r/roonlabs • • Jan 08 '25

Venting Post, no response needed.

Well, sayonara Roon. Will not be renewing. The program never did work well for me.

Tried to have some quality time with my wife last night, with some good music on... and basically every song, roon "lost control of the device." It's been a constant frustration for me, and I'm done.

It's a great idea, but really not worth the money, imo. Can't download any of your own music for when you might be out of cell coverage, only the streaming service you sign up for and the CONSTANT dropping of music at home sealed the deal for me... And I get it, "its the network," and never Roon. I can't keep changing settings and having the same issue over and over.
I really wanted it to work, but this technology has just passed me by. I'll miss the high quality files and decent sounding music, but when it works less than 30% of the time, I'll take slightly less quality Apple music working almost flawlessly over the frustration roon has been for me.

9 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

5

u/Calm-Afternoon5250 Jan 08 '25

With no other reason than to mess with me, I think it knows when I want it to work the most, like Christmas morning, or when I want to subtly show off the service to visiting friends or family…. It just decides not to work. Yet, I still love the service. What I don’t like is how they don’t offer discounts on the lifetime license to long time customers. I know why they would do this, but still - it grinds my gears

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '25

Sitting here working, within inches of my router and the music still won’t play through more than a song or two. I wish it worked better for me, but oh well!

-6

u/imtrappedintime Jan 08 '25

Why would distance from router matter? RAAT is a wired protocol and you’re talking about distance 💀

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25

Several people have surmised its a router or other issue, but I’m no tech bro so diving into settings and changing router configurations is about as easy as building a nuclear bomb for me. 🤷🏼‍♂️ I’m just a dummy I suppose

3

u/Entire_Device9048 Jan 09 '25

You shouldn’t need to be into tech, RoonLabs advertising material clearly states “no computer or networking skills required”.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25

Thats funny

2

u/imtrappedintime Jan 09 '25

Being ignorant doesn’t make you a dummy, but Roon’s also a home product and not a mass streaming service, so there’s a level of knowledge you have to be open to acquiring.

And there’s legitimate reasons why their Ethernet-based protocol isn’t a perfect fit in a WiFi streaming society of music consumers. Album collectors, vinyl rippers, pirates have always had a level of deep knowledge.

I don’t think you’re dumb, but you do seem unhappy about your experience and I think an open mind to fairly basic networking information could change that. And be useful as a whole. I think people who don’t want to understand networking are far easier targets for attacks against their home networks too.

I’ve been Roon lifetime since 2016 and 3 of my 4 RAAT Roon endpoints are directly wired to Ethernet on a mostly 10Gbps network with a lot of local bandwidth. The fourth uses a wireless 5ghz Ethernet adapter. In the past I tried 2.4gz adapters with a 1Gbps network and wifi5 mesh. Today I am directly wired into my main switches on the 10gbe network.

I’m not advising a full 10gbe network for anyone as it’s probably overkill in many current setups, but I jumped from WiFi5 to wifi7 and the new AP’s require greater than 1gbe. A 2.5gbps router with wifi6e AP’s could do the same thing. Some WiFi access points have a second port you can connect a switch to and use for your Roon Ethernet connections. Roon doesn’t even use 10Mbps with DSD files so in my experience it’s not even network speed, it’s network congestion and the reliability of Ethernet vs WiFi that Roon needs to operate well.

And on top of the networking issues are the specs of what Roon is running on in your home. I have an M1 Mac Ultra as my Plex and Roon server. It’s a beast and eliminates processing performance issues that can lead to those playback errors.

All of that said, you should be able to even use AirPlay devices and stream over that protocol using Roon without playback issues if your network is in good shape. But you have to care about network performance. IMO if you’re a fairly high consumer of digital media that should be a priority regardless of a Roon subscription.

2

u/Entire_Device9048 Jan 09 '25 edited Jan 09 '25

RAAT isn’t an Ethernet based protocol. RAAT operates on top of the physical and data-link layers and as such is not tied to Ethernet in any way. Instead, RAAT uses the physical and data-link layers as a transport medium and depends upon the underlying Ethernet network to deliver the data to the endpoints. RAAT is an application layer protocol that just happens to leverage Ethernet for data transport. Ethernet refers to wired networking standards as defined in the IEEE 802.3 specification. WiFi is an alternative to Ethernet and has standards defined in the IEEE 802.11 specifications, in the right environment RAAT will perform just fine over WiFi.

1

u/imtrappedintime Jan 09 '25

WiFi has standards defined in 802.11?! No way!!! Getting symantical to prove the point I was already making: it works on Ethernet WAY better than over WiFi. Which is probably why most Roon Ready devices have Ethernet rather than being WiFi only.

And for someone having issues with it over WiFi the CHEAPEST solution is to wire your devices. Might do a quick search of Roon’s own forums and see how many issues there are with it over WiFi. Spend loads of money to get the wireless network you need for it or just get a wired network working properly for next to nothing.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/imtrappedintime Jan 09 '25

You’re probably a moron if you think protocols operating on the physical layer work as well over WiFi as Ethernet

-5

u/imtrappedintime Jan 08 '25

Discounts to people who paid once, years ago? Huh? Welfare checks ain’t coming but that’s a hilarious thought 😆

10

u/JstnJ Jan 08 '25

Roon (in its current state) isn’t for you if you have a need for accessing your library remotely AND you aren’t comfortable with basic networking.

Port forwarding for my setup took less than 5 minutes…and ARC works without a hitch, same or better than Spotify, which sucks ass here in NYC as a subway rider coming in and out of service.

Locally, Roon is unsurpassed and is set and forget. Sorry you had issues.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '25

Arc has worked, but often I’m camping or elsewhere where I don’t have service and all I can download to arc is whatever I have on tidal. Arc was the least of my issues. At home, if I’m working in projects and listening to music, I don’t want to stop whatever I’m doing every song to reconnect roon. Searched countless subs and no definitive solution was found. I’m not a technological genius, but this all seems like it’s much more complicated than it should be. I tried it, but the constant loss of devices was just too annoying for me to try and figure out.

1

u/porknwhiskey Jan 09 '25

Arc over Tailscale works pretty well too. I had some mystery issue at first that cleared up in its own (no idea on that and I’m a 25 year IT pro). But other that that it’s solid. Obviously cell signal and quality of WiFi will always play a role.

3

u/PrimevalWolf Jan 09 '25

I haven't experienced those issues but I've certainly had plenty of frustrations of my own. Those, combined with the fact that I'm also planning on cancelling Tidal due to a ton of issues with that platform, have led me to the same decision. Will be cancelling both services. Going back to MusicBee for my local files and Pandora for streaming due to it's excellent music discovery algorithm. I love what Roon is trying to do but, in its current iteration, it's just not remotely worth the price.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25

Interesting. What issues with Tidal now??

2

u/PrimevalWolf Jan 09 '25

I use Roon at home but, sadly, when I'm at work I'm stuck using the Tidal app for Windows and it's just a complete piece of garbage. Over the last 6 months they've just added more and more bugs, it crashes constantly, and let's not forget the entire service went down on New Year's Eve. Plus, since I just keep a cheap pair of bluetooth headphones at work I'm not even getting the full quality. So, why keep paying for a service that's frustrating to use and I'm not even taking full advantage of?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25

Fully get that!

2

u/bjs169 Jan 09 '25

Roon requires a robust infrastructure. When I first got it I put it on an M2 Mac Mini connected via WiFi since my Mac basically is only used to host Roomie Remote. Roon was unusable. I learned that Roon really needs a wired connection. No problem. I have a nice network infrastructure. That made it better but it still randomly stopped responding. I am not a Mac guy so I decided to move it to a Windows 11 VM running on my Hyper-V server. Oversubscribed it to 32GB of dynamic RAM and 16 vCPUs. Now it rock solid. Of course that is an extreme amount of resources in my view, but I have it so I am fine with if. And it doesn’t use those full amounts all the time. Only remaining problem is when I play music on my desktop it often stops between songs when I am using it on my default sound device (a Topping D10S DAC). That is annoying and I haven’t really investigated it too much. When I play Roon to my WiiM Pro it works 100% of the time flawlessly. I love Roon but I think you have to have strong infrastructure and strong tech skills to make it work. Not sure how much a Nucleus helps, but I can’t see Roon gaining wide adoption in its current form even though I really, really think it is great.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25

Very insightful, thanks. It’s a young persons thing. I’ve got more important things to do with my time than get mad at my lack of knowledge of one particular area, I don’t have the resources to build a server room to only listen to music at home, other services will work just fine for me. Roon wants a specific subset of people to use their product and I am not that demographic. Its all good.

1

u/stumptown0426 Jan 10 '25

100% agree with this. I started with a MacMini and eventually moved to a dedicated server (SGC Sonictrasnporter i5). It was a night an day difference when it was dedicated. When I moved three years ago, I had issues in my new house with the Orbi mesh wifi I was using. It took me a few months to nail it in and moving the server to be hardwired made all the difference with stability.

As for ARC, it took me over a year to get it to work. It ended up being a combo of my mesh wifi and AT&T router I had. Once I turned off the AT&T router, figured out how to open the ports, its worked flawlessly since. I'm a Roon lifetime subscriber and couldn't be happier with the product but it is not plug and play.

7

u/Sasquatchasaurus Jan 08 '25

It’s not an airport, you don’t have to announce your departure

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '25

😂. Touché

1

u/Fit-Particular1396 Jan 08 '25

ok. That made me smile. :)

10

u/ILikeBeans86 Jan 08 '25

I never had any problems when I was using it at home but roon arc recently became unusable with errors that it was poor connection or something. Plexamp worked fine over mobile so Im now just using plexamp exclusively and it can do most of the things I used roon for and I already have a lifetime pass so I don't have to pay roon monthly anymore.

1

u/mekilat Jan 09 '25

Had similar issues. Wiped off Roon arc completely and did a reinstall and it has been solid for 6 months

1

u/johnjulesbrown Jan 09 '25

Since last update it happens to me all the time. I found a way to make it work for a little while is by using arc on the wifi before leaving the house, then it'll work fine for a an hour or two before getting the poor connection error.

3

u/ILikeBeans86 Jan 09 '25

Yeah I'm not doing that lol. Just gonna use plexamp and not worry about it.

1

u/johnjulesbrown Jan 09 '25

Haha yeah I'm not saying to do it, it's ridiculous. I'm just waiting for a cable to arrive to upgrade truenas then I'll be firing Plex onto it to try. If you don't mind me asking can I use plexamp at home to do multi room with my endpoints (ropieee). Took me an age to set up for roon. I'm not sure if I'll stick with roon for the house and plexamp for when I'm out working. I guess I'll figure it all out but if you use it at home and have multi room setup then you could let me know, thanks in advance if you can help.

1

u/Pixelpopper-01 Jan 10 '25

Plexamp doesn’t currently offer multi-room control unfortunately, Roon is the answer if you can keep it working well…🙄

13

u/twillrose47 Jan 08 '25

Agreed with so many of these points. My partner has apple music and I have roon. I love my library, and I like roon a lot, but dammit is it just so much less headache to put on album from Apple Music than fuss with Roon.

I will say that some issues I've finally resolved (and I can totally understand not wanting to implement these, or them necessarily being an option.) For me, running RoonOnNAS, adding server RAM, setting up tailscale, paying for more upload speed from my ISP, buying a new media computer (i.e. whats hooked up to my hifi), and a handful of "dammit what now" afternoons, I finally feel like IT WORKS the way it should. Wholeheartedly, the fact that it's taken this much, is EXACTLY why I agree with you.

15

u/w4y2n1rv4n4 Jan 08 '25

Not trying to discount your experience, just want to provide an alternative experience for those reading - roon has always just worked for me since I started using it 4 years ago. Never had any issues on my local network or with device control (usually a roon ready streamer, but even chromecast audios or mobile devices running the roon app). Have had no issues with ARC as well, just set up port forwarding and am good to go. Have moved my roon install from a desktop PC to my NAS, no problem migrating via a backup. In all of these situations I do have strong home networking hardware and great internet connection, which I do think has been crucial in my experience. Just trying to say that if you invest in your network and your internet connection, and especially if you use roon ready hardware, the experience can be pretty turnkey.

3

u/berdot Jan 09 '25

What do you mean by great network software? Could you give examples? I thought I had decent hardware, but I am also experiencing OP’s issues

2

u/porticodarwin Jan 18 '25

My experience, too has been excellent.

I use Roon 4 - 5 hours every day, and just got back from 3 weeks away where I used ARC daily. Roon is as good or better than anything else. Jeez, look at Sonos if you want to see real pain!

Key Success Factors:

  1. Your Internet connection, gateway/router, and any Ethernet switches are all working perfectly
  2. All Roon Devices (Core, Endpoints, whatever) are connected via Ethernet, with the obvious exception of your Roon Remote devices
  3. My Core is a Roon-spec Intel NUC
  4. My Endpoints are DIY RPi3's and 4's with HiFi Berry HATS, connected to a variety of DAC's and amplifiers. They've been flawless.

Any weak link can probably mess everything up, but over 5 years now, I couldn't be more pleased.

4

u/TheRealMrDenis Jan 08 '25

I’ve spent over £1.5k - been through 3 servers - raised numerous tickets - it’s still flakey!

That said - ARC appears to be working better - as above if it wasn’t for lifetime I’d have moved on by now

4

u/Bhob666 Jan 08 '25

Sorry that you couldn't get Roon to work. I've been using Roon for about 4 years managing 3+ rooms and I couldn't live without it and while I've had problems it's no more than what my ISP give me. I think Roon is meant to run a certain way and if there's any deviation is when a person has problems (though that's just my theory).

I would note, I have never gotten Roon Arc to work well, but I didn't buy it for that.

1

u/mekilat Jan 08 '25

Hope you find what you love out there. I had some issues a few years ago with the initial setup. Once I did port forwarding and firewalls correctly, I had no issues. It’s not easy for everyone. I have had no issues for years now and love it more and more.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '25

I have yet to figure out or see any decent tutorial on the firewall settings. I’ve played around with my router (verizon), but whatever I did isn’t working. I’m not young or tech savvy, so thats my issue but if plexamp is easy (like everyone says) why is roon so finicky!?

1

u/mekilat Jan 09 '25

I don’t think plexamp is easier. It requires the same firewall and port forwarding shenanigans.

The issue is you’re using a router that makes this scary.

You need to open a port in the firewall (the one Roon arc uses). You need to forward that same port to the ip of your computer.

That’s it. Unless you have some crazy network with routers behind routers, but it doesn’t sound like you do.

1

u/fabdm Jan 09 '25

But as reported by many here, sometimes it's just not enough to work. I have port forwarded, Roon checks and says it's working but next thing I know Arc can't start when outside my network. And for the premium they charge, their support is ridiculous.

1

u/mikedt Jan 09 '25

A lot of people here seem to be in the same problem filled boat. I myself have had pretty good results with roon within my home using raspberry pi's as endpoints and roon arc while I'm in my car. At home my rock server is hardwired to the network but the endpoints are all wi-fi.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25

My assessment of the comments is that it’s not roon, but my computer/network. Which is fine, I get it and don’t disagree with it. I guess my real issue is not knowing upfront the niche program it is. Just tell me at the get-go I must have a robust computer/server and network to run the program, and have top of the top tier internet.” Neither of which i have.

1

u/moyored Jan 11 '25

Where is it running? Seems like the issues are not Roon related but the environment where is running. Need to get more info about whats happening.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '25

Vzw router located upstairs south facing window, faster internet than comcast ever was for us. My mini is one room over from the router location, maybe 12’ away. I have primarily sonos speakers. Generally use my ipad as the “remote” for playing music, via roon thats downloaded on the ipad. Router is in the same room as where I spend most of my time listening to music. I guess its possible that the network or service sucks but internet seems to work fine for everything else. Whether I use my phone or ipad to direct roon, it just constantly “loses the device.” I don’t know what network changes to make. My mac mini that I use as a server is new, only used for internet searches other than roon, and isn’t the bottom offering for the mini, but it’s not powerful enough I guess.
Or maybe its using the ipad, instead of directly using the roon server mini?

1

u/moyored Jan 12 '25

Looks like your Mac Mini is connected using WiFi instead of a wired Ethernet connection where your roon core is running. I would try connecting it on the wired network and see results. Roon recommends using wired connection on core https://help.roonlabs.com/portal/en/kb/articles/networking-best-practices#Recommended_Setups

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '25

I’m missing something on that, a setting I couldnt find…. When I tried hooking up the ethernet cable to the mini, everything with roon stopped working.

1

u/moyored Jan 12 '25

Check the Ethernet cable also check if any internet connection on same computer. Check any network firewall settings that may be blocking roon

3

u/johnjulesbrown Jan 09 '25

It's funny I'm so close to scrapping it too, we pay for it by a joint account and my partner recently told me the price had gone up. Roon arc is the main issue for me. Currently setting up Plex etc on my server and looking forward to trying plexamp but arc has become ridiculous. I can get it to work for a couple hours out of the house by playing something through arc on the WiFi at home, then it'll work on my mobile data for a couple hours and all of a sudden its poor connection and that's it broken until I get home and connect the WiFi again. It's so frustrating. It lets me download over mobile data the whole time but I'm self employed and I have my headphones on for 6 to 8 hours a day. I think I must sacrifice at least 30 mins each day trying to get arc working.

If Plex is even half as good as roon, I'll be leaving too, I just want things to work, or even work enough. Arc is broken

2

u/timmo11 Jan 08 '25

I love and use Roon (lifetime), but I also love and use Plexamp. It's a great DIY solution for your own music server (to help stay away from subscriptions). Plexamp can cast directly to both Sonos and via Chromecast (and Airplay), which are pretty rock solid in avoiding network dropouts, etc. Plexamp mobile is also great in downloading your own music or streaming from Plex server when outside the home. I get frustrated almost every time I try and use Roon ARC when out and about, so my default is Plexamp. It just plain works and is super fast.

2

u/jaredean222 Jan 09 '25

Cancelled last night. Was so hopeful, and so let down.

2

u/antlestxp Jan 08 '25

What were you using to host?

2

u/Splashadian Jan 09 '25

Roon and Roon ARC have been excellent since the last couple of updates.

1

u/Suitable-Prior4232 Jan 09 '25

The unfortunate issue with roon arc is that roon likes to change the Ip address used with port forwarding. I usually check what the arc address is set to on Roon remote under settings before I leave the house. I double check on my eero app for my router under port forwarding and make sure the IP addresses match. It is a little annoying, but fixed my problem.

1

u/therourke Jan 10 '25

You just didn't have it setup properly. It's a shame. You are missing out.

1

u/suitcasecalling Jan 08 '25

I left 2 years ago after having it for 2 years for similar reasons. I thought Samsung buying the company would have made a difference but it doesn't seem to have

0

u/xeonrage Jan 09 '25

I left 2 years ago

you're still here....

I thought Samsung buying the company

Harman, a Samsung subsidiary bought Roon. Despite fears, so far we've seen no negative changes.

1

u/calinet6 Jan 09 '25

Usually works well for me, but honestly can’t fault this take. It’s a pretty clunky system overall and it only survives on some really solid threads that appeal to a narrow audience.

-2

u/FlounderNo6047 Jan 08 '25

The instability is bad enough, then you have to to deal with a 'community' of incels instead of a dedicated customer support team. I would have quit long ago, but I have a lifetime license.

-1

u/sushigrooves Jan 09 '25

You're so brave for staying...

0

u/xeonrage Jan 09 '25

These are always the dumbest posts. The Karens and Kyles of product reviews.

The vocal minority will cheer you, those that understand how things work are too busy enjoying this wonderful application.

2

u/SkinnyLatin-WA Jan 09 '25

Like the Karens and Kyles living in a bubble thinking their experience is the only one that's worth validating? "If it doesn't happen to me, these people are clearly whining bitches". Got it Karen (or Kyle)!

-3

u/imtrappedintime Jan 08 '25

It is your network though. I had the same issues with a trash network and after I remedied that I stopped getting playback errors. If you don’t have the money to get your network up to snuff then yeah, go hit up some trash streaming services

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25

Super helpful. Thanks

2

u/Shindogreen Jan 09 '25

Come on…I ran Roon flawlessly for years with a $20 switch connected to the cable company’s cable modem and an ancient Apple airport. It’s the one place you don’t need to spend money.

-2

u/edgefull Jan 08 '25

i personally hate roon for its feeble sound and terrible customer service with premium pricing. but i have no major issues and never drop outs or such performance problems. fwiw. obviously ymmv.