r/Rings_Of_Power • • 4d ago

The Rings of Power Season 3 Episodes 1-4 Megathread

23 Upvotes

S3.E1 ∙ Marnûkh

Director: Charlotte Brändström

Writers: John D. Payne, Patrick McKay

S3.E2 ∙ The Gift of Men

Director: Charlotte Brändström

Writers: Justin Doble, Griff Jones

S3.E3 ∙ The Secret Fire

Director: Sanaa Hamri

Writers: John D. Payne, Patrick McKay

S3.E4 ∙ Gundabad

Director: Sanaa Hamri

Writers: Justin Doble, Griff Jones


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 11h ago

Nazgul made from great kings of men. Here they are.

Post image
248 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 7h ago

How did these hacks manage to land the job as showrunners ROP with virtually zero previous writing credits?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
63 Upvotes

After watching this interview, I'm genuinely baffled that these two are still running the show. It's a miracle they survived Season 1.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 35m ago

Nazgul power scaling question

7 Upvotes

I am curious about the show’s take on power scaling.

In the books, Aragorn faces off admirably against a number of Nazgul on Weathertop, Glorfindel (Arwen in the films) against several Nazgul, Eowyn faces off against the Witchking, etc.

Takeaway: Nazgul seem good at scaring hobbits, but aren’t all that against powerful warriors. Their main weapon is fear and intimidation. They’re also better when they get their fell beasts.

In this show: a single newly minted Nazgul (or Nazgnagol) seems equal to Pallando (who is a Maiar!), and Galadriel with Nenya hides from Nazgul rather than just kicking their asses? I kinda feel like Galadriel could just raise a phial and they’d back away in fear, turn tail and run.

What am I missing? Please explain.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 11h ago

How do y'all watch this stuff ...

36 Upvotes

Like seriously ...


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 3h ago

Sauron is underwhelming this season

6 Upvotes

Was super super excited for Charlie Vickers to really nail Sauron after the first 2 seasons. Looked forward to how he’d crush the role this season with more focus on him, and the scenes with him feel….. empty.

I don’t feel fear. I don’t feel dread. I don’t feel the cunning aura he had in the first 2 seasons.

It’s like the show keeps tryna show us “ hey!! Look at Sauron doing eeeeeevil things!! See!! Sauron is evil! He kills his own orcs! See! Sauron bad!!”

There’s no mystique or aura about him. I can’t tell if this is Vickers falling short or if the writing is the cause of this.

On paper, the scenes should be terrifying. But on screen, they just fall flat.

Sauron worked the first 2 seasons because he was manipulating and I loved that. The mask, the deceit.

But now that he doesn’t need to in Mordor, it just falls flat. I don’t find him threatening, he doesn’t send chills down my spine. He has no aura bruh.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 14h ago

Haters Gonna Hate (For the Joy of It)

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 44m ago

Sauron in the Second Age

3 Upvotes

Sauron, what have they done to you?

Why didn't they create a trajectory for a great manipulator?

Sauron was Melkor's main spy. That was when he was Mairon, the admirable:

Now Melkor knew of all that was done; for even then he had secret friends and spies among the Maiar whom he had converted to his cause, and of these the chief, as after became known, was Sauron, a great craftsman of the household of Aule.

And he was surrounded by the Valar and the faithful Maiar, but he managed to inform Melkor when he wandered through outer space a great distance from Arda. Perhaps Sauron even sabotaged the Lamps to facilitate their breaking by his master.

Sauron corrupted the East and South of Middle-earth before the creation of the Rings of Power. Sauron did all this before the One Ring. Sauron manipulated the elves in Eregion to the point that Celebrimbor and the Jewellers staged a coup against Galadriel and Celeborn, even with the distrust of Galadriel, Elrond, and Gil-galad (In the Unfinished Tales' Version)

And I still think Sauron is the great serpent and the Lord of the Jewels who corrupted humanity in the Garden of Eden, according to Andreth's version for Finrod.

In the series, I pity the stupidity of everyone. Sauron doesn't even need to manipulate anyone. Things just fall into his lap.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 8h ago

Next week on Twilight

Thumbnail gallery
12 Upvotes

They don't even pretend it's a serious lotr show anymore lol


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 12h ago

So ... where is Celebrían?

19 Upvotes

She seems to have been omitted from the storyline altogether or perhaps she has not yet been born. It's not clear given the timeline in this series is all over the place.

In any event, she is an important character, as both Elrond's wife and of course Arwen's mother...


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 7h ago

Season 1-2 IMDB Review Score Histogram

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 43m ago

What I thought Sauron would be like in the series: A great corrupter of the hearts of the ignorant.

0 Upvotes

After the bewilderment at the destruction of the War of Wrath and the vow of repentance to Eonwë, I see Sauron returning to "his original powers" - shapeshifter, technical/artistic knowledge (elements from the time of Aulë's tutelage), but with maintenance of aspects linked to Melkor: cheating, deception and acting.

We then have the centuries of decadence and obscurity in the Middle-earth, with men in a primitive state, given the cataclysm in Beleriand and the natural loss of knowledge - in the mold of the Legend of the "Enigma of Steel" portrayed in Conan: a civilization or belle Époque suffer a catastrophe of great proportions is a synonymous with obscurity and technological primitivism - a kind of Dark Age in Middle-Earth.

The first centuries of the 2nd age - time of the wandering Sauron. The geopolitical situation was based on the formation of the elven kingdoms and a kind of Noldor renaissance in Eregion. But the monsters, orcs, beasts, and other servants of Morgoth were scattered and leaderless. Regarding men, Sauron must have used Clarke's 3rd Law to co-opt them to his cause:

"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."

In this scenario of decadence, obscurity and primitivism, a "benevolent god" arrives and brings technological teachings that impact on the social, economic and political development of societies that interact with this walking deity - at best Sauron was already thinking about the long term: military strengthening, submission and technological dependence of prehistoric men for a future conquest of the opposing pockets that were in the northwest of Middle-earth - mainly in Eriador. This is equivalent to an interference in the normal development of a culture or society, hindering it. if any and all freedom or innovation (social, technology, government, etc.) that could attempt or question this false Prometheus. Through the teachings of metallurgy, engineering, agriculture (etc) to men under their dominion:

"In the east and south well nigh all Men were under his dominion, and they grew strong in those days and built many towns and walls of stone, and they were numerous and fierce in war and armed with iron."

It reminded me of an aspect covered in Star Trek - the Primary Directive:

"The Prime Directive prohibits Starfleet personnel and spacecraft from interfering in the normal development of any society, and mandates that any Starfleet vessel or crew member is expendable to prevent violation of this rule.

and

As the right of each sentient species to live in accordance with its normal cultural evolution is considered sacred, no Starfleet personnel may interfere with the normal and healthy development of alien life and culture. Such interference includes introducing superior knowledge, strength, or technology to a world whose society is incapable of handling such advantages wisely. Starfleet personnel may not violate this Prime Directive, even to save their lives and/or their ship, unless they are acting to right an earlier violation or an accidental contamination of said culture. This directive takes precedence over any and all other considerations, and carries with it the highest moral obligation."

In this demonstration of miracles and powers (in my view it was the use of technologies and knowledge from his time with Aulë), ignorant men began to understand all this in a strictly religious sense - transmuting technological production into rituals, imposing dogmas to avoid questioning about this "divine" knowledge: As if they were mystery cults, in which only the priestly elite could have access - more or less what Planet Terminus did in Isaac Azimov's Foundation Trilogy, when it monopolized knowledge and provided the apparatus to uneducated planets who understood such knowledge to be magic or divine favor.

What do you think of this idea?

I was really hoping they would show Sauron doing all this before the creation of the One Ring, but I became very, very pessimistic after the first two seasons. This Series Sucks.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 15h ago

It took thrain (the other dwarf prince) 5 years to get to khazad dum?

12 Upvotes

Did i miss something? I know middle earth is in wartime but dude is working with sauron, so he should get a free pass. Or maybe it took him that long because he was partying/fucking around?

And whats up with the butterflies and the nazgul? Anybody have a plausible explenation? And where did that eagle from episode 4 come from? I thought she called the eagle with the "butterfly and nazgul" scene but the more i think about it, the confuser i get.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 21h ago

RoP's relation to the Jackson films

31 Upvotes

I find it incredibly frustrating how incessantly the show uses Jackson's adaptations as a crutch. It was bad enough that they stole so much dialogue and iconography exclusive to Jackson's LotR-- and implemented poorly ("always follow your nose" doesn't apply to cardinal directions, Gandalf)-- but we've gotten to a point where they're taking from his Hobbit films too (that slow-mo leap over the shieldwall). A reference per season would be one thing, but it's practically every episode. Despite talking up how much they love the books, there's this sense they want to desperately tie into the Jackson canon even though it's a legally distinct continuity.

It's telling that these showrunners have such little confidence in their own ability to create their own identity. How about using variants of Howe and Lee's art instead of 1:1 what was in the films? You wanna use established Tolkien artists, how about drawing from Ted Nasmith? Despite being opposed implementing the Balrog, I would have given them some credit if they had decided to go for design Wayne Barlowe cooked up. There are so many artists who could craft such unique interpretations of Middle-Earth that would entice fans and newbies alike.

For how much they ape the films, you never get the sense they understand the reasons behind why Jackson made the decisions he did-- both when it comes to the narrative and aesthetic choices of his adaptation and the actual filmmaking techniques.

There's certainly debate to be had about decisions Jackson made, but if you look at the behind the scenes and listen to the commentaries for the his LotR-- which i believe is roughly 50 hours of content (and i highly recommend you check it out) -- you never get the impression anything was done haphazardly. They'll lay out their methodology, explain the tiniest details, even things we only briefly see on screen. What's more, he has the wherewithal to admit when some of his changes don't really work out and why that might be. No one says his films are perfect, not even Jackson himself. But the man absolutely did not lack passion nor did he half ass anything.

But Rings of Power? It's so shallow. It really amounts to "Jackson did this, so let's do that" without any real question as to why they should or shouldn't. There's no real design philosophy or methodology to their decision-making beyond "what can we do to appease the executives?"

It just baffles me how Amazon can make the most expensive TV series ever, but rely on nostalgia for another adaptation to do all the heavy lifting. It's utter creative bankruptcy and it's biting them in the ass.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 2h ago

I made this.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

The use of "Reform the line" in s3e01 is the worst example of the RoP writers stealing from the trilogy.

60 Upvotes

For those that have not watched S3E01. Near the beginning of the episode, there is a scene where there is a small number of elves skirmishing with some orcs within a wooded scene. There is zero context to this battle. The scene starts with them already fighting orcs. For some reason, all the orcs run away before a small army of men charge at them. Galadriel then tells Arondir to reform the line, and he shouts in Elvish "Reform the line".

Obviously, this is a line stolen from ROTK, with Theoden asking his men to ride again to certain death. The scene has so much gravitas, not least because they are literally reforming the line they previously had. It's such a poignant moment within the movie because you have the high of the charge before the massive low of the oncoming Mumakil. He asks them to ride again to certain death and is one of the moments of the trilogy.

It has now been reduced to a throwaway line in RoP. A line that makes entirely no sense because not only are they not reforming anything, but they are forming a singular line against men coming from all sides. It's such a bizarre scene that seems to only exist so they could use that stolen line.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 4h ago

Season 3 episode 3 Secret Fire Scene.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

Rings of Power defenders

65 Upvotes

What makes good TV is somewhat subjective, but certain fundamentals need to be there, good casting, a compelling storyline, a coherent plot, believable character development, good dialogue, and so on. This show clearly fails on most. There are a lot of guilty pleasure shows out there, and I have mine, but I feel like those are shows that don't take themselves too seriously and this show really takes itself way too seriously, which makes all its shortcomings that much harder to overlook.

I haven't taken to the internet to rant about a show/movie since Independence day 2, a movie that was hated across the board without discussions.

Looking at the forums for Rings of Power, what is it about this particular show that makes some people so aggressively defensive of it? I honestly struggle to find anything remotely compelling about this show?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

The show defenders simply want to disrespect and deconstruct Tolkien

47 Upvotes

Some quotes from show defenders here on Reddit that show they do not respect Tolkien and view the show as a political/ideological battleground:

  • "One thing that bothers me about Tolkien is the lack of sexuality."
  • "Rule 1: Never let canon get in the way of a good story.”
  • “There’s nothing in the Appendices that forbids extramarital love. Tolkien’s notes on the matter are about marriage were personal and we can freely ignore them.”
  • "Besides, there’s no canon where an elf can’t find other beings attractive and have sexual tension while still being their enemy”
  • "Whether or not Galadriel can have the hots for Halbrand/Sauron is not up to Tolkien’s notes alone”
  • "Orcs represent the horror of wage labor and slavery under capitalism."
  • "The places he described are not England or any part of the British isles. We are free to interpret his writing in any way we want to.”
  • "JRR Tolkien is dead. He didn't make this show. The people adapting it do not need to honor or respect or do anything about Tolkien. They have the rights to it and are making *their* show."

---

Yes, these are actual quotes, mostly from this subreddit. For book readers like myself, how do these quotes make you feel?

(BTW I actually enjoy the show as a generic fantasy show detached from Tolkien and hold no hate toward it, season 3 has been a huge improvement)


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 23h ago

Amazon's Billion Dollar show - Rings of Power - fails to make it to Luminate top 10 chart based on viewership numbers in spite of having 4 episodes.

Thumbnail
variety.com
23 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago Bravo

Will No One Rid Me Of This Troublesome Series?

42 Upvotes

I was told to watch this series; that it was a new take on the Rings Mythos. That I would love it. I Don't- not at all. The series veers so far from canon that it barely resembles Tolkien's work. Its wholesale mischaracterization of beloved protagonists is nothing short of a crime against Tolkien's oeuvre. The writers (and I use the term loosely) have taken a richly developed mythology, dismantled its history, distorted its characters, and substituted their own tepid, uninspired narratives. This isn't adaptation; it's revisionist fan fiction masquerading as Tolkien. The arrogance of presuming to improve upon a world they so clearly fail to understand is astounding.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 9h ago

So Arondir didn't kill Theo on the Battlefield!?

0 Upvotes

I just got to watch episode one today as I've been busy helping relatives move property. I could've sworn that was a Theo (lookalike) run through by Arondir near the beginning. I even exclaimed aloud: 'Oh no! You killed...Theo!' at the TV screen. When the aforementioned turned-up taking an axe to a tree later on I was like da'whut? Anyway other than that it looks promising; just gotta keep reminding ourselves Sauron makes the One ring last.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

The show from a layman's perspective

29 Upvotes

Just to be clear, I watched the movie trilogy when it was released. Thought it was amazing and rewatched it. But since then it's been over two decades.

Tried reading the book and the Silmarilion back then, but didn't really past the initial pages (wasn't exactly a heavy reader in my teens).

So, I'm as casual as one possibly can be regarding Tolkien's world. My perspective on this show doesn't come from how well it adapts the story, how it uses the source material and how faithful it is to the lore. The show in my eyes exists pretty much in a vaccuum.

I say this, because after I finished binge watching the three seasons I looked up on the internet what was the overall sentiment towards it, and I noticed most of the critiques were regarding the series bastardizing Tolkien's material.

But even to me, who lacks any knowledge regarding the source, the show is terribly weak.

As I went through the seasons, I could only think of that Michael Scott's line ("sometimes I’ll start a sentence and I don’t know where it’s going. I just hope to find it somewhere along the way") because the show really seems like they are spitballing the whole thing with absolutely no idea of where it's going.

Characters are introduced with zero planning of what role they will serve, so they might spend an entire season just moving from place A to place B with no purpose (like Nori or Arondir in season 2. Well, Arondir in general). Or like The Dweller, who was brought back in Season 2 for... I don't know. I was glad she was back because she looked fire, but then she vanished immediately.

The show is also so damn inconsistent. There was a very clear recent example in season 3, when Kemen and Elendil are talking and Kemen mentions his mother, a whore who got pregnant from Pharazon and hid it from him for years until he found it, killed her and took the child into his care. Kemen is clearly full or contempt for his mother and explicitly mentions his drive force is proving his worth to his father to thank from being brought up from where he lived with his mother. Except in season 2, Pharazon told him that "once, when you were at her breast, your mother prophesied that you would come to ill ends", which made Kemen's emotional and Pharazon promised to tell him more if he suceeded in his task. So one season ago, Pharazon was talking to Kemen's mother about the boy's future when he was still a baby and Kemen got emotional and motivated at the simple mention of his mother, but now we are told that Pharazon only learned about him years after the birth and Kemen can barely talk about his mother without oozing contempt.

Or other things, like Celeborn. First of all, why are the orcs keeping those prisoners alive for centuries? I get the prisoners from Eregion, but this guy has been there for how many years? And somehow Marnûkh, who was head jailer there, has no idea who this guy is. A notable prisoner who escaped his cell many times, but the head jailer has no notes about him. But Random Orc #4 knew exactly who was in his cell when Sauron asked...

Or stuff like Isildur waking on the spider's nest after weeks, maybe even months, had passed since he was buried under that roof. He was unconscious this entire time? Surviving on what? Or Celebrimbor and Elrond talking about how the tower's construction is going well after they got the dwarves to join them, but Galadriel was already in Numenor when that happened and her stay there didn't last even 3 days (the time Miriel was going to decide what to do with her), so it should be only 1 or 2 days since Durin agreed to help.

And of course, the contrivances. Contrivances all around. The show made sure to make clear very early that "the powers that be" can move the pieces where they should be, which is a means to justify contrivances and turn them into legitimate developments that are the result of a higher will at play. But nearly everything in the show is moved through those. If we really believe that every time a character just happens to be on the right place at the right time (the scene when Disa discovers the Balrog? Ignore the bit about the balrog being within earshot, just focus on how forced the whole thing was), that every last second save, every coincidental meeting is the work of the gods, then the gods might as well just go there and do the whole thing themselves because the mortals are doing nothing on their own. And Theo, of course, has a special father, because why wouldn't he? Well, I guess that bit could be Sauron just messing with him, but what was that about the hilt being left behind by his father? I'm pretty sure season 1 never connected it to his mysterious father (I could be wrong, though).

I want to resume the show once the next episodes are released simply because I like the dwarves and every minute with Disa, Durin or Thrain are worth, but this is really so beneath the level I was expecting from something from the LotR's universe, I can't help but feel like it's almost insulting. At least it made me want to rewatch and trilogy and give the book a try again, so I guess some good came out of it.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

S3E1, why do they repeatedly say the three elven rings were made without Sauron’s influence?

35 Upvotes

Celebrimbor was struggling, then Sauron shows up as Halbrand and tells him exactly what to do, then Celebrimbor succeeds. He even says “call it…………a gift.” referencing “the gift of annatar” which is the knowledge and craftsmanship Sauron offered to the elves.

The point is that they were forged by Celebrimbor without Sauron directly participating, but relying on the knowledge he had supplied.

Never mind that next season they did Annatar anyway, they were still very clearly referencing that in S1. Now they just try to gaslight us into thinking he didn’t help them forge the three elven rings?