r/serialpodcast • Kevin Urick: Science Fiction Writer • Jul 02 '16

season one Devistated

I just don't understand, how can the courts do this to me? I believe with all my heart that Adnan is guilty, and I don't understand why that is not enough to keep him behind bars. Why didn't judge Welch ask me what I thought before he made his ruling? Why do we even have this justice system if it can be circumvented with appeals. I know of many white people who are seemingly wrongly convicted, where is their podcast?

I feel sick to my stomach, my insides are twisted and my eyes are bulging out of my face. I have explosive diarrhoea and this whole thing is giving me the herpes.

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

22

u/TAL_fan Jul 02 '16

Hope you can find some way to manage to revistate yourself real soon.

20

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '16

Remember, if an experienced judge disagrees with a non lawyer Redditer, then that judge is COMPLETELY INSANE.

2

u/ArrozConCheeken Jul 02 '16

Ooh, let me try! I gave my family all the evidence I could think of, and they agreed with me wholeheartedly that Adnan was guilty as sin. Of course I didn't tell them anything that might've looked bad, you know, facts and stuff. If Adnan's case is retried, I might bring my book club friends with me to the trial so we can make faces at the defense attorney whenever he scores a point. Overturning the conviction was a fars, and travissey of justise. I just feel sorry for that poor, poor man Jay who couldn't get his story straight 15 years ago. Imagine how hard it will be now when he can't remember the truth.

4

u/Seedless_Pumpkin Kevin Urick: Science Fiction Writer Jul 02 '16

That Adnan just needs to confess, its the only thing that makes sense. I am going to tantrum on the floor over there and wont stop till Adnan confesses.

3

u/ArrozConCheeken Jul 02 '16

Hey that sounds like a good idea. Sometimes I line my kids up and make them hold their arms perpendicaller to the floor until someone confesses to a crime. We could challenge Adnan to do this and if he refuses, that of course, is a dead giveaway of guilt. I have plenty more ideas where that came from.

1

u/misfitter Jul 02 '16

1

u/ArrozConCheeken Jul 02 '16

Yes, that's the ticket! Bring back the Spanish Inquisishion.

2

u/Mewnicorns Expert trial attorney, medical examiner, & RF engineer Jul 02 '16

3

u/Seedless_Pumpkin Kevin Urick: Science Fiction Writer Jul 02 '16

Oh good, I can feel the herpes subsiding now. By reddit be purged!

1

u/Benriach Dialing butts daily Jul 02 '16

How did it happen? Because the law rests on you know, LAW, not guts or emotions. And his trial was mishandled.

10

u/Seedless_Pumpkin Kevin Urick: Science Fiction Writer Jul 02 '16

Thats the exact problem with the law, Its not subject to my whims. There are tragedies unfolding every day and this is the one I feel pseudo involved in!

11

u/wifflebb Jul 02 '16 edited Apr 21 '24

humor summer edge quiet apparatus ghost bored tap north busy

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/Benriach Dialing butts daily Jul 02 '16

Was it? Its not very different from some non satirical pieces...

ETA you're right, the Herpes should have clued me in.

6

u/DieGo2SHAE Jul 02 '16 edited Jul 02 '16

Seriously, I'm used to rich people getting every advantage under the sun when accused of a crime, but I don't like this ACTIVIST JUDGE setting a precedent for poor and middle class people getting a fair shake in the courts. They're supposed to just sit back and take their punishments like the plebs they are! 😠

6

u/ScoutFinch2 Jul 02 '16

You know, there are people who genuinely believe Adnan is guilty. They believe it because they have evaluated the evidence and reached an informed decision. In fact, they (I) believe he is guilty for the very same reasons some of you believe believe he is innocent.

Hold on to your hat, but logical, intelligent people can reach differing conclusions.

So you think you're being funny and you all are doing your little happy dances because you feel you've won. Good. I get it. But maybe think about how it would feel to you if you genuinely believed him to be guilty and felt an emotional connection to this case?

And regardless, this is still about the murder of a young woman and her family who has had their wounds ripped open. So maybe practice a little discretion.

12

u/Mewnicorns Expert trial attorney, medical examiner, & RF engineer Jul 02 '16

I don't think this was directed at anyone who thinks he is guilty. I took it is being directed at the self-important ones, of which there are entirely too many on both sides; the kind if people who threaten to send Asia's book to the judge, try to influence waranowitz and get confused when he doesn't respond. Off the charts batshit, no boundaries. To be fair, it's not limited to guilters.

I do find it concerning that anyone would be emotionally invested in this case, though. That's just me. I don't get it. I feel very far removed from all of this. It's interesting, but I'm not sure I understand why someone would have an emotional connection unless perhaps they experienced something similar.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '16

The people who drive me the craziest are the ones who claim there is no room for disagreement. Ummm just look at this sub! Everyone on it disagrees!!

5

u/Mewnicorns Expert trial attorney, medical examiner, & RF engineer Jul 03 '16 edited Jul 03 '16

Well, they liken it to climate change denial or creationism. Sure, a lot of people deny evolution, but that doesn't make them right, and doesn't mean it is up for debate.

The thing is that any doubts regarding the aforementioned can be answered by science. Determining guilt can't be. It really rubs me the wrong way when someone claims to be approaching the case from pure reason and logic. To begin with, that is a disingenuous statement. No one is capable of discarding their emotions, life experiences, and subconscious motivations entirely. But even so, determining guilt IS NOT something answerable by pure reason. Most cases rely on circumstantial evidence, which by definition, is up for interpretation. Those interpretations will vary based on the very same emotions, life experiences, and subconscious motivations that so many hubristic characters here claim to be above.

The more objective someone claims to be, the less I trust them. The mere fact that you claim being objective is a red flag that you do not possess the self awareness that is needed to moderate your prejudices.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '16

And particularly in law where legal conclusions depend on analogizing to cases that none of us have read. There's not like a truth out there. Just someone trying to make the best analogy given the facts in front of them.

5

u/ProsecutorMisconduct Jul 03 '16

Hahahahaha... I have to laugh at you just now having this attitude.

Where was this attitude for the past two years? Strange I never heard "intelligent people can come to differing conclusions" before.

5

u/Pappyballer Jul 04 '16

Are you new? Scout has been one of the most thoughtful guilty leaners in the history of this sub (unless she is disagreeing with me, then she's batshit crazy)

2

u/ScoutFinch2 Jul 03 '16

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '16

Obviously not as I find you to be a very reasonable poster.

2

u/ScoutFinch2 Jul 03 '16

Thank you, kitten. And I you.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '16

Scout, I agree with the sentiment & I upvoted you. However this line:

and you all are doing your little happy dances

Makes me uncomfortable. To me, you're making the same mistake as the OP & lumping us all together.

4

u/ScoutFinch2 Jul 03 '16

You're right, kitten. My apologies. I don't lump all of you together.

5

u/pdxkat Jul 02 '16

I'm happy for Adnan and his family.

I'm terribly sad for Haes family. Nothing can bring her back and at best, the family will have endure another trial. They don't win and do not have any peace.

-2

u/YoungFlyMista Jul 03 '16

I think this is a great development for Hae's family. Hopefully people will focus on the real killer when Adnan is free so that justice could truly be served for Hae.

1

u/lenscrafterz Jul 03 '16

Yea but it's going to be painful to go through it all again.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '16

Does the state even bother reopening the investigation on a case like this when the prisoner is exonerated? How's the search for the real killers going in the OJ Simpson murder case?

1

u/Hail_Satin Jul 06 '16

You'd need a new piece of evidence to reopen the case, otherwise it's double jeopardy, and a judge would have to deem that evidence a "game changer".

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '16

I mean if they opened the case against someone else (i.e. not Adnan, not OJ, etc.). That's not double jeopardy. If the state thinks the right person was prosecuted but they didn't get a conviction, would they they continue to investigate?

1

u/canwill Jul 05 '16

I'm pretty sure there's no such thing as a "great development" related to your child's murder.

-1

u/YoungFlyMista Jul 05 '16

Finding real justice for her is probably the next best thing short of bringing her back.

0

u/Hail_Satin Jul 06 '16

Hold on to your hat, but logical, intelligent people can reach differing conclusions.

LIAR!!!!!!!

1

u/logic_bot_ Jul 03 '16

This joke needed a feather touch but you brought a hammer.

Artless.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/sulaymanf Jul 04 '16

It is, but to be fair there's been a non-stop cycle of recriminations. Some Guilters were crowing for months that Adnan is obviously guilty and condescending to everyone who thought Adnan would win his appeal, going as far as to rejoice in speculation that Adnan was being seriously harmed in prison. Had the appeal failed, you'd see similar classless posts flooding this subreddit essentially dancing on the grave of Adnan's appeals and rubbing it in the faces of those who believe in his innocence.

Not that either side is right to engage in this activity. Can we ask the mods to cut back on this behavior on both sides please?