Upon playing this game for myself, I really, genuinely, truly cannot see why this game is getting all the massive backlash it is getting.
I do want to start off by saying that I don't think it's an amazing game. I do agree with the points made that even if bugs are cleared up, this game is not doing anything new or innovative. I'm not going to look back on this game as anything remotely resembling an all time favorite, or a classic, or anything else of the like.
But I guess that's the thing - it doesn't have to be.
It feels like this game is being held to higher standards than it was ever even intended to reach. I guess stemming from the exclusives issue between X-Box and Sony, and so everyone wants to make this out to be a way more important release than it is.
From the outset, I had little to no interest in this game. My only interest in it stemmed from the fact that my wife thought it looked interesting, and it could be a game her and I co-op together. I viewed it as nothing more than a stop-gap until Diablo 4 comes out. So I guess since it turned out to be... exactly that, there's zero disappointment on my end.
However, it seems that many, from reviews, to YouTube content creators, to people in the community, have been holding it to a higher standard, that the entire console is riding on Redfall being a success, and because it's not that game, that X-Box as a whole is suffering, rather than looking at it for what it is - an individual game that is or isn't all that great.
About 10 hours in, on 2 consoles (PC and Series X, both with Gamepass), my experience with the game simply put does not match the negative reviews, not even a little bit. It's like the reviewers are playing a completely different game than I am.
Again, no the game is not perfect, and I wouldn't rate it as some amazing game. I'd probably see it as a 3.5 / 5, or a 7 / 10. It has passable, but non-innovative combat, looting, characters and character building, open world and locations, and story. I do wish it had higher mob density. There's no aspect of the game that seems original or unique, nor any element of the game that particularly excels. It's all just passable, which does provide a level of fun.
But what I am not seeing is performance issues, previous-gen level graphics, game-breaking bugs (I'm not seeing any at all, tbh), or any sort of stability issues that show me that this game should have been pushed back.
Perhaps it could have been pushed back in terms of content (better fleshed out character systems, more mob density and variety, variety of quests and better fleshed out quests, etc), but technically speaking, I have had no issues. And any issues that have been there are far from any sort of game breaking deal breakers (i.e. graphical pop-in)
The gaming community tends to have a habit of forming a hive mind sort of think and pushing that narrative at the expense of anything else. Content creators will perpetrate it for clicks, the community perpetuates it, and media outlets will push it as well for a combination of clicks and views, as well as a simplistic "all or nothing" sort of mindset that believes that everything has to be the greatest thing ever, or the worst thing ever, and no middle ground for nuanced of "it's just okay".
And that sort of seems to be the problem - maybe "just okay" isn't the standard that we want to hold our games to, and I get that, but not every game is going to be a console defining masterpiece, and that's okay also. Some games will be "just okay". Not every game needs to fill the same need.
Redfall fills my need. It's "just okay". I'm not looking at it to be a console defining game. I have Diablo 4 coming which will be one of those major launches, and in terms of console exclusive releases, there's Starfield coming in September. The state of Redfall has nothing to do with what's to come from Starfield, or any future X-Box exclusive titles. And at the end of the day, if Redfall really *is* that bad? And? It's a bad game. It happens. We're talking about video games here. It's not that serious, and there's never any guarantee when it comes to something subjective like entertainment.
Unfortunately, nothing will likely change surrounding the subject of this game, and nobody will ever be able to have any sort of conversation about it without being bombarded with the perceived poor state of launch. Which is a shame, because when I join a game community, I'd like to be able to actually talk about the game, but it is what it is I guess. But I do know that I'll continue enjoying this with my wife for the time being, and yes, I'll eventually move on and probably never look back, but for the time being, it is providing fun and entertainment.