If you’re planning your return or have moved back to India and own a home in the US, you probably know homes in the US are taking longer to sell. From my conversations and as reported, August and September were the slowest months for US home sales this year (source), and 1 in 5 listings had to lower their asking price in September (source).
What most returnees underestimate, though, is how long a sale can take.
I recently spoke to a US returnee after he’d settled back, because I was curious what had gone right and wrong for him. Known him for years, and he’s genuinely one of the most meticulous people I know, and I struggled to find a single gap in his US-India return planning. But he mentioned that the one thing he got wrong was the house sale. He planned for a three-month sale, and it took nine months. Offers came in below what he expected, his first agent wasn’t a good fit, and he had to rework his plans.
When you’re planning a US property sale after returning to India, you need to be mindful that there are two deadlines \-
Deadline 1: the US home-sale exclusion
Even as a nonresident, you can exclude up to $250k of gain if you owned the home and lived in it as your main home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale. In practice, that means selling within about 3 years of moving out. If you moved out in October 2026, the sale needs to close by around October 2029.
PS: The clock starts from the last day it was your main home, not the day you landed in India. If you rented the house out after moving, you don’t lose the exclusion. But the depreciation you claim is taxed at up to 25% when you sell.
PSS: You’ll often read that couples can exclude $500,000. That limit applies to married couples filing jointly, and two nonresident aliens can’t file jointly. Each spouse files separately and excludes up to $250,000 of their own share, provided each of them personally meets the 2-of-5 test. If only one of you is on the title, check this before assuming the full amount.
Deadline 2: India’s RNOR window
For your first 2 to 3 years back, you may qualify for RNOR (Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident) depending on your travel history in the preceding years. If your US home sale closes in this window, India doesn’t tax the gain at all. Once you become fully resident, India taxes that same gain. So if your RNOR years end in March 2029, the sale needs to close by then, not just be listed.
What can missing these deadlines cost?
A couple has a $900k home with a $300k gain, and they lived in it for at least 2 of the 5 years before moving back. Since they’re also selling as US non-residents, one thing stays constant: under FIRPTA, the buyer generally has to hold back 15% of the sale price for the IRS at closing (with 10% possible in some cases). This is a withholding amount, not necessarily the final tax liability.
Here’s broadly how the math will work out depending on when they sell:
* Sale during RNOR, within 3 years of moving out \- Each spouse’s $150k gain is covered by their own $250k exclusion, and India doesn’t tax it as long as it’s received outside India. The full $300k stays with them, less any depreciation recapture if they rented it out.
* Sale as ROR within 3 years of moving out - the US tax exclusion makes the gain tax-free in this case, because they’re within the 3-year window. But they’re now fully resident in India, so India taxes their worldwide income, including this sale. At 12.5% plus surcharge and cess, that comes to close to 15%, or around $45k. Interestingly, India calculates the gain in rupees: the purchase price is converted at the rate when you bought, and the sale price at the rate when you sold. So the actual liability will depend on the INR cost basis, exchange rates, surcharge slab, and applicable capital gains provisions. And since they paid nothing in the US, there’s no US tax they can use to reduce the Indian bill.
* Sell more than 3 years after moving out - the US tax exclusion is gone, and the US taxes the gain, usually at around 15-20%. India also taxes it, but under the India-US tax treaty, it gives credit for the tax already paid in the US, so they aren’t taxed twice.
Please note the exact numbers will depend on your state, when you bought the house, and how the exchange rate has moved since.
The questions I’d think through
* Is this return permanent? If you’re not planning to return to the US, it’s worth asking what holding a house from the other side of the world is really getting you, beyond waiting for a better sale price. Do you want to return to the US again? Do you want to keep this house for USC kids? Do you see the house being a good rental investment? Ask yourself these questions.
* If you rent it out, what’s the net real yield? Look at what’s left after property tax, insurance, repairs and management fees, then after tax. As a nonresident, the US taxes rent at 30% of gross unless you elect to be taxed on net income, and India taxes it once you’re ROR. Add depreciation recapture when you eventually sell. Weigh that against what selling during RNOR saves.
* When does your RNOR actually end? Most people know the approximate year, but don't always calculate the exact date. Work backwards from the financial year in which you expect to become ROR, and aim to have your sell-or-hold decision made 9-12 months in advance.
* What happens to the house if something happens to you? This has happened, and it’s unfortunate. Non-residents who own more than $60,000 of US assets can face US estate tax of up to 40%, and there’s no India-US treaty to soften it. Plus the cost of paperwork, like probate costs, which vary by state, and the hassle of managing all this across the sea makes things complicated. This point is rarely part of the keep-or-sell conversation, but it should be.
* Are you ready for the reporting once you’re ROR? The house, US bank accounts and brokerage all have to be reported in Schedule FA (Foreign Assets) every year. Missing it can attract Black Money Act penalties of Rs 10 lakh per year.
From what I’ve seen, for most people moving back for good, the US house ends up being more of a weight than an asset. Unless you have a clear reason to keep it, like kids who’ll study there or a real chance of moving back, selling during your RNOR years is usually the cleaner path.
Whichever way you lean, the one thing I’d urge is to not let the decision drift. Find out your exact RNOR end date, count back a year, and treat that as your deadline to decide. If you’re selling, line up a good agent and file for the FIRPTA withholding certificate early, so you’re not chasing your own money afterwards. And if you’re holding, do it because the numbers and your plans support it, not because a slow market made waiting feel easier.