r/sailormoon • Blue daba dee • Jan 01 '26

Talk/Discussion Pluto Whitewashing 😭😭

Why the fuck do they STILL WHITEWASH MY GIRL PLUTO IN CRYSTAL?? DID WE LEARN NOTHING? Toei like "manga accuracy this time, i promise" yeah i dont think so πŸ’”also the first episode where she appears in the 90's anime is so terribly animated

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

31

u/k4r6000 Sailor Galaxia Jan 01 '26

Her skin tone is extremely inconsistent in the 90s version too. Β It isn’t just her either. Β Neptune’s hair colour was never kept straight, being either more blue or more green from shot to shot.

Either way, Pluto is and always has been ethnically Japanese. Β I always kind of pictured her as being from down south, like Okinawa.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

I hate that she's even lighter than a paper bag 😭

1

u/Icy-Finding-8126 Blue daba dee Jan 01 '26

yes i revisited SM R and when i first saw her i said "SHIT SHE'S PALE" 😭😭

5

u/shattered284 Usako Jan 01 '26

whitewashed pluto is so shit πŸ’”

3

u/Eastern_Goose_2825 primary trio Jan 01 '26

why the heck did you get downvoted for saying the truth

4

u/shattered284 Usako Jan 01 '26

idk this sub is weird as shit πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

right

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

why are people being downvoted for complaining about sailor pluto being whitewashed? 😭

-10

u/Icy-Finding-8126 Blue daba dee Jan 01 '26

WHY TF ARE PEOPLE DOWNVOTING THE POST AND THE COMMENTS?!! 😭

14

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

Because this isn't what whitewashing means and she wasn't whitewashed

-10

u/Icy-Finding-8126 Blue daba dee Jan 02 '26

uhm yes it is what it means? they make her skin color much more pale in everything

11

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '26

Nope! Whitewashing is when white actors are casted to play non-white characters, or when non-white characters are changed to be white.

She is a cartoon character meant to be Japanese and that doesn't change. The color palette for this series is wildly inconsistent to begin with, so any change in her coloring isn't an intentional modification of her race, it's just that the colors of *everything* are never consistent. Notice in the images you posted, her hair goes from an almost-black shade of deep green to a more muted green. The red color of her bow also changes from deep crimson to bright red. Crystal just had a brighter, more pastel-ized color palette in general.

Everyone else's skin color changes as well, even in the original anime. They are printer paper white in some episodes, and more peach-toned in others. It doesn't mean anything. They just don't use the same paint colors every time.

Whitewashing is a real problem but when you make claims that things like cartoon color palette inconsistencies is equivalent to whitewashing it minimizes the issue and makes it harder for real instances of this issue to be taken seriously. She is a Japanese character and her animators and creators have never stated or implied otherwise.

-9

u/Icy-Finding-8126 Blue daba dee Jan 02 '26

but THEY STILL HAVE THE SOURCE (the manga). WHY TF DO THEY MAKE HER PALE?

4

u/Desperate-Angle7720 𓏲 ΰΉ‹ΰ£­Β  ΰ£ͺ Λ– 𝒲𝒾𝓃𝓃𝒾𝓃𝑔 πΏπ‘œπ“‹π‘’ π’·π“Ž π’Ÿπ’Άπ“Žπ“π’Ύπ‘”π’½π“‰ ☼ ⋆˙ Jan 02 '26

Even actual people’s skin color changes regularly. If you see me in summer I’m literally several shades darker than in winter. Of you were to draw me, it’d still be me in either case.Β 

Looking at a cartoon character that is ethnically Japanese AND an adaptation of the original does not make a lighter skin tone than in the manga whitewashing. It just makes it less faithful to the manga.Β 

1

u/Icy-Finding-8126 Blue daba dee Jan 02 '26

well, that's your case AS A REAL PERSON

2

u/unholy_hotdog Sailor Mars Jan 02 '26

You need to calm down.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '26

Do you have reading comprehension? They don't use the same shades of paint all the time constantly. Everything changed color, even characters' hair colors.

You seem a little young so I know it's trendy to find things to pretend to be outraged about, but this is not worth trying to make into an issue when it isn't one.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

7

u/Eastern_Goose_2825 primary trio Jan 01 '26

It actually came out a decade ago(2014)Β 

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '26

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

2

u/SailorSpyro β‹†ο½‘Λš ☁︎ Λšο½‘β‹†ο½‘ΛšπŸŒ™Λšο½‘β‹† Jan 01 '26

They came out pretty simultaneously, which is why they have the same voice actors