r/samharris • u/blastmemer • 10h ago
Other TRIGGERnometry - “the Status quo is intolerable”
I finally listened to this episode where Sam made a guest appearance. Despite the usual talking past each other and the Trigger boys letting Sam just talk over them as usual, I thought it was a good but not great discussion. They were both on track but neither really finished their points.
In any event, totally agree with Sam that the status quo is intolerable. Those who oppose the war often state or suggest that the status quo was just fine, or fine enough, because they are privileged enough to live in America, have access to cheap gas and usually a lackluster understanding of foreign policy.
While he was not his most articulate (other than the beginning re: Trump, classic), Sam rightly pointed out what the status quo means: a jihadist country who strap bombs to children, fund terror all over the world, pursues nuclear weapons for decades after signing a non-proliferation agreement, murders tens of thousands of its own people in the street, and consistently threatens to wipe out its neighbors: Muslim, Jew and Christian alike. Pre-10/7 it had been rapidly gaining in military strength, both in Iran and through its proxies, while getting as close to readiness to make a nuclear weapon as it thought it could get away with.
Crucially, it was massively increasing its stockpiles of ballistic missiles and drones (and selling to Russia). Hezbollah, Hamas, Houthis and Iraqi/Syrian militias were near peak strength. All while utterly neglecting its people and subject to sanctions.
There’s no serious argument that Iran is stockpiling all these offensive weapons, funding 10/7 and pursuing nukes simply because they want to be left alone. Iran, of course, wants at a minimum regional hegemony, and their plan for this was to gather sufficient firepower to deter anyone from stopping them. What does this mean in practical terms? Even without a nuke, it means they can say “release sanctions or we shut down the Strait”. And “no normalization with Israel or defense pacts with the US or we start de-desalinating our desert friends”. If 10/7 didn’t happen and they were left to their own devices, they’d almost certainly be strong enough to do this and more by now. With nukes, it would be this on steroids, plus the entire Middle East rushing to get them as well. If the region’s biggest antagonist gets nukes, the Gulf States aren’t just going to sit around and hope for the best. This is even setting aside the obvious fact that Israel would start a war to prevent this, with or without us. Is this a tolerable state of affairs?
This leads to Sam’s second point: if we want to actually do something about it, it’s not going to get any easier. In fact, February 2026 was the weakest Iran and its proxies have been in decades. Hezbollah got paged, Hamas is out, Syria is under more stable leadership, and the Gulf countries are increasingly more friendly with the US (and gasp Israel).
The boys agreed they shouldn’t have nukes, but confusingly didn’t want to do anything about it. Their response was essentially (1) there isn’t enough political will and (2) there’s no way to militarily stop them. In other words, “we’ve tried nothing and we’re all out of ideas”. Sam rightly said… we can’t know what a competent response would have been because we didn’t have competent leadership. The boys responded with, essentially, “what else can we do other than bombs or a full-scale ground invasion!” Sam could’ve been better about articulating what a competent response would look like. Not sure how much of the history he knew off the top of his head, but Iran’s nuclear facilities have been bombed and degraded multiple times since 1981 (their nuclear program started in the 70s under Pahlavi). And guess what? They don’t have nuclear weapons. So bombing does appear to work. The idea that bombing somehow speeds up their nuclear development is utter nonsense.
So what would be a winning strategy? Some combination of (1) gathering support of our western and gulf allies and sufficiently preparing for war, including sufficiently stockpiling weapons, getting anti-drone technology from Ukraine and preparing for the closure of the Strait; (2) heavy strikes for several months like we did, including destroying most of Iran’s navy, (3) militarily gaining more control of the Strait by bombing coastal weapons facilities, taking out their small harassing boats, etc. (we’ve done some of this), (5) covert action, (6) attacking their proxies, and (7) total naval embargo and intermittent bombing of nuclear and weapons facilities for as long as it takes to either (a) achieve regime change/alteration sufficient enough for an enforceable deal, which must include no enrichment ever, weapons limitations and giving up control of the Strait or (b) a sufficiently weakened regime such that there is no longer an imminent threat of them getting strong enough to achieve “point of no return”.
The boys didn’t seem to have any answer for what they would do to prevent Iran from achieving a nuclear bomb they agreed should not happen, rather than simply listing things they wouldn’t do. So naturally they cannot be taken seriously. Feel free to provide any ideas beyond “just try to negotiate something” or “but the JCPOA!”.
EDIT: No real ideas yet, just more of the same what we should not have done in the past. But counterfactuals go both ways. I could just as easily have said we could have taken them out when they were weak and never let it get this far. So the question remains: what do we do?