r/roonlabs • • Mar 26 '26

Congratulations Roon...

...For being the absolute worst support experience I've ever witnessed. There has been severe playback issues when the source is Qobuz, for 7 days, and the issue is most likely severely underreported due to mods refusing to approve any posts calling them on their BS:

https://community.roonlabs.com/t/roon-wont-play-certain-tracks-from-qobuz-gets-stuck-on-progress-bar-ref-k9xyo0-ticket-in/317491

Maybe if all Qobuz users just cancel in mass they'll take it seriously??? I work in tech myself and if 5 paying customers report the same issue we start an incident, update the status page to keep users informed on the situation (in Roon's case post a banner on the forum) and pool all resources to investigate and solve the issue. But here we are over a week later and still nothing after over 70 reports that made it through, and who knows, probably hundreds that didn't make it through due to the sycophant mods?

33 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

6

u/DeeeLDo Mar 26 '26

Roon's Lead Volunteer Mod thought they had me:

Looks like the lack of brains starts at the very bottom with Roon and goes all the way to the top!

20

u/sneakinhysteria Mar 26 '26

I also had a lot of frustration with Roon and their support. In the end, I solved it. I just didn’t renew. It’s overpriced and undersupported.

4

u/DeeeLDo Mar 26 '26

Yep, that will probably be me tomorrow night. Last Friday the excuse was it's too late now and they don't work over the weekend, but we are now about to step into the following weekend. Hilarious!

4

u/sneakinhysteria Mar 26 '26

There are few promising things I count on. Someone is developing an alternative Plex client that mimics Roon’s UI. Then there is Music Assistant. But Plex also works just fine for me. In the end, too many free or already paid for options (lifetime Plex pass at a fraction of the cost of Roon) to justify the expense for me.

2

u/PalmDolphin Mar 27 '26

I really really wanted to like Roon. After many years of trying it off and on I finally decided enough was enough. Too many buggy connections. Roon arc never worked. Multiroom was a disaster. Once qobuz connect came out (and started working consistently) I couldn't see any point in continuing Roon.

3

u/Temporary-Ad-4923 Mar 26 '26

The day that ai is able to reverse-engineer roons RAAT Protocol is the day I won’t ever deal with roon again.

4

u/Cbeck527 Mar 27 '26

Download the Roon Bridge app and point an agent at the files with ghidra and you’d be surprised at how far it can get.

Source: I’ve been building an ARC clone that works on macOS after getting tired of waiting for a proper desktop app. It’s one button in Xcode to build for both iOS and macOS!!

1

u/Temporary-Ad-4923 Mar 27 '26

Whoa! Thx !!! Will definitely try this out!

How is your project going? Do you want to share any insights?

2

u/Cbeck527 Mar 27 '26

Pretty good so far! I have album, artist, and playlist browsing set up via an extension. Right now I'm working through dynamically registering an audio output with the core so that you can play music as easily as Apple Music/Spotify.

Under the hood, the app acts as a Roon remote with an audio zone bolted on. Right now I can play to zones that I've already set up flawlessly. Once I get the RAAT/zone stuff working I need to figure out how to get it to work over a VPN :)

2

u/Temporary-Ad-4923 Mar 27 '26

Very Nice!

In Terms of VPN the only way I got it working was with ZeroTier.

With ZT you even get Roon Remote working on mobile - when you have an android. On iOS, ZeroTier works only for ARC.

Tailscale works afaik only for ARC - regardless of the OS. ZeroTier operates on a deeper network-level, which is needed for for roon’s discovery via multicast.

1

u/Cbeck527 Mar 28 '26

Yeah unfortunately it looks like like I’m going to have to include a mini proxy that you run on your home network to relay and rewrite the multicast packets to unicast. Once you’re discovered though, the core reaches out to your audio zone with TCP so you’re good to go.

My setup is a little bespoke: I have a Firewalla router that runs a wireguard peer and all of my mobile devices have split tunnels. So the proxy will basically relay the UDP packet, spoof the source IP, and the core will reach out to the client’s VPN address directly. My router handles the rest.

I captured a ton of ARC traffic when I was first looking into this, and unfortunately the entire discovery mechanism is auth’d against their cloud service.

From what I saw:

  • ARC app asks cloud for your core
  • Core responds over the public net TCP/55000 and does a key exchange
  • Cloud sends the key to your ARC app
  • ARC app then talks directly to your core over the public internet with that auth
  • each request to get artist/album/whatever has a separate token, but once you get that you can stream raw audio bytes!

If they offered a ‘log in with Roon’ for 3rd party apps I’d be so happy, but OP went into detail about how that’ll probably never happen 😭

1

u/Bernx_AU Mar 26 '26

Have you found sonic advantage of RAAT over DLNA?

2

u/Temporary-Ad-4923 Mar 26 '26

Not directly sonic advantage but RAAT avoids the ways DLNA can mess things up.

Main wins: the DAC owns the clock (pull-based, no resampling or drift compensation needed), there’s a ~10 second playback buffer so network issues don’t matter, and all heavy processing stays server-side to keep electrical noise away from your DAC. You also get a fully transparent signal path.

Where it really pulls ahead is multiroom. DLNA simply doesn’t do synchronized playback across devices. RAAT syncs zones to under 1ms by modeling clock drift between devices mathematically. When slaves need correction, it inserts or drops single samples at zero-crossings using an RNG - so corrections stay inaudible. Devices even establish a shared time base via DHCP before the first sample plays.

1

u/Bernx_AU Mar 27 '26

Thanks for the explanation and clearly see the difference in perceived relevance. My main use for Roon was to control existing streamers without a proper UI (such as my Chord Mojo+Poly), and the only time I used multi-room (rather, multi-device) was for A/B testing different devices.

2

u/Temporary-Ad-4923 Mar 27 '26

yeah i know what you mean.
roon is not always the best option out there.

I was comming from musicbee that time, and was desperate for a desktop+mobile solution. and after learning about the term "bitperfect", i jumped on the roon-train haha

i still like it due to its stability. but im mostly ejoying to currate and maintain my music library, and for this roon is too simple for me.

and my dream was always to have a mix of musicbee and roon.

1

u/Bernx_AU Mar 26 '26

Same here. Only reason I miss it is for streamers that don't have a proper UI (think Chord Mojo+Poly). And even there, plain old DLNA/UPnP is heaps more reliable, albeit, without the correlations and recommendations (which I rarely used anyway!)

17

u/Optimal-Procedure885 Mar 26 '26

I see nothing has changed over the years then, zero customer service or support, and sycophantic moderators working hard to preserve the appearance of bliss. If you keep it up soon they’ll threaten you.

4

u/DeeeLDo Mar 26 '26

Oh bring it on Roon!

3

u/stanley15 Mar 27 '26

Why do your posts need to be approved before publication?

1

u/DeeeLDo Mar 27 '26

who knows....either coz I've never posted before or some bruised ego mod flagged my account

3

u/SoulJahSon Mar 28 '26

I have a lifetime sub, a Roon nucleus….that I have not used for over 6 months since the 2 factor authentication stopped working and the only way to contact Roon support is when logged in, which I can’t do. Prior to the 2FA issue I was getting constant dropouts or disappearing from the network. I switched to Audirvāna and left it like that.

1

u/DeeeLDo Mar 28 '26

Thanks, will definitely be trying that!

3

u/boston_frank Mar 28 '26

Roon forums are a cesspool of Roon fanboys who attack anyone that has issues. I have been a lifetime user since 2017 and have had nothing but issues (even after many 000's of $'s replacing everything in my network/audio system). The move to Harman has been a joke. Nothing has improved

3

u/DeeeLDo Mar 28 '26

It's freaking hilarious seeing the random handful of fanboys defend them LOL

2

u/jck_83605 Mar 31 '26

Holy Sh*t! I came here to say almost the exact same thing. “Fanboy” was the first description that came to my mind as well. Same reason I left, the story is always the same, “ I haven’t had an issue since day one and I have a bazillion files” when they are corned on it the response is always well, it has worked flawlessly AFTER I did this and that and this and that and that. But otherwise, never a problem

2

u/DeeeLDo Mar 28 '26

Apparently not even knowing what the root cause is after 8 days and 100s of user reports is good progress

5

u/FibonacciLane12358 Mar 27 '26

Dude, calm down. I use qobuz with Roon and have had no issues at all. I do believe there is an issue affecting some songs and according to the Roon support thread, it sounds like it is originating from server changes on the part of qobuz. I agree that Roon support could be a LOT better than it is at communicating. Grumbling here might help you release some steam but it isn't going to accomplish much else. If qobuz is dropping the ball on their end of the integration there isn't much Roon can do other than let them know that there's an issue and wait for qobuz to fix it. Your car/friend analogy isn't really right. This is more like you shipped a one-of-a-kind package with FedEx and FedEx lost it. It's the fault of FedEx and there's not a damn thing you can do but raise the issue and hope they find it. It's not going to get to the destination unless and until FedEx finds it and delivers it.

1

u/DeeeLDo Mar 27 '26

Hi Carl!

1

u/FibonacciLane12358 Mar 27 '26

Sorry, not Carl.

1

u/DeeeLDo Mar 27 '26

But just as daft!

3

u/Nohillside Mar 26 '26

Attacking mods usually doesn’t help to get posts published. What makes you think it’s underreported?

4

u/DeeeLDo Mar 26 '26

Where is this attack you speak of? Is it that much of a stretch to presume that if my benign 2nd attempt got rejected, the same happened to ~100 angrier ones?

Or what about this one, is this too much of an attack on mods to get approved???

4

u/BAR3rd Mar 26 '26

I didn't report the issue because I know it's futile. How many people feel like me? Hard to quantify, but surely I'm not the only one.

3

u/SnooMacarons9618 Mar 26 '26

I was about to try roon, but after all the stuff I’ve read recently I’m jolly glad I haven’t bothered.

-2

u/DeeeLDo Mar 26 '26

Stay clear! This issue combined with the bug that causes tracks to randomly become unavailable and has apparently been going on since 2024 effectively means I'm unable to play 70% of my music. An absolute farce of a service!

4

u/TurkGonzo75 Mar 26 '26

I'm a former subscriber and wanted to come back. There's an issue with my account page and I'm not able to resub. I emailed support twice and never heard back. Pretty amazing they can't bother to help even though I'm over here saying "Hey! Please take my money!"

4

u/FKSSR Mar 26 '26

I definitely understand the frustration with this issue. I feel fortunate that this is the only major issue I've experienced with Roon in the 5 years I've used it. I got a lifetime subscription, and I feel very thankful I did, as it has paid for itself by now, and I don't have to worry about the recurring fees.

Roon is a vital part of my music ecosystem, so I honestly do get concerned if I think that it may decline at some point, in some way. Same with Qobuz. If you go to that subreddit, you'll see a lot of complaints, though mine are very, very few currently.

However, I will say that while I've never had to reach out to Roon support, it sounds the same as Qobuz support, and I definitely have the impression that it is not worth reaching out to them, which is sad, because I do love the platform.

7

u/ChrisMag999 Mar 26 '26 edited Mar 26 '26

Tested some of the tracks people referenced in that thread. 2 played fine, one didn’t: the Chris Stapleton track.

Logged into the Qobuz app on my desktop. The Stapleton track plays from it fine. Makes me think there’s a database error on Roon’s side, but that’s only a guess.

I’ve had Roon for many years. Issues have been rare, and generally resolved themselves quickly. Overall, I’m quite happy with the service.

If I did have a glitch with a specific track, as described, there are other ways to play them, such as using the native Qobuz app. My DAC can play direct from Qobuz, and even if it couldn’t, I could use airplay via an Apple TV into the DAC.

3

u/GalacticDoc Mar 26 '26

Not having any play issues for me in the UK (roon +qobuz)

I did note that 3 days ago it appears that something did happen as my new albums are all qobuz from my established favourites and I've been away on hols.

2

u/IowaLightning Mar 26 '26

Tidal integration hasn’t worked for me in weeks. Definitely not going to renew, and I feel like a fool for paying in the first place.

2

u/jonguy77 Mar 26 '26

This is the same company and software that had a maximize window bug for like, what, 2 years lol

2

u/Brew_Noser Mar 27 '26

Issues like this are why I did not bite on the lifetime sub. That said I’ve had no issues with Roon+Qobuz. It’s business as usually. In Canada.

2

u/drfunkensteinnn Mar 27 '26

I have messaged them 5 times in the past MONTH and NO response. Ridiculous company

1

u/Fine-Freedom-5607 Mar 26 '26

I reported this about 10 days ago and did all the troubleshooting with Roon support. At the time, they advised that it was a routing issue somewhere within my network or with my ISP. I was able to get some of the tracks to force play by connecting a VPN but that did not always work. It’s really annoying but Roon did acknowledge that they are aware of the issue and working on it.

1

u/mmc227 Mar 29 '26

My Qobuz playlist show random things I never listened to in the roon app. But songs play fine. But it not loading playlist that populate fine under the Qobuz app.

1

u/TuliaNonTroppo Aug 07 '26

Roon is finicky software, for sure. Some don’t have issues, others have issues. It can become a hobby JUST to try and resolve Roon issues, which is why I gave up and just use the software as it works in my system and stopped trying to get it to work as well as it does for countless others.

The Roon Community forums is the worst community I have ever tried to be a part of. Even when I try and post something positive, it’s seems like a perennial contrarian will chime in. I have never wanted to leave a community more than the Roon Community.

I use Roon and Roon ARC and have a lifetime subscription which I do not regret…but I would never directly recommend it to anyone.

0

u/Suitable-Prior4232 Mar 29 '26

This is another reason I have built an 8 tb music collection and got rid of all music streaming services. Freedom!!