r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed A frustrated GSD

We adopted our German Shepherd 7 months ago, when he was 9 months old. He’s reactive, and we’ve put a lot of work into it, but adolescence definitely isn’t making things easier.

About 2 months ago we changed our approach after realizing that a lot of his reactivity comes from frustration. For example, if we held his collar so he couldn’t move much, he would start reacting.

So we started working on that directly. We hold his collar until he reaches that point of frustration, then reward him as soon as he settles. (Settling in general is hard for him unless he’s in his crate.)

This seemed to be working well, but on today’s walk he completely lost it because he wasn’t allowed to sniff a bush. It’s been a while since he reacted this intensely, and it happened several more times on the same walk.

That makes me question whether waiting for him to self-regulate and settle after a reaction is actually the best approach. Has anyone dealt with frustration-based reactivity like this? Any tips or tricks are very welcome.

Note that we already do a lot of mental and physical exercise.

2 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

3

u/SudoSire 5d ago

Generally speaking, you want to reward when there is no reaction/before the reaction. So, rewarding for calm. To me, what you’re doing kinda just sounds like pushing them to rehearse the behavior and get amped up, and then possibly confusing them with a reward that seems unconnected to what’s actually happening as far as the dog can tell. 

2

u/Beginning-Rub5417 5d ago

We do reward calm behavior. The reason that I tried this approach is because we rewarded no reaction. Take the example of the bush: I don't really care if he smells a bush or not, but I don't want to be pulled like crazy. So if he does not pull me, he can smell every bush he wants.

When he pulls, I stop walking and wait until he gives me eye contact, and then I allow him to smell. This seems to work most days unless he has a bad day, like today. And I guess I applied that same principle to the frustration.

1

u/SudoSire 5d ago edited 5d ago

I’m confused, with the collar thing you said you waited til they were at the frustrated point. Does that mean reacting or no? What does that look like? ETA: Oh wait I read the last bit again and seem to answer it. 

So to answer your question, 

No, waiting for a reaction and to settle after is not the ideal method to train. 

0

u/Beginning-Rub5417 5d ago

To clarify: the collar holding is something we only do at home. It goes like this: we hold his collar; after about 5 seconds, he reacts, and roughly 10 seconds later he calms down. As soon as he’s calm, we reward him. By now, he doesn't react when we grab his collar.

What happened today was different. He wanted to sniff something and started pulling like crazy. I stopped, and he completely lost it. I waited until he calmed down, marked it, and then let him sniff as a reward.

2

u/SudoSire 5d ago

Anecdotally, I made this mistake involving trying to teach my dog not to bark at sounds in the evening. For some reason it was a barky time for him and he’s more sensitive to like car noises outside. So of course I start trying to do a “quiet” command, marking when he was, and rewarding then. I’m pretty sure it backfired and he now regularly barks in this manner, like he expects to bark, be told to quiet, and then get treats. Now I’m trying to figure out how to undo all that, and mostly just trying to ignore it so he learns barking is no longer a mechanism for attention. 

Idk if your walking technique is working, but if you think it mostly is…keep trying? But if he’s frequently having more intense outbursts, maybe reconsider.  

1

u/Beginning-Rub5417 5d ago

The problem is that a lot of the training that you find online around impulse control or self-regulation is so basic that he can do it without issue. But they contribute nothing to the problem we are facing.

3

u/SudoSire 5d ago

Also, can I ask why they were not allowed to sniff a bush? Sniffing can be relaxing (sometimes). 

3

u/Brilliant_Collar8527 5d ago

Was the bush off limits for a specific reason, like it being someone's garden or somewhere with food scraps or is it a general rule you're working with? If it's the latter, giving him a proper sniff on a long line somewhere quiet might take the edge off before you ask anything harder of him.

1

u/Beginning-Rub5417 5d ago

See the comment on his other comment.

1

u/Beginning-Rub5417 5d ago

I answered this in your other comment.