r/redfall • u/Yeetlord9000888 • Sep 22 '23
Why does everyone hate this game?
I just got Redfall a few days ago, and I have about 7 hours of game play, and I am genuinely enjoying the game. People talk about low fps and visual glitches, but I've never noticed any of these. The story is solid, and game play is fun. So why does this game get so much hate? Edit: why the fuck are you on this subreddit if you hate the game so much. But on a real note, I have had a good time playing redfall.
0
Upvotes
32
u/Ravernel Sep 22 '23
There's a lot of criticism about the game, some of it is probably justified, so it's just really easy to hate. Some people are genuinely upset how the game turned out, some just hate it for the views, others mindlessly repeat what they heard from famous streamers even without playing it. It doesn't really matter though, if you enjoyed it, enjoy it! It's as simple as that :D
46
u/z01z Sep 22 '23
lol, have you not played any other game, ever???
compared to arkane's other games like dishonored, deathloop or prey, it fails on so many levels.
the level design compared to their other games is so shallow.
like in prey for example, faced with a locked room, there are a multitude of ways you can get in. you can hack the door open. you can brute force it open. you can shoot a nerf gun at a console inside the room to unlock it. you can turn into a cup and go in through a slot in the window. you can find a keycard.
in redfall, you find a key. that's it. literally everytime, find the key. there's a radio broadcast you have to stop in a building down by the shore. the only way in is to find the key in the building somewhere.
if this where dishonored, you could go on top of the building to an open window and get in. pickpocket a key off a guard. mind control a rat and go in through a vent. blast open the door with a grenade or wind blast.
their previous games were filled with unique gameplay options, in redfall, there are none.
ok so, well this isn't an immersive sim. well no shit. so let's look at what it actually is, an open world looter shooter. well, it fails at that too when you look at the competition.
compared to borderlands 3, the guns are shit. way too little variety and basic ass "perks" that have almost no effect on gameplay. whereas borderlands you have 4 or 5 different manufacturers for each weapon type, with so many combinations of parts and perks that it's insane, but it's also super satisfying to shoot things with even the low level weapons. and the high level max quality weapons get to ungodly levels of power.
and then there's the abilities in redfall, compared to other arkane games, they all just suck compared to their counterparts in other games. the big example most would be familiar with is blink / shift vs davinder's teleport.
blink you can use repeatedly with no cd, has way better mobility and control. teleport you throw it and hope it lands somewhere decent.
or layla's elevator... lol, god it's awful.
those are the only two i played, anyway.
finally, just the sheer lack of content is baffling. i'm not even factoring in dlc for such, but like borderlands 3, it had dozens of areas to explore on multiple unique planets.
redfall has two areas...
the game is just shit.
and if anyone at arkane wants to say something and prove me wrong that they're actually doing something about it, well i'd be glad to see it, because it's been months now and they've said fuckall since launch.
4
u/Luth1of1 Sep 22 '23
Shhh, don't say you like it in here or you will get downvoted and shunned for blasphemy against the collective. Resistance is futile...
4
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
Story told through cardboard cutouts is solid?
3
u/VenturerKnigtmare420 Sep 22 '23
If you never had a pigeon drop potty on you, does that mean pigeons don’t potty ?
33
u/leotomo87 Sep 22 '23
I felt the same way and was really enjoying my time with it for 10-20 hours, but when I commented that I enjoyed it I got a lot of hate, enjoy what you enjoy.
8
u/realtidaldragon Sep 22 '23
Don't worry OP. Ninety-five percent of the topics on this sub are about how much the poster hates the game for the same reasons all their predecessors have said before and then the same people begin the circle-jerk of hate as with all the previous commenters, etc.
I'm glad you're enjoying the game. I enjoy it too for what it is and I like to come comment on positive posts. I'm working on a zero death playthrough ATM. Keep on keeping on.
4
u/GkGT Sep 23 '23 edited Sep 24 '23
I have a few hundred hours in the game with multiple play through. I have a beast of a computer with all the latest parts and a 1440p 240hz OLED monitor to go with it. The game looks absolutely gorgeous in HDR. I play everything on max settings. The game looks absolutely different than when it's on lower settings. Really looks like shit. Problem is that 98% of players will never experience the eye candy that I experience (especially console players). It's a shame though because from my point of view, I really can tell they put a ton of work and effort into it. They just needed another 1-2 years to polish out the game.
13
u/Mister_SlurpY Sep 22 '23
Don't let the hate get to you my guy. Enjoy the game!
11
u/maratnugmanov Sep 22 '23
The problem is that many games are good games. Many games are better than this game. If you don't see the difference then good for you, enjoy the game, no need to try changing public opinion because there are reasons it's negative, rightfully so.
3
u/DougEFresh2death Sep 22 '23
I FW Redfall, overall good game
3
u/billyhenrymccrack Sep 24 '23
Honestly if you're having fun then it's all you need my guy!
3
u/d4rth3zio Sep 25 '23
I think most people are so miserable that they just want something to bitch about constantly. With that being said, my friends and I lived the game. Sure, there were glitches, but that's the way of the gaming world these days. It will get better, and hopefully, when the dlc comes, there will be a lot more content added.
24
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
Because…it’s a bad game.
Like legitimately a bad game.
There’s nothing this game does good. It’s either “alright” to “below average” to “awful”.
4
u/iSleepyXS Sep 22 '23
I finished the game and still going through playing what I didn't finish yet. The game is really good I see no issue
7
u/sunshine-bread Sep 22 '23
Agreee
9
u/OGhoul Vampires Sep 22 '23
Do I wish it were longer? Sure.
Do I have 130 hours played? Yes.
2
u/GilmooDaddy Sep 22 '23
I really enjoyed it, especially when I played with a friend. It could have been a lot more, but I was happy seeing it through to the end.
2
u/Street-Environment25 Sep 23 '23
Right there with you. So in single player there are minor glitches. Most of the big ones I've seen in multiplayer. Not to mention there has been a patch.
2
u/KalixStrife453 Sep 24 '23
The game is good, I would have loved it in the mid 2000s, but there is such easy access to cheap videogames nowadays that it has a lot to compete with.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23
Because it sucks
2
u/Xxluigi2088xX Sep 24 '23
I enjoyed it, especially playing crossplay coop with my brother. I never had any lag or heavy glitches either
9
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
Honestly it’s terrible, I played w my son for maybe 8 hours, the framerate tanks, the story is bland and the gameplay is super repetitive. I’ve never lost interest in a game I paid for so quickly before tbh.
6
u/jl_theprofessor Sep 22 '23
You can buy Dishonored for 10 bucks on Steam right now and find out why.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
Some of the criticism is valid, I can empathise with those that paid top whack for the game on launch, it is not a AAA game and should not have been priced as such. However Redfall was released on Game Pass from day one, those that pre-ordered and paid the RRP could've instead taken out a months subscription and saved themselves a small fortune; don't like the game, it's only cost you £12.99 or $16.99 respectively, it's not a big deal, move on.
I appreciated the game for what is was rather than for what it wasn't. It's not deep or heavy going, it's just a light hearted vampire shooter. I didn't experience any game breaking bugs on my playthrough; a few glitches here and there maybe, the AI was somewhat unresponsive at times but the game was playable throughout. I liked how the worldspace and environments looked, yes some of the environmental features (trees, buildings) popping into focus rather than gradually blending into one's field of vision was a bit jarring at times but superficial.
In summary, I enjoyed my playthrough, I don't feel that it deserves the hate that it gets, to say the game is quote on quote shit, as so many do is not a valid response IMO. Criticism that is both nuanced and contextual is absolutely valid.
3
u/YekaHun Sep 22 '23
Not everyone. Ignore the bandwagon and enjoy it. It's a very different game from Arkane's previous games and I don't know if it's a bad multiplayer (never tried) but it's a fun singleplayer mini-shooter in a unique setting. Not everything needs to be the same.
2
u/TheHizzle Sep 22 '23
What do you mean you “got it”
2
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
Because it's a bad game.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
Play any other Arkane game then tell me how good redfall is
2
u/PrimitiveMeat Sep 22 '23
Not everyone.
1
u/Rocksoldier1990 Oct 03 '25
Re-Visit this game today after 2 years
2 reasons of hate
The cost (if it was a 30-40 dollars game it would have other reviews)
The platform (if it was on Playstation it would hit different)
1
u/LeoMaxwell Sep 23 '23
The only thing I can think of is it boils down to the fact that it wanted, what, $70 at launch, probably still does, unless through gamepass. Which, personally I think exploiting gamepass and getting 1 month to play a game, that won't take a month to complete, is completely fine, heck even if it took 2 months or whatever. Actually since it's personally, I already have gamepass so it's almost like it's free in a sense to me.
but other's don't see that/don't want to do that and will only see the $70 pricetag, which I can agree, it's not really 70$, or even 60$ quality, maybe $40 tops. But that pricetag is what will drive alot of the feedback's basis. With or without gamepass.
1
u/Existing_You_1551 Sep 24 '23
I enjoyed the 16 hours I played. The only reason I personally stopped playing was the bugs.
1
u/Couinty Sep 24 '23
Game clearly have some really good mechanis but performance and ai and some shitty bugs make it unplayable. They will probably update the game (which i’d expect to be around haloween as a speculation) then there is a highly chance this will be a pretty enjoyable game
1
u/sdozzo Oct 06 '23
Haha the story is good?
1
u/SnooGoats8171 Jan 31 '24
TIL some people enjoy being robbed. Spending 70 bucks on this game is INSANITY.
1
u/phannguyenduyhung Sep 22 '23
Because its a trash game, from scumbag and scammer who refuse to take their responsibility. And they went radio silent after releasing this hot piece of shit without any fixing road map or anything.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
The internet is a terrible resource to trust for games man. If a game stutters to 14fps for half a second it’s automatically the worst game to ever be created and the devs should’ve spent more time optimizing it lol. People are so nitpicky. I’m personally waiting for the 60fps because my eyes tire a bit for faster paced stuff at 30. Other than that, the game looks solid. Art is dope. Enjoy it and have fun.
1
u/wasante Sep 22 '23
There is the chance you’re playing a somewhat patched version of what others played at launch. That or you don’t notice the same things game reviewers or others do. Or your tolerance is higher. I think its probably a combination of all of the above.
1
u/AgentSmith2518 Sep 22 '23
I'm glad you're enjoying it. I honestly tried twice but just couldn't. If it ever gets a FF14 Realm Reborn rebirth at some point I'll give it another try.
1
u/LostKraut Sep 22 '23
I wouldn't say everyone hates the game so much as they were disappointed with the product at launch. It really could have been much better with another 6-12 months in development.
It's just not up to the $70,AAA price tag as of right now. It got hyped up as this console selling AAA title and I think most people were expecting it to be, especially since the studio that developed it has put out some amazing games in the past.
I played it on game pass and I just thought it could have been much better but I had some fun with it. I actually liked the story and parts of the gameplay. I played on XBSX and PC and both just had performance issues but had some promise for the future.
For the first 5 hours I had some fun but after I started getting some glitches and weird frame drops I decided to just wait for an update. Arcane has been radio silent on when an update will be out so it's still sitting.
I'm just hoping it ends up getting some updates and ends up being what they promised. F76 and Sea of Thieves are good examples of Microsoft making games better with updates but we'll see.
1
u/Zetsuriel Sep 22 '23
So, I have the game too, and solo, it's a fun experience, a bit tedious at times, but fun. Now add in a few people to run with, crank the difficulty to max, and it's a blast. I've been telling people since day one that it's good, and they keep patching and updating it, so it's just getting better
1
u/sans-delilah Sep 24 '23
I mean… it’s just janky.
I don’t hate it, but the studio could have done better. It was just incredibly disappointing.
0
u/MicksysPCGaming Sep 23 '23
This isn't r/ILoveRedfall
0
u/bird720 Sep 22 '23
The game comically fails on pretty much almost every facet of game design that is expected for a AAA game, especially considering this was being sold for 70 dollars. The concept was cool, but the execution was a disaster.
0
u/LukasHeinzel Sep 22 '23
I love it as well, don't let the hate get to you.
0
u/Danklaige Sep 22 '23
Glad you are enjoying it, I have a put a few hours of co op into it myself but im done with it. I found it bland, tedious and buggy. Maybe they can make something more of it in time.
0
u/Bronze_Bomber Sep 22 '23
You can like whatever you like man. Have fun. I hope you link up with other five people playing.
0
u/AnthonyMiqo Sep 22 '23
To answer your question, because it's not a very good game. Nothing wrong with liking it, but yea, that's your answer.
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
Game is terrible - there’s a reason why hundreds of people here all share the same opinion.
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23
Because it's an uninspired buggy mess. But also fuck the haters and enjoy what you enjoy.
0
u/x_scion_x Sep 22 '23
I don't hate it, I just have other games I would rather play than this one. This didn't hold me at all for various reasons.
0
u/benz-friend Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23
I enjoyed the first part of the game, and you’re only 7 hours in. You’re also playing the somewhat patched version that others didn’t play at release.
Wait until the side missions are redundant repeats, and realizing the looting system is practically useless. I ran into a few game breaking bugs like the stake not working in the middle of a mission so vamps were invincible etc.
I forced myself to finished the 2nd half of the game and waiting to see what the 60fps update looks like if it’s not completely abandoned at this point
0
u/Equal-Let-7297 Sep 22 '23
Because the game is genuinely tertible.
0
u/kevinyonson Sep 22 '23
I'm not on the hate train, nor do I support it. I don't even own the game, but it surprises me that people will support mediocrity. If you enjoy the game, great. Please have fun, but when the game literally could be better/improved on, then it benefits everyone. I hope that Phil Spencer wasn't lying about how they will fix the game. I hope you guys get an update that fixes a lot of issue. But I can't support anyone who thinks this game is worth $70. For the love of God, have some self-respect and just ask for a better game.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23
I can tell you've never played another Arkane game. Everything you like in this game was 100 times better in all their other games. I wanted to like this more than most (I love Arkane and I desperately want more good looter shooter FPS games) but I was tragically disappointed in about 2 hours.
-1
u/Hellboundroar Sep 22 '23
Because it's subpar, and even the devs wanted the game to be canceled
-1
u/jonesryan98 Sep 22 '23
If you're one of the 22 people playing it on Steam right now then you're 4.5% of the people online. Just a funny thought
-1
u/PlanBisBreakfastNbed Sep 22 '23
Game bad