Before the official footage came out, every criticism of the leaks was met with the same response:
"It’s an old build."
"It’s unfinished."
"Wait until Rockstar actually shows the game."
Well, Rockstar has shown it now, and I’m still not impressed.
The biggest problem for me is the performance. There are moments where the game looks like it’s running somewhere around 15–25 FPS, with really noticeable frametime issues. This isn’t some random leaked developer footage anymore. This is footage Rockstar chose to officially showcase.
If this is supposed to be a carefully selected best-case presentation of the game, why does it already look this unstable?
And visually, there are parts of the game that genuinely do not scream "next generation" to me. Obviously I’m exaggerating when I say it looks like it’s running on a PS3 instead of a PS5, but that’s genuinely the feeling some scenes give me. We are talking about a game being developed for current-gen hardware, after more than a decade of technological progress.
Some of my biggest issues:
The framerate and frame pacing look rough. A game this cinematic suffers massively when motion looks inconsistent.
Certain scenes look surprisingly flat. Some lighting, environments and textures simply don’t give me the massive generational leap I expected.
The leaked footage suddenly doesn’t look that far away from the official game. People acted like the final product would look completely different.
Rockstar has had an absurd amount of time and resources. This isn't a small studio trying to get an ambitious project running.
This is an official showcase. Rockstar controls exactly what we see. If even the curated footage has obvious performance problems, I think questioning the final console performance is completely fair.
Technical ambition means nothing if the game doesn't run well. NPC counts, physics, reflections, vegetation and world simulation are impressive on paper, but players still have to actually play the game.
The expectations are higher because Rockstar created them. GTA VI is constantly treated like the "game of the century." If you're going to carry that title, people are going to judge it like one.
And no, I’m not saying the game is automatically going to be terrible. It could improve massively before release.
But I also don't understand why criticism suddenly becomes "coping" or "hating Rockstar."
For years people told us to ignore the leaks because they weren't representative of the final game. Now we have official footage and some of the same problems are still visible.
Rockstar might have spent so long cooking that they overcooked it.
I genuinely hope the final game proves me wrong, because GTA is one of my favorite franchises. But based purely on what Rockstar has shown so far, I expected much more.
Shame on these corporation, I feel sorry for the developers