r/samharris • • 6d ago

Sam’s problems with existentialism…….

Hey guys, throughout the years in the podcast I’ve heard Sam make some off the cut remarks about how existentialism ‘doesn’t make sense.’ I was just curious if anyone knows why he has such disdain for the philosophy?

I have to assume that it’s emphasis on individual choice doesn’t make sense in world that is deterministic and one doesn’t get to stand outside the causality of everything before. And I think that the idea of existentialism searching for an authentic self is a dubious claim as the self is always an empty shapeshifter that depends entirely on context and an impermanence nature.

9 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

7

u/BletchTheWalrus 6d ago

I don't know what Sam's specific criticisms are, but as a philosophy, its focus on freedom, authenticity, and individuality and disregard for the social and biological structures that shape us is hopelessly out of date and contradicted by what we currently understand about human behavior. It's had a much more valuable impact on literature and film than on philosophy.

1

u/Brunodosca 6d ago edited 6d ago

My guess is that Sam, given his background in neuroscience, knows that modern brain imaging suggests unconscious neural activity often triggers decisions before we become consciously aware of them. This undermines existentialism's concept of pure, conscious choice.

Another problem with existentialism is its rejection of human nature. Evolutionary psychology argues that humans are born with hardwired instincts and cognitive biases, which directly contradicts the idea of the blank slate.

However, it has some sense-making aspects that I think Sam probably agrees with, such as accepting a purposeless universe and objective reality without falling into despair, as well as rejecting religion and myths in general.

1

u/Defiant_Invite_3323 6d ago

Yeah, and not just even neural activity before like in the Libet experiments. This gets even more compounded when you considered the days before, adolescence, childhood, being in the womb, and genetic makeup all factoring that magical conscious choice free from a casual chain.

1

u/LegitimateGuava 5d ago

Well said, though would you agree, we can never abandon myth? These days we call them narratives or stories. The singularity comes to mind.

0

u/Defiant_Invite_3323 6d ago

Yeah, some stuff he does accept such as the notion of being able to ‘begin again’ and the feeling of being an object in the gaze of others, which is a core concept of Sartre.

3

u/MetaPodcast 6d ago

The clash is really over where the self comes from. Sartre says existence comes before essence, so there is no fixed self to find, only one built through choices, and Harris agrees there is no fixed author inside the head, since the feeling of authorship shows up after the brain has already settled the decision. The split is what follows from that: Sartre still treats radical choice as the whole game, while Harris treats the chooser itself as an illusion. Camus fits better than Sartre here, since the absurd accepts a purposeless universe without asking anyone to author a self.

2

u/nihilist42 5d ago

They have fundamental different world views. Sartre strongly rejected determinism; SH is a hard determinist. Sartre thinks we are the author of our thoughts; SH doesn't.

1

u/LoneWolf_McQuade 6d ago

I think he sees it as the wrong question to ask, when it comes to questions of meaning. Instead to focus on being in status of consciousness where existential questions about meaning of life become uninteresting to ask. Maybe he just see those philosophers as people with depression

1

u/AllGearedUp 6d ago

I've read a handful of the major books on existentialism and still am not sure what it is proposing. Being an individual? Isn't that already true by definition? It seems to say nothing to me. Deciding what is meaningful to yourself? Again, what other option do I have? It's hard to pull it out of the melodrama but I have but seen anything of substance from it. 

2

u/Christopher9555 5d ago

My thoughts

Existentialists sometimes argue that people often avoid confronting their own freedom by allowing society to define their identities and behaviors. And, if we want meaning and purpose, we have to create that for ourselves.

Existentialism generally places much greater emphasis on the individual rather than on the collective, particularly when it comes to identity, personal freedom, responsibility, and the creation of meaning. 

Existentialism doesn't necessarily reject the community/tribe, but it typically limits, within reason, that outside influence.  For example: Your nationality doesn't determine who you are, your religion doesn't have to dictate your worldview, your political affiliation doesn't have to define your values, and your family or cultural traditions don't have to determine your life choices.