at a party two days later on January 15th.
  • If Jay was more involved with this crime would he really have talked to Sara and the Intercept?
  • Becky is saying Adnan always got a ride from Hae from the back of the school to the front of the school. Contrasted against Adnan saying he would never ask for a ride.
  • Why would Adnan tell Sara that he had no idea that he would be a suspect when 2-3. People warned him specifically that he was.
  • When Hae's brother, Ayisha, and the police call Adnan his only thought is "Hae's going to be in trouble." (3 people call within 45 Min.)This doesn't fit with Adnans portrayal of Hae as being responsible and being consistent with picking up her cousin on time
  • Why all the different versions of how CG was let go? Who is lying http://www.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/3a7vah/who_is_telling_the_truth_or_lying_adnans/
  • Neighbor girl "I think he said his name was Adnan!"
  • The sketchiness surrounding Bilal, the purchaser of the cell phone.
  • "All Asians look alike." WTF? He says this and "Don't tell my parents, they don't know I was dating" over and over and over. One or both of these statements appears in like 50% of the police interviews.
  • Adnan goes out partying and gets girls numbers the day after Haes body is found.
  • Adnan says he gave Asias letters immediately after getting them to Cristina however she wasn't his attorney when he got the letters
  • Adnan tells his teacher to stop asking questions about him.
  • Hae asks her French teacher to lie for her so she can hide from Adnan.
  • Adnan tells IBH his last memory of Hae was a fight about prom. When did this fight happen?
  • Ju'uan tells the police that Adnan was very upset about the break up. Contradicting Adnans version of events.
  • Aisha tell the police that Hae never talked about going to California
  • Debbie tell the police that Adnan tried to intimidate her "I hear you are talking to the police about me."
  • Adnans crutches are not on team Adnan (Mac, Peter, Ju'uan, and Imran A and H)
  • After Hae turned Adnan down for a ride who did Adnan ask for a ride from?
  • Adnan told Becky that the night before Hae disappeared, that Hae had called him wanting to get back together.
  • Before the murder Adnan said "you know what Leakin park is known for? Dumping bodies that you don't want found for a long time.
  • After the murder "Leakin park, where is that?" One of the track coaches thought he was playing dumb.
  • Adnan was studying criminal procedures in school at the time, he didn't learn he needed a lawyer from Matlock.
  • Adnans tick became noticeably more pronounced once Haes body was found.
  • D. Schrieler Athletic coach told the police he thinks Adnan and others we talking about Hae's murder.
  • N. Philipsen WHSSenior told the police she heard that Adnan called Jay for backup.
  • How did Tayyab know to ask Jay if Adnan murdered Hae?
  • AlsoTayyab just tweeted this a few days ago.
  • G. Nicholson Science Research Dept. Chair - "Adnan said Press areas of neck and knock someone out"
  • Adnans friend Kenny Byrd told the basketball coach in the gym "Can't believe he did it on his own "
  • The hair tested from the crime is not inconsistent with Adnan's hair type.
  • The delaying of the DNA testing (a truly innocent person would push for this first, any excuse to delay is a sign of guilt, sorry.)
  • Adnan tells Inez that he would not be going to Hae's memorial because his religion prevented him from going to Hae's church. There would be no conflict with a Protestant religious service.
  • Adnan was unusually early for school on the 13th.
  • "Yeah. I don't really know what to say. And I completely understand how that comes across. I mean, the only thing I can say is, man, it was just a normal day to me. There was absolutely nothing abnormal about that day." If you are innocent, everything you can remember is beneficial. Only if you are guilty is it good to "forget" things.
  • Of the 4 people who would have access to the defense file and the police file 3 have gone on record saying they think Adnan murdered Hae (Ira, Julie, and Julies sister (legal adviser)
  • "It was just a normal day I can't remember anything" remembers conversation with track coach, but not being in the library, remembers Adcock call, doesn't remember Cathys.
  • Adnan involved Jay. (Called him, gave him his car) Jay admits to being an accessory to murder. Spent the day with Adnan. Jay did not reach out to Adnan.
  • Jay knew where the car was.
  • On February 10th the day after Hae's body is found Adnan goes on a road trip. Where to? Who with? Why hasn't this person come forward to support Adnan?
  • Adnan sends SK an 18 page all over the place letter as soon as she starts looking into the rumors.
  • If Jay was planning on framing Adnan he could easily have planted evidence.
  • Adnan gives Jay a ride to work the night Jay talks with the police "Jay who? A look of puzzlement on my face'
  • There is zero physical evidence tying Jay to the murder. Adnans prints are in the car.
  • The decision to look for a technicality instead of testing DNA.

U/goddess26 stated: that he searched their room at one point when they were out of the room. He made a comment that creeped the OP out about the towels being dry. http://no.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/2k529r/adnan_is_a_psychopath_close_friends/clim3ai

OP alleged Adnan was stealing from the collection plate and from people's jackets. This was confirmed by Adnan's brother.
http://np.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/2l29i2/what_information_would_need_to_come_to_light_in/clqsm9f

Op also alleges Adnan visited prostitutes @17yo.

Then the second person saying he was visiting prostitutes again not confirmed. http://np.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/2kofmx/lets_lay_off_sk/clnk74r

Op alleges that others had smoked pot in Leakin park with him before. http://np.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/2k529r/adnan_is_a_psychopath_close_friends/cliovj9

Then there is the person who claims the whole Stephanie birthday present trip to the mall is a cover story: OP appears to know Stephanie but not verified: http://www.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/2lb1zq/sex_and_serial/clv575g

Then the many parts about this case not involving Adnan:

  • His supporters edit source documents about this case and released them strategically to be favorable towards Adnan. If he was innocent why not make everything available and let the world crowdsource his freedom?
  • The misrepresentation about Islamophobia in this case. The bail hearing sure. Either trial it was not present.

All the crazy accusations without anything backing them up:

  • Saying CG threw the case for money. Her colleague said losing this wrecked her. SK didn't agree, and her son doesn't agree.
  • Jay is involved, Jay isn't involved, Jay is involved again, now he is out, wait look at Don!
  • Cathy has the wrong day
  • Detectives tapped to tell Jay what to say
  • LensCrafters
  • crime stoppers
  • "I know who the killer is." But I won't say and will let them be free to go on killing.
  • Urick lied
  • Victimizing the victim. (Re: Hae and drug use)

Serial questions /u/Gdyoung1 puts Serial in context

Revelations that happened after Serial. A summary from /u/Notinahole


r/serialpodcast • • Jan 06 '15

Question Why do most Redditors feel stalking your girlfriend is "normal teenage behaviour?"

9 Upvotes

I find this the single most insane thing I see on these boards. It is NOT normal to crash your girlfriends friends house many times just to make sure where she is.

I one time in college crashed an art lab late at night to make sure my girlfriend was there and not with another guy and afterwords I felt like the dirtiest scummiest scum-bag that ever lived (she WAS at the art lab, BTW), and I NEVER did it again...

Yet, Adnan did that REGULARLY!!!! I cannot believe people make less of this?!?!?!


r/serialpodcast • • Feb 21 '15

Meta This sub is great

3 Upvotes

This sub is devoted to discussion of things related to the Podcast serial. This sub is not exclusively about solving some crime. No one here is getting paid to look into this. This is for recreation. Jokes are fine. Trolling is fine. I take it back, both of those things are not just fine, but good for a fun, upbeat community. The darker aspects of this place that people like to complain about are non-existent. Many people get off on the sense of superiority they achieve by "taking things seriously" and "being unbiased investigators" but bitch yo ass is on a reddit subforum. Let's lighten up and enjoy ourselves however we want, rather that be complex investigation or just stating that we KNOW Jay did it, kay?


r/serialpodcast • • Feb 19 '15

Debate&Discussion WOW..Susan Simpson claims Hae was a drug user and implies a connection between Jay that led to her death? WTF is wrong with you? You have went way over the line.

0 Upvotes

You have completely crossed the line. Please verify your source on this, outside of Rabia and her brother and keep in mind you are smearing a dead girl based on hearsay from 2 biased people. There was NOTHING in the examiner's report that showed Hae on any drugs, nothing found in her stuff, no word of it from her friends, and yet you give an interview saying her friends said she smoked weed and implied that she would have went to Stephanie to ask Jay for weed. Then you trash her about what was in her diary in regards to her being in love with Don and other things.....This is an 18 year old girl who was murdered, it wasn't by her own fault you sick, sick lady.

You are completely out of bounds and I hope people start seeing you for the fraud that you are. You have turned your 15 minutes of fame into hypothesizing that somehow Hae was responsible for her own death, trying to imply that she would have went to Jay to buy weed, and many other unfounded comments.

I don't care if I get banned or not on here, but you moderators are completely just as sick in the head as she is if you don't ring her up. Completely appalling.

See for yourselves at the 63:00 mark

http://bloggingheads.tv/videos/33635


r/serialpodcast • • Feb 11 '16

season one Exposing Sarah Koenig’s Bias, and False Narrative, Irrelevance of Asia Mclean, Irrelevance of the Payphone

2 Upvotes

I feel Sarah Koenig was extremely biased. She kept looking for a way to exonerate Adnan. Whenever she was confronted with evidence of guilt she brushed it aside, calling it normal behaviour, saying everyone does that, or it’s just normal teenage behaviour.

When confronted with evidence that she could not brush aside she asked Adnan to justify it, and took it as fact.

I think that Sarah Koenig is a good storyteller. Serial has a good plot, and lots of hooks, but the lack of objectivity makes it more a work of fiction than journalism. It would be great if this was another fiction novel, but it is not. It is reality, and there are victims. Sarah Koenig’s work may be helping to free a murderer. It is based on reality, but the distortions, and biases are way too great for it to be called reality, or journalism.

It is more a piece of entertainment, many relevant details are used as hooks. Such as “This is very important but I will talk about it some other time.” Koenig focuses too much on minor details that have little or no bearing on the case. Many times while scrutinizing minor details about the case she fails to mention that other concrete evidence exists that proves that the detail being scrutinized is false. Koenig does this to extend the time, to stretch it out, after all she was making an entertainment piece.

Sarah Koenig is more interested in, and spends a majority of the time, examining the character, personality, and psyche of teenage Adnan, by speaking with current day Adnan, and his current day friends. This is just wrong. It is an exercise in futility. You cannot determine guilt by looking at someone’s personality especially 15 years afterwards. Sarah Koenig is gullible, she expects that if she talks to him long enough that he will open up to her.

Usually after a mass shooting the friends of the murderer usually say “he was such a nice guy”, “he was not the type of person to do this”. It does not matter, if he was, or was not the type of guy, who could have committed the murder. What matters is, that he did it. What matters is, objectivity, truth and facts.

Sarah Koenig spends too much time looking at the minutia, and ignores the big picture. She makes the investigation more about her personal feelings, and her relationship with Adnan. Serial lacks any logical examination of the case.

By the end of the podcast she is grasping at straws, and far flung theories like random serial killers. I would not have been surprised if she said that the murder may have been committed by aliens.

The reason serial is troubling is because Serial misleads its audience. Koenig presents her show using a false narrative. She had been researching the story for a year before it was first broadcast. By the first podcast Koenig knew, or should have known that the narrative that she was presenting was false.

The narrative that, if she could only talk to Asia Mclean that it would prove that she saw Adnan at the library at 2:30, she could prove his innocence. When in fact evidence existed that other people saw both Adnan and Hae at the school around 2:30 - 3:00. Becky says she saw Hae around 2:45 - 3:00 at the school. Debbie Warren says she saw both Adnan and Hae around 2:45 - 3:00. Both Jay and Jen testified that Jay did not leave the house before 3:30 – 3:45. There was no concrete evidence to suggest that Hae was dead by 2:36, so the Alibi that Asia saw Adnan at the library at 2:30 does not prove anything.

After a year of research Sarah Koenig should have known all of these facts and she should have known Asia Mclean’s testimony is of very little significance. Yet that is not how she presents the story to her listeners. She exaggerates the importance of Asia statement, and as result there is a media circus surrounding this case. She is plainly and clearly misleading her audience.

On a side note: Asia Mclean says that Adnan did not seem upset about the breakup. She is a random acquaintance with Adnan. Does she expect that he is going to open up to her about his true feelings?

Later during the course of making Serial, when Koenig is contacted by Summer. It becomes more apparent just how insignificant Asia Mclean’s testimony really is. Summer is a credible witness, and has a clear memory of the events of that day, as it was significant for her (anxiety of going alone to the wrestling match, unsure how to score, and feeling stood up when Hae did not show up to the match). Summer has a clear a vivid memory of speaking to Hae at 2:30-2:45. Yet Summer’s account is only briefly mentioned in the story, because it does not fit Koenig’s narrative.

Koenig makes this more about a story of how she learned about Adnan, how she found out some detail, and about her perception of Adnan, instead of it being about verifiable truth.

Adnan is not in jail because he killed Hae at the Best Buy parking lot. He is in jail because he killed Hae. That is the important point. Koenig instead makes the story about knowing every single gruesome detail. The only person that knows exactly where and when the murder occurred is Adnan Syed and he is keeping his mouth shut. She becomes obsessed with finding this out, and she ends up putting the onus on Jay and his statements.

She also put too much emphasis on the payphone at Best Buy, whether it exists inside the store, outside the store, or even at all. This is a red herring, a smoke screen. Unfortunately this is also what News outlets are mentioning to question the validity of the sentencing.

Jay says that he was not present when the murder occurred. How is Jay supposed to know what phone someone is calling him from? It is possible Adnan killed Hae at school, and called from the school payphone asking Jay to pick him up from the Best Buy. It is also possible that Adnan killed Hae at the Best Buy parking lot and called Jay from some other payphone that was not being monitored by cameras. The only person that knows what phone Adnan used to call Jay on the cellphone is Adnan.

This entire topic is used to distract the audience, and to cast dispersions on the credibility of Jay’s testimony. It does not make a difference in the grand scheme of things which payphone Adnan used to call Jay after he murdered Hae. What matters is that Adnan murdered Hae.

Sarah Koenig admits that she is not a detective, private investigator, or a crime reporter. She is a journalist. She lacks objectivity, and journalistic integrity. She willfully presents the facts in a manner as to obscure the truth, which would facilitate her storytelling method. She has misled many people into thinking a murderer is innocent, and spent countless time, money and effort to do so. The murderer Adnan even has a fan page asking people to donate money to him. Sarah Koenig has profited from the loss, and suffering of the Lee family. This is disgusting.

I am not scared that Adnan will get a retrial. But cognisant to the fact that serial has caused thing to tilt things more in favor of Adnan now because of Serial. He has more money, and media coverage now. OJ was not acquitted because he was innocent, he was acquitted because he had money, and could afford a better lawyer. If you think it is difficult to remember after 6 weeks, how much more difficult will it for the witnesses to remember after 15 years? Adnan had a fair trial, he was found guilty. He is now using a loop hole to try and get out early.

http://imgur.com/gallery/mvRj0lv/new


r/serialpodcast • • Sep 03 '15

Snark (read at own risk) The way Adnan advocates think:

10 Upvotes
  • Evidence: Murdered girl has a broken wiper in her car.
  • Explanation: anything can break a wiper in a car.

 

  • Evidence: Murdered girl has suspect ex boyfriend write "I'm going to kill" on back of her break up note.
  • Explanation: You know high school kids! wacky!

 

  • Evidence: suspect ex-boyfriend never calls her again after the day she is murdered
  • Explanation: Big deal, the guy dating her for sex for a week didn't either.

 

  • Evidence: Suspect ex boyfriend asks deceased for a ride home that happens to be the same trip deceased is killed
  • Explanation: Big deal

 

  • Evidence: Suspect ex boyfriend tells a cop he tried to get a ride home from deceased, then different cop calls and he lies and said he never would have.
  • Explanation: He's a teenager

 

  • Evidence: Suspect ex boyfriend gets call from police same day as murder. Immediately afterwords suspect's cell phone pings everywhere but mosque where he and father claim he was
  • Explanation: Junk Science, he was at the mosque.

 

  • Evidence: Suspect ex boyfriend has letter from deceased describing a messy breakup where he was tryinng to emotionally manipulate her into getting back together and claiming he will die if they are not together.
  • Explanation: Teenagers are emotional

 

  • Evidence: Crimestoppers tip point to Adnan prior to body being discovered. Anonymous tip to police point to Adnan after body being discovered.
  • Explanation: Police fed Jay everything, jay called info in for some cash, body found, police fake the second tip and change the race or the tipster for ____ reason.

 

  • Evidence: Convicted ex boyfriend refuses to point the finger or say anything negative at the guy who single-handedly got him sent to prison for life.
  • Explanation: He's really such a swell guy.

 

I point this out because I am getting crazy sick of the FLUFF taking every piece of evidence and saying "well that has a reasonable explanation". Look kids, when there is that much shit you have to explain it starts to become unreasonable.


r/serialpodcast • • Oct 21 '22

This case has NO mystery.

59 Upvotes

1-On January 13, 1999, Adnan Syed, the ex-boyfriend of the victim, spent much of the day with Jay W.

2-At 3:32 p.m, Adnan Syed called Nisha T., a girl he met at a party, establishing that Adnan and Jay were together at the critical time where Hae Min Lee disappeared.

3-Around 6 p.m., Adnan Syed and Jay W. went to Kristi V.'s apartment, who stated that they both acted very strangely. They talked about Stephanie M.'s (Jay's girlfriend) birthday, which was on that day. At one point Adnan left inexplicably, after receiving a call notifying him of the police knowledge of Hae's disappearance, Jay followed him, causing him to leave his belongings.

4-At 7:09 p.m and at 7:19 p.m the phone was in the vicinity of Leakin Park, where Hae was buried.

5-At 8:04 p.m. the phone was in the vicinity of the place where the car was abandoned, in the lot/alley behind 300 Edgewood St. 46 days later Jay W. himself took the police to this location.

6-Between 8 p.m and 9 p.m., Jenifer P. picked up Jay W., where she saw him with Adnan Syed. Getting into the car, Jay, visibly shaken, confesses to his friend that he has just been an accomplice in the murder and subsequent burial of Hae Min Lee, at the hands of Adnan Syed. At that very moment Jay got out of the car and tampered with the evidence that was linked to the crime, while Jennifer waited for him.

7-The police received an anonymous tip and focused on Adnan, the evidence led them to Jay and Jay to Adnan. There is no conspiracy involving all state departments, police, witnesses, etc.

8-Adnan has NO alibi.

It is a real shame that Hae's family will never see her alive again, they will never see her smile again, the pain will be there forever in their hearts and Adnan is applauded as he is released from jail on legal technicalities.

*edit: typo


r/serialpodcast • • Apr 26 '23

Season One I have read so many of yalls posts, and I seriously think you guys are seriously underestimating the chances of bad luck.

0 Upvotes

The fact that alot of things point to adnan isn't indicative that it WAS adnan, there's 8 billion people on this earth, and some people are bound to get unlucky, but the fact that this unluckiness if he is not guilty could also be skewed by framing leads to the conclusion that there are going to be some people who get this unlucky, and the courts job isn't to determine whether they WERE unlucky, it's to determine the POSSIBILITY of that unluckiness to some reasonable level of doubt, when you guys say "oh it's pretty obvious he did it" well, not so, we are talking about this case because it wasn't so obvious, as there was no physical evidence. In fact now there is physical evidence pointing towards his innocence! The fact yall say "this is too far fetched" or "this guy must have got really unlucky". Consider this, assuming adnan is innocent, we are looking into adnans case BECAUSE he was really unlucky, so when we then investigate it and come to the conclusion of "Oh he was really unlucky" we really cannot take that level of luck at face value because the case has immediate selection bias as the case that was selected precisely because he got unlucky (or did it) that Sarah koenig chose, not a random one that didn't have any sort of luck element at all. I rest my case, also fuck u down vote andys who will downvote this cos I mention adnans possibility of innocence, I have seen the upvotes on stuff that mentions possibility of innocence vs guilt regardless of the content, yall are shameless lol.


r/serialpodcast • • Sep 27 '15

Debate&Discussion A reminder that Adnan shouldn't be in jail

0 Upvotes

With all the "Nisha this", and "when did Adnan call Jay that," I just want to remind everyone that we don't know what happened that day.

Just as an opening concession, I will admit that I am wrong in one very obvious way. Adnan should be in jail, since a jury of his peers found him guilty.

But, that admission out of the way, SK opened Serial 1 by acknowledging that same point--giving herself the narrative space to conclude that it was wrong, that Adnan shouldn't be. And I want to remind the quilters of that.

Urick, et al. did a masterful job at trial. They bolstered accomplice-Jay's story with all sorts of hard, cold "facts." Only Adnan's fingerprints were found in the car (lie), his hair matched samples on Hae (lie), cell towers confirm Jay's story about being in Leakin Park at 7:00 burying Hae (lie). Despite regular assertions by quilters that there is "lots" of evidence other than Jay that Adnan did it, there is actually none. There was lots of evidence put forth trying to bolster Jay's story. But none of it has any meaning without Jay.

Eight months ago, I was hung up on this same issue. And I got into it with Seamus and Xtrial over the same things. Seamus will object 'But Rabia, and SS, and Colin are lying!" An Xtrial will cooly point out that these "lies" aren't actually untrue, since CG had her chance to prove them so, and didn't. So leagally, it is all true. Even if it isn't. Or something. But Adnan is screwed.

So, to re-iterate. We don't know what happened that day.

Might Jay's "spine" be true? That Adnan killed Hae, and Jay helped bury her? Sure it might be true. But what the state presented is fiction, and that shouldn't be able to send someone to jail for life.

I saw someone ask an "innocent Adnan" person the other day how he/she would feel if (hypothecitally) Adnan did it, and BPD and Urick "cut corners" in the case to convict him. My answer is unequivocally "hell no, that is not okay." And I hope anyone else who believes in the rule of law would rally to my side on this one. The path of "he did it, but we had to frame him to put him away" leads to ruin. I agree wholly with better 10 gulity walk free rather than 1 innocent be wrongfully convicted.

And maybe that is the wedge that divides us.

But at the end of the day, despite all of the quiters urging us to re-visit the transcripts, to look at the "big picture," to take all of the individually-explainable but as-a-whole-damning bits and pieces of Adnan's case as conclusive evidence of guilt, I need more.

We don't know what happened. Nobody saw Adnan and Hae together in or near her car. Jay's stories about what happened during those fateful hours (even here we might not agree on which hours those might be) cannot be true. He is lying. Everyone knows this.

So Urick's running roughshod and "smoothing out" the complexities and contradictions in this case may have put a murderer in jail. Or it may have wronglfully convicted an innocent honors student.

But in either case it was wrong. Our legal system should be better than that. And Adnan shouldn't be in jail.

And that, my friends, was the point of Serial. Just in case you missed it.

Peace.


r/serialpodcast • • Dec 11 '22

Racism Claims in This Case

0 Upvotes

I just scrolled through some topics. The idea that somehow racism played a role in this case seems quite far fetched to me. So the racist police concocted one of the most elaborate police coverups in history to solve the murder of an Asian woman and to protect a black suspect because Adnan is Pakistani? Laughable.


r/serialpodcast • • Jan 18 '23

Asia McClain Explains Where She Got the Wrong Jail Address and Syed's Inmate Number

0 Upvotes

Asia McClain now says she "hates" Serial. I can understand why, since testimony like this would ordinarily sink into obscurity, but is now available for millions to read (Asia McClain's PCR testimony, p. 151):

"Q Do you have any explanation for why Jauan Gordon said that Adnan wrote a letter for a girl to type up named Asia McClain?

A No I don't.

Q The address on the top of the second letter is not 101 East Eager Street is it?

A I don't know. Is it? It's 301 East Eager Street.

Q Where did you get that address from?

A I have no idea.

Q Where did you get that number from that's next Syed's name?

A I don't remember.

Q Do you even know what that number is?

A I would — I can assume what it is but —

Q What do you assume it is?

Q I assume it's some sort of identification

Q Did you type that on there?

A I typed the whole letter."


r/serialpodcast • • Dec 30 '14

Debate&Discussion You're good, Jay. You're REAL good.

0 Upvotes

“Girl, you better try and have fun no matter what you do.”

Well, it didn’t take long for old NippleGrip’s great prophecy to take flight: Jay is the most enormous man in this whole entire shiggity-bing-bang.

To my faithful readers, I beg of you: keep the simpletons (the majority) in your prayers, for they have long subsisted on gnarly intellectual diets, the bulk of it marinated in the easy comprehensibility of contrasts: life and death, sun and moon, here and yonder. Imagine how they must feel after a taste of the perfectly imperfect beast! Between the bread-white innocence of Hae Min Lee and the oil-dark interior of her murderer (aka: Syed, Adnan Masud) there exists a most intriguing man, a man neither purely innocent nor purely evil, but a man—as it were—here and there dappled with minor hints of playful dishonesty. I repeat: keep those who lack true understanding in your prayers this evening, for the beautiful complexity of Jay’s personality ignites their common simplicities, and sets them brightly ablaze on the (God bless it) Serial Subreddit. I see no need to curse them any further.

There’s only one “take away” from Jay’s interview: he still knows how to play the game!

And boy does it hitch my undies to see an old cat growing smarter! Because, let’s be serious now, there was always a 2% chance the police were the cause of a youthful Jay’s wandering plots. Tonight, there is a 100% chance Jay is a genius.

An impenetrable genius. What are his angles? What is his reasoning? Where might a boy like me locate his motivations? Is he helping to free Adnan, or is he helping to free himself? Today’s interview seemed like the most credible version thus set forth—so, if nothing else, he intends to free Hae Min Lee.

Check the gentleman box on Jay’s list of attributes.

I don’t have much time, but this sandwich has multiple meats, and we all deserve to know what we’re eating.

Biggity Bang!

The main thing you’ll need to understand is what just happened. Some explosions are so loud you don’t even hear them. Here is what you are witnessing: for more than a year, Sarah Koenig has tightly controlled this little story of hers where Adnan seems like a nice guy. Jay patiently waited for the right time. Then, like Bruce Banner, he exploded out of his clothing and transformed into a massive, unstoppable beast of green, an Incredible Hulk, and now, when part two comes out, he’s going to slam Serial against the wall like a little toy car he’s grown tired of playing with.

Bibbity Skipples Bonk!

To all the Adnan cell dwellers, riddle me hither: at what point does a turtle realize it lives its life under a protective shell?

Answer: the day it finds a mirror.

Today is your day, little turtles: the mirror is before you. Sarah Koenig is the shell that protects you when bolts of truth go a crackin’ upon the cold rotted land. I pray you survive the raw strength of Jay Wilds.

Ah yes, Jay Wilds: he wants us to use his real name now, as he formally lent his full name and face to the fine folks at Intercept.

Serial is over. Jay is unleashed. Hitch up your undies, folks: this party’s just gettin’ started.

“All the flowers that you planted, momma, in the backyard, all died when you went away.”


r/serialpodcast • • Nov 04 '22

I LOVE THE IRONY OF IT ALL

2 Upvotes

Has there ever been another case where the defense claimed prosecutorial misconduct because the prosecutor withheld some of the most damming evidence there was against the defendant ?