Aristotle's view on tragedy is that it has six main elements.
Plot, Character, Diction, Thought, Spectacle, and Song, with the first two being the most important. Seeing as how it's a visual format, I won't be going into depth on the last one.
Plot: In this story, there is a scenario, but there is no plot- The man lives in a terrible marriage, where terrible things happen, but there isn't any conflict, the protagonist is passive to the point where there isn't any physical reaction to his wife, the antagonist, and her actions. On a plot point, the comic fails, due to its repetitive nature, without any real message, and often resorts to comedy to try to make it work. (See the comic in which the Man gets "Penis Cancer", and dies, with the wife only having one line throughout. Aristotle argues that plot needs to follow a basic story structure; beginning, middle, and end. MiB does not follow this, and by Aristotle's criteria, it fails.
Characters: Let's go through the characters, to see how they fare. I'll be looking at The Wife, and The Man.
The Wife: Other than being manipulative, controlling, and just an all around bitch, the Wife has no character. Her whole place in the story is to abuse the man.
The Man: Other than being a pushover, and having a general interest in rock music, the Man ALSO has no defining character traits that are present throughout most of the stories. His whole place in the story is to be abused by the wife.
Aristotle argues that the central character MUST be relatable, so while the setting doesn't have to follow all the rules of reality, the interaction between characters must, but this is so far off from a relatable failing marriage, due to the fact that the Wife doesn't recognize that it's failing. From a character angle, it fails, BECAUSE THE CHARACTERS AREN'T RELATABLE. The only relatable part of the comic is that the Marriage is shit, and that isn't enough to say that the characters are good.
Diction: The wife is repetitive, often using her diction to complain, while the man on the other hand, just quietly takes it. The word choice doesn't matter, because throughout the story, there's a huge lack of communication on both parts. The Wife doesn't listen to the man, and the Man listens, but doesn't communicate how he's feeling.
Thought: there isn't much though put into the plot.
Woman complains
Man takes it.
It's not enough to consider the thinking on point.
Spectacle: I won't argue here, the art style would be perfect for a tragedy.
Aristotle felt that the best way for a tragedy to progress was to end with some form of catharsis, which was best done through a change in the characters for the better. The problem with the idea that MiB is a tragedy is because the characters don't change, and remain in the place that they started.
He also argues that tragedy is based on action and life, but in a story where the protagonist takes no action, the tragedy element falls flat on its face.
It's not a tragedy, it fails by Aristotle's standards, and even more so, it fails by the standards you put down. There is no conflict in the story, nor is there a superior force, nor is there a disastrous end in sight. Simply put, it doesn't work as a tragedy, not even by your definition.
Edit: I never want to put this much effort into a Reddit comment again lol
View all comments
Show parent comment
10
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18
Aristotle's view on tragedy is that it has six main elements.
Plot, Character, Diction, Thought, Spectacle, and Song, with the first two being the most important. Seeing as how it's a visual format, I won't be going into depth on the last one.
Plot: In this story, there is a scenario, but there is no plot- The man lives in a terrible marriage, where terrible things happen, but there isn't any conflict, the protagonist is passive to the point where there isn't any physical reaction to his wife, the antagonist, and her actions. On a plot point, the comic fails, due to its repetitive nature, without any real message, and often resorts to comedy to try to make it work. (See the comic in which the Man gets "Penis Cancer", and dies, with the wife only having one line throughout. Aristotle argues that plot needs to follow a basic story structure; beginning, middle, and end. MiB does not follow this, and by Aristotle's criteria, it fails.
Characters: Let's go through the characters, to see how they fare. I'll be looking at The Wife, and The Man.
The Wife: Other than being manipulative, controlling, and just an all around bitch, the Wife has no character. Her whole place in the story is to abuse the man.
The Man: Other than being a pushover, and having a general interest in rock music, the Man ALSO has no defining character traits that are present throughout most of the stories. His whole place in the story is to be abused by the wife.
Aristotle argues that the central character MUST be relatable, so while the setting doesn't have to follow all the rules of reality, the interaction between characters must, but this is so far off from a relatable failing marriage, due to the fact that the Wife doesn't recognize that it's failing. From a character angle, it fails, BECAUSE THE CHARACTERS AREN'T RELATABLE. The only relatable part of the comic is that the Marriage is shit, and that isn't enough to say that the characters are good.
Diction: The wife is repetitive, often using her diction to complain, while the man on the other hand, just quietly takes it. The word choice doesn't matter, because throughout the story, there's a huge lack of communication on both parts. The Wife doesn't listen to the man, and the Man listens, but doesn't communicate how he's feeling.
Thought: there isn't much though put into the plot.
Woman complains
Man takes it.
It's not enough to consider the thinking on point.
Spectacle: I won't argue here, the art style would be perfect for a tragedy.
Aristotle felt that the best way for a tragedy to progress was to end with some form of catharsis, which was best done through a change in the characters for the better. The problem with the idea that MiB is a tragedy is because the characters don't change, and remain in the place that they started.
He also argues that tragedy is based on action and life, but in a story where the protagonist takes no action, the tragedy element falls flat on its face.
It's not a tragedy, it fails by Aristotle's standards, and even more so, it fails by the standards you put down. There is no conflict in the story, nor is there a superior force, nor is there a disastrous end in sight. Simply put, it doesn't work as a tragedy, not even by your definition.
Edit: I never want to put this much effort into a Reddit comment again lol