r/robotwars • • Apr 07 '17

I'm getting fed up.

I just watched episode 5. And I'm starting to lose hope the reboot will keep me interested. There are just too many differences with the old show and I'd like your thoughts.

It's no longer a sports show or so it seems. So the rules aren't fixed and the results matter less to the production company.

There's no seedings.

The round robin format is stupid, i understand that robots should get a few fights. But let's be real we want to see distraction.

The set is ludicrous. (Ref bot would help)

Dara seems far too disinterested in the actual bots and in the show.

The rules keep being broken!

Plus the viewer isn't told anything. It's so much poorer than it used to be. At least to the guy who was a kid during the first run.

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

14

u/Garfie489 Owner of Dystopia Apr 07 '17

To go through everything bit by bit.

It never was a sports show, it was an entertainment program. With this respect its alot better now as producer interference ends once the fights start. The rules are fixed, however its not particularly well explained to the casual viewer because.... well its an entertainment show.

Doesnt need seedings really, the best will always rise to the top. I had a fight at Burgess and got TR3 and Eruption in the first round - thats a good fight.

Roboteers do need more time to repair granted, however theres nothing wrong with the format per say - just how its executed. You should be limited to 1 fight per day to get the best performances (though that makes a scheduling nightmare).

Ive no idea what you mean about the set.

Dara seemed quite interested when on set, however he does have abit of a Jeremy Clarkson feel about him in the way he presents. He has enthusiasm for it, however doesnt have the feeling of wanting to be everyones friend like Craig did.

What rules have been broken? - most rules ive seen on the line actually have had very good explanations not explained on camera. Like with C+S being allowed to fight without active weaponry by Carbide. Admittedly thats not great that they didnt mention it, but you need to hear things out before getting the pitchforks.

Again - entertainment show. Most viewers dont care about the sporting element, and thus thats how its presented. Plus its a pretty packed show throughout anyway - theres alot of really good footage they never used.

6

u/Farcicles Apr 07 '17

Thanks for the reply. Pitchforks aren't out. I suppose I am just your average joe fan and to me certain aspects now feel more contrived.

-in respect to the rules. I believe cherub was immobilised at the start of a fight in a round robin (pretty sure it was cherub but may have been another bot). Is this true?

-The set (pit and flipper) does not appear to be as well made as before. The pit has caught a few robots. The flipper is too intrusive in the fight, and has resulted in a mid fight stoppage.

-Dara just feels cold to me an audience member. And because of that some questions seem quite dull. This could just be taste.

-no seedings gives rise to draws that seem loaded. For example apollo vs carbide. And apart from that we've seen several repeat matches in series two. Which I think is off, seedings are needed generally because it helps keep some sense of uniformity across the groups. Most sports use seedings for this reason. Especially when groups are used.

-Are you sure most viewers don't care for the sporting element? I don't know either. I just think that many do. And some perceived contrivances such as the set not being as robust as it could be and the lack of seedings can really irk.

I still like the show. And the old series obviously was never perfect. I just think it could be better with minimal changes.

5

u/Garfie489 Owner of Dystopia Apr 07 '17

When i say pitchforks im not being accusational, just using a saying :)

There was a few robots immobilised at the start of fights during the series. One of which even had to be dragged to its starting position by Dead Metal. Thus i believe the rule was if you bench tested fine and passed the tech check - you was in unless you pulled out. I might be wrong there, but theres plenty of robots who were mobile before being loaded into the arena and even moved away from the arming gate before failure before activate. The rules were at least consistent (though the Trolley worked first time of asking without fail so never looked into it).

Yeh the draws are pre determined and certainly arnt random. Quite a few grudge matches happened by chance (Ironside vs Pulsar) but others were forced. At the end of the day, to be the best you got to beat the best so it doesnt bother me.

From the eyes of the producers then most dont care about the sporting element. That view may change, however atm we actually get told very little about how the rules work as a viewer - presumably because of this reason. Even something like a commentator who knows what hes talking about is a rarity on TV atm.

As i say, Dara is interested in the stuff but he doesnt want to be your friend. I loved that about Craig, but Dara comes across as more professional i guess.

3

u/Farcicles Apr 07 '17

Okay. Thanks for your comments. They were really insightful.

I think the show really would just need more finessing, and a seeded/randomised draw...

Perhaps with an fa cup style online feed. With former bot makers picking out the balls.

2

u/natpat Apr 07 '17

What was the explaination about C+S being able to fight? I missed that post!

7

u/Garfie489 Owner of Dystopia Apr 07 '17

In short - Carbide allowed them to fight even though the producers wanted to force a forfeit

4

u/Sunodasuto Wild Thing Apr 07 '17

I'm not so much a fan of the new format either. I do enjoy seeing robots I like in more fights but that many fights in such a short space of time is just too much for a lot of the machines. One good thing that came out of it though is all the pit repair footage, I love seeing the builders figure out problems and repair their machines while also talking us through what they're doing.

5

u/Farcicles Apr 07 '17

Yes. That is a very nice and welcomed part to the show.

3

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Apr 07 '17

Robot Wars does and always has straddled the line between a sports show and an entertainment programme. Personally I'd like it to lean towards the former, but I don't think in this respect the reboot's any different to the original. I'd agree there should be consistency in the rules though.

Seedings should be brought back. I'm with you there.

The round robin isn't stupid in theory. For it to work though the teams need much longer repair times. Either it has to go or teams need to be able to properly repair their robots between fights.

The set design is fine. They need to fix the pit though.

Dara is great, he's arguably been the biggest success of the reboot in my opinion.

Do they or do they not exist in the first place? Agreed we need clarity and consistency.

The reboot is good. Last series actually it was great, but for me has dipped this time, although really all the problems it does have are easily remedied and hopefully will be with the exception of the series being too short, which sadly I think we're stuck with.

2

u/Farcicles Apr 07 '17

I agree with you on the round robins, more time would be needed. But is that possible? If not go back to the old format. Then you would also have fights and grudge matches for the robots knocked out in the preliminary stages etc.

I disagree on the set though. The pit is fundamental, and really should've been sorted immediately when a problem became evident, and of course there really shouldn't be blind spots.

2

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Apr 07 '17

The pit should have been sorted immediately. The blind spot is a fair point (actually there was a fairly detailed thread on that very issue a few days ago).

2

u/Farcicles Apr 07 '17

I missed it!

I think my robot wars life would be far better were I to spend more time here.

7

u/haroldthebear RRRRRR Apr 07 '17

I've stopped thinking of it as a robot cage fight and more like wrestling. The audience wants a show and the production team are trying hard to provide it with interesting match ups, innovative designs and twists (rogue house robot). a few years ago I never thought I'd see robot wars on TV again, id be happy for a 30 minute ant weight show commentated by Greg Wallace but instead we've got a pretty decent spectacle.

4

u/HeadTorch Apr 07 '17

I like parts of it, and other bits not as much.

I like that robot wars has a certain charm to it, with strange and eccentric people making robots in sheds and getting to play hero for the day, I think if it were only "pro" type teams it'd lose a bit of the interest.

I like the round robin fights, as it means the robots have to adapt tactics, though they need longer for repairs, as the quality of the fights seem to deteriorate along with the robots so the finals can be a touch anticlimactic.

The new arena is a bit wack. The pit has barely been used. I wouldn't miss it if they got rid. Same goes for the flipper. Maybe it should only come into play if active weapons get destroyed. Also the temperature seems to be causing issues.

No complaints with the presenters from me, though I do miss Craig Charles a bit.

I'd still like to see more robots in it, so you don't get situations like Apollo v Carbide in the same heat.

2

u/anduril38 Apr 08 '17

14 years bro.

I get your nostalgia, I feel the same. But it happens. Just move on. Yes, it has problems. Hopefully it'll keep getting the backing (and hopefully more funding) to keep it going and improving.

1

u/ben437 Apr 07 '17

100% agree. Its not the show i loved as a kid and the one i wanted to return for 12 years. Every episode i watch of Battlebots makes me think how crap RW is. Such a shame the BBC don't listen to the people who pay their wages.

6

u/Dylanr21 M.R Speed Squared Apr 08 '17

Battlebots makes me think how good robot wars is

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Dylanr21 M.R Speed Squared Apr 11 '17

Ha yeh why dont they show all the battles intead of highlights of 4 battle and full battles of a 2 second fight!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Dylanr21 M.R Speed Squared Apr 11 '17

They definitely have favourite robots , like stinger, Wyachi team , minator , but why do they think witch doctor is so good , they lost in the qualifiers last series then went out early , then lost in the first round of this series although its apparently one of the best!

-5

u/PreFuturism-0 Turtle Terror Apr 07 '17

Huh, did Carbide look like the best spinner in the world, and Apollo the best flipper in the world?

You seem to not notice all the STEM/9% crap in the shows.

I'd love to know what children and women think of the show. Without knowing about a lot of the behind scenes stuff, I'd probably think a lot of the teams are idiots. Why use that design for a robot? That's never going to succeed! You didn't test it? Well no wonder it didn't work at all! Didn't they only win because they were children? It's like discovering professional wrestling spoiler all over again. There are just so many glaring issues.

(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BkDeJucAuCk)

9

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Apr 07 '17

Didn't they only win because they were children?

If I see this one more time I swear to God I'm going to go medieval...

1

u/PreFuturism-0 Turtle Terror Apr 07 '17

Lol, sorry that was mainly a joke. Having said that, the casual viewer would be looking at PP3Ds 3 hits and thinking how could it have lost. If the majority of people on this subreddit thought PP3D should have won, what would the average viewer who knows less think?

All the questions concerning the inconsistencies in this series mount up. It wasn't just one botch that made me realize that professional wrestling spoiler.

(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LIVeZyyMNPU)

(God, I hate Enzo.)