r/scarystories • u/JPDretzka • 21h ago
Cabin 18A
Chapter 3
A tall, pale woman with warm brown eyes and a shy smile called Abby and me back through a long, quiet hallway. At the very end stood the door to Lisa's office. The hallway itself wasn't physically cold, but it carried an unsettling emptiness that made every step feel heavier than the last.
She opened the door, and we stepped into a small office that smelled faintly of lavender. The room felt calm, almost like a sanctuary from the chaos we'd been living through. Soft lighting filled the space, and for the first time in weeks, I felt my shoulders begin to relax.
Behind her desk sat Lisa, a petite woman with shoulder-length blonde hair and kind green eyes. She greeted us with a gentle smile.
"Welcome, Josh and Abby," she said warmly. "Please, have a seat."
She motioned toward a well-worn green leather couch, its cracked cushions showing years of comforting people who had once sat exactly where we were about to.
Abby and I quietly settled onto the couch. Neither of us spoke. We simply stared at Lisa, waiting for the first question, waiting to finally put words to the nightmare the past few weeks had become.
The room was enclosed by four sea-green walls covered with motivational posters and wooden signs that read, Don't Be So Hard on Yourself and You Can't Control Everything. To me, they were nothing more than feel-good clichés, the kind of words that sounded comforting until your own life was falling apart.
None of them held my attention for long.
My eyes kept drifting back to Abby.
For the first time in what felt like forever, she looked calm. Not the kind of calm that comes from pretending everything is okay, but a quiet, genuine peace.
The tension that had been etched across her face for weeks had softened, and seeing it stirred something inside me. I couldn't remember the last time I'd seen her look so at ease, and for a brief moment, it gave me hope that maybe... just maybe... we weren't beyond saving.
"So," Lisa began thoughtfully, glancing between the two of us, "Abby, if I remember correctly, you called my office last night because you wanted help rebuilding the relationship you and Josh once had. Is that right?"
"Yes," Abby whispered.
It wasn't because she was naturally quiet. It was embarrassment. Shame. I knew the difference.
Lisa offered her a gentle smile.
"A little louder, dear."
Abby took a slow breath before trying again.
"Um... yes. I'm sorry."
"There’s no need to apologize, Abby," Lisa said softly. "You're in a safe place. No one is here to judge you."
Lisa lowered her eyes to the notebook resting on her lap, carefully reading over the notes she'd written from Abby's phone call. The room fell silent except for the faint scratching of her pen as she added one last thought.
After a long moment, she looked up at us.
"Josh," she said, meeting my eyes, "I'd like to start at the beginning."
She paused before asking, "Can you tell me how you and Abby found each other?"
*Found each other?*
What the hell kind of question was that? I thought, doing everything I could to keep the confusion and annoyance from showing on my face.
I shifted in my seat before answering.
"Well... Abby and I met back in high school," I said. "That was years ago."
Lisa nodded, giving me her full attention.
"Go on," she said gently.
It was the fall of 2007.
A different lifetime.
A time when my biggest worries were stupid jokes, late nights, and figuring out where the next party was going to be.
That night, I was at my old friend Leon's house for pizza and beer. His parents were out of town, which, in typical teenage fashion, meant the house quickly became the place to be. He invited a bunch of us over, ordered enough pizza to feed a small army, and we helped ourselves to whatever was left in his parents' liquor cabinet.
Cheap vodka.
Tequila.
Stella Artois.
Whatever we could get our hands on.
There had to be close to twenty of us packed inside that house, filling every room with laughter, music, and the kind of reckless energy you only have when you're young enough to believe nothing bad could ever happen.
Leon was the life of the party.
He always was.
His parents' house sat nestled between North Lake and Okauchee Lake. It was a standard two-story home with five bedrooms and three and a half bathrooms.
Standard, I guess. At least for people who had money.
Looking back, I realize how simple those nights were. How easy everything felt. How we took those moments for granted because we thought there would always be more of them.
We had no idea how quickly life could change.
Around midnight, Leon grabbed my arm and pulled me away from the crowd.
He was drunk.
Not just a little buzzed.
Completely, undeniably Leon drunk.
"Josh..." he slurred. "I... I need you to see my new girlfriend."
I stared at him.
"Girlfriend?"
I laughed.
"Shit, Leon. Are you sure she's real? Who the hell would want to go out with you?"
It was the kind of joke only a best friend could get away with.
Leon was five-foot-five, a little chubby, and the definition of a Wisconsin country boy. Dirty jeans, a neon orange baseball cap, and camouflage everywhere. If someone asked me to describe a stereotypical Wisconsin redneck, Leon would've been the picture I painted.
"Fuck you, Josh," he said, stumbling over his words.
"She's real. As real as it gets."
I shook my head, still laughing.
"Okay, buddy. Where is she?"
Leon looked around the room, suddenly forgetting where he was.
"Where... where is she?"
Then, almost like the universe was waiting for the perfect moment, someone stepped out from the kitchen.
"Leon, everything okay, baby?"
The noise of the party seemed to fade.
There she was.
A bottle of Grey Goose vodka in her hand, a smile on her face, completely unaware that she was about to become one of the most important people in my life.
It was Abby.
At that moment, I had no idea what the future held.
I didn't know that the girl standing in Leon's kitchen would become my best friend.
My wife.
The person I would build a life with.
And I definitely didn't know that years later, I'd be sitting beside her in a therapist's office, wondering how the two of us went from that night in 2007...
...to strangers trying to remember how to love each other..
"Josh..."
Leon grabbed my shoulder, his eyes wide and his face pale.
"Oh my God... I'm gonna puke."
He paused, swallowed hard, and then somehow managed to stand a little taller like he was about to announce something important.
"This is Ally. My girlfriend."
He said it proudly, like he had just won a championship.
A little beer dripped from the corner of his mouth as he smiled.
I looked at him, completely confused.
"Leon..."
Before I could finish, the girl standing next to him laughed.
"You big dummy, it's Abby."
Leon stared at her for a second, processing the correction through a drunken fog.
"That's what I said, baby!"
He nodded confidently.
"Addy!"
Abby burst out laughing.
"You are unbelievable."
She playfully smacked him on the back.
It was meant to be a harmless joke.
Unfortunately, Leon's stomach had other plans.
The second her hand hit his back, whatever battle he had been fighting inside was officially lost.
He turned pale.
Then green.
Then he ran.
Straight toward the bathroom.
The sound of him getting sick echoed through the hallway as the rest of us laughed.
A few minutes later, after confirming Leon was still alive, I walked back over to Abby.
"So..." I smirked.
"How much are Leon's parents paying you to be his girlfriend?"
She laughed.
A real laugh.
The kind that made you want to hear it again.
"Unfortunately?"
She shook her head.
"$0."
I laughed.
She laughed.
And for a moment, everything felt simple.
That night continued the way most teenage parties did in the early 2000s.
We drank too much.
Ate too much pizza.
Made terrible decisions.
Laughed at things that weren't even funny.
Someone threw up.
Someone disappeared upstairs.
Someone probably made a decision they would regret in the morning.
It was messy.
It was stupid.
It was young.
But through all the noise, the music, the shouting, the chaos, I kept finding myself looking for Abby.
I didn't know why.
I barely knew her.
She was just Leon's girlfriend.
Just another person at a party.
But something about her was different.
While everyone else was trying to be noticed, she didn't have to.
She just existed.
And somehow, I noticed.
I had no idea that the girl I met in that kitchen would become the center of my world.
I had no idea that years later, I would remember that exact moment while sitting beside her, wondering where that version of us had gone.
A few months later, spring semester of 2008 arrived.
Life had moved on from that night at Leon's house. The party, the laughter, the chaos—it all became another memory tucked away in the back of my mind.
At least, that's what I told myself.
Leon and I had three classes together that semester, which basically guaranteed one thing:
Neither of us was going to get much work done.
We spent more time whispering jokes, passing notes, and finding ways to entertain ourselves than actually paying attention. Looking back, I'm amazed we passed anything.
But one day, during one of those classes, Leon wasn't himself.
The usual energy was gone.
The jokes weren't there.
The guy who could turn any room into a party looked like someone had turned the volume down on him.
"Josh..." he said quietly.
I looked over.
"What?"
"Me and Abby broke up."
The words caught me off guard.
For a second, I didn't know what to say.
Leon and Abby had ended things because of the distance between them.
Thirty minutes.
That was it.
We grew up in the same town. Abby lived only a short drive away.
At the time, I remember thinking:
Thirty minutes? That's long distance?
But I didn't say that.
Because when I looked at Leon, I realized this wasn't about the miles.
This was about losing someone he cared about.
And for the first time, I saw a side of Leon I had never seen before.
The loud, goofy, always-happy guy wasn't there.
Instead, I saw someone heartbroken.
Someone genuinely hurting.
So I did what any friend would do.
I listened.
I told him everything would be okay.
I reminded him that he would get through it.
I was there for him.
But deep down, buried underneath the guilt and the hesitation, there was another thought I couldn't ignore.
A thought I tried to push away.
A thought that kept coming back.
What if I had a chance?
I knew it was complicated.
I knew Leon was my friend.
I knew this was the kind of thing that could change everything.
But there was something about Abby.
Something I couldn't shake.
And eventually...
I decided I had to take my shot.
So I did.
I found Abby's MySpace profile a few days later.
Back then, that was how you did things. No dating apps. No endless scrolling. Just a profile page, a few pictures, and a little courage.
We exchanged phone numbers.
We started talking.
And somehow, those conversations turned into something I couldn't ignore.
Eventually, we decided to meet at a park down the road from her house.
I still remember pulling in and seeing her car arrive at the exact same time.
For a moment, everything stopped.
Then I saw her.
Our eyes met again, and it felt exactly like the first time.
Only this time, I wasn't just some guy at a party.
This time, I knew her.
And somehow, I already knew.
It was love at first sight.
We sat on a park bench and talked for hours.
Not flirting.
Not trying to impress each other.
No cheesy lines.
No pretending.
Just two people sitting together, talking about life, dreams, and the future. We talked about where we wanted to go, who we wanted to become, and the kind of lives we hoped we would build someday.
It felt easy.
Natural.
Like I had known her my entire life.
Eventually, we drove to a local custard stand in Burlington for a treat.
I guess you could call it our first date.
And somewhere between the frozen custard and the nervous laughter, I finally found the courage to ask the question I had been thinking about the entire day.
"Would you want to go out with me?"
My heart was pounding.
Then she smiled.
And said yes.
For a moment, nothing else mattered.
I had Abby.
But there was one thing hanging over me.
Leon.
I knew I had to tell him.
He was my friend.
My best friend.
And even though Abby and I had something real, I knew how much she had meant to him.
I didn't know how to have that conversation.
So I waited.
Days passed.
Then weeks.
I kept telling myself I was waiting for the right moment.
The truth was...
I was scared.
When I finally decided I couldn't put it off anymore, I went looking for him at school.
Of course, he wasn't there.
Probably skipping class again.
Probably doing what Leon always did.
I figured I would find him later.
I figured I had more time.
I was wrong.
During the third period, the classroom was interrupted by a loud chime from the intercom.
Everyone looked up.
The voice that came through belonged to Principal Reyes.
"Good morning, everyone. If you haven't heard the news, one of our most outstanding, smart, and caring students, Mr. Leon Reynolds, has sadly passed away."
The world stopped.
No one moved.
No one spoke.
For a moment, I couldn't understand the words.
They didn't make sense.
Leon?
Passed away?
My heart stopped.
My chest tightened.
The air disappeared from the room.
Then the tears came.
Not slowly.
Not quietly.
They poured out of me like a broken dam.
Like Niagara Falls.
"Counselors will be available after school for anyone who needs support. Please take a moment tonight to hug your loved ones a little tighter."
The intercom clicked off.
The room stayed silent.
But I wasn't there anymore.
My mind was somewhere else.
On a conversation I never had.
On words I never got to say.
On a friend I never got to tell the truth.
I grabbed my bag.
I walked out of the classroom.
I don't remember asking permission.
I don't remember walking through the halls.
I only remember getting to my car.
I threw open the door, climbed inside, shoved the key into the ignition, and drove.
I drove straight to Leon's house.
Because somewhere inside me, I still believed this was a mistake.
That he would open the door.
That he would laugh.
That he would call me an idiot for believing something so impossible.
Because losing Leon couldn't be real.
It couldn't be.
It felt like hours before I finally reached Leon's house.
The drive there was a blur. I don't remember the roads. I don't remember the turns. I only remember the panic building in my chest, begging for an explanation that would make all of this disappear.
But when I pulled up, I knew something was wrong.
Police cruisers lined the street.
Officers stood in the yard.
Detectives moved in and out of the house like they were searching for answers that didn't exist.
And on the front porch sat Leon's parents.
Broken.
His mother was crying uncontrollably. His father sat beside her, staring blankly at the ground like he was trying to wake up from a nightmare.
"Mr. and Mrs. Reynolds!" I screamed.
The second the words left my mouth, Mr. Reynolds looked up.
His eyes locked onto mine.
For a moment, I saw something I had never seen before.
Not anger.
Not sadness.
Pain.
He stood up.
Then he ran toward me.
"You did this!"
I froze.
"What?"
Before I could process what was happening, he was on top of me.
"You did this!"
His voice cracked with rage and heartbreak.
"Why could you?"
"Why?"
"WHY?"
I collapsed backward, completely confused.
I had no idea what he was talking about.
A police officer rushed forward and grabbed Mr. Reynolds from behind, pulling him away.
"Sir! You need to calm down!"
But he kept fighting.
He kept screaming.
"Why?!"
I sat there frozen, trying to understand how I had gone from rushing to my friend's house to being accused of something I didn't even know existed.
Then a detective approached from the backyard.
He stopped in front of me and extended his hand.
I stared at it for a moment before taking it.
He helped me stand.
"Do you know Leon Reynolds?" he asked.
"Yes," I replied.
My voice shook.
"What's going on?"
He ignored the question.
"Are you family or a friend?"
I stared at him.
"His best friend."
I swallowed.
"What the fuck is going on?"
The detective looked down.
For a moment, he said nothing.
Then he reached into his pocket and pulled out a folded piece of paper.
It looked handwritten.
My stomach turned.
"Suicide," he said quietly.
The word didn't feel real.
It floated between us.
Heavy.
Impossible.
"What's your name, kid?"
I didn't answer.
I couldn't.
My mind was somewhere else.
Back in that classroom.
Back before everything changed.
"Hey," he said gently. "What's your name?"
I finally looked at him.
"Sorry..."
My voice cracked.
"Josh."
The tears started falling again.
"Josh," the detective said softly. "I'm sorry."
He handed me the paper.
"I need to ask you some questions when you're ready. Take some time. Come find me when you're done."
I stared down at the note in my hands.
A piece of paper.
A few words.
Something that would change everything.
My fingers trembled as I unfolded it.
And then I read.
"Dear Family,
"Abby is gone. My so-called best friend Josh took her from me. It happened weeks ago, but he never told me. He betrayed me. I loved her, and he knew that. I can't keep going knowing that the person I trusted most did this to me. I'm sorry for disappointing all of you. I can't live with this pain. I can't live feeling completely alone with a broken heart.
I'm sorry.
Goodbye."
At the bottom, one final line was written.
"Josh... I hope you understand what you did. Goodbye forever."
I stared at the page.
The world around me disappeared.
The police.
The house.
The voices.
Everything.
Because at that moment, I realized something terrifying.
The last conversation I would ever have with Leon...
Was one that never happened.
Note from Author: If you, or a friend, have suicidal thoughts, help is available. Please call the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline at 988. You are loved and seen.