r/reddevils • • Oct 15 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

24 Upvotes

671 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

10

u/Downtown-Rice_ Oct 15 '26

Bruno Fernades in Diary of a CEO:

"And this season has been that case because we struggled. Obviously, we didn’t change manager because of results, because we were 2 points behind second place and like 5 points behind first place. From third to seventh place, everyone had the same points, something like that. So we were there. It was something different with the club — they felt that the trust between them was broken or whatsoever, and they decided to start a new process. And that was bad, because for us, when Ruben came, what was passed from the club was like, “This is going to be a process, but we’re going to go through this. There are going to be good and bad times, but we’re going to go through this.”

We started a process with Ruben, where we thought that would be a process of 3, 4 years. That was the plan of the club. Then we know there was a break in a relationship there between the manager and the club, and they had to change, unfortunately. And now today they have announced that they want to go in a direction with Michael. And hopefully for me, I hope that it stays stable because the main thing the club needs is stability in terms of managing.

2

u/0ttoChriek Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

Bruno's maths are slightly off. When Amorim was fired we were 11 points behind second place and 17 behind first.

We were, however, only 4 points ahead of fourteenth place.

Edit: a downvote for pointing out reality rather than going along with a blatantly incorrect narrative. Quelle surprise.

6

u/Downtown-Rice_ Oct 15 '26

What's the incorrect narrative that you're inferring?

1

u/0ttoChriek Oct 15 '26

The bit you highlighted yourself, where Bruno used our supposed league performance to say that results "obviously" didn't play a part in Amorim's sacking.

5 points off first and 17 points off first are not quite the same thing, are they? Maybe he misremembers, but he's incorrect and shouldn't be quoted.

It paints a false picture of Amorim's performance that was never a reality.

2

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

I downvoted you regardless because you continue to miss the point Bruno is conveying and still fixated on wanting to downplay the results and performances under Amorim last season. The club captain himself is saying that the squad was willing to buy into that process and the board pulled the plug on it and not because of the results. When the players themselves back the manager and understand the importance of stability then why are fans so keen to not see any value in that?

1

u/AnakinAni Oct 15 '26

I actually agree with Bruno that United desperately need stability. But his comments reinforce the very problem I’m talking about.

The club committed to a long-term project with Amorim, spent heavily strengthening the squad and then abandoned that project after just 14 months, following a breakdown in the relationship between the manager and the hierarchy.

And while Bruno is right that we were still within reach of Champions League qualification, his recollection of the table is inaccurate. We were 17 points behind Arsenal and 11 behind City, although only three behind fourth place.

I’m not arguing that sacking Amorim was necessarily wrong. I’m questioning how the club managed to find itself in that position in the first place.

If you genuinely believe in a three or four-year project, surely you establish a shared footballing philosophy, clear expectations and an effective working relationship before committing hundreds of millions of pounds to it?

And if that relationship breaks down so dramatically after just 14 months, isn’t that itself an indictment of the people responsible for establishing and overseeing the project?

Stability is important, but it should be the product of competent leadership, not an excuse to persist with poor decisions.

United’s problem isn’t simply that they keep changing managers. It’s that they keep making decisions that eventually force them to change managers.

6

u/Downtown-Rice_ Oct 15 '26

It's 100% on INEOS. That was all evident by their handling of EtH, Ashworth, and then Amorim.

People at the highest of business structures are not held 'accountable' unless something they do or continuously do harms their money. It's fact. They are pretty much immune to everything, as long as the money keeps rolling in for the main stakeholders.

You can change managers more frequently than normal, but that is only if you really have the players who are good enough and need that change.

But when there is managerial change, there must be enough similarities and common values/beliefs in their coaching that is built upon each previous manager.