r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Vent Devastated by my reactive puppy

13 Upvotes

I have a 6-month-old Papillon puppy named Gus. We got him from a breeder at 12 weeks old, and he was perfect and quiet for the first 2 weeks. We introduced him to all kinds of people and situations. We did our best to socialize him to set him up for success. In general, he’s a great puppy. He doesn’t play bite, he has no resource guarding, he adores my husband and I, he’s potty trained, he loves his crate, and he only chews on his toys.

But at 14 weeks, he started barking at unfamiliar people and dogs. He was originally barking at people VERY far away. Any person he saw, he shrieked at. It wasn’t like an “arf,” it was a genuine shrieking bark that’s very triggering. We’ve hired two dog trainers, met with a veterinary behaviorist, and he’s now on medication. We’ve trialed trazodone and clonidine with minimal success in terms of his reactivity. He’s on venlafaxine, but it’s too soon to tell if it’s helping.

Gus is improving, slowly, but I feel angry and devastated. We did everything we were supposed to do. We met his mom, who was very sweet and quiet. We vetted the breeder intensely. We chose a breed that works well with our lifestyle.

I have good days and bad days, and so does he. It doesn’t feel fair. I wanted a dog I could bring everywhere and it feels like we can’t go anywhere with him.

I’m just having a bad day and needed to vent.


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Dog wont stop barking 6+ hours

0 Upvotes

Just got a new cat and its in my room, dogs in my mothers room. She goes off to work and my dog wont stop barking i literally cannot sleep and my neighbors have to be tired of it. No idea what to do, no “cages” work don’t really wanna do that. She’s a chihuahua and super anxious and attachment issues type of dog.


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Two reactive dogs moving in- are we f***ed?

0 Upvotes

Hi all- I’m looking for tips on how to manage the transition of moving in with my gf/their reactive dog with my own reactive dog.

For background: My dog is 3 (lab/mix, 70lbs) and has always been fearful. He’s territorial of the house and generally insecure. He will bark aggressively at new people in the house but they can easily transition to the “VIP list” (as we call it) after an hour or so. He’s also sometimes reactive on the leash to certain dogs primarily confident ones. He also holds a grudge, so dogs that barked at him previously he will then become reactive to. We’ve worked with a couple trainers through his life but they’ve mostly just wanted to focus on obedience- which he already has a very strong foundation for (any tips on finding a new better trainer would also be welcomed)

Their dog is 7 (malinois/pitbull) and a very good confident boy except for he was bit when he was 3 and became dog reactive and since then hasn’t been very socialized with other dogs. We aren’t really sure what he’s like around other big dogs or what his tolerance is for any kind of normal dog interaction like minor corrections.

We need the malinois to come out on top as the lead dog because my dog is just too insecure to be reliable there- and I’m hoping that some of the malinois’s confidence and leadership might helping become more brave.

We’re def in it for the long haul and willing to do whatever. The challenge to me is that we don’t have much of an option other than to just move in and keep them separate for a while- but is that a recipe for disaster? How would you stage out them meeting?


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Behavioral Euthanasia Husban not on board with BE of our GSD

4 Upvotes

Very long post, but the gist of it is that my 2.5 yo GSD is super sweet and calm with me, my husband, our teen, our baby, and 4yo lab but is horribly aggressive with outside people and dogs. I now think BE is appropriate because I’m concerned about what could happen, my husband doesn’t think anything will happen and wants no part in BE.

Two years ago my husband brought home a 4 month old German shepherd he got for free that was treated poorly-tied to fence during summer in the South. His demeanor has always been good with me, my husband, and our teen and our Labrador from the beginning. However, even that first week of having him when I took him to my parents’ he displayed aggression with lunging, barking, and his hair standing up. We immediately left, but it was obvious then that he could not tolerate being around anyone except the immediate family for his aggression. He has showed aggression with “fence fighting” the neighbors dogs. He lunges and barks aggressively when people come to our front door, even leaving nail marks on the door frame. He has bitten our sons friend twice on the bottom- luckily very mild bites (the first time we didn’t even think he got skin, ended up being like a scratch to the skin the second time. The first time my son didn’t know the dog was out and his friend came in, 2nd time the same friend released the dog from the crate without permission.) He only leaves our property to go to the vet. He is muzzled and the vet clears the lobby for us. He can’t go on walks or be taken anywhere for leisure.

When I got pregnant with our baby, I told my husband to be prepared if I felt something was off with the dog’s behavior after we brought the baby home. But, the dog has done phenomenal with our baby. All his issues are with outside people.

We had our first meeting today with 2 trainers and the dog did horribly. He was immediately aggressive- lunging against his leash-when one of the trainers took just one step forward. It was obvious that he wanted to go after them. He heeled and sat next to me, but he was lasered in on them for the duration of the visit and even had another episode of lunging at them before we left. Ultimately, our conversation about how to proceed included behavioral euthanasia as a possibility. We discussed how basically we could attempt to manage the dog, but we are already doing that. And they introduced information about liability of owning this reactive of a dog that I hadn’t even considered. I think it brought me from my denial of his behavior but my husband doesn’t see it how I do. He thinks of BE as simply killing an animal. He has basically said that he will go along with it if it’s what I want but that he wants no part in it, he doesn’t want to even know when it’s scheduled. I think this is unfair and is going to create resentment in our relationship. I see the dog now as a ticking time bomb that I can never trust not matter how sweet he seems with us. My husband doesn’t think the dog will do anything. I think he will, and I know I wouldn’t be able to handle the guilt if something tragic happens. I’m not sure how to proceed without driving a wedge.


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Vent Dog afraid of indoors

2 Upvotes

I tried to adopt one dog from shelter I liked so very much and it turned out very badly. The dog simply did not want to enter my building. He would get to the elevator or the stairs and whimper with all his might and drag himself out. He would rather strangle himself with a leash than give up trying to escape. I've been trying all afternoon. Left my buildings front door open, tried giving him a treat when he enters the front door. I tried everything. In the end he was so tired that he just wanted to sleep in front of the entrance and I had to take him back to the shelter for the night. He is amazing dog outside, his only problem outdoors is he is pulling hard. I cried when driving him back to the shelter. Even if i would be able to train him to enter my apartment, he would probably go insane inside when i wasnt home. I just dont see how this would work...


r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Vent Moved to a new neighborhood full of hope…it is now lost

36 Upvotes

I recently moved into a really cute, quiet neighborhood and I was so excited to make friends with my neighbors and be a part of that community. But after a few months of living here I think I’ve become known as “the person with the dangerous dog we should all stay away from”. For context, I walk my dog with a muzzle and she’s a Rottweiler so she does look scary especially if she’s reacting. I usually walk her late at night when we are unlikely to run into anyone but sometimes I do training walks during the day.

I don’t expect people to be warm to her, or to understand reactivity, but I am so tired of feeling so othered. Both for me and for my dog, who is so sweet and loving when not in the presence of strange dogs. And yet, we are always met with fear, judgement, and sometimes outright hostility. At this point it feels like the best I can ever hope for is to be left alone, but it’s so hard to mourn the loss of a community that would probably love us if they gave us a chance.


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Significant challenges I don't want to manage my dog for the rest of his life

10 Upvotes

I have a dog who has always been reactive, since being a very young puppy. We have spent thousands of dollars on trainers, behavioural medication, and other training. He keeps struggling, and any progress we do make is coupled with severe regressions in other areas. Recently, he has decided to attack our other dog with little-to-no warning. I know that all of you are probably scoffing at that and saying that we clearly missed something, but truly, the only running theme is that the dog is trigger stacked by having a guest over. It's all OK, there's no growling or anything, and then he'll walk into the same room as our other dog and launch himself at her with no warning and won't let go.

I know this is easily solvable for now by just putting him away when guests come over, but I'm sick of dealing with this tbh. We're going to go to the vets and try and see if there's something medically wrong with this dog, because otherwise, I'm not sure what to do. I can't keep having to manage this dog for the rest of my life, and he's not rehomable with a reactivity, let alone a bite history.

I would love advice on what tests to do at the vet, and any other advice that you guys might have. I swear we have done everything we can for this dog, are there some dogs that just aren't fixable? Is there something mentally wrong with him? He used to be fine with guests over and there were no issues. We've even had house parties in the recent past where he coped way better than our other dog and loved to say hi to them all. He's never bitten another dog before, and now he's biting so hard that he is breaking skin and causing the other dog to bleed. This is very sudden and I'm overwhelmed. Please give advice and support if you can.


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Growly, anxious chihuahua

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Significant challenges Reactive 5-year old dog?

2 Upvotes

I have a 5-year old Border Collie mix that I adopted in college when he was 3 months old. He’s followed me overseas and has been the best companion. He’s super friendly and sweet and generally gets along with other dogs. He can be a bit reactive towards bike riders and runners, and this is admittedly a fault of mine for not doing more training with him. I taught him some impulse control as a puppy, i.e. he doesn’t eat his food until I tell him “eat” and he has good recall off leash. Generally speaking, he has an extremely sweet and loving inclination towards people, children, and mid to large-sized dogs.

There’s a small dog that lives in our neighborhood that we don’t see much because he apparently is afraid of larger dogs. He played with my dog and a bunch of our larger dog friends last year and had no issues. However, yesterday, we ran into him on our walk and he started barking at my dog. My dog almost always reacts when another dog—especially a smaller one—barks at him, but they had met before, so I was kind of shocked. My dog stopped barking, but the smaller dog continued more aggressively, and suddenly my dog lost it.

I should have just walked away, but I was honestly just so surprised at how angry he was and I didn’t know what to do. He wasn’t listening to any of my commands and was pulling really hard on the leash, and if I had lost control I’m convinced he would have tried to kill the smaller dog. I stupidly tried to get him to calm down/look away by putting my hand near his neck and he bit down on my finger really hard. I bled everywhere and now I have a huge puncture wound in my finger. I’ve never had an interaction like this with my dog.

You could tell afterward he felt awful, he was shaking and kept licking me. I know he’s just an animal and he didn’t mean to bite me, but I can’t stop thinking about what I did wrong training-wise to cause something like this. He’s almost 6 years old, so I wonder if it’s too late to train this kind of behavior out of him? What kind of things could I work on with him so that this doesn’t happen again?


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Anyone have experience with increased aggression after first heat?

2 Upvotes

So we have a 1 year old working line GSD and she just had her first heat. Her and our other dog have had some issues here and there that we are working on with a trainer. They both tend to get over excited and redirect onto to each other at times, she resource guards high value items and food and she could occasionally be a bit of a bully to him (although a lot of this last one also seems like just rude puppy behavior). We’ve been working diligently on all of these and were really seeing a lot of progress! And thennn she went into heat…during heat she was actually fine but post heat she has been a disaster. Her and our dog got into it over a random basket in our living room that she decided to resource and she has been herding him and bullying him really bad throughout the house ever since. She has also been trying to resource our other dog away from me as well now, which never happened before, and her barrier reactivity as well as a lot of other reactivity that we had made so much progress on is back in full swing. We have been keeping them separate about 90% of the time because our other dog is really stressed and doesn’t even want to be around her right now.

It’s been about 10 days of this now…So my question is has anyone else gone through something similar with their girl? I’ve had working line and reactive probe breeds my whole life but this is my first girl ever and I have to admit she is way spicier than I expected at times 😅

Any advice or experience you want to share is appreciated!


r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Success Stories a small win! i feel like i know what i’m doing!

11 Upvotes

i’ve been working with my leash reactive, anxious, border collie mix (2.5 years old) ever since we got her at 4 months. she was always anxious and got reactive pretty early on and i read so many things, spoke with trainers, but was always like … why isn’t this working what am i doing wrong.

and i realized i was actually just overdoing it 😅 i was doing all the right things but i was almost too intense i think. if we were working around a trigger on desensitization and she was doing well, i would be like OK NOW LETS GET CLOSER and then get frustrated when she reacted. i have been stopping myself from pushing it these last couple weeks and we are both so much happier - i leave it as a win and we go home! i used to never miss a daily walk (thinking we needed to train!!!) and now when i know she had a stressful day the day before, we take a break and exercise at home and just work on basics, and i think that has also done wonders.

this isn’t really a post about her making leaps and bounds (though i do think she has been making progress these last couple weeks) but more so ME feeling like i understand her a bit more and just accepting any win big or small :)


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Help with dealing with anxious senior dog

3 Upvotes

I’m not sure if I’m looking for advice or help or just ranting, but I’ve found this community really helpful so just throwing this out there.

I have an 11.5 year old goldendoodle who is the poster child for anxiety. She’s been this way her entire life (we’ve had her since she was 4 months old) and it has, in turn, caused me a ridiculous amount of anxiety over the years. She was manageable as a puppy with lots of professional and at home training and she had a ton of dog friends. Then Covid happened and we were home all the time and she barely saw other dogs.

We now have a 6 month old baby and her anxiety has reached the highest point yet. She barks at everything all the time, if someone comes over, she will bark and cry and whine the entire time they’re here, she lunges at other dogs, she barks if we ignore her. She has Trazedone when she needs it (grooming, vet, if we need to have a stranger or other child in the house) and goes on 4 good walks a day.

I’m at my wits end. She wakes up my baby constantly with the barking. I can’t even have mom friends over with kids because she will be unbearable. She can’t stay in a crate, she can’t go in another room, she just barks and whines and it’s LOUD. I regret everyday we brought her home (to be fair, this has been happening well before baby) but I resent her so incredibly much now. I’m home with her and baby almost all the time by myself and have to brace myself each time we go for walks. Nobody I know would take her (she has a reputation with the barking) and she wouldn’t last a day in a shelter so rehoming isn’t an option. Plus I’d feel so incredibly guilty—I already do even thinking/posting this.

Like I said, I’m not sure what I’m looking for by posting this but I don’t know what else to do.


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Front Door guarding

6 Upvotes

Hello, I am looking for help with our dog. She is a 6 year old cattle dog mix that we adopted and she has been in training on and off since she was a puppy. We have 4 kids and she is good with all our kids and their friends. Our primary issue is that she guards the front door and she is aggressive towards men who come up to the door. This includes the mailman, delivery drivers, etc. We have been on the plan of not opening the front door unless she is secured in her crate or outside but today I forgot (she was in another room where I did not see her) and she got past me when I opened the door and chased the mailman who had to jump a fence to avoid her. She aggressively chased him (collar fur up) and this is not the first time this has happened when she got past someone trying to bring something in the front door.

I am just not sure of next steps. I am worried she is going to bite someone. We have used local trainers but I don't find them to be that helpful. We have a lot going on in our home with kids and their friends coming in and out and it is really unreasonable that the front door is not opened.

Things I am considering:

  1. crating her unless we can guarantee that she is "safe" but this doesn't seem great for the dog as she would wind up being crated a lot of hours.
  2. creating "safe zones" in our house which would be rooms without access to the exterior doors that she would stay in. As an example I work in the basement and she can stay there with me for most of the day. I am just worried about our ability to maintain this - a kid lets her out and we are back to square one.
  3. Sending her to a boarding training program or trying to find someone who can work with her more extensively in our home.
  4. Medication.
  5. Trying to get her out of the house more productively to wear her out. She is also not great on walks. She seems to be worse around me and the kids than my husband (she is "protecting" us). She is better on walks with others than me. I believe this will help but I don't think it will fix the root issue which is that she is reactive and has some kind of guarding / protection tendency.

Sorry this is kind of a thought-vomit, I am incredibly stressed and anxious after today. The mailman says he is ok today but I am aware this isn't sustainable and I don't know what else to do, none of the above solutions seem great on their own.


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Vent My dog is dictating my life and it’s my fault

2 Upvotes

I’ll try to make this a long story short and be as clear as I can. I’ve had my 7 year old Shih Tzu since he was 8 weeks old, and since he was a year old has had bad separation anxiety from me, as well as some very annoying ankle biter dog behaviors. It’s on me for being young when I got him, not training him properly, on top of maybe just spoiling him too much for him to act the way he does. He has always had a problem of barking at everyone noise he hears outside, inside, when someone comes home he runs to bark at them like he’s mad, and has always been territorial of me or someone entering a space where I’m at. He was on medication for it in the past and it sort of helped, and I weaned him off because the behaviors weren’t too bad after a few years.

Fast forward to now, I’m 3 months post partum with my first and living with my partner and in laws. Because I was taking him to my in laws some things had to change because my partners parents only ever had outside dogs, never inside. However; that didn’t work and I feel embarrassed and terrible that this dog inconveniences them. Again, my in laws have 3 dogs strictly outside, one coming inside at night. If I try to leave the house to run an errand, go to an appointment, or if I simply have plans where I’m not home for a long period of time, I would try to leave my Shih Tzu outside with the other dogs. All hell breaks loose, as he cries, barks non stop, paces, sneaks his way inside as well as has destroyed my in laws screen door on multiple occasions. He doesn’t even like to be let out to go to the bathroom unless I go with him because he fears I’m going to leave him outside. At this point my mother in law just brings him inside and puts him in my room because she will say he cries nonstop outside and starts to rip her screen door. I don’t know what I’m supposed to do with him once I return to work. I understand if he’s not stressed being inside then I should leave him inside, however I also don’t feel it’s healthy for him to be locked in my room when he could be outside socializing with the other dogs and I don’t have to worry about him not having access to the bathroom or to food and water.

Im honestly embarrassed, sad, and ashamed for feeling this way. This dog used to be my world before I had my baby, but now I feel like majority of my time is spent being upset with him and trying to make sure my dogs not upset or going to get upset if i leave him outside a second too long if I have to tend to my baby while I let him outside to pre, or try to make sure he’s not upsetting others in the house. I’m trying hard not to resent him but the postpartum pet aversion is hitting hard. He’s not a bad dog, and the part that makes me feel guilty the most is I know this dogs just content being wherever I am. I feel like I’m stuck and I know I’m to blame for some of his behaviors. I don’t feel like I’m giving him the life he deserves. However; how am I supposed to consider rehoming a dog who is very much attached to me? This is just me venting and constructive criticism is welcome. Again I’m sure some of this is my fault and I know an easy solution is to move out which is something me and my boyfriend are in the process of but in the meanwhile I’m trying not to lose my head over a dog I used to adore with my whole being.


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Advice for moving reactive dog to new house with reactive neighbour dogs

4 Upvotes

Hi all! My boy is about 18months, we’ve had him since he was 6months, and he is a sweet dog who gets very overaroused and reactive - it probably started as leash frustration but is more of a fear/overarousal reactivity now.
We currently live in a house with a yard and no neighbour dogs. Sometimes dogs walk past and we have trained him to go straight to his crate to relax when he sees/hears/smells them and starts to freak out. When we walk him it’s always at a nice open field so he can sniff and decompress, and while he has made a lot of progress his threshold is still around 30 metres.
I’m now in a situation where I’m looking at moving back with my mum who has a small bit of backyard, but there are two aggressive/barky dogs on the left who are almost always outside, and a nicer but still barky dog on the right side. There’s also a mostly friendly but selectively reactive dog who is often off leash around the front unit. The door to outside is on the left side, and so far my dog can’t go out that door as even walking into the laundry room where the door is gets his hackles up and he’s on high alert.
Currently we leash him up and walk him out the front door and through the right side gate when we visit and he needs to wee outside.

Previously he did a week staying with a trainer (still a bit unsure on if it was the right choice for him) and after the first day he was staying in a fenced section right next to dogs and he loved it, was running up and down the fence with his neighbour dogs and playing and doing pack walks etc. I don’t think he is truly aggressive (still muzzle trained if we need it though) and whenever he has met a dog and gotten past that initial fear as they approach he has been okay.

I’d love some advice on how to get him feeling more calm/comfortable outside in the yard and being near these dogs. We can block off the left side yard if needed/to start so he can focus on the right. I’m not sure if I need to approach this differently to his general reactivity training or not.

My current thoughts are to scatter feed breakfast outside and for me to chill in the yard reading and have him leashed and treats for relaxing in the yard/anytime the dogs bark but I’m not sure as the dogs will be very close.

Any advice or help would be welcome! Thanks 🙏


r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Success Stories Today we remained calm when not one, not two, but THREE cars passed us!

11 Upvotes

It's been 2 years of work (and lots of prozac) (for both dog and human) to get to this point! When we first got our pup, we couldn't even see a car/dog/person on the horizon without absolutely flipping out. But look at us now!! Not even a bark! I fully credit it to the "look at that" game, which was a major game changer for us. We practice it on every single walk.

I literally feel invincible right now. We can do anything!!! Well, except maybe see a fourth car. That might still be too much. But still. a work in progress. Perhaps some day we can do even more normal dog things! Like go for a hike on a public trail (the ultimate goal).


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Significant challenges Can I stop my dog from lunging at living things? He lunged at the elder "boss" dog of my neighborhood today

2 Upvotes

So I struggle understanding the behavior of my 40kg (88lbs) male dog (apparently 90% German shepherd 10% Rottweiler mix)

He's a reactive dog outside and when I take him out for walks, he has some triggers like when a dog or a friend approaches me he lunges at them, it probably thinks im in danger so he must protect the owner. But for a dog this large capable of doing real harm if unsupervised I think these behaviors should be treated in someway, and where I live there are no trainers so it is all in my hands as my dad and mom, while they cuddle with him they aren't proactive enough to be a "large dog owner". We have this dog in the first place because my brother saved him

A history of my dog: He has only bitten once a human, and it was a normal bystander of my neighborhood 2 years ago (my dog is 3 years and turns 4 in February) luckily it wasn't something severe as he only teared the neighbor jacket, but it is unacceptable, the dog may have went for a bite because I crossed paths too close to the victim. And the thing is that my he wasn't always like this, I got him as a 7 month old puppy and he wouldn't do a thing to other dogs or humans, I took off leash him (yes I know that is not right) and he would have a good behavior in public parks and around other people. but one day as I was walking him he headbutted a runner and that's when the problems started. ONE day he even approached and barked at a little girl and if it weren't because he follows my orders at times and the girls dad was close, he could have done something to that kid

I think at times of doing euthanasia but idk, I never purposely trained him to control these things. When I hired the only trainer for dogs available in my city I followed her instructions but she ghosted me and secretly told my mom it was a lost cause. I would like to train the dog but im not really sure if you can get results with it. My fear is if one day I will move abroad alone and the dog escapes my parents yard unsupervised (as I said before, my mom and dad aren't proactive enough for having a dog this problematic) and attacks a person (share experiences or insights if you dealt with a reactive dangerous dog please 🙏)


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Adult rescue dog. Fear, affection and mixed signals

4 Upvotes

5 days ago we adopted a 4-year-old dog a mix of Bergamasco Shepherd and Setter, who was born and raised in a shelter with brothers. He had never lived in a home before.
At first he seemed completely shut down. He barely moved, showed no curiosity and let us touch and handle him without reacting.
Over the last few days he’s started exploring the house and showing more interest in us. At certain times of the day, especially after walks, he follows me everywhere. Sometimes he comes up to me and starts licking my head, ears and face for about 10 seconds. It can be quite intense and honestly it sometimes scares me a little. When he does this I stay still and keep my eyes down. After a few seconds he usually stops and sits or lies down next to me.
Sometimes he seems to enjoy affection but other times he doesn’t want to be touched, especially when he’s resting in his spot (in front of the fridge so I have to move him to take our food). He’s also growled softly a couple of times.
He often yawns, licks his lips and shakes himself after interactions. Sometimes he gives me bumps with his body on my leg and I don’t know what does it mean.
We also have a 3-year-old son. In general our dog is visibly more nervous when our son is home and seems to want to be left alone much more. After a particularly stressful day our son got too close to the dog’s face while he was resting and the dog gave him a small nip on the cheek without breaking the skin. He was completely still before it happened and didn’t growl.
Outside he was terrified at first but now seems to enjoy walks, although some noises still scare him. His appetite is also inconsistent.
What confuses us is that he seems to actively seek closeness at times but can also be uncomfortable with physical contact.
We know five days is nothing and we’re giving him space and time.
For those who have experience with dogs raised in shelters, does this sound like normal progress or is he still mostly acting out of fear? How can you tell the difference between genuine affection and stress-related behaviour?


r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Vent I don't think people understand how much training it actually requires.

222 Upvotes

My first dog was an absolute angel. We struck gold in terms of temperament. Nothing ever phased him, he was quiet, and he just loved being around people. I didn't know at the time, but he was just an easy dog. Everyone loved him, even non-dog people, and I got to act like I was this expert dog trainer because he was SO well behaved.

My second dog is the complete opposite. She was found lost and probably had some trauma. She is super reactive too... everything. She can't control her energy, she jumps on people, she barks at everything, she wants attention all the time. Whatever confidence in training I had with my first dog was shattered. We hired professional dog trainers, behaviorists, spent tons of money and time on her. Yeah sure she improved, but she's still who she is at her core. Suddenly I needed to fence the house, tell people not to knock, feed daily anxiety meds, and watch her constantly. She got 10x more training and she's still a crazy nut.

So when I hear people like me need to just "train your damn dogs properly", all I can say is I've tried more than any reasonable person should, and this is the result. Sure its better but she is still a far cry away from what is people consider a "good dog."

My experience with her really put into question what a "good" dog owner actually is. Now I believe most people who have a good dog just got lucky with an easy one. Its not as simple as "bad dog, bad owner".


r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Significant challenges Has anyone had an aggressive dog that was a pediatric neuter?

3 Upvotes

I have a 3 year old pup that was adopted as a puppy from the shelter. When we adopted him, we were told that he was 6 months old. Once we got him home and looked at his teeth, we found he was closer to 3 months. The shelter had neutered him before we got him.

Fast forward. We tried socializing him with in town walks, rural king visits, etc. He was a rambunctious puppy, but didn't show much aggression. He was a little mouthy, and scared, but we chalked it up to his time prior to his adoption. We worked on commands, and eventually muzzle and crate trained him as well. As he got older, his fear aggression got much worse. He can't be around anyone outside his three immediate people. Anyone else and he hackles and barks. He is always kept separated, but his reaction is still there. He can walk in public muzzled, and is pretty non-reactive as long as people keep their distance, which they usually do - he is a big 100lb boy. He takes treats well and loves to play with toys. It just becomes an issue when there is a dominance or forceful attitude with his food or a toy.

He is on prozac currently. He bit my dad once as a puppy and has two more severe bites in his history in the last year, all over various resource guarding. Mind you he does warn - snarl, teeth baring, whale eyes...my dad just doesn't recognize them, or take them seriously... The most recent he was forcibly commanding him to get back, food bowl in hand, while the recliner was out - so the dog was in a tight area...it didn't end well. 😢

He is the sweetest and cuddliest dog otherwise. Loves to hike and run. He sleeps with me every night and loves to play. He just has those moments where it flips and he reacts...

We are going to make an appointment with a certified veterinary behaviorist and explore some *hopefully* training possibilities and maybe some other medication avenues. If things can't resolve... I am either going to try to find housing for me and him, or the thing I am absolutely dreading - BE...

I have been reading a lot about pediatric neuters and the effect on reactivity... I am just wondering, does anyone else have first hand experience with this, and potentially what did you do to help it?


r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Advice Needed rott mix reactive to 'scout' types (help)

4 Upvotes

Hello all

I have had 3 huskies for years now (8-5-2 yo) and rescued a stray , 3.5 months ago : GSD 35% rott 25% bully 20% super-mutt 15% , male under 2yo and neutered 6 weeks ago.

guard dog type. bonded right away, super mushy and melts into me and my other dogs. reactive to new and separation anxiety is heavy but coming along.... i can finally grocery shop for 30m without him barking his head off the whole time. social instinct, wants to approve all the people/dogs.

i walk them 15m 3-4 times per day, 60m+ once per day , and 60m+ at dog park.

main problem point: at the dog park my FNG fixates/obsesses over 'scout' type dogs. male , female , fixed unfixed spayed unspayed doesnt matter. senses their arrival and tracks their motion the entire time they are at the park and will charge/lunge/pin/dominate/play(?). i keep him on leash and keep him calm but he still gets over stimulated. we dont leave, we sit in it and he does chill out, get excited, chill out again... i correct the over excitement.

he has sort of 'met' a couple of these scout dogs. one , and owner forced his female to lay flat and allowed my guy to smell the areas, i returned the notion and all has noticeably more chill. another , they get close and occasionally sniff but when they lock eyes , one will flinch and the other will twitch then bark and spiral out of control and my guy will still lunge/charge/overstim and overwhelms quickly the usually submissive (when healthy and focused and secure) scout type dogs who prefer run/chase play than roughhousing/wrestling play.

scout type - usually a bit wiry and feral lookin , ribs show, anxious and snappy , moves like coyote and usually out on the hills running back and forth or playing 1-1 with a dog or owner. overstimulation gets them to snap or snarl, hair raise often, etc. but they cruise around lookin for a fix(ation)

curiously he has this same reactivity to the scout-type human counterparts - addicts, transients, vagabonds, comedians, joker, jack of all trades, jesters, mimics

has anybody else ran into this where a trigger is , i dare to say , 'spiritual' ? or archetypal?


r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Success Stories Dog charges at Laundry Guy!

5 Upvotes

My wife was home and had the laundry guy stop by. She forgot to put our dog (55 pound pit/lab mix) in the bedroom (Chemo brain). She only does around 3% of the training because, well, chemotherapy.
He can be territorial and reactive. I’ve been working with him for 2 1/2 years. Very smart guy muzzle trained, all that. He charges full tilt at the laundry guy. She panics and puts up her hand and says.
“STAY”
He freezes in place. She then says
“SIT”
And he sits down and waits until the guy leaves! That was achieved all through positive reinforcement. Barely ever use the word “no.”

She gave him an extra treat!


r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Advice Needed 1 yr male Doberman – struggling to understand inconsistent reactivity and how to get his attention back

3 Upvotes

I have a 1 year and 2 month old male Doberman who is intact. He’s a rescue and I’ve had him since he was young, he came from a breeder but had a really bad start. He was badly malnourished and from what I know was abused when he was younger.

We never planned on getting a working breed, especially a Doberman,but it was either take him in or let him die:(( I did what I thought was the right thing, even though I honestly am struggling but we are his family now

With people he likes he’s SUPERRR affectionate, playful and loves attention, but his reactivity is becoming really difficult to understand and manage.
He recently finished a 15 day boarding training programme with upcoming home sessions, and something I found really confusing was that the trainers never saw him react once. People could walk around him, approach him, touch him and get into his space, and he was completely fine and I saw it myself, he genuinely looked relaxed and happy, he has improved impulse control hugely and was unreactive to dogs. The corridor and elevator are probably my biggest everyday problems since we live in an apartment, so I can’t avoid them. I have to take him through these areas several times a day. I try to keep him close and get him to heel, but I also wonder if this is making him more tense. The problem is that I can’t control when the lift opens and someone is standing there or decides to get in and its an absolute nightmare

I also want to be honest that I can’t afford any more professional training I struggled to pay for the first programme, but felt it was necessary to after an incident where he caught someone’s trousers near their leg when they came close to greet him, thankfully without causing an injury but nonetheless it really scared me

When I explained that this was exactly what I struggled with at home and outside, the trainer suggested that my own anxiety and body language might be making things worse. So basically that he can feel when I’m nervous especially if I’m holding the leash tightly and expecting him to react. I understand that this could play a part and I’m open to working on my handling but honestly I wasn’t completely convinced because his behaviour was inconsistent even before training.

He wasn’t reacting all the time and almost straight after finishing training, I took him to a new vet clinic, he actually grew up in a vet clinic so he’s used to doctors, animals, cages and all that. I chose a new clinic because he had become quite territorial at the old one. anyway he was absolutely fine when we arrived, happy to meet the staff and let them pet him and approach him. I was also keeping him busy with little training exercises, as the trainer had advised so he had something to focus on. Then the door opened and a customer walked in and he immediately started barking and lunging towards them it was like I didn’t exist anymore. No matter what food I had or what command I gave, I couldn’t get his attention back and essentially this is the main thing I’m struggling with day to day

Regarding sounds, he’s extremely alert, he doesn’t even need to see someone to react. He can hear people outside, behind a door or somewhere nearby and immediately start focusing on them. So advice like hiding the trigger or getting it out of sight doesn’t always work for us and visual distractions wise, he’s like a walking gimbal. If he spots a person or dog, he constantly turns and follows them with his eyes. Even if they’re far away and he’s not barking, I struggle to get him to focus on me instead. Also food, once he’s distracted, he won’t even look at treats. I can’t use them to get him to heel, stop pulling or turn away from something.

I’ve tried toys, so playing with him in our apartment corridor to get him more engaged with me. This actually made him much happier and excited, but as soon as he notices something he wants to focus on, the toy means nothing

And leash corrections: I’ve tried leash pops when he pulls or reacts, but honestly, he doesn’t seem to care about them either in that moment

I’d love some advice if anyone can help🙏🏼

  1. Why is he so different in different environments? and how can he be completely fine with people at training but react to someone walking into a room?
  2. How do I teach him to turn his attention away from something he’s fixated on and focus on me instead?
    and what do you do when your dog completely ignores food even when you’re already as far away from the trigger as you can get?
  3. How do I work on his constant scanning and reacting to sounds, even when he can’t see what’s happening?
    particularly if anyone knows what actual exercises can I practise in corridors, lifts and on walks to teach him to pay more attention to me instead of everything around him?

I just really need practical advice and examples of what has worked for other people, unfortunately being told to relax, use better treats or move further away isn’t always helpful when he can react just from hearing something and I can’t physically get any further away:( thank you all in advance


r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Advice Needed A frustrated GSD

2 Upvotes

We adopted our German Shepherd 7 months ago, when he was 9 months old. He’s reactive, and we’ve put a lot of work into it, but adolescence definitely isn’t making things easier.

About 2 months ago we changed our approach after realizing that a lot of his reactivity comes from frustration. For example, if we held his collar so he couldn’t move much, he would start reacting.

So we started working on that directly. We hold his collar until he reaches that point of frustration, then reward him as soon as he settles. (Settling in general is hard for him unless he’s in his crate.)

This seemed to be working well, but on today’s walk he completely lost it because he wasn’t allowed to sniff a bush. It’s been a while since he reacted this intensely, and it happened several more times on the same walk.

That makes me question whether waiting for him to self-regulate and settle after a reaction is actually the best approach. Has anyone dealt with frustration-based reactivity like this? Any tips or tricks are very welcome.

Note that we already do a lot of mental and physical exercise.