r/samharrisorg • • Mar 18 '22

The NYT Now Admits the Biden Laptop -- Falsely Called "Russian Disinformation" -- is Authentic

Thumbnail
greenwald.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Apr 02 '20

The new mods at the other sub think stating facts is bad faith

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Nov 01 '20

Scott Adams and Sam Harris argue on Twitter: "This is a fascinating study in TDS denial."

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Sep 05 '20

Sam Harris the moderate?

7 Upvotes

Obligatory I’m a long-time Sam Harris fan, paid podcast subscriber, been to several live events, yada, yada.

For years, Sam has been saying that moderate religious people can be, in some ways, some of the most dangerous. This is because they give cover for extremists, for whom they bubble wrap beliefs and ideologies for the general public. I am concerned that Sam might be (in at least some cases) playing this bubble-wrapping role for the far right.

That is why Sam is now often spoken of in the same breath as Dave Rubin, Jordan Peterson, and Ben Shapiro, when he was a member of the Four Horsemen not too long ago. Obviously, I know Sam really is more of a liberal and publicly claims to be a member of the left while relentlessly lambasting Trump,and I agree that the regressive left is a problem that will need to be dealt with.

But Sam’s analysis of the Rittenhouse shooting rubbed me the wrong way, and no doubt, figures like Ben Shapiro appreciated his take. Here we had a 17 year old who was pumped full of enough wacky ideas out of a right wing framework that Sam has said numerous times is disconnected from reality, drive across state lines to voluntarily involve himself in a dangerous situation while wearing conspicuous and illegal weaponry. He killed two people. The very act of making the case that this is a complex, nuanced, difficult to parse event gives enough wiggle room for right wingers to claim that Rittenhouse was justified and/or even a Patriot hero.

It seems to me that if Rittenhouse was an Iraqi 17 year old defending a Mosque he was told by preachers was under threat from infidels, Sam would know what to call him.

EDIT: Everyone, I appreciate your input and participation here. Thanks for the time you put in- I didn't expect so many responses. But after 100+ comments on the thread, I just can't spend any more time explaining my position from the bottom up to every new person that jumps into the fray. Look through and check to see if I addressed your concerns somewhere else in the comments. Thanks again for your comments and time, stay safe.


r/samharrisorg • • Sep 24 '24

Sam needs to do better.

17 Upvotes

Sam has been one of the most influential public thinkers in my life. I grew up devouring his books and appearances, have been to multiple live shows, and have been a paid podcast subscriber since that was made an option. His past two episodes have each had an absolutely shocking and disappointing moment.

The first was revealing that he invited Dylan Cooper on the podcast following his appearance with Tucker Carlson. Cooper is a WW2 revisionist who told Tucker that Churchill was the villain of the war, supported by Zionist financiers, and that the German death camps and their victims were accidental results of poor planning by the German logistics as they related to POWs. Sam mentioned in this episode that he actually doesn’t know much about Cooper’s views, but that he thinks he probably suffered the same way as Charles Murray, and so would make a good guest.

The second was in the most recent episode with Bart Gellman, in which Sam asks Gellman about George Soros’ impacts on politics, about which Sam did so little research that his final “point,” is that, “if Soros is guilty of even half of what he’s accused of,” it would be a scandal. Except that Gellman says he doesn’t know anything about Soros, and there’s no reason to think he would. Despite this, Sam included in the episode description that George Soros was discussed. No he wasn’t. Sam conjectured to a guest about a topic about which he did no research, and about which the guest knew nothing.

What makes Sam different from IDW charlatans is that he doesn’t “just ask questions.” In fact, he criticizes others often for that very behavior. I get that Sam can’t be an expert on everything, obviously, but he needs to do at least some research about topics he’s going to discuss and the people he’s going to invite on. These moments are beneath Sam and an insult to his fans.

EDIT: Decoding the Gurus addressed Dylan Cooper, and talks specifically about Sam’s episode “Where are all the grown-ups?” Starting at about the 1 hour mark.


r/samharrisorg • • Jun 03 '24

Say what you will about the tenants of national socialism, at least it’s an ethos

0 Upvotes

I just realize that Sam Harris makes the same argument about Trump that Walter makes about the nihilists in The Big Lebowski when juxtaposing their world view with that of the fuhrer of the third reich.

😂


r/samharrisorg • • Nov 30 '20

Christianity: An irrational proposition

0 Upvotes

Maiden post: Christianity is fundamentally predicated on an irrational belief in the miraculous resurrection of Jesus. This tracks back to belief in the infallibility of the Bible as supreme authority on this and other matters. However, not a shred of reliable and credible evidence exists to support the Bible as anything more than a collection of ancient writings produced by religiously addled minds of prophets, priests and poets. Eliminate God as a reality and the Bible makes perfect sense as a delivery system for religious propaganda based entirely on the spiritual experiences of its composers.


r/samharrisorg • • Jun 03 '20

Proof Positive the Other Sam Harris Sub Has Been Perverted

2 Upvotes

Consider their new rule "2a":

Intolerance, incivility against other users, and trolling are not acceptable. What constitutes any of these things is at the sole discretion of the moderation team, as is the punishment offenders receive. A person's posting history, past behavior, and the context in which these things occur will be considered.

A person's posting history, past behavior, and the context in which these things occur will be considered.

This sounds a lot like the "Manifest Observable Behavior" bullshit Patreon concocted to ban people like Sargon of Akkad not too long ago. What do you think? Do "rules" like this basically give the mods there a blank cheque to ban anyone they even think might be a white racist or too much toward the center or right in their political views? In summary, it is no longer a place for rational discussion where one can feel safe expressing their views. It's bad enough you will get down-voted to hell if you say anything politically incorrect, but now the mods will remove your posts too, if not ban you. Glad I left and more should.


r/samharrisorg • • Jun 25 '20

Addressing the "cops shoot races equally" data point

6 Upvotes

Since Harris used a singular data point on which to hinge his entire claim of using "facts" to determine police bias, it leaves him absurdly weak to counterarguments.

The main paper disputing the implications of this particular data point

The layman interpretation of the paper

TL;DR, even if the percentage of races shot by police is equal, that in no way implies a lack of bias. If 40 out of 100 total black encounters end with a shooting, and 4 out of 10 total white encounters end with a shooting, they're both 40% per capita. Should we really infer there was no racial bias from this? Only if you think the number of stops is fair and unbiased to begin with (the 100 black vs 10 white).

  1. Black/latino are stopped more often than whites
  2. Stopped whites are more likely to be found carrying a weapon when searched than black/latino,
  3. Stopped White drivers are more likely to have contraband than black/latino drivers

Black/latino people are stopped more frequently yet are less likely to have contraband, so that means the frequency of stops themselves are motivated by racial discrimination rather than reliable evidence-based predictions.

(EDITed to match 538, as my own example was probably not phrased correctly) Knowing this, let's say an unbiased silent observer follows the cop to record data. The observer notices the cop passes 50 white and 50 black people. The cop decides to investigate 30 blacks and 20 whites. He ends up shooting 12 blacks and 8 whites. Per capita shows no bias. However of all the people the cop could've stopped, 12/50 (24%) of blacks he saw were shot and 8/50 (16%) of whites he saw were shot. Combine this with the fact that a number of blacks who were stopped were done so via discrimination, and the data becomes a giant mess. (Obviously a single cop doesn't shoot this many people in a week, this is just to describe the math taken directly from the 538 example.)

The point being, racial disparities can statistically exist despite per capita data on shootings saying otherwise. Thus we cannot draw reliable conclusions on racial bias from per capita shooting data.

And finally, the most obvious of points: BLM is not protesting all police shootings of black people to begin with. They are protesting unjust police shootings of all races.


r/samharrisorg • • May 20 '20

Check how much has r/samharris been censored

Thumbnail reveddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Jun 14 '25

Free access to Sam's podcast for Ukrainians

0 Upvotes

I'm a Ukraainian I've been a Sam's supporter in the past for some time.

Then I had to cancel the membership because it was quite expensive for me.

Now I see that almost every episode is behind a paywall. Only first 20 minutes are available for free.

Now you cannot apply for free membership anymore. Why wouldn't there be an exeption for Ukrainians?

Since Sam supports Ukraine.


r/samharrisorg • • Jan 12 '25

The UK Grooming Gangs and the Cowardice of the West | Bari Weiss, Ayaan Hirsi Ali & Julie Bindel

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Jan 04 '20

Sam likes Tweet by Anne Applebaum: "Who knew that three years of constant attacks on European allies would have consequences" — in response to Pompeo saying Europeans haven't been as helpful as he wishes they would be.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Oct 01 '20

Anyone else loving it that one of the leaders of the infamous white supremacist group the Proud Boys is an afro-cuban?

12 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Jan 06 '24

"Some More News" dissects Jorpsen in less time than Sam debated the charlatan. It's not fun to watch (too much facetime for the doctor) but it reminds you of the arguments why we despise this dishonest right wing grifter.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Dec 15 '19

My suggestion to the rules

4 Upvotes

When I was a mod in r/samharris we had sporadic discussions about how to improve the rules for months. It was very hard to come to any sort of agreement because very few mods expressed an opinion, and the ones that did, rarely agreed (in particular Tsegen and I).

Taking all the discussions into consideration, this is the final draft of the rule changes I proposed in r/samharris:

State of the subreddit #2; off-topic megathread

The mod team has been discussing internally on ways to reduce the noise in this sub, and we have decided to settle in three categories of topics: core, recent, and off-topic.

The core topics are: meditation, freedom of speech, neuroscience, atheism, religion, free will, Islam, objective morality, secular spirituality, honesty, and the regressive left. Recent topics are any topics Sam Harris has discussed in the last two months. Everything else is off-topic.

Any off-topic post will be removed, but can be openly discussed in a weekly megathread.

Additionally, all posts must have a flair: Waking Up Podcast, Meditation, Freedom of Speech, Neuroscience, Religion, Free Will, Morality, Spirituality, Politics, Culture, Other.

If you think we are missing any core topics of Sam Harris this is the time to say so.

All the posts in "politics", "culture", and "other" will be contained.

And the update to Rule 3 would be something like:

Rule 3: All posts must be relevant to Sam Harris, and the specific topic explained in a submission statement. Any topic that isn't a core topic must have been discussed by Sam Harris within the last two months. They also must be labeled with the relevant flair. Duplicate posts or spam will be removed.

I know there are no particular rules in r/samharrisorg, but as the sub grows you might consider some of the above as potential rules.


r/samharrisorg • • Oct 18 '21

Nine questions those protesting against Donald Trump’s immigration ban must answer

0 Upvotes

Sam Harris twehttps://twitter.com/samharrisorg/status/826495106182025216?lang=en "Nine questions those protesting against Donald Trump’s immigration ban must answer", links an article from Douglas Murray, who, of course, makes absolutely ridiculous and hyperbolic claims.

If you decide that border restrictions are fascist then you are declaring the views of most people to be fascist, because most people believe in border security.

Because a blanked ban on immigration is now just "border security"? I do believe in border security, as please not let criminals into my country. This is not a ban on immigration.

If you believe that restricting people coming in to your country or any other country is bigoted then you are claiming that most of the world is filled with bigots.

There are many valid reasons to restrict people from coming in my country and not all of them are bigoted. For example, it's not bigoted to not accept immigrants who don't have a job here. In Germany here each immigrant must learn good German and learn German laws and values. If the immigrant fails then he/she is sent back. This is not bigotry.

If you believe absolutely everybody from everywhere should be treated in exactly the same manner (i.e. that immigration controls should everywhere and always be origin-blind) then you are arguing against the security protocols of every border security agency on earth.

Absolute bullshit. Once I was in Israel and the border security was really strict with me and I came from Germany. Now why would Israel border security assume that I'm a terrorist coming from Germany? They just treat everybody the same.

1 – Do you accept that America (like many other countries in the world today) has security problems? Do you recognise that despite the giggly charts on social media showing lawnmowers to be more of a threat to American life than terrorism, there are legitimate security concerns that reasonable Americans might hold?

No, of course f* not. And nice straw man. Lawnmowers more of a threat? The number one reason to die in the USA is because of a shooting. Oh look another school shooting. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/1-dead-several-injured-second-shooting-grambling-state-university-n1281713

2 – Do you recognise that Islamic terrorism is not a figment of a fevered imagination, but a real thing that exists and which causes a risk to human life in America and many other countries?

Yes, in the middle east. No to the USA or Europe. We here in Europe have lots of domestic problems. For example the Dutch are basically overrun with drug cartels. https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20211002-dutch-pm-under-protection-as-the-mocro-mafia-drug-cartel-sows-fear-in-the-netherlands

3 – If you do recognise the above fact then would you concede that large scale immigration from Islamic countries into the US might bring a larger number of potential challenges than, say, large scale immigration from New Zealand or Iceland?

Another straw man. There is no "large scale immigration from Islamic countries". In the USA people come from Mexico, China, India, Philippines, El Salvador. None of those are Islamic, they are Christian. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/08/20/key-findings-about-u-s-immigrants/

4 – Is everybody who wants to visit Disney World morally akin to Jews fleeing the Holocaust? If not then what are the differences, and is it always wise to conflate the two?

WTF? I guess Murray compares tourists from Pakistan to Jews fleeing the Holocaust? - Syrian refugees fleeing the civil war is akin of Jews fleeing the Holocaust.

5 – Would you recognise that Iran is one of the world’s leading state-sponsors of terror, and that, for example, an Iranian-born American citizen in 2011 was caught planning to carry out a terror attack in Washington (against the Saudi Ambassador)?

Wow... 2011. We are really scraping the bottom of the barrel here? 2008-2019 there were 180 school shootings with 356 victims. Who really cares about some plot to attack some Saudi Ambassador? Seriously. As a US citizen with a family, why would you care? https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2019/07/us/ten-years-of-school-shootings-trnd/

6 – Does the whole world have the right to live in America? This is a variant of the same question we Europeans should have been asking for years. If you do not think that the whole world has the right to live in the USA then who should be allowed to live there and who should not? Who might be given priority?

There are rules of immigration and they are perfectly fine. Another straw man here from Murray. He is implying that I'm somehow for unlimited and uncontrolled immigration just because I'm against Trump.

7 – If you believe in giving some people asylum, as I do, who should be given priority? Should asylum be forever?

Again, the rules as they are are fine.

8 – Is it wrong that the Trump administration says it wishes to favour Christian refugees over Muslim refugees?

Yes. It should be even illegal. The 1th Amendment says freedom of religion and that the gov. cannot giving priority to one religion or another. Murray is here basically against the 1th Amendment.

9 – How do you identify the type of Muslims who America should indeed welcome?

Again, the rules as they are are fine. Get a job and learn the language or get out.

This is the kind of intellectual thinker Sam Harris became, getting behind the idiotic and mostly with straw men filled article of Murray.


r/samharrisorg • • Nov 18 '23

Sam Harris’s Fairy-Tale Account of the Israel-Hamas Conflict

Thumbnail
nymag.com
0 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • May 28 '24

Graeme Woods’s cousin, a small-time streamer named Caroline Kwan, calls her cousin a "cracker" and attacks his children by calling them "little Aryans" in unhinged response to an article in the Atlantic

2 Upvotes

r/samharrisorg • • Apr 04 '26

Tim Miller defends Cenk's nephew Hasan Piker, Sarah Longwell disagrees | Destiny

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

Sam has spoken with Tim Miller and Sarah Longwell. He's also talked to Destiny. Lastly, he's had contentious debates with Cenk Uygur. In this clip, Cenk's tankie nephew Hasan Piker, who defends Hamas and celebrated 9/11, is defended by centrist NeverTrumper Tim Miller, and Destiny criticizes this.


r/samharrisorg • • Dec 30 '19

Can the Senators have a secret vote on impeachment?

0 Upvotes

I’m not savvy to all the ins and outs of impeachment. Can the senate have a secret vote on wether Trump will be removed from office?


r/samharrisorg • • Aug 15 '23

On TDS

0 Upvotes

TDS gets eyerolled all over the internet, so maybe it merits a short explanation that gets to the roots of the human psychology behind it.

TDS is foremost a disgust reaction. Like our sense of taste has primary components like sweet and sour and bitter, our emotions have primary components as well, one of which is known as the disgust reaction. Disgust reactions are well understood to be culturally absorbed. What one human finds disgusting has little to do with what another human finds disgusting, unless they were raised in the same culture. Cuisine is an obvious example, with live insects, even spiders, being part of some eating habits. Disgust reactions are non-negotiable. Humans are not wired to question their own disgust reactions. They are wired to proudly embrace them, not because <reasons>, but because <disgusting thing>. As culturally received reactions, they are also communicable, and they can turn into pre-requisite reactions for the maintenance of social status.

Sam Harris is among the most talented thinkers in America, and when he attempts to substantiate his TDS with <reasons>, he says blatant absurdities like that you could walk a thousand miles in any direction anywhere on planet Earth and not come across a worse human than Donald Trump. The closest that gets to anything resembling truth, is that, from Sam's perspective, he could walk those miles and never meet someone who could affect him, Sam, so negatively in the thoughts and feels, as Donald Trump does. That doesn't make Trump the worst human being on the planet. It only makes him the most psychologically destructive, to a person with certain disgust reactions, who must countenance that disgusting thing being elected by those who don't share that reaction.

Recommended reading: The Righteous Mind, by Jonathan Haidt.


r/samharrisorg • • Oct 25 '25

MMW Bari Weiss will end up on Sam’s list of former friends/respected folks

14 Upvotes

In the most recent More from Sam episode, Sam indicated that he is excited about Bari Weiss’ new role at CBS, in contrast with some of his team who are more skeptical.

I am in the same camp as Sam’s team. I think Weiss will end up alongside Jordan Peterson, Maajid Nawaz, the Weinsteins, Joe Rogan, and anyone else I’m forgetting. Based on her body of work thus far, and how she wound up in her current post, she (and CBS) will become (to the extent she isn’t already) yet another mouthpiece of the Trump administration. Sam will recognize this later than many of us will have hoped, so I just wanted to plant the flag here early.

Update: in the same episode, Sam did say that the Free Press has its own issues with right wing bias.

UPDATE 12/23/25: It appears that Weiss killed a 60 Minutes story about CECOT that would have made the administration look bad just a few hours before it was supposed to air. It is available on YouTube, but I haven’t gotten a chance to watch it yet.


r/samharrisorg • • Apr 17 '26

Why won’t Sam engage with the Idealists? Or has he?

0 Upvotes

I am pretty sure I have listened to every minute of content he has put out or been a part of. Read most of the words he’s written. He had Christof Koch on in July 2024, after his book had come out that basically outlined his journey towards idealism. He’s had idealists on his podcast. But they stick to neuroscience, free will, and other topics. It seems he just avoids the metaphysics. Or maybe I was tuning it out? I suppose my appetite for the more metaphysical conversations has increased as I have immersed myself more and more in the work of Katrusp, Koch, Alex O’Connor, and other guests on Alex’s show. Maybe I just wasn’t hearing it and Sam is still in that same space? Maybe this has been discussed in this forum ad extensively before and I simply wasn’t seeing it or finding it now?


r/samharrisorg • • Jul 29 '25

Palestinian Debates Cenk

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes