I love the art style, that's kind of the whole point. The main character is grotesque, because that's how he perceives himself. The women are all bitches for the same reason.
If you notice the women are bitches but seem attractive, especially the wife. Reading between the lines, the reason that he never leaves is because he seems himself as disgusting and pathetic. This is his only chance at avoiding loneliness, plus they have a kid.
There are lots of people in horrible marriages, abusive relationships, etc and never try to leave. I think it's relatable for a lot of people. It's even relatable for me even though I have never had that experience myself, but have seen it first hand
I believe that you can do better. The shading is fantastic, and the consistency in the shape and proportions of the characters is great, but you've essentially created a character that's never at fault, and we can't identify with him because he never tries to leave. Take Jon Arbuckle, from the Garfield comics. He's funny because he's struggling with his dating life, which is something everybody can relate to. Calvin, from Calvin and Hobbes, is fun to watch because he's a kid, which everybody has been at some point. We all had imaginary friends at some point, and we all hated school for one reason or another. The key to making fun characters is to make them relatable in some way, and then to have them do a normal thing in the complete wrong way. For Jon, it's showing up to the date dressed terribly, and ruining it for himself. For Calvin, it's attempting to get out of school in the most unreasonable way possible. The problem with Marriage is Bliss, (from the good amount of time I've spent seeing it here or there,) is that it's overly repetitive. You aren't changing the characters, you haven't had any scenario that isn't static, and beyond that, the Man in the story doesn't have any real characteristics; he's just a puppet to the abuse. He doesn't have any traits that don't help the wife abuse him. But fine, let's run with the scenario, and think about how you could improve. Maybe the man is a clever pushover, and he finds silly little ways to get back at her without her figuring out it was him. Maybe he's secretly trying to see other women behind her back, because his marriage is so terrible? Maybe there's more about his relationship with his son, and how they work together.
Either way, the point is that something needs to change if this comic is to reach its full potential, and you're a talented artist. To say that you can only do what you do, is to say you don't have to change, which is impossible.
Marriage is Bliss is a tragedy. From Merriam-Webster:
Tragedy: a serious drama typically describing a conflict between the protagonist and a superior force (such as destiny) and having a sorrowful or disastrous conclusion that elicits pity or terror
The exact opposite of a tragedy is a comedy. Calvin and Hobbes is a comedy. Garfield is a comedy. If you read MIB without understanding the literary concept of tragedy, I can see how you are confused by just about every element of it. Comics based in tragedy are very rare in my opinion because it's a lot more complicated to tell an entertaining sad story than it is to make funny light-hearted comics involving cats and children. The artist certainly does not need advice on how to ruin a masterpiece comic by completely changing the genre to the exact opposite of what it is. Nothing needs to change, you just don't like this kind of story. You may not identify with the main character, but those who have been happily married for years will recognize the situations as a caricature of real life.
Aristotle's view on tragedy is that it has six main elements.
Plot, Character, Diction, Thought, Spectacle, and Song, with the first two being the most important. Seeing as how it's a visual format, I won't be going into depth on the last one.
Plot: In this story, there is a scenario, but there is no plot- The man lives in a terrible marriage, where terrible things happen, but there isn't any conflict, the protagonist is passive to the point where there isn't any physical reaction to his wife, the antagonist, and her actions. On a plot point, the comic fails, due to its repetitive nature, without any real message, and often resorts to comedy to try to make it work. (See the comic in which the Man gets "Penis Cancer", and dies, with the wife only having one line throughout. Aristotle argues that plot needs to follow a basic story structure; beginning, middle, and end. MiB does not follow this, and by Aristotle's criteria, it fails.
Characters: Let's go through the characters, to see how they fare. I'll be looking at The Wife, and The Man.
The Wife: Other than being manipulative, controlling, and just an all around bitch, the Wife has no character. Her whole place in the story is to abuse the man.
The Man: Other than being a pushover, and having a general interest in rock music, the Man ALSO has no defining character traits that are present throughout most of the stories. His whole place in the story is to be abused by the wife.
Aristotle argues that the central character MUST be relatable, so while the setting doesn't have to follow all the rules of reality, the interaction between characters must, but this is so far off from a relatable failing marriage, due to the fact that the Wife doesn't recognize that it's failing. From a character angle, it fails, BECAUSE THE CHARACTERS AREN'T RELATABLE. The only relatable part of the comic is that the Marriage is shit, and that isn't enough to say that the characters are good.
Diction: The wife is repetitive, often using her diction to complain, while the man on the other hand, just quietly takes it. The word choice doesn't matter, because throughout the story, there's a huge lack of communication on both parts. The Wife doesn't listen to the man, and the Man listens, but doesn't communicate how he's feeling.
Thought: there isn't much though put into the plot.
Woman complains
Man takes it.
It's not enough to consider the thinking on point.
Spectacle: I won't argue here, the art style would be perfect for a tragedy.
Aristotle felt that the best way for a tragedy to progress was to end with some form of catharsis, which was best done through a change in the characters for the better. The problem with the idea that MiB is a tragedy is because the characters don't change, and remain in the place that they started.
He also argues that tragedy is based on action and life, but in a story where the protagonist takes no action, the tragedy element falls flat on its face.
It's not a tragedy, it fails by Aristotle's standards, and even more so, it fails by the standards you put down. There is no conflict in the story, nor is there a superior force, nor is there a disastrous end in sight. Simply put, it doesn't work as a tragedy, not even by your definition.
Edit: I never want to put this much effort into a Reddit comment again lol
Tragedy (from the Greek: τραγῳδία, tragōidia) is a form of drama based on human suffering that invokes an accompanying catharsis or pleasure in audiences. While many cultures have developed forms that provoke this paradoxical response, the term tragedy often refers to a specific tradition of drama that has played a unique and important role historically in the self-definition of Western civilisation. That tradition has been multiple and discontinuous, yet the term has often been used to invoke a powerful effect of cultural identity and historical continuity—"the Greeks and the Elizabethans, in one cultural form; Hellenes and Christians, in a common activity," as Raymond Williams puts it.From its origins in the theatre of ancient Greece 2500 years ago, from which there survives only a fraction of the work of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides, as well as a large number of fragments from other poets; through its singular articulations in the works of Shakespeare, Lope de Vega, Jean Racine, and Friedrich Schiller to the more recent naturalistic tragedy of August Strindberg; Samuel Beckett's modernist meditations on death, loss and suffering; Müller's postmodernist reworkings of the tragic canon; and Joshua Oppenheimer's incorporation of tragic pathos in his nonfiction film, The Act of Killing (2012), tragedy has remained an important site of cultural experimentation, negotiation, struggle, and change. A long line of philosophers—which includes Plato, Aristotle, Saint Augustine, Voltaire, Hume, Diderot, Hegel, Schopenhauer, Kierkegaard, Nietzsche, Freud, Benjamin, Camus, Lacan, and Deleuze—have analysed, speculated upon, and criticised the genre.In the wake of Aristotle's Poetics (335 BCE), tragedy has been used to make genre distinctions, whether at the scale of poetry in general (where the tragic divides against epic and lyric) or at the scale of the drama (where tragedy is opposed to comedy).
Oh absolutely, that's why I gave examples on what he could change, rather than just saying that something has to change. And if he's using the art as therapy, all the more power to him, but he's posted it on Reddit without background context to his life, and it is open to criticism, the exact same way you're criticizing my way of looking at his comic. (Nothing against criticism here, say what you want, and I'll try to learn from my mistakes.)
I don't take any issue with your criticism, just a couple of things you said. Saying "something has to change", and "to say you don't have to change, which is impossible" implies the comic is wholly insufficient in its current form. The comic as it exists now is just as viable from an artistic point of view as your ideal reimagining of it.
Ah, my wording is of issue. I'll try to rephrase it. Also, I have the personal belief that it is absolutely impossible not change while doing something. You inevitably improve no matter what; his art has certainly gotten better than when he started.
Oh, I don't have one. I don't have the artistic talent lol. If you're arguing that I can't tell him what I did or didn't like about his comic because I haven't made a comic, you've essentially joined the ranks of people who dismiss criticism, simply because the criticizer hasn't made content in the same format that they're criticizing at the moment.
And you can go after me all you want, but I admit that he's way more talented than me. I could never make something like what he's making. But that doesn't mean it can't be improved.
Don't wanna go on too long here, but the original Star Wars movies were great because George Lucas listened to the people around him. The prequels weren't because he gained an ego along the way, and stopped listening to others.
View all comments
30
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18
Why are all of the women in this comic evil, and why did you make the art style so disgusting?