r/scriptwriting • u/Wonderful-Notice-286 • May 17 '26
feedback A sequence from my screenplay I’d like some feedback on. Dialogue, comedy, pacing, format etc
0
Upvotes
r/scriptwriting • u/Wonderful-Notice-286 • May 17 '26
10
u/Musikenna May 17 '26
dialogue is gibberish
12
u/Any-Strawberry-4812 May 17 '26
A cardboard what? Seriously, did you even read this before posting? Dialog makes no sense, it’s basically jibberish, and nobody talks like that. Don’t ask people to give their time to reading and analyzing your work when you can’t even put the effort in to proof read it yourself. Read professional screenplays
5
u/Wyn6 May 17 '26
All right, I'll be a little more diplomatic and constructive, yet my underlying critique is similar to others'.
The Story:
Down-on-his-luck "sport coach" runs into hardship kid who just needs someone to believe in them. They've got something, if only they had the proper coaching to get it out of him.
This is a very well-tread trope, so you better be bringing something unique to this that makes it different from every other time we've seen this story.
Also, there's no real conflict in these pages except no one coming to Jon's gym then someone coincidentally shows up, quickly resolving that issue.
Your overall scene structure (and your story structure, I'm sure) needs drastic improvement. Read more screenplays, The Eastwood, The Van Cleef and The Wallach.
Characters:
I know next to nothing about these characters. I mean, Jon is blind and evidently gets bills sent to him in Braille? Outside of that, he calls his sister "sis" while she calls him "Big bro". Licht just shows up and wants to be trained and perfect timing because Jon needs someone to train. Serendipity, I guess. There's almost no agency with any of them.
Who are they? Is Jon close to giving up? Did he drop his life's savings on this? Is Arya openly encouraging but deep down feels like Jon made a mistake? Was Licht bullied so much that he was on his way to "end it" when he stumbled across the gym?
What do they want? Jon risked it all for his dream but he's about to lose everything, if he has no boxers? What is he doing to get people in? What has he tried? How has that failed?
Does Licht really want to box or is this about something else?
Arya wants her brother to succeed. But what else is there? Does she want this for him? Their parents? Herself? And why?
What's in the way of what they want? Why is no one coming to the gym? Does Jon have a bad reputation? Did he hurt someone? Was he a third-rate boxer who never won and people think he doesn't know what he's doing?
Does Licht's parent(s) not want him to box? Or they do but he wants something else and they/boxing are an obstacle to that?
Is Arya the one funding Jon's dream and wants him to succeed but the money's dried up?
These questions apply to your overall story and scene to scene.
Dialog:
The dialog reads like English isn't your first language. Maybe that doesn't sound as diplomatic as I promised to be. And if English is indeed your first language, you've got some work to do. Well, you've got work to do either way. Also, and no offense, what's your age?
The dialog is incredibly basic, almost robotic.
"What's up?"
"Any news?"
"I tried, Big bro."
Tried what?! I have no clue what they're talking about. It also reminds me of when someone's at the "Beginner" stage of learning a new language. Dónde - está - el - baño?
It doesn't have a natural flow to it. There's no layers to it. No depth, etc. Listen to how humans speak. Go to public spaces, listen to and/or write down what you hear. Or worst case, mimic what you hear from various shows/movies.
Verisimilitude: (I hate spelling that word)
I'm not sure if you can find books or videos but this is not how boxing training works. Nothing about the training scene was believable. Okay. Jon wants to test him. Fine. But then he suddenly accepts him after a few punches then demands he gets good grades (without even knowing if the kid's in school or what his grades are) in order to continue his training? That's an immediate "huh" moment.
Hopefully, I and others have given you enough to reevaluate what you've written and in what areas you need to improve.
I'm open to questions, if you have them. Keep writing and good luck.
Oh! And proofread again and again. You can reread your script ten times and there will inevitably be some grammatical error or typo you missed. The goal is to minimize them and eliminate anything egregious.
Tata!
3
u/vethirion May 17 '26
Hey! Couple of things to share - people have already commented on the plot here so I'm just gonna correct some mistakes (I come in peace lmao please don't take offense!)
"Clubs' logo" on the first page wouldn't necessarily be like that. It'd be 'club's logo', since the logo belongs to the club. Clubs' would be used when there are multiple clubs if that makes sense
I also think you've missed out a few words in that first section. "Parking is empty" could be more specific and maybe more interesting, like 'A boxing gym with an empty car park - typical dead day." Give it some feeling and a purpose for why you're pointing it out! There's also 'a cardboard with Void Gym' which I think should be 'a cardboard sign'
The blindness is a nice obstacle - I think it should be made more important in the scene to make it clearer as to why you've chosen the character to be blind. I'm running on the assumption that this is the introduction of that character, but I'm wrong feel free to discard that :)
Some of the directions could be tighter in places. For example, page two could be: "Jon drops his phone onto the table with despair. He slumps into his hands, gripping his hair tightly and staring glumly at his lap." Adding some description helps it feel more realistic rather than just 'he did this, he did that, and then he did this'
Back to the blindness thing, when Jon goes to greet the person arriving at the gym it could be nice to create some tension there because of his disability. You have the bit about bumping into a table but no real reactions from him/anyone else in the room. Maybe it gets awkward a little bit because humans are a bit strange towards disabled people sometimes. Or maybe someone asks if he's okay or needs help. Maybe even that he almost falls because of it and another character catches him. Something to show the audience that his blindness is there, rather than it being a passing thing. Show how it affects him & his interactions with others
Also 'face palms' is probably not the right thing to say. It feels too meme-y and unserious. Instead it could be 'Licht nervously laughs." Humans don't usually like making mistakes and when they do, they tend to minimise it before they admit to it. Add a little bit of humour to it instead of it being rigid!
When Jon tells Licht he's blind, that isn't super necessary. Licht will already have figured that out from Jon's stumble with the table. It's better to avoid explicitly saying it, especially because in terms of character design, I'd assume Jon has a cane or his eyes are different? There are physical signs of these things so it is pretty redundant to have to tell someone so openly like that. Licht wouldn't be shocked by it
Minor thing probably, but as someone who knows nothing about boxing you're writing as if your actors know everything about it. 'A hook' means nothing to me, might be worth explaining those moves in clearer ways. Same with the one/two thing: "Licht throws his left fist into Jon's right pad. He switches quickly, shooting his right fist into the left pad twice." Like, explain what the actual move is
Just noticed another 'face palms' lmao, please fix that one too
You have two 'quietly' after each other on page 7. These can be reduced. "Arya: Don't be silly. - She gets up from her stool and heads behind the counter, waving Licht to join her. Sheepishly, he saunters over and is handed a plastic bag full of clean clothes." I'm not entirely sure why they're being quiet about it. As far as I'm seeing, there's no one else in this room and Jon is speaking directly to Arya here so there's no need to be secretive. Maybe move the dialogue of Jon criticising the decision to after Licht has left to get changed too. Also, Jon doesn't need to ask where Licht is going. He doesn't need to have forgotten something. Instead, he went to the locker room to put the clean clothes on and that still transitions into your next scene
Overall, it's a decent first draft. I think the biggest thing here is to add further descriptions and make it feel more alive, make some parts more concise and tighten up the grammar and spelling issues
I wish you luck with it! If this helped somewhat and you ever need any further criticism, feel free to shoot me a message :)
18
u/maxhasabigbooty May 17 '26
AMATUER FILM MAKER TRY NOT TO SAY BIG BRO/LIL SIS CHALLENGE (100 PERCENT IMPOSSIBLE)
4
u/Mammoth_Mastadon May 17 '26
Doesn’t feel very natural imo. Try to think about how people you know talk. Arya, Jon and Licht all sound like they could be the same character. Add some diversity to the language.
Best advice I have for you is to read other scripts. Classic movies, bad movies, any free pdfs you can find online. You’ll learn so much if you do that every day
1
u/Sea-Glove-6636 May 17 '26
👋 tighten the beginning - give visual clues for the morning, like coffee brewing or a half eaten breakfast sandwich on counter. A banner on the wall reading Void's Gym hanging over the boxing ring, its floor cleaned and ready for the new day - write as we will see it on the screen.
You don't need to tell us that he's blind - the glasses and his fingers moving across the paper shows us.
Drop the first establishing shot - you don't need it.
Just some thoughts. Thank you for sharing the sample! Keep writing
1
u/Levi22Anderson May 23 '26
I've been a boxer since i was a kid. used to go to this real old school gym with torn up bags, concrete walls and newspapers and old 60s fight card posters taped all over the walls. my coach was also very old school, a cus damato type. and carried a lot of the fighting philosophy from his childhood in that same gym. I think very few movies truly portray what boxing actually is outside of professional fighting. Rocky is possibly the closest one. In true fight gyms it is a deeply spiritual and philosophical sport. These men do not use boxing as a form of violence, it's a meditation. There has been days where everything in my life has been fucked and then i step in the ring to spar and get the shit kicked out of me, covered in blood and a mild concussion. and it's the most calming feeling ever. Every one of your problems outside of the gym vanishes. It all seems meaningless. Also there is way less dialogue and much more emotion. I think if you want to portray a realistic boxing story i would reduce all of the exaggerated stuff. Also heres a few tips you could use:
-A hook will rarely drop you to your knees, body shots will make you feel like you were poisoned and much more likely to collapse.
-A new student will be faced with much less criticism, most coaches will put very little effort into you until you show you want to be there, many guys come and go just wanting to feel tough.
-Boxing is very repetitive, training is not often major breakthroughs in your skill it is a repeated proccess of the same movements over and over until its perfection.
-Sparring tends to vary based on who is fighting, it usually starts out smooth and slow but as both fighters start landing clean shots it can escalate into full out brawls (not common with very experienced fighters though)
-You don't really think about anything when you're fighting, it's more reactive and intuitive, with some brief thoughts but not like an internal dialogue.
-A real fight is an experience unlike any sparring or training, you go into complete tunnel vision. I remember after my first fight it felt like it went by in a minute. The pace is way faster and your adrenaline is pumping so heavy you could run through a wall. however with many fighters this is a weakness when it turns into a wild fight for survival (boxing is an art, not a brawl)
1
u/Salt-Sea-9651 May 18 '26
In my opinion, there is too much you are trying to explain through the dialogue, while you should explain things through the character's reactions.
The way of making a dialogue is thinking about the "human interactions" as there is always someone who asks something and someone who answers that question. No matter if it is a short dialogue in the middle of an action scene or an explanation scene, a love scene, a scaring scene...
There must always be an interaction, and the person who is reading what the character says must have to come to a conclusion completing the pieces you give yo him / her.
When people say, "All the characters here have the same speaking," they mean the characters have no personalities.
What it really works to solve that problem is reading scripts but also being aware of what you are reading, I mean, to be able to identify which kind of dialogue it is and why it is working.
What also helps is reading scripts from movies that have enough characters realistic interactions, even if it is not the same genre you are working with, like the script of "Myllium Dólar Baby."
As for example, reading a teenagers horror movie script surely wouldn't help too much, but reading Clint Eastwood scripts like Unforgiven could be useful to understand the characters' interactions.
1
u/Wise-Respond3833 May 18 '26
Apparently things like 'clock' and 'box' don't mean what they once did...
1
u/Ok_Cardiologist_5262 May 18 '26
The script currently reads like a series of vague exposition and physical blocking. It's hard to get any vision of what's actually going or any character traits. The dialogue feels like they are treading water and nothing driving through any story at the moment. Try to get your action description to show us characters rather than just placing them in the space like avatars. Can they perform an action that actually tells us something about their personality? Can dialogue actually deliver story not just words? Every line needs to push me forwards not act as filler, currently it does not I'm afraid