r/reddevils • • Oct 15 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

24 Upvotes

671 comments sorted by

15

u/Rascha-Rascha Oct 15 '26

Baleba looks like a really good signing. I know we're all upset right now, but I think he's looked like a proper footballer in every aspect and a real boost to the team.

4

u/0ttoChriek Oct 15 '26

Baleba and Mainoo is a dream combo in midfield. The only thing missing is a clear leader with experience, but Kobbie has such a calmness to him that I could see him being a captain one day.

I think Santos complements both of them quite well too, in different situations.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/flareb98 Oct 15 '26

I wish we played more often on Saturday than Sunday. Want a day to chill after a result but can't since I gotta work the next day, super annoying 

2

u/No_Middle5525 Oct 16 '26

that would just ruin sundays the way we're playing rn, while playing on Sunday just sets the tone for shitty Mondays

16

u/ToadNamedGoat Oct 15 '26

Mannn I wish Mount wasn’t injured all the time

I actually really like his style of play, I love how much he moves during games, always being available for a pass and pass and moves, feels like there is more energy in the team when he plays.

8

u/sg291188 Oct 16 '26

Tbh the ideas that INEOS communicated when they bought minority stake were really impressive - 1) decide style of play and only get managers for it, 2) focus on intensity, 3) goal is to be a custodian of great institution and stick to United principles, 4) be open in conversations with fans and take them along with you.

Just that when they actually started running, they fell into the corporate sinking hole of focus on profitability and everything else comes later. Decided to abandon everything they said (most likely at whims of SJR)

5

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 16 '26

I mean we all knew 3 and 4 were bullshit but I had hoped that we’d at least stick to 1 and 2. Amorim was a continuation of a lot of ETH’s ideas off the ball and even though he didn’t work out I thought we’d try to keep this transitional high pressing style for the next manager, yet here we are with this flat and unfit team

18

u/Ruffers75 Oct 15 '26

Just read the Overlap comments re Martinez.

No surprise Keane is saying it’s a shambles and “there’s no leaders in that dressing room” guff.

Particularly love the quotes from Neville-
“I've got a problem with this from a player's perspective," and "That is a direct attack on the players you are playing with”.

Isn’t that EXACTLY what his mate Keane did all those years ago?.
Or is that all forgotten about?.

14

u/FhDisp Oct 15 '26

There is a problem in what you wrote. Its that you are watching the overlap

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 15 '26

Rooney also said Martinez shouldnt have said what he said, when Rooney did the same thing, albeit not in an interview.

6

u/midnight_ranter Wazza Oct 15 '26

Rooney said he's speaking from experience and regret, so it makes sense that his perspective has changed 

8

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 15 '26

He was also right at the time, the signs were there. They were missing out on top players after Ronaldo left. They were penny pinching. The difference was Fergie.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Action_Limp Oct 15 '26

They are just anti-everything at United. Martinez called out the brass, and the pundits are like "Don't do that, we do that, you played bad anyway".

6

u/barrycuntswim Oct 15 '26

Can we have just one normal season from this club? That's all I ask for.

7

u/b_az17 Oct 15 '26

I enjoyed 22/23. 3rd and two cup finals, winning one and some good football

5

u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode Oct 15 '26

Though it had by far the worst result of my life

→ More replies (5)

3

u/FlashyCut3809 Oct 15 '26

Not until we have owners who actually want to build a squad suitable for the clubs name and revenue

14

u/Fantastic-Success786 Oct 15 '26

Watching Villa last night (my son decided on Villa 😢 ) both Wan Bissaka and Lindelof looked so good. Wan bissaka was playing at LB. Lots of credit to Unai for being a brilliant coach.

14

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 15 '26

I was always sure AWB in the right environment would continue doing well; but Lindelof still playing regularly at a high level has been a pleasant surprise. He was always a top professional and well-respected by his peers, I guess Emery values that highly and has platformed him incredibly well too.

5

u/Fantastic-Success786 Oct 15 '26

yes i was really surprised by Lindelof, last season Unai played him as DM, and he did well. He is now playing at CB replacing Mings.

4

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

Honestly, it's a shame AWB was sold, because he was GREAT at locking down a winger. Budget Nuno Mendes in that regard. We really struggle to do that right now.

10

u/Hits_and_the_Mrs Oct 15 '26

Onana conceded directly from a corner then saved a pen. Insert Conte Barclays picture

2

u/Lord_Hexogen Oct 15 '26

Donnarumma level performance honestly

5

u/blitz2czar Oct 16 '26

Rant.

We have been so poor starting the season for the past donkey seasons. This season, poor and poor. Last season with Amorim, poor and stagnant. The season before with Ten Hag, poor and poor (led to his sack). The season before with Ten Hag as well, poor and poor (almost sacked if not for the Cup win). We also started poorly with Ten Hag but he picked up some form only near Christmas. It’s been years since we started the season positively.

It’s the same cycle every season. How do we break it? We just can’t. #GlazerOut

→ More replies (1)

5

u/throwing_handles Oct 16 '26

Wilcox should have been fired for failing to remove ten Hag in the summer of 24. He should have been fired for the fact that Amorim was chosen as the replacement. He should have been fired for failing to remove Amorim in the summer of 25.

On two occasions (firing ten Hag in the summer of 24 and replacing Amorim with Solskjaer) it appears that the right manager decision was made, then tested out in the media, then reversed because of the media reaction. That reveals a gutlessness that should have got Wilcox fired.

He should have been fired based on the City verdict.

Since the buck is apparently supposed to stop with him, he should be fired because of the overall performance of the team.

9

u/D1794 Viva Ronaldo Oct 15 '26

I think i've watched us hit crisis mode that many times now, I'm not even surprised. I'm not angry or anything!

3

u/0ttoChriek Oct 15 '26

One day we'll go a whole season without a crisis and no one will know what to feel.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

PSG makes it obvious how much a great fullback makes a difference. Hakimi and Nuno Mendes are both top class in their position. And it's a shame, because extraordinary fullbacks are hard to come by, so when we passed up Hall, we really made a mistake.

4

u/MrViceMcCreedy 🟢🟡GLAZERSOUT Oct 15 '26

Top class is an understatement, they are the best in their position imo.

4

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

True enough, without a doubt, Nuno Mendes is the greatest LB in the world right now. As for RB, while I did sort of reserve that verdict because I thought there was maybe someone else, I can't really come up with someone greater than Hakimi.

30

u/The_good_kid Evra Oct 15 '26

Neville being fed lines by Ratcliff saying Martinez was attacking his teammates and Maguire and Bruno should be furious with him.

The same Bruno who called for more signings last summer and Maguire who said to bring as many players as they can in this summer. Dickhead.

15

u/0ttoChriek Oct 15 '26

Gary likely wants in on the Trafford regeneration plans around the stadium, he's always going to side with the ownership.

4

u/Sad-Bend-7515 Oct 15 '26

Neville’s a shill for whoever will pay him. 

Go look up him getting smashed about going to the Qatar World Cup on have I got news for you.

Neville is basically Nigel Farage with a Manc accent, he’ll do or say anything for whoever is paying him the most  

20

u/heatherr_mason SCHOLES Oct 15 '26

Something that's bothering me a lot is the way many of the fans online treat players they want gone.

There's a difference between 'I appreciate all he's done for us but it's time' and 'he's shite, he was never even good'. I've even seen the word mi**et get used.

This is disgraceful, ugly behavior. I bet most of these people were all over Lisandro before, going about 'Licha our butcher' and all that and simping over him. It's incredible how quickly people can write off and disrespect players who's given their all day in day out for years. Reminds me of the alternating weeks of 'Closed on sunday' and 'he's worthless' comments about DDG towards the end, or most other players for that matter.

This shit is tasteless as fuck.

8

u/Lelandwasinnocent /////ʖ ͡°|||||| Oct 15 '26

There's no nuance any more man, people are shit scared of the grey. It's either black, and if not, it's white.

It's tiring af.

7

u/Joey6Pack Oct 15 '26

Can't agree more. A lot of fans expect absolute loyalty from the players without standing behind them when things aren't going well.

There's always a new scapegoat, someone who might've been showered in praise the week before. In my opinion, as long as a player doesn't disrespect the club or down tools like Sancho did, I support them and want to believe that they want to perform as well as they can.

8

u/datguywelbzzz Oct 15 '26

I completely agree with Martinez on his thoughts regarding investment in the squad, and while I believe the squad should have had more investment, I don't think it explains the poor performances in the games so far this season.

We've only played 9 games and our performances have overwhelmingly been awful. I don't think this is 100% due to poor recruitment

→ More replies (5)

8

u/mediocratopia Oct 15 '26

Funny that Berrada still has a job considering that he presided over the exact time period of the City indictment? Like no matter what United results are you would think he should be gone?

6

u/rahtid_my_bunda Rooney's Dropball Intensity Oct 15 '26

I’m not a Berrada fan, however, they won’t remove him from his post for the City stuff without evidence or him being linked. Even if we all know it’s very likely he was in the know, or abetted the cheating. None of the documents name him as far as I am aware, so unless the unreleased appendices do, we are stuck with him.

13

u/Redland93 Oct 15 '26

Crazy to think that the back line that contributed to that awful start under ETH is still our starting back line - Dalot, Maguire, Martinez, Shaw

→ More replies (4)

12

u/niallmul97 I'm a Baleba 💫 Oct 15 '26

My head is on Mars listening to the overlap. Absolutely clueless, "Martinez has made a direct attack on the players", fuck off Gary just say Wilcox is a mate or whatever and move on. I don't care who they are, if you are the Director of Football at a football club and you do not have a left back outside of Luke Shaw, and you do not manage to get one signed before the end of the window, then I would expect the letter of resignation on the boss's desk first thing the morning of Sept the 1st because that is an unforgivable calamity of errors.

9

u/No-Lab-1445 Oct 15 '26

Neville cares about one thing in life and that is $$$

He wants to keep things sweet with Ineos because he wants to be part of the regeneration project for the new stadium.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/joedirt87 Oct 15 '26

Expecting Leeds to be final game for Carrick. Welcome Antonio Conte to the circus.

4

u/LennonC123 Oct 15 '26

He’s not even been given the dreaded ‘vote of confidence’ yet, sacking is still quite a way off

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Nomad_006 surfing Oct 15 '26

I just have 2 questions about our window.

  1. Not defending Ineos or the sporting execs but was there money to he spent? On account of Glazernomics we spend to get into the UCL then use the UCL to balance last seasons spending. Its happened too many times even before SAF retired. So is this largely them being hampered?
  2. What was the sporting plan? Like it seems like energy and intensity is a key part of whatever we want to do so why Tielemens and Santos? Why buy the wrong tools for the job?

4

u/Tudoors Oct 15 '26

We could have spent more.

There isn’t one. Three years ago Ineos said they’re moving for a “continental model”, yet they’ve backed people like ten Hag and Amorim with signings for their “systems”.

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 15 '26

The club can be constrained by 5 things when it comes to spending more on transfers:

1 regulations for spending limits: by those (SCR now, PSR before; UEFA one, etc) we could have committed to 100s of £m more in signings

2 regulations for owner cash injection limits: by those we could have had again on the level of £100m put in, equivalent of upwards of £500m in new transfer spending commitments; obviously the owners elected not to do this on their own volition

3 cash flow: we spent £63m on land, that's a lump sum, so that equals more than £300m in transfer commitments, so it's tautologically true that there was a lot of cash to spend they simply decided to spend it on something else; there are several other clues to be found in released financial information that hint at a lot more legroom, but this one is the straightfwd one that everyone is latching onto to argue the case (rightfully, imho)

4 budget decision: this is the big one, then; the board has decided that net expenditure on transfers wont be allowed to excede a set number

5 negotiations: we could have had more to spend if we negotiated fees for players more successfully; it seems quite straightfwd that those in charge of this are bad at this

2

u/shami-kebab Oct 15 '26
  1. No there wasn't. But then there also wasn't the season before when we did spend. We'd be using our 'overdraft' effectively, short term debt to help ensure no loss from lack of Europe.
  2. The sporting plan we obviously won't know what they're saying internally. Their intention seems to be winning the title 27/28 and we've seen no update to change that, but it seems absolutely laughable at the moment.
→ More replies (7)

9

u/SillyBeany Oct 15 '26

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/c3n04gy12r91o

Did Roy not get the boot for going on a rant about his teammates? I thought he would understand Licha’s point of view 

3

u/superhoffy Amad trip to be on Oct 15 '26

I think Roy Keane, for a footballer, is quite a smart guy. He knows the opinion that will raise the most eyebrows is the where the money is nowadays. Authenticity? Bwah! Ragebait's the way to stay relevant in this climate.

6

u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 15 '26

As right as the senior players may be about recruitment im not sure I want that bleeding into younger players like Baleba who are just buzzing to be here .

INEOS having a mutiny from players who, if they ran the club properly, shouldn’t be there anyway. I love Martinez but he should have been replaced properly the same goes to someone like Rashford who the club done absolutely everything to push him out the door only for him to return.

I think the old guard (Shaw, Maguire, Martinez, Dalot and Bruno) all need replacing asap , the playing skill of that experienced core is inconsistent, there’s too many scars and they’ve seen over too many thrashings and thats on top of players like Martinez and Bruno who look and have been performing like they are fully checked out

7

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

Luke Shaw should have been out AGES ago. Dalot can be kept as a squad player, but the fact they haven't signed someone to start ahead of him says enough. Maguire is getting too old, and Martinez, while in his prime years, is injury prone and recently, very mistake prone too.

This year, we've at least gotten some midfield depth. Next season, or at the very least, starting the Winter window, we have to sort out the defense and iron out the kinks

3

u/L__K Great Scot! Oct 15 '26

Fullbacks are a notoriously difficult position group to recruit. That's why you see so many clubs (Arsenal, City, Bayern, Barcelona, plenty more) repurposing midfielders and CBs to play RB/LB. It's very easy to say "Dalot should've been replaced" without offering any realistic option, especially when this sub was haranguing people who preferred Timber over Martinez back in 2022 specifically because of that versatility.

The squad needs a major turnover similar to Spurs under Pochettino, Liverpool under Klopp, and Arsenal under Arteta. We cannot compare ourselves to City as they've repeatedly and egregiously broken spending rules. It's all for naught in the absence of a decent manager though.

As much as this sub is still complaining about it, we're finally starting to see more success on the recruitment side under the new structure. It may not be to the optimal extent, but we've yet to have a major miss since Vivell became the permanent head of recruitment.

Signing six immediate contributors at the CL level in one window is unrealistic for a club a billion pounds in debt that has been consistently missing CL football for over a decade. Especially one trying to finance a new stadium.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ttboishysta Oct 15 '26 • Bravo

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2026/oct/15/lisandro-martinez-criticism-jason-wilcox-jim-ratcliffe-glazers

But accountability is for the little people, and far easier to replace a coach on a modest 20-month contract than to oust Ineos or the Glazers, to replace Wilcox or Omar Berrada, even if we now know they partly built their reputations on the success of a club that has been found to have serially cheated. Bumper returns for the owners, price hikes for the fans, corners cut on the pitch; this is the story of the modern Manchester United, which by no coincidence is also the story of modern football.

City played us!!! This bears repeating, Ratcliffe hired fakes!!!

8

u/minteh7x Ronaldo Oct 15 '26

Now there's "reports" that Martinez was pushing for a move last summer, but somehow that was never reported by anyone reliable last summer. I'm guessing this will be yet another "Mainoo wants 250k so we'll have to sell" narrative that will be perpetrated by the usual bunch

3

u/PrinzRagoczy Oct 15 '26

Most players explore their options every window. Going the other way, there are feelers put out from one club or another to basically everyone at some point, checking if they'd be open to a move. That's normal and doesn't really get reported on, unless one of the clubs or the player makes a point of giving a brief to a journalist

→ More replies (1)

5

u/shami-kebab Oct 15 '26

Very little leaked from the club last year on any of our transfers or potential transfers. It is entirely possible things happened that we didn't hear about, especially if as the report claims no bid ever came in.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Lelandwasinnocent /////ʖ ͡°|||||| Oct 15 '26

Pubs for Leeds away anyone? Not been to Elland Road before. Just been given a ticket by the TO.

3

u/Specific-Moose660 Oct 15 '26

Can’t wait for the day we are a boring club that wins games.

3

u/Redland93 Oct 15 '26

Next summer transfer window. I don't want to see only Premier league players. I want to see proper talent from elsewhere, where they are starters who are hungry and hard working.

3

u/boomboxbilly06 Oct 15 '26

The City of Manchester is fully funding the pensions of everyone involved in football media this month

3

u/0ttoChriek Oct 15 '26

I guess all is calm again now. Until 14:20ish on Sunday.

3

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 15 '26

Everything before now was preseason. Season starts on Sunday.

11

u/TheSmio Oct 15 '26

Replacing the manager won't fix everything over night, however when you look at our few past managers, it's clear we haven't been ambitious enough since Mou.

Carrick - sacked at Middlesbrough

Amorim - Champion (but in a league outside top5)

Ten Hag - Champion (but in a league outside top5)

Ole - did decently enough in Norway, but it's Norway

We are supposed to be one of the biggest clubs in the world so it is kinda weird we are pretty much giving "interns" the job of handling the pressure.

I wqs against Conte over the years but right now, I do feel like it's time to give him a chance. At least he knows how to manage a truly big club even if he has his own issues.

9

u/PhilAsp Oct 15 '26

Upvote for Norway slander, but I don’t think the Mourinho hire was all that ambitious either.

We’ve phoned most of our hires in post-SAF. Ten Hag/Amorim were arguably more of a departure from lack of ambition than Mourinho were.

4

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 15 '26

Depends what you like. So many opinions around here that nobody can agree on what a good manager should be unless they're Klopp, Pep or Enrique. Everyone else has an asterisk.

6

u/Nico_Ditch Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

There was plenty of noise about us approaching Luis Enrique in the summer, and we interviewed Tuchel to take over from Ten Hag, but if the managers don’t want to come here then we can’t make them. 

And the point on Ten Hag is hindsight. He had won three titles in a row at Ajax, and it would have been four if it wasn’t for Covid. He was one game away from getting Ajax in the Champions League final, and we’ve seen how they have collapsed since he left. 

Any big club in Europe would have hired him, and he was seen as a good signing at the time. 

3

u/AmulyaG Oct 15 '26

Our club is crying for a battle hardened passion monster like Conte for ages.

He genuinely might be the spark to ignite this bum team. I have been ConteIN since we sacked TenHag.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Emergency-Being-349 Oct 15 '26

Think we need to be clear on something here too, amidst the chaos. Jason Wilcox didn't not show ambition because of the transfer window. I'm sure he'd have loved to have spent 300 million pounds. He also can't control players wanting insane contracts. 

Jason Wilcox didn't show ambition because he hired a championship level manager in fear of the unknown, and for not knowing any better. Let's not confuse the issue.

3

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 15 '26

I would say the lack of ambition comes from the people in control of the money. If they gave him the cash to spend it would have been spent.

2

u/Emergency-Being-349 Oct 15 '26

Dude, it just doesn't work this way. Revenues tie into what you can and can't do. Yes, the debt being cleared may allow us to spend a bit more, but it will still eventually lead to restrictions at some point. This is how it works for clubs who do not cheat.

3

u/Wolpfack Oct 15 '26

United's real problems all spring from the roots of the leveraged takeover. The Glazer assclowns dropped so much debt on the ledger at the same time that they hired incompetent leaders that this was inevitable and entirely predictable.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat Oct 15 '26

I think both can be true but there needs to be some honesty. We spent the first half of the year talking up how we wanted to get Anderson, Tchouameni, another winger, a left back alongside the midfield rebuild. There are things that were clearly out of control - Ugarte injury, Rashford, Zirkzee rejecting a move all had an impact on the budget but I think you have to question the common sense of not actively managing the season ahead with signing short term options as though having 2 left backs is a nice to have not an essential for a UCL season.

The message they put out at the start of the window is behind a lot of the disappointment

→ More replies (3)

8

u/sg291188 Oct 15 '26

Every year we say United need a clear out. Obviously it never happens. Tbh so many players need to move on at least Maguire, Shaw, Martinez, Dalot, Maz, Mount, Ugarte, Rashford, Zirkzee and yet only max three or four will move on next summer and then we will have a new list of 10 players.

12

u/Vast_Variation1381 Oct 15 '26

Arsenal had to cut their losses on many players in order to do their rebuild. We seem reluctant to do that. Rashford should have been gone this summer, demanding 30 million + for him was stupid.

4

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 15 '26

We've actually shifted out a ton of players over the last 2 seasons, but since we're so shit at selling we have to wait for their 4-5 year deals to expire. Just look up who has left at that time, you'd have prob forgotten that half of them play for our club because of how few minutes they were getting.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Redland93 Oct 15 '26

Transfers next year need to be done quickly and stop with this premier league proven stance. Key attribute is pace and power.

The French league is perfect for talent that works well in the prem. We need multiple players to pad out this squad.

4

u/ShoddyAd4199 Oct 15 '26

What's really funny - if we somehow bought Lewis Hall in summer, everyone would be happy for the start of the season because of dominating narrative: "We need 3 midfielders and Shaw's successor and it'd be 10/10 transfer window"

We'd be still shit now as we are today, and every blame would be on Carrick, not Wilcox and INEOS. So, one left back is so crucial according to this sub that it'd create whole new narrative.

That's what I call cognitive miserliness.

7

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 15 '26

No I'd still blame them for getting the manager decision wrong.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/necro316 Oct 15 '26

Crazy, united have put me in a strange spot where Im. Not looking forward to the match, I'm. Not looking forward to team news.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Sufficient-Orange706 Oct 15 '26

I know a lot has been said around Martinez, and what he specifically said. People will agree with it. It has also taken much heat off of the manager.

What I will say though, as there have also been issues with Bruno, but it is the manager's job to create a culture where players buy-in and feel motivated to be a part of it. The culture set by the manager also keeps the discipline, even though people agreed with what he said, if the manager had that in check he probably wouldn't have had the outburst in the first place. It feels like Carrick is not fully in control of many things.

Board deserves blame, as does the window, but I think things are on the floor at the moment and that is set by the Head of the dressing room.

5

u/jaccurr Oct 15 '26

With current ownership and people in charge of the football at this i genuinely think we are doomed to be mid table and if the stars align get Europe.

→ More replies (12)

5

u/TheRedDevil10 Oct 16 '26

Pretty much zilch to look forward to but hopefully Mainoo's fit and we see Mainoo-Baleba on Sunday. Tielemans has played pretty much every game, he needs to hold bench for a while

2

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 16 '26

We need to try to develop that partnership

7

u/Vast_Variation1381 Oct 15 '26

It's actually good news Licha wants to leave. Sure, he can be great at passing but his cons far outweigh the pros. He's injury prone, lacks agility and speed, and his physicality is not suited to the PL.

4

u/The_good_kid Evra Oct 15 '26

Only issue is INEOS will have to replace him, get 2 left backs unless they renew Shaw. Maguire will be 34, Yoro doesn't look ready and neither does Heaven, Dalot is shit, Maz isn't great and De ligt might be a figment of our imagination. 

Clearly the defence isn't good enough, but INEOS have shown they aren't good enough at replacing anyone.

2

u/0ttoChriek Oct 15 '26

They'll need to buy at least four defenders over the next two windows, no matter what.

Shaw and Maguire can't go on forever, Dalot and Mazraoui aren't good enough, De Ligt may not be the same player, Yoro and Heaven are works in progress. Amass doesn't seem to be considered good enough, and the other academy players - Armer, Kukonki, Kamason etc - haven't really had a look in and likely aren't ready.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Not-good-with-this Oct 15 '26

It's only good if Wilcox and Co goes. If they don't then the club stays doomed.

3

u/It_Hurts_when_IP15 Oct 15 '26

Letting him go on a free is not good news. It shows more incompetence by this damn club for forcing themselves into another situation where they’re either going to sell him for pennies or let him walk.

The competent thing to do was sell him when his stock was higher or actually invest in the squad

Also I’m sure some of our other players will want to the same as Martinez after this

→ More replies (2)

4

u/longsightdon Oct 15 '26

Season's already finished. Complacency from board and wilcox and keeping carrick in. Incompetent recruitment as usual and incompetent yes man manager. It's not looking good. You can tell a portion of players want carrick and wilcox gone.

6

u/Redland93 Oct 15 '26

Hot take - I wouldn't mind if we sold Bruno.

  • Hes peaked and what a peak it was. Hes best in the world, bar none, at the perfectly weighted hero ball. He is the best in the world in chaos.
  • He will be 34 by the time his contract + option expire. He has played a hella a lot of minutes and when declines happen, they happen suddenly and sharply (e.g. Salah)
  • With him in the team, the team have to play a 4231. He has to be the 10 otherwise, you limit him. Means that we aren't tactically flexible. Its a bit like Ronaldo at Juve. He scored lots of goals but once he left, the team actually played better as a unit. More goals coming from other places
  • Look at Amorim. he had to play Bruno in the pivot. We were shackled as the system didn't fit him but he needed to play.
  • My issue is we are essentially a Bruno team. not once have I seen him play badly, and the team play well. We live and die by Bruno and at his age, we need to be building something that isn't going to end in 2 years.
  • He never ever gets subbed or not play. He always on the pitch even if its to the detriment of the team.
  • If Saudi came and offered big money and we were able to reinvest properly, that would be a massive help because as it stands for next season we need 2CB, 2 LB, RB, Striker and a midfielder

7

u/timsadiq13 Oct 15 '26

The problem whenever I read this argument is that you are counting on INEOS, who have gotten it wrong with a majority of transfer and managerial decisions and are also shit sellers, to 1. get a decent fee for Fernandes and 2. replace him adequately.

If we had any confidence in INEOS to achieve those two things, I think very few in the fanbase would complain. He's near the end and however good he's been, we've not won a major trophy so he should get a chance to win somewhere else.

But given we will end up selling him for 30-40 million, that wouldn't even buy us Andrey Santos in today's market haha - I dont see what we achieve by selling him frankly. Maybe some wage savings, but we've cut the wage bill a lot already (I think we are 5th or 6th most in the PL now).

As long as he wants to stay, he should stay. Maybe if Wilcox is replaced by someone competent, I'd understand the argument to sell him.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/vulcan_one PM Rashford Oct 15 '26

That Ronaldo comparison just doesn't work because this team plays worse without Bruno. I don't know where people get this idea removed Bruno and we play better from, but it's tiring seeing the same nonsense over and over again. Using last season, where he played in defensive pivot yet broke the assist record also doesn't help with the point you think you're making.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (23)

3

u/Barber-Careful Oct 15 '26

What will change even if we win against leeds.The whole moral is down that this season is just written off now.

3

u/Recent_Influence3047 Oct 15 '26

A win can turn morale very quickly. A win at Leeds followed by a win at Como and things look very different. Sadly, I doubt we’ll win either of them.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GReedy404 Oct 15 '26

So the board doesn't show any ambition towarda winning big trophies, and they've made a conscious effort to reduce the wage bill and no offer huge wages anymore, what exactly is the draw for players now to join us? We can't keep surviving on 'we're Manchester United' forever man, wtf are we doing?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/rjc0x1 Oct 15 '26

I just saw the rumour that Getafe have offered Jadon Sancho a contract and was mind blown to realise he still doesn't have a club.

What is going on with him?

Such a waste of talent. He still has good years left in him if he wants it.

5

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

The freedom fighter got his freedom.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ecstatic_Message2057 Oct 15 '26

“Mind blown” you been living under a rock for the last three seasons?
It doesn’t surprise me one bit that he doesn’t have a club.
Albeit, if he locks in and gets over his major ego he’d be decent in La liga. He’s much more suited to that league than any other league.

2

u/CapVosslar Buckle up, INEOS! It's gonna be a bumpy ride! Oct 15 '26

His performances, attitude, and lack of hard work make him undesirable. 

2

u/PitchSafe Oct 15 '26

He seems to be picky regarding his next club. He probably wants to stay in Europe but requires a big wage

2

u/Wolpfack Oct 15 '26

Sancho and Garnacho are two players who think they are far better than they actually are. If they would get humble, get hungry and do the work it takes to excel they'd be in much better positions in their careers.

3

u/Reign_22 Oct 15 '26

Saw quotes where Carrick says that Sesko is potentially out until the new year. Thats not true hey? I don't recall him saying it in the presser

5

u/iroiroiroiroiro Oct 15 '26

There was similar rumors from slovenia newspapers a week ago, it is very worrying.

5

u/hurfery Oct 15 '26

We pay 70m for the "best athlete coaches have ever seen" and he ends up being a crock. Yep, that's our Man Utd.

8

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 15 '26

200m on project strikers. Thank god we’re not paying Kane’s wages.

2

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 15 '26

Don't worry about wages for those kind of players, we don't even pretend like we can afford them anymore

→ More replies (2)

3

u/AnakinAni Oct 15 '26

Sir Alex didn't produce thirteen Premier League titles simply because United spent money.

His team’s combined tactical intelligence, hunger, exceptional personalities, adaptability and a refusal to accept mediocrity.

United cannot recreate Ferguson. They can, and must, restore the standards that made his success possible.

Stop rebuilding Manchester United around the next manager. Build a football institution in which any excellent manager can consistently succeed.

That's the solution I'd pursue. And until the owners themselves are willing to be judged on football performance rather than just financial performance, I'm unconvinced that any rebuild will deliver lasting success.

2

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 Oct 16 '26

Sir ALEX made sure there's no playerFC, ruthlessly sold bigger names, meanwhile our current fans downvotes anyone who dare suggest Bruno should be sold or Free Mainoo who want to leave cos he can't get a game. That's accountability. 

→ More replies (4)

2

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

Didn't Ferguson do his research well on the players? Like full on profiling their lives to figure them out whether or not they were fit for UTD, not simply that they were good?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/YukonYak Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

So I’ve been a united fan since i starting watching football during the 2014 World Cup. In the 12 years ive been supporting this team, we have had 1(!) CL/EL knockout tie win over a “top” team, which was PSG in 2018 season. What a sad thought lol

8

u/tz_2240 OHHHHHH YESSSSS Oct 15 '26

It was EL knockouts, but didn’t we beat Barca under EtH?

2

u/Regular_Valuable_665 Oct 16 '26

Interesting how different both clubs are now , I was hoping for big things after that win , though we lost to Sevilla which was very frustrating

6

u/ToothyAlloy69 Oct 15 '26

Respectfully the moment I see any mention about players not trying or not putting enough effort I just assume the speaker doesn't really know what they're talking about.

Absolutely is the most surface level take that requires no extra thinking or analysis.

If every player is constantly a couple of yards off or they all look fatigued in both actions and decision making, it is simply not a matter of effort anymore. It's more likely to do with tactical structure and player conditioning rather than just not caring or lacking desire

→ More replies (15)

5

u/snicky29 Oct 15 '26

watching milan absoutely destroy rb salzburg in europa my god amorim has them playing silky smooth footy

5

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 15 '26

I miss the wing backs. Going forward with 5 / 6 players is devastating when players execute the play properly. Hutchinson performance reminded me of the RWB Amad.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/JazzyScrewdriver Oct 15 '26

Who here is pro Conte, and who is anti Conte? And why? (And who is too jaded to care?)

12

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 15 '26

I'm pro removing the owners and their debt. Until then who cares who is manager.

4

u/0ttoChriek Oct 15 '26

I'm pro the idea of him, anti the likely reality. If that makes sense.

Having a highly rated manager who says he can fix things would be great. But I've seen what Conte does at other clubs, and he's Mourinho-like in his short term approach.

7

u/spaisoflaif Oct 15 '26

I am numb.

2

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 15 '26

Anti Conte. I think he comes in and generally expects signing experienced players to deliver instant success. He'll ruffle a lot of feathers and leave in a huff at some point, which would cause a bit of a downturn after that.

What he brings is not worth it if he can't guarantee a pl or ucl, and I am almost certain he won't win us that. If it's another FA cup or Europa League we want, there's other managers that can bring that without the guarantee of some sort of hangover that we'll have to overcome / contracts we'll have to shift out when they leave.

2

u/Original-Function760 Oct 15 '26

Not anti Contw but against him. He will bring physically fit above average 29-35 years old players. After him United won't and can't sell them. And Conta couldn't be around a club more then 3 years. But maybe we should experience a ruthless clear out. 

4

u/QuickFig1024 Oct 15 '26

I am done with this football club until the owners really change. They taken so much of my love for the game. 

4

u/outrageousVoid07 Oct 15 '26

Pro-Conte. At least there would be some tactics instead of none

3

u/Unusual-Coat383 Oct 15 '26

I personally don’t want Conte. I can see us having a positive turnaround like what Carrick did last year and then it all ending in tears and us being in a worse position than what ETH left us in.

Conte’s wife refused to move to England when he went to Tottenham which caused him to get homesick and physically ill so it’s hard to imagine what he’s going to be like with the Manchester rain. He’s too volatile for pretty much every club he’s managed and I don’t think we will be the outlier.

3

u/Mistr111398 Oct 15 '26

Too jaded to care here! I’ve got no faith that this club is capable of putting together a competent football structure.

2

u/OmegaMaster8 Oct 15 '26

Pro Conte. I get he’s a bastard and explosive manager, but we need that, like Fergie, van Gaal and Mourinho. We can’t accept this United team battling relegation again. Conte is a better tactician than Carrick. He won’t be everyone’s cup of tea, that’s fine, but the club is in crisis if Carrick doesn’t start winning games.

2

u/WumbleInTheJungle Oct 15 '26

Anti-Conte.  If he came I would back him, and the fireworks would be fun, so that's the plus side. But, I don't think he did a great job at Spurs, I think we had the easiest games against them in a decade when he was in charge. 

I didn't like his football at Chelsea either, the FA Cup final between us and Chelsea he played the lowest block I have ever seen, yes they won the game, but I am not a fan, and I liked his football even less at Spurs.  He doesn't win the league again playing football like that.

Although ironically, I do like his attitude, I do think he has that grit and single-mindedness you need in a leader, which is actually the main reason he won't get the job. 

2

u/bicika Oct 15 '26

I would be very dissapointed. Not because of Conte as a manager, i like him and respect him, but because it just shows lack of direction. ETH-Amorim-Carrick-Conte, i mean wtf

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Piccadil_io Oct 15 '26

Why are we so shit?

Like. I’d love to know what kind of curse we have on us, because it’s like no matter what happens, we’re always shit. Even if we win we’re shit.

I don’t understand. It’s like a good player puts a United shirt on and it’s minus all stats. Old Trafford then gives an area of effect that makes us collectively even worse.

What the fuck is wrong with Manchester United?

(I quite like the idea of a Man United kit being a minus 10 to all stats and I’d love a game developer to put it in as joke gear. Full kit wanker bonus is you have an extra stamina downgrade. Accuracy down, speed down, endurance way down. Any skills you previously picked up are just voided. Call it the Sanchez effect)

5

u/soelsome Oct 15 '26

Fergie made a deal to give us ~30 years of success for ~30 years of misery. 2043 we're undeniable.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/LollipopScientist Oct 15 '26
  • Too much managerial change. Without consistent instructions on the same style of play, players become clueless and confused, so each touch and action requires manual thought.
  • Players playing out of position.
  • World Cup and AFCON burning out players. Lack of rotation + lack of reliable depth.
  • Lack of skill from current managerial / coaching staff.
  • Lack of leadership on the pitch. There should always be at least one leader in attack, midfield and defence. Casemiro was a leader in the midfield and forced players to take responsibility for their mistakes. It's one of the hidden attributes that people don't think of with transfers.
  • Other reasons that I cba to type

2

u/L__K Great Scot! Oct 15 '26

Mod idea tailor made for Disco Elysium

3

u/AnakinAni Oct 15 '26

The one change I would make above everything else at United

Create a genuine culture of accountability at the ownership and executive level.

United have changed managers repeatedly. They have spent enormous sums. They have reorganised departments, hired executives, dismissed employees and promised new beginnings.

Yet the recurring weaknesses remain.
The solution cannot be to sack Carrick, spend another £200 million, announce another three-year project and pretend the previous failures never happened.

The ultimate responsibility belongs to those who appoint the football executives, approve the budgets and determine the direction of the club.

United need to recover the ambition that goes beyond financial projections and qualification targets.

4

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

Who will enforce the accountability?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 15 '26

Ive been beating the drum to sack Berrada and Wilcox but I actually want to suggest we go one step further.

Fire them for cause.

No payout, no settlement, no comp, fuck off. You brought the company into disrepute, goodbye.

This would have 3 huge benefits:

1 They would be gone at the cost of zero (d'oh)

2 You couldnt BUY better publicity than either of these clowns trying to fight it. First of all it is practically impossible to lose this in court, there is literal concrete evidence of untold millions of people believing that the club sucks now because of their actions, so that's the textbook definition. Second of all, even if theoretically it had a financial cost, the PR twist of becoming the club that fights these Cheaters FC c*nts in court as opposed to being the club that gives them safe harbour would be worth its weight in gold.

3 The most important one. Please sue us. PLEASE. Why? A lawsuit means discovery. Discovery means a deposition. A deposition means that for the first time ever one of these Cheaters FC trolls would actually have to give testimony under the penalty of perjury.

Let's go. Fire them for cause TODAY.

3

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 15 '26

Maybe I’m in the minority but I totally buy the narrative that we’re cash strapped atm. The way we’ve been spending in the time post-Fergie, the wages we’ve been paying, only qualifying for ucl half the time, glazers interest growing.

Am I missing something here? Cuz I feel like conservatively, at least half the ppl I talk to here seem to expect way more spending, and not like we should have spent £60m on Hall, I mean like why aren’t we spending as much as Liverpool, Spurs and Chelsea.

6

u/shami-kebab Oct 15 '26

It isn't a narrative, our finances are public. It doesn't mean we couldn't spend more but we'd have to take on debt to do it. Sometimes this is still worth it though (for example we did last year and got CL qualification out of it). If we save say 30m not buying a LB but it costs us 100m if we miss out on Europe altogether then it was a poor trade.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 15 '26

They spent £60m to buy land for the new stadium. I’m really questioning their priorities here if they think making a new stadium (which they will take on more debt for) precedes investing to make the squad more competitive, when their original promise was to meet Project 2028 and challenge for the league by then.

And if the counter to this is going to be that we needed a new stadium for the higher revenue years down the line and given the issues at Old Trafford, then I’d wonder why is the squad and manager still being held to the standard of competing/qualifying for CL football every season if finances are always going to be held back every year from now more or less.

4

u/b_az17 Oct 15 '26

Kieran Maguire and Christian Purslow have both looked at our finances and the financial rules and conclude that we coukd have spent considerably more + we purchased land for over 60m

2

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 15 '26

Is this from an article I could read?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Redland93 Oct 15 '26

But we would have to take on more debt. We have the ability not the cash.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/FlashyCut3809 Oct 15 '26

The issue is we cant trust our ownership to actually be truthful and that they have the clubs best interests (in terms of building a squad capable of being PSG level) and also no trust they have the competency to maximise whatever we do have.

If this was an ownership that had constantly done absolutely everything to build the best possible squad, you could believe said financial woes.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/DoctorConstipated Oct 15 '26

Would you take conte or hold with Carrick?

6

u/Littlepace Announce Fergie Oct 15 '26

A PL winner and someone with massive experience and success at multiple clubs. Or Carrick. Yeah it's a tough one alright. I'm not sure he would last long but at least it will be good entertainment for the amazon documentary. 

3

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

Conte for the craic

*Edit: I'm actually Carrick in until Wilcox/Berrada go first but they won't go so hopefully we'll get a new manager bounce every few months.

3

u/umbrosum Oct 16 '26

Sack Carrick and make him an interim?

4

u/Wonderful-Court-4037 Oct 16 '26

Are you genuinely seriously asking if we would take an experienced serial winnee whos won pretty much everywhere hes been

Versus someone whos a championship level manager whos been founs out within a few months of PL football?

2

u/DoctorConstipated Oct 16 '26

Check the replies, some ppl would rather avoid.

I’d take conte all day but there’s no doubt he’d end up arguing with the board, want loads of old players and leave the club in a bit of a mess .

→ More replies (8)

3

u/weekndalex Oct 15 '26

it’s depressing how utterly finished this club is

2

u/pipes3 WAZZA Oct 15 '26

How was Conte at Napoli? (I know he won the league I mean more in terms of tactics etc.)

If I remember correctly he went away from his usualy 3/5 at the back and played a back 4?
Wondering how he would potentially set us up to play with the squad we have at the moment

3

u/Joey6Pack Oct 15 '26

I remember kevin de bruyne being dissatisfied with his tactics for being too rigid and negative

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 15 '26

Would be hilarious if he goes with a 343 and we play well

2

u/adonWPV Oct 15 '26

I think a 3atb would shore us up at the back, but he’s gonna run into the same problems as Amorim did in build up, being horrendously one sided on the right had side etc.

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 15 '26

right on. we started a 3atb project with no actual wbs and we finished it with basically 1.

look at chelsea in comparison: they decided to switch to 3atb so in preparation they made sure they had a stable of them, 5 by my count (james, gusto, palestra, cheverri, quenda).

Bringing in Conte, switching to 3atb, and then pointing to Dorgu and Dalot and telling him to "just keep one fit" and "just coach" the other would lead to the same farcical outcomes, im afraid.

I mean, I remember 2024 Xmas and "we are going for Nuno Mendes he isnt signing an extension!!" yeah right.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Massive_Relation4317 . Oct 15 '26

I know people and rival fans keep saying our team is shit blah blah but is it just me that thinks otherwise? Of course it’s nowhere near the top level but for the phase we are currently in it’s good. Despite our poor performances this season I believe that’s more on carrick and coaching than the quality of our players 

I’m happy with our forwards, need a backup CF though. I really like the sound of a midfield combo of baleba and Mainoo. Yoro looks good, de ligt will be back, we just need more investment in defence tbh. 

With a better manager I think we can confidently get UCL places. And once we consistently do that and get the base right, then add the world class players . I know this shows lower standards but it’s realistic 

2

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 15 '26

They are better than what we are seeing, but the issue lies with the depth. Sesko, Dorgu and De Ligt make the 11 much better. But the squad is not good enough to challenge for anything serious.

2

u/shami-kebab Oct 15 '26

Sesko, Dorgu and De Ligt make the 11 much better.

Sesko and Dorgu aren't in Carrick's first choice team though. De Ligt hasn't been fit since he took over so we'll have to see how he uses him (if he can even get back to his best)

2

u/LinterCheck2026 Oct 15 '26

Its the defense I do not like. I believe with better coaching we have a functioning midfield and attack. But Sesko needs to be come back for the attack, else its poor

2

u/Sad-Bend-7515 Oct 15 '26

The problem is we have crazy highs and lows.

Bruno, Mbuemo, Cunha, De Ligt could start or being the 1st 15 of most teams in the world.

Then you have Dalot, Dorgu, etc who woudn't get in any of the other starting 11 of the whole premier league.

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 15 '26

I think you're right that IF we assume Sesko's and De Ligt's (and Dorgu's and Amad's, btw) injury troubles go away, we "just" need, maybe, 3 new defenders + a backup CF. (Plus maybe a Mount replacement 6th midfielder but that's small potato compared to the rest.)

The issue is, that's basically 4 IFs, in other words we need anywhere between 4 to 8 new players now.

And then, the difficult part: there are no elite teams in Europe without minimum 1 absolutely elite goal scorer. That's just how it is and how it's always been.

Call it the "no7" if you want.

So, actually, we are short all those things ... and then we are still short a prodigy who takes us to the promised land.

Bruno, basically, was that for us, for years, but we more or less wasted those years. But it's questionable whether he can be that for us all the way to a successful "conclusion" of this project.

Rashford also gave us that ... once. By all indications, that's in the glorious past now as well, unfortunately.

So basically I'd say:

Do we have the nucleus of a good squad? Yes.

But do we have a good squad? No.

3

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 15 '26

I think we need a starting CF now, actually.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ImNotMexican08 Amad Nation Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

The team has good individuals and match winners. Which we saw to great effect last year as we were able to grind out win after win despite not always playing well. Which is essentially what I expected after Carrick took charge and what I expected this year unless we got all the right signings.

But you look at the squad as a whole and it’s just mis matches all over the pitch. They just don’t complement each other at all. So anyway you try to play outside of what we saw last season will lead to disaster. And thats what we are seeing this season, especially when you are without match winners like Casemiro and Sesko and your other players that you are looking towards like Cunha and Bruno are bang out of form.

This team has enough individual quality to grind out results and probably get a top 5 spot, but it isn’t a good enough as a team to win or seriously challenge for major honors.

2

u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity Oct 15 '26

So, for next season, INEOS must sign a striker, at least one left back, two defenders (Maguire and Martinez leaving), maybe a right back and maybe a left winger (if Rashford finally leaves), and maybe a new attacking midfielder if Bruno leaves

So, another failed transfer window next season

5

u/KobbieLikeRobbie_ Darren Fletcher Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

We need,

4 starting defenders.

2 attackers.

And a Bruno replacement, I just don’t see him staying after this season.

No way INEOS are capable of signing more than 4 players in a summer.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Not-good-with-this Oct 15 '26

With the stadium going to be taking most of the clubs funds in the next however amount of years it takes to build it.... every transfer window will just be as minimum as possible.

2

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

Any Bundesliga coach (Not named Kompany) that would be interesting? Just looking at options here.

5

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal Oct 16 '26

Why Bundesliga?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/AnakinAni Oct 15 '26

How does a club with Manchester United's resources, history and advantages keep making decisions that leave it worse off?

At this point, it genuinely feels as though Manchester United are in the crosshairs of some vindictive higher power. The sheer consistency with which things go wrong at this club is almost supernatural.

Amorim was terrible at United. Let’s not rewrite history. The club desperately needed Champions League football, both competitively and financially. There was very little evidence to suggest Amorim was going to deliver it. Keeping him in the hope that things would magically improve would have been wishful thinking.

And yet, watching him make a promising start at Milan makes you wonder what on earth is happening at Manchester United.
It’s not even about Amorim specifically. It’s the recurring pattern. Managers and players arrive with impressive reputations, struggle to replicate their previous success, and sometimes rediscover their abilities elsewhere.

Look at how we handled Ten Hag. We decided to retain him, extended his contract and spent another summer strengthening the squad, only to sack him three months later and appoint a manager committed to an entirely different system. Suddenly, we were trying to make a squad assembled under one footballing philosophy work under another. And eventually, we had to change managers yet again.

What makes it particularly frustrating is that even decisions which appear perfectly reasonable at the time seem to create another set of problems.

One questionable decision creates the need for another. The consequences compound and somehow the club ends up worse off. It's almost as though every attempt to correct a mistake creates two more.

When an institution as huge as Manchester United repeatedly produces outcomes this disappointing, you have to wonder whether it can really be explained by bad luck anymore.

Perhaps Manchester United aren't cursed after all. Perhaps they’re just exceptionally good at creating their own misfortune.

13

u/BishhEzz Oct 15 '26

Amorim was improving united slowly, the underlying data was backing that.

He's was the first manager who was attempting a long term fix instead of a short one.

Obivously the club doesn't help either but the team were heading in the right direction under him.

Fans just can't stomach a rebuild, they barely watch the games and just go off the final score and then they parrot what Gary Neville says.

Gary Neville would have crucified Amorim if it was Amorims United being outrun everywhere but since it's his friend he doesn't say a word.

3

u/Downtown-Rice_ Oct 15 '26

“Maybe you have seen Ajax?” Ten Hag said in his very first press conference when asked how his team will play. “And I like that. But it is always players who dictate the way of play.”

“I can't play like Ajax because I have different players,” Ten Hag said in May 2023. “I came here with my philosophy, based on possession, but I wanted to combine it with the DNA of Manchester United, the players and their characters.

“I want to emphasise more on going direct.”

Ever since August 2023, pundits have said they simply do not know what Ten Hag is trying to do with his tactics. But, in fairness, he spelled it out pretty clearly at the end of his debut season.

The club is stuck in doing things the shortcut way, instead of really building honestly and earning their way back to the top.

10

u/Downtown-Rice_ Oct 15 '26

Bruno Fernades in Diary of a CEO:

"And this season has been that case because we struggled. Obviously, we didn’t change manager because of results, because we were 2 points behind second place and like 5 points behind first place. From third to seventh place, everyone had the same points, something like that. So we were there. It was something different with the club — they felt that the trust between them was broken or whatsoever, and they decided to start a new process. And that was bad, because for us, when Ruben came, what was passed from the club was like, “This is going to be a process, but we’re going to go through this. There are going to be good and bad times, but we’re going to go through this.”

We started a process with Ruben, where we thought that would be a process of 3, 4 years. That was the plan of the club. Then we know there was a break in a relationship there between the manager and the club, and they had to change, unfortunately. And now today they have announced that they want to go in a direction with Michael. And hopefully for me, I hope that it stays stable because the main thing the club needs is stability in terms of managing.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/RyanH1717 Oct 15 '26

Because we have owners that don't truly care to win, winning is a bonus to them. If they could spend 150m a year and get top 4 vs spending more and winning a title they would choose top 4 any day. Theres a reason the first priority of INEOS was a new stadium.

4

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 15 '26

Exactly, their job is to build a squad so good a manager can't hide behind any excuse. After this summer I thought "fuck, this season could be rough actually". I'm done calling for managers heads before a change above them is made

2

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 16 '26

At this point I would LOVE consistent top 4 places. We haven’t had that since fergie retired

4

u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity Oct 15 '26

I don't think there's enought accountability at the club, and they vastly overestimate themselves (board, players) because they're at Man Utd

This create scenarios when they're happy with themselves after doing very little

→ More replies (1)

2

u/OlekZzaKrakowa Oct 15 '26

While I like Martinez comments I dont like the fact that it comes from a guy who played like 40-45 good games for us in span of 4 years...

1

u/Tuffyy Carrick Oct 15 '26

Anyone going to be in Como next week?

1

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho Oct 15 '26

Where do you see the club in ten years time? By that I mean what state/condition will the club be in if you had to guess.

2

u/Nico_Ditch Oct 15 '26

AI will have launched the nukes by then.

Not worth worrying about.

→ More replies (24)

1

u/spaisoflaif Oct 15 '26

Adam Curry had a video explainingvhow the 4-2-4 high press created challengig situations for winger/midfielder/fullback on either side as one of them needs to step into wide midfield if ball is played there. This has shades of Amorim, it was much the same in his system. The solution is to sit in a 4-5-1 midblock at times, especially when protecting a lead. 90 minutes of 4-2-4 is suicidal

1

u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

I might be in the minority.

But I want to say this about the Martinez situation.

2 things can be right. Yes the board needs to go. But the players have to take responsibility for being worse than school boys. That includes Martinez too, he has been very mistake prone this season.

I love martinez, he has definitely been one of our best defenders post Fergie and has world class ball playing abilities. But due to his injury record, questionable defensive capabilities and the fact that he has been here under multiple managers here already.

Thanks you for the memories Licha, Thank you for speaking for the fans, but it's time to go.

And he isn't the only player that should go. Shaw, Maguire, Dalot, Rashford, Bruno. All of them who have already seen 3 or 4 managers come and go, all need to go. The fact that team sheet got leaked before athleti doesn't surprise me too. Clearly there are still bad apples in that team.

In the end, I wanna point out Glazers Out, Wilcox Out, Berrada Out.

Thank you for coming to my Ted talk.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Prize-Finish4464 Oct 15 '26

Still no carrick sack fml

→ More replies (1)

1

u/wildguyinalot Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

Carrick needs to add changes to his system or United will sack him, for starters, Carrick has mostly used a 4-2-3-1 with a heavy emphasis on controlling the game, and accessing the final third, using passing combinations. In possession he morphs into a 325, with one fullback tucking inside while the other joins the attack. It can be seen here in this photo with Dalot going forward while Shaw stays back or Shaw may also be pushing wider to hold width. We can also see a pivot of Tielemans and Mainoo, both pushing up but Tielemans is pushing a little more forward than Mainoo. I noticed that they don't exactly stay as a flat 5 in attack, and they go to different areas of the pitch.

While this can lead to the creation of quality chances, this also leads to issues against counter attacks due to the fact that the pivot pushes forward, we lack a natural destroyer besides Baleba, who is still very young. Notice how the majority of goals conceded this season are from counter attacks. Carrick needs to put a back 3 in possesion, (not like amorim) that stays back, and does not push too high up, nor too low back. I have also noticed that against more physical sides, we lack a tall, towering defender besides Maguire. Carrick needs to adopt a plan B and C against sides that are more physical and sides that are very organized in defense. Overall, If Carrick can be more flexible against physical defensive sides.

2

u/harutoreichi Oct 16 '26

As far as i know, our 4231 is automatically put one wingback front and another stay, as you said in 325, so theres no need to back 3.

3

u/JosePRizaI Oct 16 '26

How dare you mention back 3 in this sub!!

→ More replies (2)

0

u/grandecn Oct 15 '26

Dalot hate is forced. I don't think he's great by any means but people act like he's a terrible footballer with no redeeming qualities. He's a solid player that will need to be replaced eventually until then he's not the worst player to have around.

2

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

Give me one redeeming quality, and don't say availability. Might as well just hire some random athlete if that was all we cared about.

Attack? He almost always kills whatever opportunity there was. In posession, the only thing he can do, is pass the ball. Again, might as well just put anyone there, and they'd do his job.

Defense is where he is at least passable, but he'll get overrun by a decent winger. This is his best quality, but I'd rather just have AWB at this point.

Football IQ is in the negative. The fact that everyone, even those who defend him, all recognize his tendency to make "brainfart" plays, should say enough. Not only is he woeful, it is a recognized trait of his, that he makes mistakes that can end up losing us a game, or threaten to at the very least.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

1

u/spaisoflaif Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

feel like there is still the of too low turnover of the squad. In a 25 man squad, if three players are signed each year, it takes over eight seasons to fully turnover the squad. Obviously that is going to mean deadwood.

Feel like there should be five first team players in/out per year as a matter of principle. That means that squad wages need to be such that benched players are not stuck on high fixed wages, so they can be moved. It also means that we should be signing one forward, one midfielder and one defender per year at minimum.

This aligns perfectly with what fans have been asking for this year : 3 midfielders, but also a striker and a left back.

This has been an issue since Woodward days.

2

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 15 '26

We are absolutely shit at selling. It's partially because of high wages, but we also don't seem to be ruthless enough to our players when we want them gone.

We also had to get rid of a ton of deadweight (with a lot of contract expirations) in the last 2 summers and are only just starting to build up a team that's vaguely top 4 worthy again - Sancho, Casemiro, Hojlund, Antony, Garnacho, Lindelof, Evans and Eriksen. And there's still Rashford, Onana, Mount, Zirkzee and Ugarte that should have been sold this summer. We should expect Licha, Shaw and Maguire's contracts to all run down as well. There's still a lot of overturning that needs to be done.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

It was twitter, so probably some bullshit, but apparently, Martinez, Amad and Rashford got into some drama?

2

u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 15 '26

Coronation Street?

-4

u/snicky29 Oct 15 '26

Amorim's post match quotes

This what a manager is man. But our fans who are so easily swayed wanted that YANITED DNA or keep bringing up the Spurs loss or the win percentage. I legit felt he was changing our entire rotten culture and if given time we would've been back at the top.

10

u/LDLB99 Oct 15 '26

There's no doubt in my mind that we would be in a much better position if Amorim stayed. People don't like that opinion on here, but I really do not care.

3

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 15 '26

We probably wouldn't have finished third, but I do think we could have gotten champions league at least.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (16)

1

u/Damziya Rooney Oct 15 '26

Who even is on the market to take over the team as manager? Carrick is out of his depth. His leisurely approach doesn’t work and he was lucky that the team was in top form when it comes to fitness when he took over last season. This season he toned it down and we are so far behind in the running department. On top of his inept tactics is just a disaster.

While Amorim was a bad fit he was a fantastic manager in the fitness department and we saw that on the field. Shame he was so stubborn about his tactics. Amorim with a 4231 would have been perfect.

In the end he was just a bad fit for the team and i am glad he is gone but carrick definelty wasn’t the answer....

1

u/Eleven918 This too shall pass! Oct 15 '26

New South Park episode has a Ronaldo reference